Energetic Particle Precipitation Research Articles

Mid‐Latitude Auroras and Energetic Particle Precipitation Occurred Unusually in a Moderate Magnetic Storm on 1 December 2023

Mid‐Latitude Auroras and Energetic Particle Precipitation Occurred Unusually in a Moderate Magnetic Storm on 1 December 2023

Turbulence Around Auroral Arcs

AbstractThe spectacular visual displays from the aurora come from curtains of excited atoms and molecules, impacted by energetic charged particles. These particles are accelerated from great distances in Earth's magnetotail, causing them to precipitate into the ionosphere. Energetic particle precipitation is associated with currents that generate electric fields, and the end result is a dissipation of the hundreds of gigawatts to terrawatts of energy injected into Earth's atmosphere during geomagnetic storms. While much is known about how the aurora dissipates energy through Joule heating, little is known about how it does so via small‐scale plasma turbulence. Here we show the first set of combined radar and optical images that track the position of this turbulence, relative to particle precipitation, with high spatial precision. During two geomagnetic storms occurring in 2021, we unambiguously show that small‐scale turbulence (several meters) is preferentially created on the edges of auroral forms. We find that turbulence appears both poleward and equatorward of auroral forms, as well as being nestled between auroral forms in the north‐south direction. These measurements make it clear that small scale auroral plasma turbulence is an integral part of the electrical current system created by the aurora, in the sense that turbulent transport around auroral forms enhances ionospheric energy deposition through Joule heating while at the same time reducing the average strength of the electric field.

IMF Bx, By, and Bz dependence of energetic particle precipitation in the magnetosphere

The orientation of Interplanetary Magnetic Field (IMF B) components plays a major role in magnetospheric Energetic Particles Precipitation (EPP). This is because the IMF B components in the Geocentric Solar Magnetospheric (GSM) coordinate system control magnetic reconnection at the subsolar magnetopause. This study intends to unravel the dependence of the preceding conditions of the orientations of IMF B components that drove geomagnetic storms on the EPPs produced in the Van Allen radiation belt. We classified the geomagnetic storms based on their drivers and IMF Bz orientations prior to the storms’ onset. Energetic particle fluxes, IMF B, and solar wind data were used. The study showed that electrons are more reactive to solar wind speed than protons. Additionally, storms with southward IMF Bz orientation caused more EPP enhancement than with northward orientation. Our results also showed that protons are more influenced by magnetospheric compression than electrons at the northward orientation of IMF Bz. In fact, at this point, the proton’s motion violates adiabatic invariants. As particles interact with electric fields, a significant population of EPPs is produced by pitch angle diffusion. Generally, IMF Bx and IMF By are often anticorrelated. The preceding conditions of orientations of the IMF Bx indicated weaker dependence on auroral indices, and invariably on energetic particles precipitation than the IMF By.

Martian Crustal Magnetic Field Effects on the Ionospheric Main Peak

Planetary magnetic fields can affect ionospheric plasma transport and coupling with the solar wind. In contrast to the terrestrial global magnetic field, there are only weaker and sporadic crustal magnetic fields on Mars. Many studies have indicated that Martian crustal fields can still modulate the topside ionosphere and its coupling with the solar wind. Nevertheless, it is unclear whether the crustal fields can affect the ionospheric main peak, which does not directly interact with the solar wind and is dominated by photochemical processes. In this study, the crustal field effect was identified from ionospheric measurements over unevenly distributed crustal fields. Both the intensity and configuration of the crustal fields were found to be capable of affecting the ionospheric main peak. The ionospheric peak electron density tends to decrease in the strong horizontal crustal field region. The results suggest that the crustal fields may affect the ionospheric main peak through modulating solar wind energetic particle precipitation; strong horizontal magnetic fields can partially prevent energetic particle precipitation and thus weaken impact ionization.

Energetic particle precipitation influences global secondary ozone distribution

The secondary ozone layer is a global peak in ozone abundance in the upper mesosphere-lower thermosphere (UMLT) around 90-95 km. The effect of energetic particle precipitation (EPP) from geomagnetic processes on this UMLT ozone remains largely unexplored. In this research we investigated how the secondary ozone responds to EPP using satellite observations. In addition, the residual Mean Meridional Circulation (MMC) derived from model simulations and the atomic oxygen [O], atomic hydrogen [H], temperature measurements from satellite observations were used to characterise the residual circulation changes during EPP events. We report regions of secondary ozone enhancement or deficit across low, mid and high latitudes as a result of global circulation and transport changes induced by EPP. The results are supported by a sensitivity test using an empirical model.

