Educational Practice Research Articles

Perceptions and usage of AI chatbots among students in higher education across genders, academic levels and fields of study

AI chatbots have ignited discussions and controversies about their impact on teaching and learning practices in higher education. This study explores students’ adoption and perceptions of ChatGPT and other AI chatbots in higher education. Based on survey data from a large sample (n=5,894) across Swedish universities, the study employs descriptive statistical methods to analyze usage, attitudes, and concerns, and inferential statistics to identify relations between attitudes and usage and background variables (gender, academic level, and field of study). The results reveal broad awareness and use of ChatGPT among students, but not of other AI chatbots. More than half of the students expressed positive attitudes towards the use of chatbots in education, but almost as many expressed concerns about future use. Statistically significant differences were found across all examined grouping variables, particularly between genders and fields of study. Female students and students from the humanities and medicine consistently expressed more negative attitudes and concerns about AI's role in learning and assessment, while males and technology and engineering students showed higher usage and optimism. These findings not only validate the continued relevance of student backgrounds as a determinant of technology adoption but also expose several challenges and considerations surrounding AI and chatbot usage in education. The study supports the development of local solutions to AI in education tailored to student attributes and needs, and it provides insights for developers, educators, and policymakers.

Accommodating Learners: An Adaptive Approach to Surgical Hand Preparation With Crutches

Accommodations for injured and disabled surgical providers have to balance an individual's needs with measures that ensure sterility requirements, patient and provider safety. The highly specialized nature of the surgical environment poses challenges when implementing changes in the operating room and literature is limited on adaptive surgical hand preparation techniques necessary to maximize a disabled medical student's active participation in their surgical clerkship. This paper presents a detailed account of the development and implementation of an adaptive surgical hand preparation designed to address mobility needs, enabling a student's active participation and education in the surgical curriculum. This offers a framework for adapting traditional surgical hand preparation techniques for crutches consisting of essential requirements in terms of equipment and personnel, step-by-step guide for implementation, discussion of potential risks related to contamination and safety, and a discussion on future directions for further innovation. An adaptive surgical hand preparation technique was necessary to sterilize forearm crutches for a third-year medical student with a physical disability to ensure accessibility in the operating room and equity in surgical clerkship and medical education. Successful use of this protocol, in over 40 surgical cases throughout an 8-week surgical clerkship, created opportunity for a disabled medical student to access the sterile operating table through collaboration and innovation in the operating room. The adaptive hand preparation and sterile crutch cover solution was necessary for the student to assist in open, laparoscopic, and surgical procedures resulting in high clinical performance marks in the surgical clerkship. Beyond the individual benefit, this protocol promotes the importance of equity in medication education and encourages diversity through adaptive measures in the surgical field. Designing an adaptive sterilization protocol for use of crutches in the operating room serves as an example of educational engineering and adaptable accessibility. The entire collaborative effort involving the medical student, university, surgical providers and operating room staff demonstrates the importance of teamwork in creating access in healthcare settings. Through learned experience, the authors provide insights for future directions for innovation, aiming to enhance access and inclusivity in medical education and surgical practice. This paper reflects on the broader implications of educational engineering and inclusive practices in healthcare.

A deep learning algorithm that aids visualization of femoral neck fractures and improves physician training

PurposeMissed fractures are the most common radiologic error in clinical practice, and erroneous classification could lead to inappropriate treatment and unfavorable prognosis. Here, we developed a fully automated deep learning model to detect and classify femoral neck fractures using plain radiographs, and evaluated its utility for diagnostic assistance and physician training. Methods1527 plain pelvic and hip radiographs obtained between April 2014 and July 2023 at our Hospital were selected for the model training and evaluation. Faster R-CNN was used to locate the femoral neck. DenseNet-121 was used for Garden classification of the femoral neck fracture, while an additional segmentation method used to visualize the probable fracture area. The model was assessed by the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC). The accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity for clinicians fracture detection in the diagnostic assistance and physician training experiments were determined. ResultsThe accuracy of the model for fracture detection was 94.1%. The model achieved AUCs of 0.99 for no femoral neck fractures, 0.94 for Garden I/II fractures, and 0.99 for Garden III/IV fractures. In the diagnostic assistance study, the emergency physicians had an average accuracy of 86.33% unaided and 92.03% aided, sensitivity of 85.94% unaided and 91.78% aided, and specificity of 87.88% unaided and 93.13% aided in detecting fractures. In the physician training study, the accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity of the trainees for fracture classification were 81.83%, 77.28%, and 84.85%, respectively, before training, compared with 90.65%, 88.31%, and 92.21%, respectively, after training. ConclusionsThe model represents a valuable tool for physicians to better visualize fractures and improve training outcomes, indicating deep learning algorithms as a promising approach to improve clinical practice and medical education.

