Effective Theory Of Gravity Research Articles

Spinning binary dynamics in cubic effective field theories of gravity

We study the binary dynamics of two Kerr black holes with arbitrary spin vectors in the presence of parity-even and parity-odd cubic deformations of gravity. We first derive the tree-level Compton amplitudes for a Kerr black hole in cubic gravity, which we then use to compute the two-to-two amplitudes of the massive bodies to leading order in the deformation and the post-Minkowskian expansion. The required one-loop computations are performed using the leading singularity approach as well as the heavy-mass effective field theory (HEFT) approach. These amplitudes are then used to compute the leading-order momentum and spin kick in cubic gravity in the KMOC formalism. Our results are valid for generic masses and spin vectors, and include all the independent parity-even and parity-odd cubic deformations of Einstein-Hilbert gravity. We also present spin-expanded expressions for the momentum and spin kicks, and the all-order in spin deflection angle in the case of aligned spins.

Aspects of non-topological soliton stars in a class of induced gravity theories

We explore some interesting properties of soliton stars arising in a class of effective gravity theories having a Higgs scalar field that serves a dual role of generating an effective mass of a fermion field as well as generating an effective gravitational constant. With a suitable choice of non-minimal coupling, such solitons have the canonical effective gravitational constant in their exterior while in the interior the effective gravitational constant could be arbitrarily smaller. Such a choice enables an exact determination of gravitational effects on the total conserved energy of the soliton. While the external metric of such a soliton is the standard Schwarzschild metric, the interior entropy is much larger than that of a black hole of the same equilibrium temperature.

Effective field theory of black hole perturbations in vector-tensor gravity

We formulate the effective field theory (EFT) of vector-tensor gravity for perturbations around an arbitrary background with a timelike vector profile, which can be applied to study black hole perturbations. The vector profile spontaneously breaks both the time diffeomorphism and the U(1) symmetry, leaving their combination and the spatial diffeomorphism as the residual symmetries in the unitary gauge. We derive two sets of consistency relations which guarantee the residual symmetries of the EFT. Also, we provide the dictionary between our EFT coefficients and those of generalized Proca (GP) theories, which enables us to identify a simple subclass of the EFT that includes the GP theories as a special case. For this subclass, we consider the stealth Schwarzschild(-de Sitter) background solution with a constant temporal component of the vector field and study the decoupling limit of the longitudinal mode of the vector field, explicitly showing that the strong coupling problem arises due to vanishing sound speeds. This is in sharp contrast to the case of gauged ghost condensate, in which perturbations are weakly coupled thanks to certain higher-derivative terms, i.e., the scordatura terms. This implies that, in order to consistently describe this type of stealth solutions within the EFT, the scordatura terms must necessarily be taken into account in addition to those already included in the simple subclass.

Spherical collapse in scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity: Taming ill-posedness with a Ricci coupling

We study spherical collapse of a scalar cloud in scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity—a theory in which black holes can develop scalar hair if they are in a certain mass range. We show that an additional quadratic coupling of the scalar field to the Ricci scalar can mitigate loss of hyperbolicity problems that have plagued previous numerical collapse studies and instead lead to well-posed evolution. This suggests that including specific additional interactions can be a successful strategy for tackling well-posedness problems in effective field theories of gravity with nonminimally coupled scalars. Our simulations also show that spherical collapse leads to black holes with scalar hair when their mass is below a mass threshold and above a minimum mass bound and that above the mass threshold, the collapse leads to black holes without hair, in line with results in the static case and perturbative analyses. For masses below the minimum mass bound, we find that the scalar cloud smoothly dissipates, leaving behind flat space. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Gravitational waves on charged black hole backgrounds in modified gravity

The stability of Reissner–Nördstrom black holes with an extremal mass–charge relation was determined by calculating the propagation speed of gravitational waves on this background in an effective field theory (EFT) of gravity. New results for metric components are shown, along with the corresponding new extremal relation, part of which differs by a global factor of 2 from the past published work. This new relation further develops the existing constraints on EFT parameters. The radial propagation speed for gravitational waves in the Regge–Wheeler gauge was calculated linearly for all perturbations, yielding exact luminality for all dimension-4 operators. The dimension-6 radial speed modifications introduce no constraints on the sign of the modified theory parameters from causality arguments, while the deviation from classical theories vanishes at both horizons. The angular speed was found to be altered for the dimension-4 operators, with possible new constraints on the modified theory being suggested from causality arguments. Results are consistent with existing literature on Schwarzschild black hole backgrounds, with some EFT terms becoming active only in non-vacuum spacetimes such as Reissner–Nördstrom black holes.