The Relationship Between Electron Precipitation and the Population of Trapped Electrons in LEO: New Evidence Supporting a Natural Limit to the Flux of Energetic Electrons

AbstractEnergetic particle precipitation into the atmosphere has been identified as a key loss process for electrons in the Earth's outer radiation belt region. However, direct measurements of the electron flux precipitating into the atmosphere are challenging from high altitude low inclination spacecraft, such as the Van Allen Probes, due to the small angular size of the loss cone along the orbital path of these high‐altitude spacecraft. Here we use data from the Polar Orbiting Environmental Satellites (POES)/Space Environment Monitor in low‐Earth orbit to assess the relationship between the trapped and precipitating electron flux in integral energy channels >30, >100, and >300 keV. Our results highlight that there is a strong non‐linear relationship between the flux of trapped and precipitating electrons, with the ratio of precipitating to trapped flux only becoming significantly enhanced once the trapped flux reaches a critical level. This transition from low to high levels of precipitation is consistent with the theory proposed by Kennel and Petschek (K‐P) (1966) https://doi.org/10.1029/JZ071i001p00001, whereby intense chorus waves are excited and trigger pitch angle diffusion, resulting in energetic particle precipitation and limiting the trapped flux. Using electron flux data from POES and chorus wave data from the Van Allen Probes, we further test the observations against predictions from the K‐P theory. A particle tracing model is also utilized to illustrate a direct link between the drift paths of injected electrons, the occurrence of chorus waves and the spatial distribution of strong electron precipitation into the atmosphere at different energies.

Energetic Particle Precipitation in Sub‐Auroral Polarization Streams

AbstractSub‐auroral polarization streams (SAPS) are one of the most intense manifestations of magnetosphere‐ionosphere coupling. Magnetospheric energy transport to the ionosphere within SAPS is associated with Poynting flux and the precipitation of thermal energy (0.03–30 keV) plasma sheet particles. However, much less is known about the precipitation of high‐energy (≥50 keV) ions and electrons and their contribution to the low‐altitude SAPS physics. This study examines precipitation within one SAPS event using a combination of equatorial THEMIS and low‐altitude DMSP and ELFIN observations, which, jointly, cover from a few eV up to a few MeV energy range. Observed SAPS are embedding the ion isotropy boundary, which includes strong 300–1,000 keV ion precipitation. SAPS are associated with intense precipitation of relativistic electrons (≤3 MeV), well equatorward of the electron isotropy boundary. Such relativistic electron precipitation is likely due to electron scattering by electromagnetic ion cyclotron waves at the equator.

Frequency Chirping of Electromagnetic Ion Cyclotron Waves in Earth's Magnetosphere

AbstractElectromagnetic ion cyclotron (EMIC) waves are known to exhibit frequency chirping occasionally, contributing to the rapid acceleration and precipitation of energetic particles in the magnetosphere. However, the chirping mechanism of EMIC waves remains elusive. In this work, a phenomenological model of whistler mode chorus waves named the Trap‐Release‐Amplify (TaRA) model is applied to EMIC waves. Based on the proposed model, we explain how the chirping of EMIC waves occurs, and give predictions on their frequency chirping rates. For the first time, we relate the frequency chirping rate of EMIC waves to both the wave amplitude and the background magnetic field inhomogeneity. Direct observational evidence is provided to validate the model using previously published events of chirping EMIC waves. Our results not only provide a new model for EMIC wave frequency chirping, but more importantly, they indicate the potential wide applicability of the underlying principles of TaRA model.

A Case Study of Pc1 Waves Observed at the Polar Cap Associated with Proton Precipitation at Subauroral Latitudes

The importance of ElectroMagnetic Ion Cyclotron (EMIC) ultra-low-frequency (ULF) waves (and their Pc1 counterparts) is connected to their critical role in triggering energetic particle precipitation from the magnetosphere to the conjugated ionosphere via pitch angle scattering. In addition, as a prominent element of the ULF zoo, EMIC/Pc1 waves can be considered a perfect tool for the remote diagnosis of the topologies and dynamic properties of near-Earth plasmas. Based on the availability of a comprehensive set of instruments, operating on the ground and in the top-side ionosphere, the present case study provides an interesting example of the evolution of EMIC propagation to both ionospheric hemispheres up to the polar cap. Specifically, we report observations of Pc1 waves detected on 30 March 2021 under low Kp, low Sym-H, and moderate AE conditions. The proposed investigation shows that high-latitude ground magnetometers in both hemispheres and the first China Seismo-Electromagnetic Satellite (CSES-01) at a Low Earth Orbit (LEO) detected in-synch Pc1 waves. In strict correspondence to this, energetic proton precipitation was observed at LEO with a simultaneous appearance of an isolated proton aurora at subauroral latitudes. This supports the idea of EMIC wave-induced proton precipitation contributing to energy transfer from the magnetosphere to the ionosphere.