Educational Sustainability Initiatives in Higher Education: An Integrative Approach to Urban Areas in northwestern Portugal

This paper explores the integration of sustainability and climate change education within Higher Education (HE), emphasizing the societal impact of such initiatives. Through a comprehensive analysis of various educational projects conducted between 2020 and 2024 in Portugal, the research highlights the critical role of education in fostering sustainable development and resilience to Climate Change (CC). Utilizing a participatory-based methodology, including the TIP (Territory, Intervention, Proposal) model, the study involved collaboration among students, experts, and local stakeholders to address urban and environmental challenges. The findings underscore the importance of embedding sustainability into educational frameworks to equip students with the necessary knowledge and skills to tackle complex environmental issues. Moreover, the projects demonstrated how HE institutions can act as catalysts for societal change, aligning with Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and promoting a multidisciplinary approach. Future research should focus on evaluating the long-term impacts of these educational practices on fostering sustainable behaviors in young people and local communities, crucial agents of change in the face of climate change.

Immersive virtual reality aggression and violence management education for nursing students: A pre-test, post-test, follow-up evaluation

BackgroundNursing students attending clinical placement encounter similar exposure to aggression and violence as qualified clinicians. Universities encounter barriers in aggression and violence management education delivery due to resourcing and time requirements. Immersive Virtual Reality (IVR) education may reduce barriers while maintaining comparable learning outcomes to face-to-face simulation-based education. MethodNursing students (n = 72), recruited from one public university in Perth, Western Australia, completed a 15-20 minute IVR education program. Pre-, post-, and 4-month post-intervention questionnaires investigated self-reported confidence. Cross-sectional data were collected for system usability and motion sickness. ResultsSignificant differences in self-reported confidence were observed (p < .001, partial η2 = 0.53), with large improvements from pre- to post-intervention (p < .001, d = 1.21) and follow-up (p < .001, d = 1.25). Cross-sectional data indicated the program is easy to use and incurs negligible motion sickness. ConclusionIVR can deliver effective aggression and violence education for nursing students. The short duration, high usability, and persistence of confidence improvements over time indicate potential for IVR to support current nursing education practices.

