Embryonic Temperature Research Articles

Temperature effects on blood gases in embryonic American alligators (Alligator mississippiensis)

Numerous studies report on the influence of temperature on blood gases in ectothermic vertebrates, but there is merely a cursory understanding of these effects in developing animals. Animals that develop in eggs are at the mercy of environmental temperature and are expected to lack the capacity to regulate gas exchange and may regulate blood gases by means of altered conductance for gas exchange. We, therefore, devised a series of studies to characterize the developmental changes in blood gases when embryonic alligators were exposed to 25, 30 and 35 °C. To determine how blood parameters were impacted by changes in embryonic temperature, blood was sampled from the chorioallantoic membrane artery. The blood in the chorioallantoic membrane artery is a mixture of oxygen-poor and oxygen-rich blood, which based on the embryonic vascular anatomy may reflect blood that perfuses the chemoreceptors of the developing animal. Our findings indicate that following a 48 h exposure to 25 °C or 35 °C, there was a positive relationship between CAM artery blood PO2, PCO2 and glucose. However, blood pH suggests embryonic alligators lack an acute regulatory mechanism for adjusting blood pH.

Effects of warming at embryonic and larval stages on tadpole fitness in high-altitude Rana kukunoris

Global warming may affect the early developmental stages of high-altitude amphibians, thereby influencing their later fitness. Yet, this has been largely unexplored. To investigate whether and how the temperatures experienced by embryonic and larval stages affect their fitness at later developmental stages, we designed two experiments in which the embryos and larvae were treated with three temperatures (24, 18 and 12 °C), respectively. Then, the life history traits of the tadpoles during the metamorphotic climax in all treatments were evaluated, including growth rate, survival rate, morphology, thermal physiology, swimming performance, standard metabolic rate (SMR), oxidative and antioxidative system, and metabolic enzyme activities. The results revealed that elevated temperature accelerated metamorphosis but decreased body size at metamorphosis. Additionally, warming during the embryonic and larval stages decreased the thermal tolerance range and induced increased oxidative stress. Furthermore, high embryonic temperature significantly decreased the hatching success, but had no significant effect on swimming performance and SMR. Warming during larval periods was harmful to the survival and swimming performance of tadpoles. The effect size analysis revealed that the negative impacts of embryonic temperature on certain physiological traits, such as growth and development, survival and swimming performance, were more pronounced than those of larval temperature. Our results highlight the necessity for particular attention to be paid to the early stages of amphibians, notably the embryonic stages when evaluating the impact of global warming on their survival.

Using qPCR to Identify Potential Effects of Thermal Conditions during Embryogenesis on Mitochondrial DNA Copy Number in Juvenile Brown Trout Salmo trutta

Changes in the number, structure, and function of mitochondria during the early life stages of animals can play an important role for an organism’s metabolic rate, growth, and health. Previous studies have shown that juvenile brown trout (Salmo trutta) subjected to elevated temperatures during the embryonic stage respond phenotypically with a reduced metabolic rate. The aim of this study was to explore if embryonic temperature affects the mitochondria content of young brown trout and as such explains the previously found differences in metabolic rates. Here, we optimize a quantitative PCR (qPCR) method for the mitochondria cytochrome c oxidase subunit I gene, and then use the method as a proxy for mitochondrial DNA content. We hypothesize that young trout subjected to elevated temperatures during the embryonic stage respond phenotypically with a reduced mitochondrial DNA content. To test this hypothesis, we subjected brown trout to either control ambient (4.4 ± 1.5 °C) or elevated temperatures (7.1 ± 0.6 °C) during embryogenesis. Subsequently, we extracted DNA from liver and white muscle tissue of juvenile brown trout from the two different incubation temperature treatments and successively optimized qPCR for mitochondrial DNA. We found that the amount of mitochondria DNA in liver tissue was 18 times higher than in white muscle tissue, but there was no significant difference in mitochondria content in liver or muscle tissue between brown trout exposed to elevated and ambient control temperatures during embryogenesis. We conclude that reduced metabolic rate is not likely associated with mitochondria DNA content. We also suggest that qPCR is a simple and cost-effective method to quantify mitochondria DNA in frozen and partly degraded tissue from different treatment groups and a useful proxy for identification of differences in mitochondria number.

