Electron Transfer Dissociation Process Research Articles

Estimation of Rates of Reactions Triggered by Electron Transfer in Top-Down Mass Spectrometry.

Electron transfer dissociation (ETD) is a versatile technique used in mass spectrometry for the high-throughput characterization of proteins. It consists of several concurrent reactions triggered by the transfer of an electron from its anion source to sample cations. Transferring an electron causes peptide backbone cleavage while leaving labile post-translational modifications intact. The obtained fragmentation spectra provide valuable information for sequence and structure analyses. In this study, we propose a formal mathematical model of the ETD fragmentation process in the form of a system of stochastic differential equations describing its joint dynamics. Parameters of the model correspond to the rates of occurring reactions. Their estimates for various experimental settings give insight into the dynamics of the ETD process. We estimate the model parameters from the relative quantities of fragmentation products in a given mass spectrum by solving a nonlinear optimization problem. The cost function penalizes for the differences between the analytically derived average number of reaction products and their experimental counterparts. The presented method proves highly robust to noise in silico. Moreover, the model can explain a considerable amount of experimental results for a wide range of instrumentation settings. The implementation of the presented workflow, code-named ETDetective, is freely available under the two-clause BSD license.

金属–ペプチド複合体をプローブとした電子移動解離メカニズムに関する研究

金属–ペプチド複合体をプローブとした電子移動解離メカニズムに関する研究

High-Confidence Sequencing of Phosphopeptides by Electron Transfer Dissociation Mass Spectrometry Using Dinuclear Zinc(II) Complex.

Phosphorylation is the most abundant protein modification, and tandem mass spectrometry (MS2) with electron transfer dissociation (ETD) has proven to be a promising method for phosphoproteomic applications owing to its ability to determine phosphorylation sites on proteins. However, low precursor charge states hinder the ability to obtain useful information through peptide sequencing by ETD, and the presence of acidic phosphate groups contributes to a low charge state of peptide ions. In the present report, we used a dinuclear zinc complex, (Zn2L)3+ (L = alkoxide form of 1,3-bis[bis(pyridin-2-ylmethyl)amino]propan-2-ol) for electrospray ionization (ESI), followed by ETD-MS2 analysis. Since (Zn2L)3+ selectively bound to phosphopeptide with addition of a positive charge per phosphate group, the use of (Zn2L)3+ for ESI improved the ionization yield of phosphopeptides in phosphoprotein digest. Additionally, an increase in the charge state of phosphopeptides were observed by addition of (Zn2L)3+, facilitating phosphopeptide sequencing by ETD-MS2. Since the binding between (Zn2L)3+ and the phosphate group was retained during the ETD process, a comparison between the ETD mass spectra obtained using two dinuclear zinc complex derivatives containing different zinc isotopes, namely (64Zn2L)3+ and (68Zn2L)3+, provided information about the number of phosphate groups in each fragment ion, allowing the phosphorylation site to be unambiguously determined. The details of the fragmentation processes of the (Zn2L)3+-phosphopeptide complex were investigated using a density functional theory calculation. As in the case of protonated peptides, ETD induced peptide backbone dissociation in the (Zn2L)3+-phosphopeptide complex proceeded through an aminoketyl radical intermediate.

Hypervalent radical formation probed by electron transfer dissociation of zwitterionic tryptophan and tryptophan-containing dipeptides complexed with Ca2+ and 18-crown-6 in the gas phase.