ПРАКТИКА ФОРМУВАННЯ ЕСТЕТИЧНОЇ КУЛЬТУРИ ТА ЕСТЕТИЧНОЇ КОМПЕТЕНТНОСТІ СТУДЕНТІВ

Today, the processes of forming aesthetic culture and aesthetic competence are becoming increasingly relevant for future specialists in higher education institutions due to the fact that the individual integrative qualities contribute to the comprehensive development of a personality, in particular its spiritual values, which are the basis for a harmonious lifestyle in society. The purpose of the article. Summarizing the research of predecessors in the correlation of the practice of forming aesthetic culture and aesthetic competence of students in higher education institutions in terms of outlining the dominant forms, teaching methods, and pedagogical technologies. The study used a set of the following methods, such as analysis, systematization, generalization of scientific sources, and comparison. Results of the study. The following scientific achievements were analyzed and summarized: A. Karam, H. Sotska, L. Hlazunova, L. Kyrychenko, M. Biletska, M. Necheporenko, S. Dudiaha, Sintin Liu, T. Pidvarko, Y. Shevchenko and Y. Sopina. The formation of aesthetic culture and aesthetic students’ competence involves the aestheticization of the educational environment and requires the use of a set educational components and specific courses, educational and production practices, extracurricular activities, forms, methods of teaching, and pedagogical technologies. Conclusions. Among the forms of training are the following: lecture; seminar and practical classes; practices; conferences; conduct curatorial hours; consultations; subject olympiads; clubs; museum and artist workshops visits; organization and conduct art exhibitions, arts events, round-table discussions; theatrical activity; local lore exploratory expeditions; groups of interest; master classes; reading days; oral journal; distant travels; press conferences; competitions; exhibitions of creative works; aesthetic atelier; scientific association sessions. Teaching methods include: modeling of moral and aesthetic situations; conversational interaction; gaming; creative assignment solutions; crush trouble; dispute; discussion; training; individual and collective discourse; self-reflection and self-esteem methods; microteaching and portfolios. There are dominant pedagogical technologies: problem-based and project-based learning, training, game simulation, and case-technology. Key words: aesthetic culture, aesthetic competence, education, students, forms, methods, pedagogical technologies.

Challenges and Solutions in Teaching Writing to Azerbaijani Learners of English

This study explores the challenges and potential solutions in teaching English writing to Azerbaijani learners, focusing on linguistic, cultural, and pedagogical factors that impact writing proficiency. Through a mixed-methods approach involving surveys, interviews, and classroom observations, the research identifies key difficulties such as grammatical errors, rhetorical differences, and the influence of educational practices. The study also highlights effective strategies, including process-oriented writing activities and culturally responsive teaching methods, which enhance both writing skills and learner engagement. Despite the valuable insights, limitations such as sample size and the focus on short-term outcomes suggest the need for further research, particularly in exploring long-term impacts and the role of digital tools in writing instruction.

Exploring alternative practice placement models in occupational therapy and physiotherapy: perspectives and experiences of learners and practice educators: a qualitative systematic review

AbstractWithin physiotherapy and occupational therapy practice placements, there is a predominance of the one-to-one supervision model which creates limitations for placement capacity expansion. Alternative placement models must be explored to meet training requirements for these professions and ensure the availability of a future workforce. The aim of this review is to explore the experiences and perceptions of practice educators and learners regarding alternative placement models, to inform future planning and the adoption of these opportunities. This qualitative systematic review followed the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology. A comprehensive search was conducted across six databases (CINAHL, MEDLINE, PubMed, Scopus, ERIC, PsycINFO), covering the period from January 2010 to December 2022. Meta-aggregation was used to synthesise the findings from the included studies. A total of 16 articles were included within this review. The learner voice was represented in 14 categories aggregated to five synthesised findings: professional growth and development, personal and psychological adaptation, alliances within collaborative learning, educational and learning process, and managing professional relationships. The practice educator voice was represented in 11 categories aggregated into four synthesised findings: providing the right support; professional identity; peer relationships and levels of satisfaction. This review highlights positive aspects associated with skill development, personal growth, and the formation of professional identity following alternative placement experiences. However, it also reveals concerns including uncertainty and anxiety related to role clarity, expectations, and the structure within these environments. This understanding of the perceptions and experiences of both learners and practice educators can inform the development of targeted support and guidance from universities, addressing these challenges and enhancing overall satisfaction. Further adoption of alternative placement models has the potential to expand practice placement capacity for learners offering a promising environment for healthcare education. These models provide learners with invaluable experiences and skills essential for their future careers.

How did educational institutions respond to students with special needs during COVID-19: considerations for policy?

