The failure assessment diagram (FAD) is a widely used tool for evaluating the fracture acceptance of structural components. In addition to linear elastic fracture mechanics, elastic-plastic fracture mechanics, and limit load analysis, the ASME Code incorporated FAD as an alternative safety evaluation method for flaws in nuclear pipes starting from 2004 edition. This paper conducts a series of finite element elastic-plastic fracture mechanics analyses to establish the specific J–based FAD curves considering various loading and geometry conditions for ferritic pipes containing various circumferential flaws. By comparing with the suggested FAD of ASME Code Section XI - Appendix H, it is found that the radius-to-thickness ratio of pipes and the flaw depth influence the applicability of FAD, but with minor effects of crack length. In addition, the effects of material properties between base metal and weld materials on FAD are also discussed. The result of this work could be a reference when applying the FAD to evaluate the flawed piping for nuclear power plants.