Embryonic temperature has long-term effects on muscle circRNA expression and somatic growth in Nile tilapia.

Embryonic temperature has a lasting impact on muscle phenotype in vertebrates, involving complex molecular mechanisms that encompass both protein-coding and non-coding genes. Circular RNAs (circRNAs) are a class of regulatory RNAs that play important roles in various biological processes, but the effect of variable thermal conditions on the circRNA transcriptome and its long-term impact on muscle growth plasticity remains largely unexplored. To fill this knowledge gap, we performed a transcriptomic analysis of circRNAs in fast muscle of Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) subjected to different embryonic temperatures (24°C, 28°C and 32°C) and then reared at a common temperature (28°C) for 4months. Nile tilapia embryos exhibited faster development and subsequently higher long-term growth at 32°C compared to those reared at 28°C and 24°C. Next-generation sequencing data revealed a total of 5,141 unique circRNAs across all temperature groups, of which 1,604, 1,531, and 1,169 circRNAs were exclusively found in the 24°C, 28°C and 32°C groups, respectively. Among them, circNexn exhibited a 1.7-fold (log2) upregulation in the 24°C group and a 1.3-fold (log2) upregulation in the 32°C group when compared to the 28°C group. Conversely, circTTN and circTTN_b were downregulated in the 24°C groups compared to their 28°C and 32°C counterparts. Furthermore, these differentially expressed circRNAs were found to have multiple interactions with myomiRs, highlighting their potential as promising candidates for further investigation in the context of muscle growth plasticity. Taken together, our findings provide new insights into the molecular mechanisms that may underlie muscle growth plasticity in response to thermal variation in fish, with important implications in the context of climate change, fisheries and aquaculture.

Temperature during embryonic development in brown trout influences juvenile behaviour in encounters with predators

AbstractVariation in thermal conditions during embryogenesis can have far‐reaching impact throughout ontogeny and may give rise to behavioural variation. Many animals, such as salmonids, exhibit behavioural trade‐offs related to foraging and predator avoidance. How embryonic temperature affects these behaviours has remained unexplored. Not only abiotic conditions during embryogenesis but also biotic factors such as predator conditioning may affect fish behaviour, especially anti‐predator responses. We examined how elevated temperatures and predator odours throughout embryogenesis affect the behaviour of 28–37 mm young‐of‐the‐year brown trout (Salmo trutta) in encounters with predators, namely Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar; 20 cm) and burbot (Lota lota; 40 cm). Juvenile brown trout were more active and aggressive if they were incubated in warmer water as eggs than if they were incubated in colder water, and trout remained inactive longer when encountering predators if they were cold incubated. Brown trout were less active and aggressive when an Atlantic salmon was present than when a burbot or no predator was present. Behavioural responses did not differ between trout that had been subjected to water with versus without predator odours during embryogenesis, possibly because brown trout were not subjected to conspecific alarm cues during egg incubation. This study shows that thermal conditions during embryogenesis can influence fish behaviour early in life and thus contribute to behavioural variation, with potential effects on life history. Considering the rapid warming of northern regions, elevated embryonic temperatures may contribute substantially to variation in salmonid behaviour in the near future.

236 Assessment of Early-Stage Thermal Manipulation on Broiler Chicken Muscle Satellite Cell Populations at Transfer and Hatch