This bibliometric study analyzes the scientific production on the educational response of institutions to families with children with special educational needs (SEN) during the COVID-19 pandemic. The research identifies emerging trends and distinctive characteristics, providing a foundation for improving strategies in schools. The analysis reveals an increase in publications from 2020 to 2023, peaking at 24 articles in 2022. A total of 246 researchers participated, with Castro-Kemp S and McIntyre LL standing out for their productivity and citations. Institutions such as UCL and the University of Oregon led in publications, while the University of California, Santa Barbara, topped the citations. In terms of scientific production, the United States had the most articles, followed by the United Kingdom and Spain. However, the United Kingdom led in global citations, indicating a high level of interest in the topic. The main journals in this field include Frontiers in Education and Education Science. Twelve collaboration networks among authors were identified, with a primary network of seven closely collaborating researchers. The pandemic exacerbated pre-existing difficulties in the education of children with SEN, increasing stress and emotional burden on parents. The transition to home education and the lack of adapted resources presented significant challenges. However, some strategies, such as dialogic literary gatherings and collaboration between schools and families, proved effective in mitigating negative impacts. The study underscores the need for inclusive public policies that address disparities in educational support and prioritize the psychological well-being of children with SEN. It recommends a proactive and equitable approach in school psychology training and educational practice. In conclusion, this analysis provides a solid foundation for future research and improvements in schools, promoting an inclusive and resilient educational environment.

QuPath Edu and OpenMicroanatomy: Open‐source virtual microscopy tools for medical education

AbstractVirtual microscopy is becoming increasingly common in both medical education and routine clinical practice. Virtual microscopy software is typically designed either for (1) training students in anatomy, histology, and histopathology, or (2) quantitative analysis—but not both simultaneously. QuPath is one of the most widely used software applications for histopathology image analysis in research and provides a comprehensive set of computational tools to evaluate histology slides. We have enhanced QuPath by developing a new extension, QuPath Edu, which adapts the software to function as an intuitive microanatomy learning environment. Additionally, we have created an entirely new, complementary software platform called OpenMicroanatomy, which provides an alternative way to access QuPath Edu teaching content through a web interface. These tools have been used in teaching of first year medical and dentistry students at the University of Oulu Medical Faculty, and we conducted a user survey for the Class of 2023 to assess the usability and student experience. In general, the introduced annotation and quiz features were appreciated by the students and the system usability of OpenMicroanatomy was considered excellent (SUS score 84.8). Together, these freely available tools enable teachers to develop and deploy innovative training material for anatomy, histopathology, quantitative analysis, and artificial intelligence in a wide range of contexts. This unique combination can provide the next generation of students with essential multidisciplinary skills.

Computational transformations of early childhood education: Pathways toward child‐centred computing in two educational change projects

AbstractProgramming is becoming a key subject in early education globally, with surging problems of how computer science can become a subject for children of all ages and backgrounds. Problems of implementing new technologies in the old curricula have long been noted, and lately, concern over computer science education goals is often too narrow and skills‐based without concerns for the critical educational potential. This study follows the change process of two case preschool departments implementing programming with a floor robot across a seven‐month design process. Mixed analytical techniques based on activity theory are used to examine the tensions, conflicts and development of pedagogical alternatives. The studies show the strenuous change processes involving local transformations toward a child‐centred, inclusive early computer science education and development of projects centring making, children's exploration, tinkering and play as key parts of the learning process. It discusses how the considerable change processes enabled pedagogical solutions coherent with important concepts in computer programming and how computing education can build on child‐centred pedagogies through local adaptations and age‐appropriate designs. Practitioner notesWhat is already known about this topic Computer science and programming are becoming part of early education worldwide. Less is known about how to implement computing with ever‐younger age groups, especially for those under three. That technological change can be a strenuous change process building on societal, historical and educational tensions, requiring individual learning and organisational change. What this paper adds Two cases of change designing computing education for 1–2‐ and 3–5‐year‐olds. Design processes raising critical questions about current standard childhood programming materials being resolved to enable a child‐centred computing education. Challenges and potentials specific to early childhood in adopting computer science education. Implications for practice and/or policy Computing education challenges pedagogical notions, such as the role of failure in education. Computing education can be developed for very young children. However, there are considerable critical challenges to resolve in developing a child‐centred approach. Childhood fundamentals such as play‐based pedagogy can work synergistically with computer science activities, providing educational potential, also relevant for computer science education at large.