On-shell operator construction in the effective field theory of gravity

We construct the on-shell amplitude basis and the corresponding effective operators for generic modified gravity theory, such as pure gravity with higher derivatives, scalar-tensor gravity, Einstein-Yang-Mills, etc. Taking the Weyl tensor as the building block, we utilize the Young tensor technique to obtain independent operators, without equation of motion and total derivative redundancies. We update our algorithm and vastly increase the speed for finding the monomial basis (m-basis) of effective operators expressed in terms of Weyl tensors with Lorentz indices, the familiar form for the General Relativity community. Finally, we obtain the complete and independent amplitude and operator basis for GRSMEFT and GRLEFT up to mass dimension 10.

Quantum effects of the conformal anomaly in a 2D model of gravitational collapse

The macroscopic effects of the quantum conformal anomaly are evaluated in a simplified two-dimensional model of gravitational collapse. The effective action and stress tensor of the anomaly can be expressed in a local quadratic form by the introduction of a scalar conformalon field φ, which satisfies a linear wave equation. A wide class of non-vacuum initial state conditions is generated by different solutions of this equation. An interesting subclass of solutions corresponds to initial states that give rise to an arbitrarily large semi-classical stress tensor leftlangle {T}_{mu}^{nu}rightrangle on the future horizon of the black hole formed in classical collapse. These lead to modification and suppression of Hawking radiation at late times after the collapse, and potentially large backreaction effects on the horizon scale due to the conformal anomaly. The probability of non-vacuum initial conditions large enough to produce these effects is estimated from the Gaussian vacuum wave functional of φ in the Schrödinger representation and shown to be mathcal{O} (1). These results indicate that quantum effects of the conformal anomaly in non-vacuum states are relevant for gravitational collapse in the effective theory of gravity in four dimensions as well.

A Note on Modular Invariant Species Scale and Potentials

AbstractThe species scale provides an upper bound for the ultraviolet cutoff of effective theories of gravity coupled to a number of light particle species. Modular invariant (super‐)potentials provide a simple and computable expression of the species scale as a function of the moduli in toroidal orbifold compactifications of type II and heterotic string are pointed out. Due t o modular symmetry, these functions are valid over all moduli space and not only in asymptotic regions. Additive logarithmic corrections to the species scale arise from the requirement that the latter be modular invariant are observed. The moduli‐dependent expression of the species scale in terms of the gravitino mass or the scalar potential of these models are recasted and swampland conjectures such as the anti‐de Sitter distance conjecture and the gravitino conjecture are connected.

A proposal for 3d quantum gravity and its bulk factorization

Recent progress in AdS/CFT has provided a good understanding of how the bulk spacetime is encoded in the entanglement structure of the boundary CFT. However, little is known about how spacetime emerges directly from the bulk quantum theory. We address this question in an effective 3d quantum theory of pure gravity, which describes the high temperature regime of a holographic CFT. This theory can be viewed as a q-deformation and dimensional uplift of JT gravity. Using this model, we show that the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of a two-sided black hole equals the bulk entanglement entropy of gravitational edge modes. In the conventional Chern-Simons description, these black holes correspond to Wilson lines in representations of PSL(2, ℝ) ⨂ PSL(2, ℝ). We show that the correct calculation of gravitational entropy suggests we should interpret the bulk theory as an extended topological quantum field theory associated to the quantum semi-group {textrm{SL}}_q^{+}left(2,mathbb{R}right)bigotimes {textrm{SL}}_q^{+}left(2,mathbb{R}right) . Our calculation suggests an effective description of bulk microstates in terms of collective, anyonic degrees of freedom whose entanglement leads to the emergence of the bulk spacetime.

Higher derivative contributions to black hole thermodynamics at NNLO

In an effective theory of gravity, thermodynamic quantities of black holes receive corrections from the infinite series of higher derivative terms. At the next to leading order, these can be obtained by using only the leading order solution. In this paper, we push forward this property to the next to next to leading order. We propose a formula which yields the Euclidean action of asymptotically flat black holes at the next to next to leading order using only the solution up to and including the next to leading order. Other conserved quantities are derived from the Euclidean action via standard thermodynamic relation. We verify our formula in examples of D-dimensional pure gravity and Einstein-Maxwell theory extended by 4- and 6-derivative terms. Based on our formula, we also prove that for asymptotically flat black holes, the physical quantities are invariant under field redefinitions.