STEVE Events With FUV Emissions

AbstractSTEVE, Strong Thermal Emission Velocity Enhancement, was often observed by ground‐based imagers in visible wavelengths and rarely detected by global FUV imagers. We present a new event, and revisit two reported STEVE events, that were observed by the DMSP/SSUSI FUV imager at O 135.6 nm, N2 LBHS, and LBHL emissions. Coincident particle and plasma drift observations showed that the events were associated with high ion drift speed, low ion density and no energetic particle precipitation. This is consistent with earlier findings (e.g., MacDonald et al., 2018, https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aaq0030; Gallardo‐Lacourt et al., 2018a, https://doi.org/10.1029/2018ja025368, 2018b, https://doi.org/10.1029/2018gl078509; Archer et al., 2019). In this paper, several new features are identified: (a) Detection rates of FUV STEVE are much lower than that of visible STEVE; (b) The STEVE on 27 March 2008 covers 3‐hr local time with a length up to 2,700 km around 60° magnetic latitudes; (c) Different widths of STEVE observed in O 135.6 nm and N2 LBH images indicate a large altitude range in the STEVE FUV emissions; (d) The true ion (assuming O+) drift speeds during the 27 March 2008 STEVE event could be up to 20 km/s, well above the DMSP SSIES sensor limit. The kinetic energy of the high speed ions is larger than the excitation potential of the observed FUV emissions; (e) The requirement of such extreme high ion drift speed explains why FUV STEVE have been rarely observed, compared to the visible STEVE; (f) The three FUV STEVE events occurred during moderate geomagnetic activity; (g) Theses events were conjugate in both hemispheres.

The Hemispheric Difference in Electric Potential and Electron Precipitation Observed by DMSP in the Auroral Zone

AbstractIn this case study, we focus on how hemispheric differences in the electric potential distribution in the auroral zones are related to hemispheric differences in the energetic particle precipitation that indicate the presence of field‐aligned potential drops. Utilizing data during the spring and fall equinox in 2013 and 2014 from the Defense Meteorological Satellite Program (DMSP) F16 and F17 satellites, we systematically examine simultaneous measurements of plasma drift velocity and particle precipitation in magnetically conjugate regions across the auroral zone in both hemispheres. This allows us to establish the degree to which the interhemispheric differences in ionospheric electric potential may be accounted for by field‐aligned potential drops. Thirty‐seven eligible cases examined show accelerated electron energy spectra at conjugate locations in the northern and/or southern hemispheres. Of these 37 cases, 23 show conjugate differences in electric potential that agree qualitatively with the observed electron acceleration and average energy of precipitating electrons in each hemisphere. This result suggests that the hemispheric differences in ionospheric electric potential in the auroral zone may be most frequently accounted for by field‐aligned potential drops along the magnetic flux tubes connecting conjugate points to the equatorial plane. The spatial and temporal variability of the potential distribution, electron precipitation, and magnetic field configuration could account for deviations from the normally observed situation in the remaining cases. More magnetically conjugate observations at various altitudes in both hemispheres are needed to investigate this hemispheric coupling in more detail.

Solar influences on the Earth’s atmosphere: solved and unsolved questions

Solar influences on the Earth’s atmosphere: solved and unsolved questions

Atmospheric Ionizations by Solar X‐Rays, Solar Protons, and Radiation Belt Electrons in September 2017 Space Weather Event

AbstractEnergetic particles from space deposit their energies on the Earth's atmosphere and contribute to variations in the concentration of neutral components such as ozone which controls the atmospheric temperature balance. Comprehensive understandings of their global impact on the atmosphere require whole pictures of spatiotemporal ionization distributions due to them. We first attempt to evaluate and summarize the altitude profiles of ionization for the September 2017 space weather event with cutting‐edge space‐borne and ground‐based observations of different types of particle inputs. In early September 2017, the Sun showed notable activity, including X‐class flares and solar proton events. During this period, ground‐based radar observations have confirmed atmospheric ionization events by energetic particle precipitations of solar flare X‐rays, solar protons, and radiation belt electrons, the main sources of ionization into the Earth's atmosphere. We estimate the altitude profiles of the ionization rate by using the Particle and Heavy Ion Transport code System (PHITS) with the input of the particle fluxes obtained by satellites. The estimates are then compared with measurements of the ionization altitude, ionization intensity, and electron density by the radars in the polar region, such as the PANSY radar at Syowa Station and the EISCAT in Tromsø, Norway. We conclude that the PHITS simulation results reasonably reproduce (within the error of a factor of two) those ionizations measured by ground‐based instruments with inputs of observed ionization sources by satellites.

