Abstract Paraoesophageal hernias (PEH) are often symptomatic and can lead to life-threatening complications including volvulus and ischaemia. Dyspnoea was recently reported as the most prevalent symptom of giant PEHs, although it has been perceived by some as a contraindication to surgery. The aim of this study is to evaluate the effect of surgery on resolution of dyspnoea amongst patients with giant hiatus hernia defined as greater than 30% of the stomach above the diaphragm. Data were extracted from a prospectively maintained single-surgeon database containing records of patients undergoing composite hernia repair. Patients who underwent standardised composite laparoscopic repair of giant PEH without mesh prosthesis between March 2009 and December 2015 and had documented dyspnoea were included. Patients were reviewed post-operatively at 6 weeks, 3 months, 12 months, and then annually unless more frequent visits were clinically indicated. The primary outcome of the analysis was the difference in patient-reported pre-operative and post-operative dyspnoea. Secondary outcomes included differences in pre-operative and post-operative dysphagia and clinical aspiration as well as recurrence of PEH of any size. Inclusion criteria were met by 154 patients. There were 127 females (82.5%) and 27 males (17.5%). The average age at time of operation was 71.2 years (range 49–93, SD 9.66). The average hernia size was 64%, based on intraoperative evaluation by the surgeon (range 30–100%, SD 20.2). After surgery, there was a significant improvement in all symptoms: dyspnoea (100% pre-operatively, 2.6% post-operatively, P¬ < 0.001), dysphagia (46.1% pre-operatively, 15.6% post-operatively, P < 0.001) and clinical aspiration (9.1% pre-operatively, 1.3% post-operatively, P = 0.002). Hernia recurrence was found in 37 patients (24.0%) amongst whom dyspnoea was rare (5.4%, 2 patients). This study suggests that dyspnoea resolves following laparoscopic repair of giant paraoesophageal hernia. This may be explained by the effect of surgical repair on improving hernia-related atrial compression, pulmonary congestion and reduced lung capacities. The presence of dyspnoea should be regarded as an indication rather than a barrier to surgery. Therefore, we recommend all patients with giant hiatus hernia to be assessed by a specialist surgical service.
Read full abstract