New framework to study unmodeled physics from gravitational wave data

A confident discovery of physics beyond what has been consistently modeled from gravitational wave (GW) data requires a technique that can distinguish between noise artifacts and unmodeled signatures while also shedding light on the underlying physics. We propose a new data analysis method, \texttt{SCoRe} (Structured Correlated Residual), to search for unmodeled physics in the GW data which can cover both of these aspects. The method searches for structure in the cross-correlation power spectrum of the residual strain between pairs of GW detectors. It does so by projecting this power spectrum onto a frequency-dependent template. The template may be model-independent or model-dependent and is constructed based on the properties of the GW source parameters. The projection of the residual strain enables the distinction between noise artifacts and any true signal while capturing possible dependence on the GW source parameters. Our method is constructed in a Bayesian framework and we have shown its application on a model-independent toy example and for a model motivated by an effective field theory of gravity. The method developed here will be useful to search for a large variety of new physics and yet-to-be-modeled known physics in the GW data accessible from the current network of LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA detectors and from future earth- and space-based GW detectors such as A+, LISA, Cosmic Explorer, and Einstein Telescope.

General effective field theory of teleparallel gravity

We construct the effective field theory (EFT) of the teleparallel equivalent of general relativity (TEGR). Firstly, we present the necessary field redefinitions of the scalar field and the tetrads. Then we provide all the terms at next-to-leading-order, containing the torsion tensor and its derivatives, and derivatives of the scalar field, accompanied by generic scalar-field-dependent couplings, where all operators are suppressed by a scale Λ. Removing all redundant terms using the field redefinitions we result to the EFT of TEGR, which includes significantly more terms comparing to the EFT of general relativity (GR). Finally, we present an application in a cosmological framework. Interestingly enough, although GR and TEGR are completely equivalent at the level of classical equations, we find that their corresponding EFTs possess minor but non-zero differences. Hence, we do verify that at higher energies the excitation and the features of the extra degrees of freedom are slightly different in the two theories, thus making them theoretically distinguishable. Nevertheless, we mention that these differences are suppressed by the heavy mass scale Λ and thus it is not guaranteed that they could be measured in future experiments and observations.

Negative scalar potentials and the swampland: an Anti-Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture

In this paper, we derive a characterisation of negative scalar potentials, V < 0, in d-dimensional effective theories of quantum gravity. This is achieved thanks to an Anti-Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (ATCC), inspired by a refined version of the TCC. The ATCC relies on the fact that in a contracting universe, modes that become sub-Planckian in length violate the validity of the effective theory. In the asymptotics of field space, we deduce that −V′/V ≥ c0 when V′ ≥ 0. The rate {c}_0=2/sqrt{left(d-1right)left(d-2right)} is successfully tested in several string compactifications for d ≥ 4. In addition, a new asymptotic condition, V′′/V ≥ {c}_0^2 , is derived. By extrapolation to anti-de Sitter solutions of radius l, we infer the existence of a scalar whose mass should obey m2l2 ≲ −2. This property is verified in many supersymmetric examples.

Estimating global charge violating amplitudes from wormholes

We consider the scattering of high energy and ultra relativistic spherically symmetric shells in asymptotically AdSD spacetimes. We analyze an exclusive amplitude where a single spherically symmetric shell goes in and a single one comes out, such that the two have different global symmetry charges of the effective gravity theory. We study a simple wormhole configuration that computes the square of the amplitude and analyze its properties.

The criteria of the anisotropic quark star models in Rastall gravity

Quark stars are terrestrial laboratories to study fundamental physics at ultrahigh densities and temperatures. In this work, we investigate the internal structure and the physical properties of quark stars (QSs) in the Rastall gravity. Rastall gravity is considered a non-conservative theory of gravity, which is an effective gravity theory at high energy density, e.g., relevant to the early universe and dense, compact objects. We derive the hydrostatic equilibrium structure for QSs with the inclusion of anisotropic pressure. More specifically, we find the QS mass–radius relations for the MIT bag model. We focus on the model depending on the Rastall free parameter η and examine the deviations from the General Relativity (GR) counterparts.

A statistical field theory underlying the thermodynamics of Ricci flow and gravity

This paper proposes a statistical field theory of quantum reference frame underlying Perelman’s analogies between his formalism of the Ricci flow and the thermodynamics. The theory is based on a [Formula: see text] quantum nonlinear sigma model (NLSM), interpreted as a quantum reference frame system which a to-be-studied quantum system is relative to. The statistic physics and thermodynamics of the quantum frame fields is studied by the density matrix obtained by the Gaussian approximation quantization. The induced Ricci flow of the frame fields and the Ricci–DeTurck flow of the frame fields associated with the density matrix are deduced. In this framework, the diffeomorphism anomaly of the theory has a deep thermodynamic interpretation. The trace anomaly is related to a Shannon entropy in terms of the density matrix, which monotonically flows and achieves its maximal value at the flow limit, called the Gradient Shrinking Ricci Soliton (GSRS), corresponding to a thermal equilibrium state of spacetime. A relative Shannon entropy with respect to the maximal entropy gives a statistical interpretation to Perelman’s partition function, which is also monotonic and gives an analogous H-theorem to the statistical frame fields system. A temporal static three-space of a GSRS four-spacetime is also a GSRS in lower three-dimension, we find that it is in a thermal equilibrium state, and Perelman’s analogies between his formalism and the thermodynamics of the frame fields in equilibrium can be explicitly given in the framework. By extending the validity of the Equivalence Principle to the quantum level, the quantum reference frame fields theory at low energy gives an effective theory of gravity, a scale-dependent Einstein–Hilbert action plus a cosmological constant is recovered. As a possible underlying microscopic theory of the gravitational system, the theory is also applied to understand the thermodynamics of the Schwarzschild black hole.