Electricity consumption in Finland influenced by climate effects of energetic particle precipitation

It is known that electricity consumption in many cold Northern countries depends greatly on prevailing outdoor temperatures especially during the winter season. On the other hand, recent research has demonstrated that solar wind driven energetic particle precipitation from space into the polar atmosphere can influence the stratospheric polar vortex and tropospheric weather patterns during winter. These changes are significant, e.g., in Northern Europe, especially in Finland. In this study we demonstrate that geomagnetic activity, as a proxy of energetic particle precipitation, significantly influences Finland’s average temperature and total wintertime electricity consumption in Finland. This influence is only seen when the prevailing equatorial stratospheric winds, so called QBO winds, are easterly. The results demonstrate a previously unrecognized societal influence of space weather, and imply that long-term energy consumption forecasts could potentially be improved by considering long-term space weather predictions.

Physical effects from the powerful Tonga volcanic eruption of January 15, 2022, in the earth–atmosphere–ionosphere–magnetosphere system

The powerful Tonga volcanic explosion and eruption has been reliably determined to cause numerous processes on a global scale; nevertheless, a comprehensive model of these processes is absent in the literature, which remains an urgent scientific objective. The purpose of this paper is to thoroughly analyze and model the main physical processes that accompanied the volcanic explosion within the Earth (lithosphere, tectonosphere, ocean) – atmosphere – ionosphere – magnetosphere (EAIM) system on January 15, 2022. The study attempts, for the first time, to comprehensively model or estimate the magnitude of the main effects arising in the solid Earth, the troposphere, the ionosphere, and in the magnetosphere. The effects include a rich assortment of waves: Lamb, sound, seismic, tsunami, infrasonic, and atmospheric gravity waves, which propagated on a global scale, with the blast wave launching secondary tsunamis and seismic waves. The powerful waves nonlinearly distorted their profiles and suffered nonlinear attenuation, while the electrical processes in the troposphere caused perturbations in the global electric circuit enhancing the strength of the ionospheric electric fields by one to two orders of magnitude that led to the emergence of secondary processes in the magnetosphere and radiation belts. The volcanic explosion excited all resonators in the EAIM system, perturbing their parameters. Resonances occurred in the Earth's solid shell (Rayleigh wave), in the Earth–ionosphere cavity (Schumann resonances), in the atmosphere (acoustic resonance), in the ionosphere (Alfvén resonances), and in the magnetosphere (magnetospheric resonance). The magnetic effect has been estimated of the submarine volcanic explosion and eruption (∼100–1000 nT), the tsunami (∼0.1 nT), of the volcanic plume (∼1–10 nT), and in the ionosphere due to the ionospheric hole (ΔB ∼ 0.1–10 nT) and an external current in the atmospheric wave field (ΔB ∼ 0.1–1 nT). The magnetospheric effects were caused by electromagnetic emissions in the ∼10–100 kHz band generated by lightning in the volcanic plume, which triggered the precipitation of energetic radiation belt particles into the ionosphere. This is the first time that feedback and main coupling processes, positive and negative, have been observed to emerge among the EAIM system components.

Kinetic Modeling of Radiation Belt Electrons With Geant4 to Study Energetic Particle Precipitation in Earth's Atmosphere

AbstractWe present a new model designed to simulate the process of energetic particle precipitation, a vital coupling mechanism from Earth's magnetosphere to its atmosphere. The atmospheric response, namely excess ionization in the upper and middle atmosphere, together with bremsstrahlung X‐ray production, is calculated with kinetic particle simulations using the Geant4 Monte Carlo framework. Mono‐energy and mono‐pitch angle electron beams are simulated and combined using a Green's function approach to represent realistic electron spectra and pitch angle distributions. Results from this model include more accurate ionization profiles than previous analytical models, deeper photon penetration into the atmosphere than previous Monte Carlo model predictions, and predictions of backscatter fractions of loss cone electrons up to 40%. The model results are verified by comparison with previous precipitation modeling results, and validated using balloon X‐ray measurements from the Balloon Array for RBSP Relativistic Electron Losses mission and backscattered electron energy and pitch angle measurements from the Electron Loss and Fields Investigation with a Spatio‐Temporal Ambiguity‐Resolving CubeSat mission. The model results and solution techniques are developed into a Python package for public use.