Abstract Multi-stage hatching egg incubators are challenging to manage but still common throughout the US broiler industry. It is difficult to satisfy all embryonic temperature requirements in systems where late-stage embryos must be kept from overheating while ensuring early-stage embryos are not at sub-optimal temperatures. Our previous work showed improvements in performance and meat yield when incubation temperature was increased to 38.6 °C from embryonic day (ED) 4 to 11 as opposed to lowering it to 36.4 °C compared with a 37.5 °C control. The objective of this work was to assess the effect of thermal variation (TV) during early-stage incubation (ESI) on muscle satellite cell (SC) heterogeneity in broiler chicks at transfer and hatch to explore the mechanism responsible for increased meat yield in our previous study. Broiler breeder eggs (n = 2,160) were incubated at 37.5 °C from embryonic day (ED) 0 to 3. On ED 4, COLD incubator set points decreased to 36.4 °C, HOT incubator set points increased to 38.6 °C, and control incubators remained 37.5 °C (n = 2 incubators per treatment). On ED 11, all incubators were set to 37.5 °C until ED 18 when eggs were transferred to hatchers. At transfer (ED 18) and hatch (ED 21), pectoralis major (PM) and biceps femoris (BF) muscle samples were collected from 6 chicks per treatment. Samples were immunofluorescence stained to facilitate taxonomy of SC populations expressing the myogenic regulatory factors and SC markers, MyoD, MRF4, and Myf5, by fluorescence microscopy. Data were analyzed as a 1-way ANOVA with the GLIMMIX procedure of SAS. Means were separated at P ≤ 0.05 with the PDIFF option. Tendencies were declared when 0.0501 ≤ P ≤ 0.10. Chicks from COLD incubators had the greatest density of MyoD+:Myf5+ SC in their BF (P = 0.0261) and tended to have a greater density of MyoD+:MRF4+ SC in their PM muscle (P = 0.0562) compared with chicks from HOT incubators. On ED 21, chicks from HOT incubators had the greatest density of MyoD+:MRF4+:Myf5+ SC in their PM muscle (P = 0.0406). Temperature gradients as small as 1.1 °C during ESI altered BF SC populations in chicks at transfer and PM SC populations at both transfer and hatch. Overall, these results indicate that TV during ESI can influence SC population kinetics in both PM and BF muscles of modern, fast-growing, high-yielding broiler chicks at ED 18 and 21. Further investigation is needed to understand the longer-term effects on SC populations and the cell signaling pathways involved over time during the post-hatch grow out period to explain the meat yield responses observed in our previous work.

The effects of egg incubation temperature and parental cross on the swimming activity of juvenile brown trout Salmo trutta

Personality varies among individuals and is influenced by the environment. Here, we tested the hypothesis that egg incubation temperature had carry-over effects on swimming activity of juvenile brown trout, Salmo trutta. Eggs from different crosses involving anadromous and lacustrine-adfluvial parents were incubated under two temperature regimes, unheated (cold) or heated c. 2.5 °C above ambient temperature (warm), until first exogenous feeding. In the laboratory, we used open-field tests to quantify swimming activity in a new environment, and mirror-image tests to measure time spent swimming and resting motionless near a mirror, measures often used as proxies for aggression. These tests were conducted for two cohorts, with one tested in June 2018 and the other in June and August 2019, enabling us to test for repeatability and if differences persisted over the summer. In June, when adjusting for differences in body size between cold- and warm-incubated trout, we found that juvenile trout incubated as embryos at cold temperatures showed more swimming activity and took less time to initiate swimming for their size than those incubated in warm water. There were also body size and year effects but no effects of parental cross. For August, none of the incubation temperature effects observed in June persisted, but cold-incubated trout spent a larger proportion of their time motionless near the mirror than warm-incubated trout and there was a general body size effect on time to initiate swimming. The lack of any persistent effects of incubation temperature between June and August suggests that the effect is ephemeral. Notwithstanding, these results support the hypothesis that incubation temperature has short-term effects on activity of juvenile of brown trout during their first summer.Significance StatementWe studied the effect of embryonic temperature on juvenile fish behavior, focusing on swimming activity under different conditions. Brown trout eggs were incubated under two temperature regimes, cold and warm. We show that juvenile trout originating from cold conditions as embryos spent a greater proportion of time swimming and less time to initiate swimming than trout originating from warm conditions. These effects were present in June but not August, which suggests that the effect is short-lived, and occurs during the first summer when mortality of juveniles is high. The duration of the effects needs further study as our previous studies have shown persistent embryonic temperature effects on metabolism, body shape, reproductive potential and emigration of subsequent life stages of salmonids. These results also have bearing on ongoing climate change as even small differences in embryonic temperature may have ecological consequences for subsequent life stages.

