Abstract Direct current (DC) electrical resistivity is a common laboratory soil characterization method to support geotechnical infrastructure design and to supplement site investigations. The complex electrical resistivity method has the potential to provide additional electrical soil properties to enhance electrical soil characterization. Both methods are conventionally performed under fully saturated soil conditions; however, many environments exist where soil is not fully saturated, such as ballast structure supporting railways. In this study, a new experimental setup featuring a current enhancing agent (agar) for complex electrical resistivity testing is evaluated by testing five different soil specimens reconstituted at saturated and unsaturated conditions. Results showed that the new experimental setup is valid and can be used to obtain repeat measurements, particularly for specimens reconstituted in the unsaturated conditions where the traditional DC electrical resistivity setup yields results that are unreliable. This is one of the very few studies where tolerances for triplicate specimens are reported to establish differences in measurements from sample preparation versus discernable variability between different geomaterials. Additionally, all results are supported by a Cole-Cole model. The results show that the additional data collected in a complex electrical resistivity test can be used to differentiate different soil types that are ambiguous with the DC electrical resistivity method. The additional data have the potential to more fully characterize the electrical properties of saturated and unsaturated soils, as well as to help distinguish unique geophysical signatures of various geomaterials to enhance a geophysical site investigation for identifying soil variability in the subsurface.