Influence of geomagnetic activity on the southern atmosphere and its cross‐seasonal association with SAM

AbstractThis study investigates the interannual cross‐seasonal association between the winter energetic particle precipitation, which is related to the geomagnetic activity (GA), and the southern annular mode (SAM) in the following summer by employing the ERA5 reanalysis dataset. The results reveal a marked negative correlation between these variables on an interannual timescale. Therefore, we analyse the GA signatures in the southern atmosphere and find that the evolution of SAM to the negative phase driven by GA may be caused by the following two mechanisms: First, for high GA levels, the middle and lower stratospheric polar vortex becomes weaker from October to November, with considerable changes in the stratospheric thermal structure and more anomalous planetary wave upwelling, accompanied by weakening of the circumpolar westerly. Over time, the anomalous signal from the upper layer can be transmitted downward and is conducive to inducing and strengthening the negative SAM in the following summer, which may serve as the stratospheric pathway for the geomagnetic impact on the SAM and Southern Hemisphere (SH) climate. Second, another possible way is that the preceding GA also appreciably regulates negative anomalies in the Ferrel circulation in SH, implying poleward anomalies in the direction of the pressure gradient, which promotes the development and enhancement of the negative phase of the SAM. In addition, easterly quasi‐biennial oscillation conditioning plays a positive role in the response of the southern atmosphere to geomagnetic forcing, thereby strengthening the connection between them.

Atmospheric and ionospheric impacts of energetic particle precipitation (EPP) from Earth’s ring current and radiation belts

Atmospheric and ionospheric impacts of energetic particle precipitation (EPP) from Earth’s ring current and radiation belts

The impact of an extreme solar event on the middle atmosphere: a case study

Abstract. A possible impact of an extreme solar particle event (ESPE) on the middle atmosphere is studied for present-day climate and geomagnetic conditions. We consider an ESPE with an occurrence probability of about 1 per millennium. In addition, we assume that the ESPE is followed by an extreme geomagnetic storm (GMS), and we compare the contribution of the two extreme events. The strongest known and best-documented ESPE of 774/5 CE is taken as a reference example and established estimates of the corresponding ionization rates are applied. The ionization rates due to the energetic particle precipitation (EPP) during an extreme GMS are upscaled from analyzed distributions of electron energy spectra of observed GMSs. The consecutive buildup of NOx and HOx by ionization is modeled in the high-top 3D chemistry circulation model KArlsruhe SImulation Model of the middle Atmosphere (KASIMA), using specified dynamics from ERA-Interim analyses up to the stratopause. A specific dynamical situation was chosen that includes an elevated stratosphere event during January and maximizes the vertical coupling between the northern polar mesosphere–lower thermosphere region and the stratosphere; it therefore allows us to estimate a maximum possible impact. The particle event initially produces about 65 Gmol of NOy, with 25 Gmol of excess NOy even after 1 year. The related ozone loss reaches up to 50 % in the upper stratosphere during the first weeks after the event and slowly descends to the mid-stratosphere. After about 1 year, 20 % ozone loss is still observed in the northern stratosphere. The GMS causes strong ozone reduction in the mesosphere but plays only a minor role in the reduction in total ozone. In the Southern Hemisphere (SH), the long-lived NOy in the polar stratosphere, which is produced almost solely by the ESPE, is transported into the Antarctic polar vortex, where it experiences strong denitrification into the troposphere. For this special case, we estimate a NO3 washout that could produce a measurable signal in ice cores. The reduction in total ozone causes an increase of the UV erythema dose of less than 5 %, which maximizes in spring for northern latitudes of 30∘ and in summer for northern latitudes of about 60∘.

Observations of 4.26 μm CO2 Auroral Emissions From AIRS Nadir Sounder Measurements

AbstractThe Atmospheric Infrared Sounder (AIRS) instrument onboard the NASA Aqua satellite is used to observe aurora associated with the CO2 4.26 μm emission. These observations are due to non‐local thermodynamic equilibrium (NLTE) resulting from the vibrational excitation of CO2, which arises in the process of auroral energetic particle precipitation, as opposed to the dayside NLTE occurring due to solar radiation. The observations are confirmed to be associated with aurora using the Sounding of the Atmosphere using Broadband Emission Radiometry (SABER) limb measurements and the SuperMAG Electrojet (SME) index. The high spectral resolution and low noise associated with the AIRS instrument allows for the emission spectrum to be calculated and confirmed to arise from CO2. Our new NLTE index values derived from AIRS provide the ability to globally measure auroral events associated with CO2 with a spatial resolution on the order of ∼13.5 km.