Methylome, transcriptome, and phenotype changes induced by temperature conditions experienced during sexual reproduction in Fragaria vesca.

Temperature conditions experienced during embryogenesis and seed development may induce epigenetic changes that increase phenotypic variation in plants. Here we investigate if embryogenesis and seed development at two different temperatures (28 vs. 18°C) result in lasting phenotypic effects and DNA methylation changes in woodland strawberry (Fragaria vesca). Using five European ecotypes from Spain (ES12), Iceland (ICE2), Italy (IT4), and Norway (NOR2 and NOR29), we found statistically significant differences between plants from seeds produced at 18 or 28°C in three of four phenotypic features investigated under common garden conditions. This indicates the establishment of a temperature-induced epigenetic memory-like response during embryogenesis and seed development. The memory effect was significant in two ecotypes: in NOR2 flowering time, number of growth points and petiole length were affected, and in ES12 number of growth points was affected. This indicates that genetic differences between ecotypes in their epigenetic machinery, or other allelic differences, impact this type of plasticity. We observed statistically significant differences between ecotypes in DNA methylation marks in repetitive elements, pseudogenes, and genic elements. Leaf transcriptomes were also affected by embryonic temperature in an ecotype-specific manner. Although we observed significant and lasting phenotypic change in at least some ecotypes, there was considerable variation in DNA methylation between individual plants within each temperature treatment. This within-treatment variability in DNA methylation marks in F. vesca progeny may partly be a result of allelic redistribution from recombination during meiosis and subsequent epigenetic reprogramming during embryogenesis.

Effect of photoperiod during incubation on embryonic temperature, hatch traits, and performance of 2 commercial broiler strains

Provision of light during incubation has shown the potential to enhance hatching traits and affect posthatch productivity, physiology, and behavior. In this study, 2 repeated trials were conducted to investigate the effect of photoperiod and strain on the embryo temperature, hatching traits and posthatch growth performance of 2 commercial strains of broilers (Ross 308 and Cobb 500). In each trial, hatching eggs were randomly distributed into 6 incubators with 3 photoperiod treatments: blue LED light for 12 h d-1 (12L:12D) or 18 h d-1 (18L:6D) during entire incubation were compared with no illumination condition (DARK). Data were analyzed as a 3×2 factorial arrangement with the trial as the blocking factor. Embryos incubated under 12L:12D and 18L:6D had lower air cell temperature (P < 0.05) than the DARK embryos from d 13 of incubation onward except on the day of candling. The response of air cell temperature to periodic illumination differed between 2 strains. Cobb embryos had lower air cell temperature in 12L:12D than those incubated with 18L:6D from d 16 of incubation onward, whereas lower air cell temperature was found in Ross embryos when illuminated with 18L:6D photoperiod compared to those under 12L:12D. The 12L:12D treatment was associated with improved (P < 0.05) navel closure condition of hatchlings. There were no differences in hatchability, embryo mortality, body weight, or length at hatch among photoperiod groups or its combination with strain. No differences in production parameters were found between DARK and illuminated groups. However, 12L:12D had heavier (P < 0.05) body weight on d 14 of age and higher (P < 0.05) body weight gain than 18L:6D from d 7 to 14 of age. The results of this study indicate that providing blue LED light up to 18 h d-1 has no detrimental effect on production of broilers, however, 12L:12D light regime improved chick quality at hatch compared to DARK and resulted in heavier birds by d 14 compared to 18L:6D.