The relationship between peptide structure and electron transfer dissociation (ETD) is important for structural analysis by mass spectrometry. In the present study, the formation, structure and reactivity of the reaction intermediate in the ETD process were examined using a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer equipped with an electrospray ionization source. ETD product ions of zwitterionic tryptophan (Trp) and Trp-containing dipeptides (Trp-Gly and Gly-Trp) were detected without reionization using non-covalent analyte complexes with Ca(2+) and 18-crown-6 (18C6). In the collision-induced dissociation, NH3 loss was the main dissociation pathway, and loss related to the dissociation of the carboxyl group was not observed. This indicated that Trp and its dipeptides on Ca(2+) (18C6) adopted a zwitterionic structure with an NH3 (+) group and bonded to Ca(2+) (18C6) through the COO(-) group. Hydrogen atom loss observed in the ETD spectra indicated that intermolecular electron transfer from a molecular anion to the NH3 (+) group formed a hypervalent ammonium radical, R-NH3 , as a reaction intermediate, which was unstable and dissociated rapidly through N-H bond cleavage. In addition, N-Cα bond cleavage forming the z1 ion was observed in the ETD spectra of Trp-GlyCa(2+) (18C6) and Gly-TrpCa(2+) (18C6). This dissociation was induced by transfer of a hydrogen atom in the cluster formed via an N-H bond cleavage of the hypervalent ammonium radical and was in competition with the hydrogen atom loss. The results showed that a hypervalent radical intermediate, forming a delocalized hydrogen atom, contributes to the backbone cleavages of peptides in ETD.

Gas-Phase Rearrangement in Lysine Phosphorylated Peptides During Electron-Transfer Dissociation Tandem Mass Spectrometry.

Tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) strategies coupled with collision-induced dissociation (CID) or radical-driven fragmentation techniques such as electron-capture dissociation (ECD) or electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) have been successfully used for comprehensive phosphoproteome analysis. However, the unambiguous characterization of the phosphorylation site remains a significant challenge due to phosphate-related neutral losses and gas-phase rearrangements, which have been observed during CID. In particular, for the analysis of labile N-phosphorylated peptides, ECD and ETD are emerging as a complementary method. In contrast to CID, the phosphorylation site of histidine, arginine, and lysine phosphorylated peptides can be characterized by ETD. Here, we present a study on the application of ETD for analysis of phospholysine (pLys) peptides. We show that, depending on the charge state of the precursor ion as well as the presence of basic amino acid side chains, phosphate transfer reactions during the ETD process can be observed leading to ambiguous fragment ion spectra. Basically, pLys is stable under ETD conditions allowing an unambiguous assignment of the site of phosphorylation, but some factors/parameters have to be considered to avoid gas-phase rearrangement which would lead to false positive results in phosphoproteomic studies.

Characterization of top-down ETD in a travelling-wave ion guide

Top-down sequencing methods are becoming increasingly relevant for protein characterization, in particular electron capture (ECD) and electron transfer dissociation (ETD) which allow for extensive backbone cleavage with minimal side reactions. The ability to obtain sequence-specific fragments while maintaining aspects of the higher-order structure, as well as the position of deuterium labels in H/D exchange, has attracted interest from scientists in the field of structural proteomics. Recently, ETD has also been combined with ion mobility on commercially available quadrupole/time-of-flight instruments, and this implementation paves the way to novel structural studies and investigation of the ETD process itself. In the current work, we investigate the use of ETD for fragmentation of standard peptides and proteins and provide a detailed description of the effect of the parameters controlling the time and efficiency of the reaction. We also highlight how the combination with ion mobility separation after electron transfer provides extended analytical benefits, such as assignment of fragments to a specific charge-reduced state of the precursor.

Combined use of ion mobility and collision-induced dissociation to investigate the opening of disulfide bridges by electron-transfer dissociation in peptides bearing two disulfide bonds.

Disulfide bonds are post-translational modifications (PTMs) often found in peptides and proteins. They increase their stability toward enzymatic degradations and provide the structure and (consequently) the activity of such folded proteins. The characterization of disulfide patterns, i.e., the cysteine connectivity, is crucial to achieve a global picture of the active conformation of the protein of interest. Electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) constitutes a valuable tool to cleave the disulfide bonds in the gas phase, avoiding chemical reduction/alkylation in solution. To characterize the cysteine pairing, the present work proposes (i) to reduce by ETD one of the two disulfide bridges of model peptides, resulting in the opening of the cyclic structures, (ii) to separate the generated species by ion mobility, and (iii) to characterize the species using collision-induced dissociation (CID). Results of this strategy applied to several peptides show different behaviors depending on the connectivity. The loss of SH· radical species, observed for all the peptides, confirms the cleavage of the disulfides during the ETD process.

