A comparison of the results of the Born and impulse approximations for a well-defined situation is made by calculating the nucleon-deuteron differential elastic cross sections in both approximations at incident nucleon laboratory energies of 32, 94, and 146 Mev. In order to carry out the impulse approximation computation in complete detail, including, in particular, contributions from off- energy-shell two-particle matrix elements, the assumption is made that the two- particle scattering is completely described by effective range theory. This assumption, though incorrect, nevertheless retains some of the features of the actuai physical situation and provides a means of comparing the results of calculations using the impulse approximation and the Born approximation as well as a way of studying the effect of including two-particle matrix elements off the energy shell. Exact solutions to the two-particle model are written down with the aid of the Gel'fand-Levitan theory and are used in a precise numerical evaluation of the impulse approximation expressions. The results of the Born and impulse approximations differ considerably. Also, indications are that, as expected, the pickup term (which dominates at large angles) is not adequately treated by either of the above approximations. When this term is not considered, a study ofmore » the remaining expressions shows that off-energy-shell effects are significant for the deuteron wave functions employed. In view of the rather restrictive assumptions made on the twoparticle data, a detailed comparison of the results with experiment is not possible. Nevertheless, there is a suggestion that the impulse approximation, including offenergy-shell effects, describes the experimental results best. (auth)« less
Read full abstract