Elevated Embryonic Temperature Has Persistent Adverse Effects on Zebrafish Swimming Capacity

In recent years, global warming of anthropogenic origin and its impacts on biodiversity have increasingly gained public awareness. Here, we demonstrate that embryonic temperature can have persistent and crucial effects on zebrafish swimming capacity and cardiac shape. Three different embryonic temperature treatments (TE = 24, 28 or 32 °C) were applied to zebrafish embryos until hatching. Fish were then raised in common conditions (28 °C) until adulthood. Ventricle roundness was found to increase significantly with a rise in TE in juvenile (10% increase) and male (8% increase), but not female fish. TE and sex significantly affected zebrafish swimming performance. Juveniles, males and females raised in cold (24 °C) presented significantly greater swimming capacity than those raised at 28 and 32 °C TE. Our results represent a direct link between the physical capacity of adult fish and embryonic temperature fluctuations that add to the emerging rationale of the potential climate change scenarios on wild fish populations.

Egg incubation temperature influences the population-specific outmigration rate of juvenile brown trout Salmo trutta.

The present experiment tested if temperature during embryogenesis and parental heritage affected the migratory behaviour of young brown trout Salmo trutta. Two parental forms were used, a freshwater resident form and an anadromous form, both from the same river system but geographically isolated since 1993–95. Four groups of young S. trutta were produced and reared from (a) freshwater resident parents spawning in a tributary to the River Imsa, Norway, (b) anadromous parents spawning in the main stem of the same river system, (c) resident male × anadromous female parents and (d) resident female × anadromous male parents. The eggs were incubated until first exogenous feeding in River Imsa water, either unheated or heated c. 2.7°C above ambient temperature. Thereafter, all fish experienced the same ambient river temperature until release. Groups were released below an impassable waterfall 900 m upstream of the mouth of the River Imsa, either as age‐0 in October 2019 or as age‐1 in May 2020. About 7.5% of the released fish moved downstream and were captured in a trap at the outlet. For any given body size, the proportion of warm incubated trout that moved downstream was greater than the proportion of cold incubated trout. It was also found that most emigrants of the October‐released S. trutta were caught within a month of release. Also, most May‐released S. trutta emigrated in October. The offspring of the freshwater resident parents emigrated to a larger extent than offspring of anadromous parents. Thus, the difference in emigration with regard to embryonic temperature was phenotypically plastic and may be associated with an epigenetic effect of the thermal conditions during early development. The effect of parental origin suggests there may be genetic divergence between the geographically isolated populations.

Identification of different critical embryonic periods to modify egg incubation temperature in mule ducks

Egg incubation of mule ducks, mainly used for fatty liver production, is one of the critical phases in this sector. Based on hatching rate, the best incubation parameters have already been well described for poultry, but the literature on ducks is lacking. In this study, we tested different incubation conditions by varying two important factors, temperature and relative humidity, in mule ducks. These variations were applied at different periods during embryogenesis in order to measure the impact of environmental disturbances on different zootechnical performances. The temperature was increased by 1.5 °C (16 h/24) and the relative humidity was set up to 65%, during 10 days. Six 10-day developmental windows were tested, from embryonic day 9 to embryonic day 14. Our results are in line with previous reports showing that increasing incubation temperature, even when relative humidity is adjusted, can have a negative impact on duck embryonic mortality up to 24.5% for the condition E10-E20 (P < 10−5). However, the hatchability can be maintained at the level of the control groups when these modifications are applied on the latest windows (from the 11th embryonic day). Sex ratio, hatching BW, and internal temperature are also sensitive to these incubation changes, and their modification could have a major impact on later zootechnical performance. These results should contribute to the development or embryonic temperature programming approaches, especially for the fatty liver production industry.

