Recycling production waste in the reactive injection molding (RIM) process is a step towards sustainability and efficient material usage. The recycled thermoset composite (RTC) material obtained by shredding the production waste is reused with a virgin thermoset composite (VTC). This study presents a mold-filling simulation approach considering this polydisperse suspension of RTC and VTC. Mold-filling simulations can assist in predicting processability and assessing the impact of reinforced RTC on the final part of production. State-of-the-art mold-filling simulations use the Cross-Castro-Macosko (CCM) model or anisotropic fiber-orientation-dependent viscosity models. The rheological parameters are determined either for the VTC or neat resin. However, these models do not account for changes in viscosity due to the reinforcing of fillers such as RTC. An effective viscosity model is developed by extending the CCM model using the stress-strain amplification approach to overcome this gap. This model is implemented in the computational fluid dynamics code OpenFOAM, and simulations are performed using an extended multiphase solver. To validate the simulations, experimental trials were executed using a two-cavity mold equipped with pressure sensors. Molding compounds with different compositions of VTC and RTC were injected at different speeds. Reinforcing VTC with RTC increases the viscosity. Results demonstrate that RTC-reinforced compounds require higher injection pressure for mold filling than VTC alone. The qualitative agreement of pressure profiles from simulations and experiments for different proportions of reinforcing RTC and different injection speeds shows that the implemented viscosity model can reproduce the experimental mold-filling behavior.