Use of CID/ETD mass spectrometry to analyze glycopeptides.

Collision-induced dissociation (CID) tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) does not allow the characterization of glycopeptides because of the fragmentation of glycan structures and limited fragmentation of peptide backbones. Electron transfer dissociation (ETD) MS/MS, on the other hand, offers a complementary approach, prompting only peptide backbone fragmentation while keeping post-translational modifications intact. Characterization of glycopeptides using both CID and ETD is summarized in this unit. While CID provides information related to the composition of glycan moieties attached to a peptide backbone, ETD permits de novo sequencing of peptides. Radical anion transfer of electrons to the peptide backbone in ETD induces cleavage of the N-Cα bond. The glycan moiety is retained on the peptide backbone, largely unaffected by the ETD process, thus allowing the identification of the amino acid sequence of a glycopeptide and its glycosylation site. This unit discusses the use of both CID and ETD for better characterization of glycopeptides.

Direct mass analysis of neutral molecules by superconductivity

Dissociation related to ion collision reactions produces neutral fragments in addition to ionic fragments, and the ability to analyze both neutral and ionic fragments is crucial for fully understanding chemical reactions in the gas phase. However, conventional mass spectroscopy (MS) instruments are unable to directly analyze multiple neutral fragments without reionization. This inability is called “ neutral loss.” We report the first tandem MS instrument realized by a kinetic-energy-sensitive cryodetector (a superconducting tunnel junction operated in the Giaever mode) as the second mass separation (KEMS) to quantitatively analyze multiple fragment molecules, either neutral or ionic, in a keV kinetic energy range. The performance of the MS/KEMS instrument was examined using the collisions of singly charged acetone or acetyl precursors with a Xe target. These singly charged ions undergo either collisionally activated dissociation (CAD) or electron transfer dissociation (ETD), including a dissociation path of ABA + + e → ABA* → A + B + A or AB + A, which produces neutral fragments only. Our approach is able to determine the branching ratios of the competing CAD and ETD processes and may provide a method to overcome the neutral loss.

Precursor Charge State Prediction for Electron Transfer Dissociation Tandem Mass Spectra

Electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) induces fragmentation along the peptide backbone by transferring an electron from a radical anion to a protonated peptide. In contrast with collision-induced dissociation, side chains and modifications such as phosphorylation are left intact through the ETD process. Because the precursor charge state is an important input to MS/MS sequence database search tools, the ability to accurately determine the precursor charge is helpful for the identification process. Furthermore, because ETD can be applied to large, highly charged peptides, the need for accurate precursor charge state determination is magnified. Otherwise, each spectrum must be searched repeatedly using a large range of possible precursor charge states. To address this problem, we have developed an ETD charge state prediction tool based on support vector machine classifiers that is demonstrated to exhibit superior classification accuracy while minimizing the overall number of predicted charge states. The tool is freely available, open source, cross platform compatible, and demonstrated to perform well when compared with an existing charge state prediction tool. The program is available from http://code.google.com/p/etdz/.

Letter: High-Energy Electron Transfer Dissociation Using a Tandem Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometer with an Electrospray Ionization Ion Source

A tandem time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometer with an electrospray ionization (ESI) ion source (ESI-TOF/quadTOF) was enhanced to perform high-energy electron transfer dissociation (ETD) experiments. Specifically, the collision cell for rare gas targets of ESI-TOF/quadTOF was replaced with one for alkali metal targets. High-energy ETD spectra were obtained of doubly protonated polypeptides and a phosphopeptide using a Cs target. Peaks due to several c- and z-type fragment ions formed by the high-energy ETD process were clearly observed in all cases. These results demonstrate that high-energy ETD can be performed using ESI-TOF/quadTOF.