Respiration Measurements of Juvenile Brown Trout Raised Under Varying Embryonic Temperatures to Test Climate Impacts

Respiration Measurements of Juvenile Brown Trout Raised Under Varying Embryonic Temperatures to Test Climate Impacts

Embryonic and larval development is conditioned by water temperature and maternal origin of eggs in the sea urchin Arbacia dufresnii (Echinodermata: Echinoidea)

Introduction: Embryonic and larval development in sea urchins is highly dependent on maternal nutritional status and on the environmental conditions of the seawater. Objective: To compare the development of Arbacia dufresnii in two different water temperatures and in progeny with varying maternal origins. Methods: We induced A. dufresnii females and males from Nuevo Gulf to spawn, collected the eggs of each female individually (progeny), separated them into two seawater temperatures (12 and 17 °C), and fertilized them. We recorded the percentage of fertilized eggs and embryos per developmental stage according to time, temperature and progeny. We measured larval growth by total length (TL) and midline body length (M) according to time post fecundation (DPF), temperature, and progeny. Results: Temperature did not affect fertilization, but embryo development was faster and more synchronized in the high temperature treatment. The generalized linear models indicate that embryo development depends on a quadruple interaction between the embryonic stage, time (h), seawater temperature and progeny. Larval growth was faster, producing larger larvae at the highest temperature. Larval growth depends on a triple interaction between time (DPF), seawater temperature and progeny. Conclusions: We found a temperature and progeny impact during embryonic and larval development and, in both cases, these factors generate a synergistic effect on developmental timing and larval size. This probably provides a survival advantage as a more rapid speed of development implies a decrease in the time spent in the water column, where the sea urchins are vulnerable to biotic and abiotic stressors.

Eggs of little bitterns show high variation and their size increases with latitude

Egg size is an important determinant of offspring weight and survival. However, despite extensive research on factors affecting egg dimensions, causes of egg variation are not fully understood. Between 2000 and 2016 we studied a population of little bitterns in western Poland, and examined a total of 529 eggs from 88 clutches. Furthermore, we conducted an extensive literature search for data on clutch and egg size from other populations of the species to test hypotheses explaining the relationships between these variables and latitude. Little bitterns in western Poland laid big eggs but also produced large clutches compared to most other studied populations of the species. The ratio of largest to smallest egg calculated for egg volume was 1.75 for all studied eggs, and up to 1.35 within clutches, suggesting a huge variation between and within clutches in the studied population. Egg dimensions were highly intercorrelated, but egg size was not related to clutch size in the study population. The comparison of data from different populations of the species revealed that egg volume increased significantly with latitude and was positively correlated with clutch size. These results support the embryonic temperature hypothesis and clutch cooling rates hypothesis, but contradict the optimal egg dimensions hypothesis.

Short communication: Context matters: Adult size is contingent on embryonic temperature in Drosophila melanogaster.

Temperature is a critical factor in shaping ectothermic development. Developmental temperature may constrain, alter, or redirect phenotypes expressed later in life. Recent studies have begun to analyze the consequences of mismatches between developmental and adult environments. Few studies analyze the consequences environmental mismatches during development yield on adult phenotypes. The aim of this study was to determine how mismatched temperatures during development affect adult size in Drosophila melanogaster. We employed a full factorial design in which eggs were incubated for 24h in one of two temperature treatments (18°C or 28°C) with half of the flies subsequently being switched to the opposite temperature treatment for the remainder of development. We measured body size shortly after eclosure. We found that variation in size after eclosure was contingent upon the temperature during the embryo stage. Flies reared initially in 18°C eclosed larger regardless of the subsequent temperature until eclsoure. Flies reared initially in 28°C, however, eclosed smaller only if they remained in 28°C until eclosure. The degree of plasticity in size was therefore contingent upon temperature during the embryo stage. We discuss the implications of employing full factorial approaches to consider the full context of phenotypic outcomes in light of changing developmental environments.

Effect of increased embryonic temperature during developmental windows on survival, morphology and oxygen consumption of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