Gravity as a Quantum Field Theory

Classical gravity is understood as the geometry of spacetime, and it seems very different from the other known interactions. In this review, I will instead stress the analogies: Like strong interactions, the low energy effective field theory of gravity is related to a nonlinearly realized symmetry, and like electroweak interactions, it is a gauge theory in Higgs phase, with a massive connection. I will also discuss the possibility of finding a UV complete quantum field theoretic description of all interactions.

Modified Starobinsky inflation by the R ln (□) R term

In the context of effective theories of gravity, a minimalist bottom-up approach which takes into account 1-loop quantum corrections leads to modifications in the Einstein-Hilbert action through the inclusion of four extra terms: R 2, CκραβCκραβ , R ln (□) R and Cκραβ ln(□) Cκραβ . The first two terms are necessary to guarantee the renormalizability of the gravitational theory, and the last two terms (nonlocal terms) arise from the integration of massless/light matter fields. This work aims to analyze how one of the nonlocal terms, namely R ln(□) R, affects the Starobinsky inflation. We consider the nonlocal term as a small correction to the R 2 term, and we demonstrate that the model behaves like a local model in this context. In addition, we show that the approximate model in the Einstein frame is described by a canonical scalar field minimally coupled to general relativity. Finally, we study the inflationary regime of this model and constrain its free parameters through observations of CMB anisotropies.

The effective theory of gravity and dynamical vacuum energy

Gravity and general relativity are considered as an Effective Field Theory (EFT) at low energies and macroscopic distances. The effective action of the conformal anomaly of light or massless quantum fields has significant effects on macroscopic scales, due to associated light cone singularities that are not captured by an expansion in local curvature invariants. A compact local form for the Wess-Zumino effective action of the conformal anomaly and stress tensor is given, requiring the introduction of a new light scalar field, which it is argued should be included in the low energy effective action for gravity. This scalar conformalon couples to the conformal part of the spacetime metric and allows the effective value of the vacuum energy, described as a condensate of an exact 4-form abelian gauge field strength F = dA, to change in space and time. This is achieved by the identification of the torsion dependent part of the Chern-Simons 3-form of the Euler class with the gauge potential A, which enters the effective action of the conformal anomaly as a J · A interaction analogous to electromagnetism. The conserved 3-current J describes the worldtube of 2-surfaces that separate regions of differing vacuum energy. The resulting EFT thus replaces the fixed constant Λ of classical gravity, and its apparently unnaturally large sensitivity to UV physics, with a dynamical condensate whose ground state value in empty flat space is Λeff = 0 identically. By allowing Λeff to vary rapidly near the 2-surface of a black hole horizon, the proposed EFT of dynamical vacuum energy provides an effective Lagrangian framework for gravitational condensate stars, as the final state of complete gravitational collapse consistent with quantum theory. The possible consequences of dynamical vacuum dark energy for cosmology, the cosmic coincidence problem, and the role of conformal invariance for other fine tuning issues in the Standard Model are discussed.

Searching for gravity without a metric

Recently it has been explicitly shown how a theory with global $GL(d,\mathbb{R})$ coordinate (affine) invariance which is spontaneously broken down to its Lorentz subgroup will have as its Goldstone fields enough degrees of freedom to create a metric and a covariant derivative arXiv:1105.5848. Such a theory would constitute an effective theory of gravity. So far however, no explicit theory has been found which exhibits this symmetry breaking pattern, mainly due to the difficulty of even writing down a $GL(d,\mathbb{R})$ invariant actions in the absence of a metric. In this paper we explicitly construct an affine generalization of the Dirac action employing infinite dimensional spinorial representations of the group. This implies that it is built from an infinite number of spinor Lorentz multiplets. We introduce a systematic procedure for obtaining $GL(d,\mathbb{R})$ invariant interaction terms to obtain quite general interacting models. Such models have order operators whose expectation value can break affine symmetry to Poincar\'{e} symmetry. We discuss possible interactions and mechanisms for this symmetry breaking to occur, which would provide a dynamical explanation of the Lorentzian signature of spacetime.