Protein Conformations Can Be Probed in Top-Down HDX MS Experiments Utilizing Electron Transfer Dissociation of Protein Ions Without Hydrogen Scrambling

Electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) is evaluated as a technique to provide local information on higher order structure and dynamics of a whole protein molecule. Isotopic labeling of highly flexible segments of a model 18 kDa protein is carried out in solution under mildly denaturing conditions by means of hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX), followed by transfer of intact protein ions to the gas phase by means of electrospray ionization, and mass-selection of a precursor ion for subsequent reactions with fluoranthene radical anions. The ETD process gives rise to abundant fragment ions, whose deuterium content can be measured as a function of duration of the HDX reaction in solution. No backbone protection is detected for all protein segments spanning the 25-residue long N-terminal part of the protein, which is known to lack structure in solution. At the same time, noticeable protection is evident for segments representing the structured regions of the protein. The results of this work suggest that ETD of intact protein ions is not accompanied by detectable hydrogen scrambling and can be used in tandem with HDX to probe protein conformation in solution.

Electron Transfer Dissociation of Amide Nitrogen Methylated Polypeptide Cations

Unmodified and amide nitrogen methylated peptide cations were reacted with azobenzene radical anions to study the utility of electron transfer dissociation (ETD) in analyzing N-methylated peptides. We show that methylation of the amide nitrogen has no deleterious effects on the ETD process. As a result, location of alkylation on amide nitrogens should be straightforward. Such a modification might be expected to affect the ETD process if hydrogen bonding involving the amide hydrogen is important for the ETD mechanism. The partitioning of the ion/ion reaction products into all of the various reaction channels was determined and compared for modified and unmodified peptide cations. While subtle differences in the relative abundances of the various ETD channels were observed, there is no strong evidence that hydrogen bonding involving the amide nitrogen plays an important role in the ETD process.

Characterization of glycopeptides by combining collision‐induced dissociation and electron‐transfer dissociation mass spectrometry data

Structural characterization of a glycopeptide is not easily attained through collision-induced dissociation (CID), due to the extensive fragmentation of glycan moieties and minimal fragmentation of peptide backbones. In this study, we have exploited the potential of electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) as a complementary approach for peptide fragmentation. Model glycoproteins, including ribonuclease B, fetuin, horseradish peroxidase, and haptoglobin, were used here. In ETD, radical anions transfer an electron to the peptide backbone and induce cleavage of the N-Calpha bond. The glycan moiety is retained on the peptide backbone, being largely unaffected by the ETD process. Accordingly, ETD allows not only the identification of the amino acid sequence of a glycopeptide, but also the unambiguous assignment of its glycosylation site. When data acquired from both fragmentation techniques are combined, it is possible to characterize comprehensively the entire glycopeptide. This is being achieved with a mass spectrometer capable of alternating between CID and ETD on-the-fly during an LC/MS/MS analysis. This is demonstrated here with several tryptic glycopeptides.

Charge-dependent dissociation of insulin cations via ion/ion electron transfer

The dissociation reactions of various charge states of insulin cations obtained directly from nano-electrospray were investigated as a result of ion/ion electron transfer from azobenzene anions. Data were collected with and without simultaneous ion trap collisional excitation of the first generation charge-reduced product during the ion/ion reaction period. Neither separation of the two constituent chains nor cleavages within the loop defined by the disulfide bridges were observed under normal electron transfer dissociation (ETD) conditions for any of the charge states studied. However, substantial sequence coverage (exocyclic region: 82.6%; entire protein: 38.8%) outside the ring structure was obtained for insulin +6, while only limited coverage (exocyclic: 43.5%; entire protein: 20.4%) was observed for insulin +5 and no dissociation, aside from low abundance side-chain losses, was noted for insulin +4 and +3 in the normal ETD spectra. When the first generation charge-reduced precursor ions were subjected to collisional activation during the ion/ion reaction period, higher sequence coverages were obtained for both insulin +5 (entire protein: 34.7%) and +4 (entire protein: 20.4%) with backbone cleavages occurring within the loop defined by the disulfide bonds. Dissociation of insulin +3 was not significantly improved by the additional activation. Separation of the two constituent chains resulting from cleavages of both of the two disulfide bridges that link the chains was observed for insulin +6, +5, and +4 when the charge-reduced species were activated. The dissociation of disulfide linkages in this study suggests that as the charge state decreases, disulfide bond cleavages dominate over N–Cα bond cleavages in the electron transfer dissociation process.