Temperature is a crucial environmental factor that influences physiological functions in fishes, and increased temperature during development can shape an organism's phenotype. An active line of inquiry in comparative developmental physiology is whether short-term exposure to thermal changes have lasting phenotypic effects. This is the first study to apply a developmental 3-dimensional critical window experimental design for a vertebrate, using time, temperature, and phenotypic response (i.e., variables measured). Rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) are an anadromous species for which resident populations occupy freshwater environments that are likely impacted by variable and rising temperatures, particularly during embryonic development. To assess thermal effects on fish development, we examined trout hatchling phenotypes following rearing in constant temperatures (5, 10, 15 and 17.5 °C) and following exposure to increased temperature above 5 °C during specific developmental windows. Time to 50% hatch, hatchling mass and body length showed general trends of decreasing with increasing constant temperature, and survival was highest in constant 10 °C incubation. Thermally shifting embryos into 17.5 °C during gastrulation and organogenesis reduced survival at hatch compared to 10 °C, and exposure to 15 and 17.5 °C only late in development produced lighter and shorter hatchlings. Oxygen consumption rate (V̇o2) at organogenesis differed between embryos incubated constantly in increased temperature or exposed only during organogenesis, but generally we found limited temperature effects on V̇o2 that may be due to high data variability. Collectively, these results suggest that survival of rainbow trout hatchlings is most sensitive to 17.5 °C exposure during gastrulation and organogenesis, while warm water exposure later in development has greater impacts on morphology. Thus, trait-specific critical windows of thermal sensitivity exist for rainbow trout embryos that alter the hatching phenotype.

Embryonic Temperature Shifts Increase Adult Size in Drosophila melanogaster

The developmental history of organisms is critical in determining phenotypic outcomes. Shifts in environmental factors can constrain or redirect ontogeny in ways that traditional models of plasticity have failed to predict. In this study we examined the impact of shifting between high and low thermal regimes during the embryonic stage in Drosophila melanogaster. We found that extreme temperatures (both high and low) resulted in larger flies at enclosure than the temperature during subsequent development would have predicted. Thus, embryonic temperature poses a critical factor that can have lasting effects on morphology and fitness.

Immediate and Persistent Effects of Temperature on Oxygen Consumption and Thermal Tolerance in Embryos and Larvae of the Baja California Chorus Frog, Pseudacris hypochondriaca.

The developmental environment has significant immediate effects on phenotypes, but it may also persistently or permanently shape phenotypes across life history. This study examined how developmental temperature influenced embryonic and larval phenotypes of Baja California chorus frog (Pseudacris hypochondriaca), an abundant amphibian in southern California and northern Baja California. We collected egg clutches from native ponds in northern San Diego County within 24 h of fertilization, and clutches were separated and distributed between constant temperatures of 10, 15, 20, and 25°C for incubation. Oxygen consumption rate (O2), developmental stage, and embryo and yolk masses were measured throughout development. Time to 50% hatch, survival at 50% hatch, and hatch duration were determined. Development rate was strongly affected by temperature, with warmer temperatures reducing time to hatch and hatch duration. Survival to hatch was high across all temperatures, >90%. Mass-specific O2 of embryos either remained constant or increased throughout development, and by hatching energy demand was significantly increased at higher temperatures. There were limited temperature effects on growth, with embryo and yolk dry mass similar between temperatures throughout embryonic development. To examine long-term effects of embryonic temperature, we reared hatchlings from each temperature until onset of larval feeding. Once feeding, larvae were acclimated to 20 or 25°C (>2 weeks). Following acclimation to 20 or 25°C, we measured larval mass-specific O2 and critical thermal maximum (CTMax) at a common developmental stage (Gosner stages 32–36, “hindlimb toe differentiation”). Embryonic temperature had persistent effects on larval O2 and CTMax, with warmer temperatures generally resulting in similar or higher O2 and CTMax. This partially supported a “warmer is better” effect of embryonic incubation temperature. These results suggest that in a thermally robust amphibian species, temperature may program the phenotype during early development to construct traits in thermal tolerance and energy use that may persist. Overall, P. hypochondriaca displays a thermally robust phenotype, and it is possible that amphibians that possess a wider range of phenotypic plasticity will be relatively more successful mitigating effects of climate change.

Embryonic incubation temperature has a long-term effect on the spleen immune transcriptome and its response to lipopolysaccharide in adult zebrafish (Danio rerio)

Embryonic incubation temperature has a long-term effect on the spleen immune transcriptome and its response to lipopolysaccharide in adult zebrafish (Danio rerio)