Eksplorasi Wawasan Pedagogis KH. Abdul Wahid Hasyim: Tinjauan Sistematis Terhadap Literatur Pendidikan

KH Abdul Wahid Hasyim is a prominent figure in Islamic education in Indonesia. This research explores his views on education, teaching methods, and their application in modern contexts. The aim is to understand his contributions deeply, evaluate the relevance of his concepts in current educational practices, and provide a foundation for innovation in progressive education systems. The research employs the Systematic Literature Review method to systematically explore Hasyim's pedagogical insights. Researchers gather, evaluate, and synthesize information from journals published between 2019-2024. Hasyim's educational perspective reflects the belief that education plays a strategic role in guiding individuals towards maturity, enhancing human dignity, and improving social conditions. The goal is to create individuals who are religious, knowledgeable, and intellectually sound, relevant in the modern educational context by integrating religious values with contemporary needs. Teaching methods like Wetonan, Sorongan, Hafalan, and Tutorial illustrate an adaptation between tradition and modernity, creating a holistic educational environment. According to Hasyim, teachers are agents of change, and students are active, creative, and independent learners. Hasyim's contributions in advocating inclusivity, liberalizing thought, reforming curricula, and establishing the Islamic University of Indonesia reflect his efforts to transform Islamic education to be more inclusive, progressive, and relevant to the times. Future research will focus on implementing Hasyim's teaching methods in modern education, evaluating the roles of teachers and students, and assessing his contributions to contemporary education, while promoting discussion forums to share thoughts on the implications of Hasyim's educational views in current educational practices.

Inclusive Education Practices of Technology and Livelihood Education Teachers in Public Junior High Schools at Lipa City, Batangas

Inclusive education is an approach that ensures every student, regardless of their learning needs, has fair access to quality education. This study delved into the inclusive education practices, difficulties, and recommendations of Technology and Livelihood Education (TLE) teachers in public junior high schools in Lipa City, Batangas, Philippines. Drawing inspiration from frameworks, like the Salamanca Statement, Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences and Vygotsky’s Social Constructivism, the research explored how TLE teachers incorporated education into their curriculum design, instructional strategies, and assessment of learning. Using a descriptive-quantitative research design, this research surveyed 81 TLE teachers from 21 public junior high schools. Their demographic profiles were collected, along with their inclusive education practices in the aspects of curriculum design, instructional strategies and assessment of learning. Significant differences were observed in the teachers’ curriculum design and instructional practices while there was no significant difference in their assessment of learning when grouped according to their ages and educational attainment. No significant difference was observed in the three aspects of their inclusive education practices when grouped according to their sex, number of years in teaching, areas of specialization, and length of inclusive education training attended. A comprehensive professional development program for TLE teachers in Lipa is proposed as a way of addressing key challenges and opportunities in the practice of inclusive education. It emphasizes inclusivity in practices and acknowledges the significance of equal provision of high-quality education for all students, stakeholder collaboration, sufficient fund allocation, and continuous professional development to further improve inclusivity and ensuring that no student is left behind in any learning process.

Mental Health Literacy and School Behavioral Health: Introduction to the Special Issue

ABSTRACT Background Mental health literacy is a promising approach to meeting the growing behavioral health needs of youth, and schools offer an ideal setting for this work. Purpose In the introduction to this special issue, we provide an overview of mental health literacy and discuss the connection between mental health literacy and school behavioral health. Methods Literature on mental health literacy and research on school mental health literacy programs are synthesized, followed by an overview of the six papers included in this issue. Results The key components of mental health literacy are defined and contextualized alongside the importance of mental health literacy for promoting well-being. A brief history of research on mental health literacy programs is provided, noting the growth in application to school settings. Discussion Connections between mental health literacy and school behavioral health are discussed, highlighting opportunities for integration with schools’ multi-tiered systems of support. Translation to Health Education Practice This introduction concludes with a discussion of implications for aligning mental health literacy with Health Education.

The Double-Edged Sword of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in Education

Objective: The purpose of this paper is to conduct a thorough review and investigation on the function and importance of AI in education. The development of technology in the sector, and the emergence of raising interest to apply this AI technologies with a view to enable disruptive efficiencies across all aspects of education. Methodology: The study uses a systematic review of literature for exploring the existing literatures and research findings about AI implementation in Education. For learning it tells you good &amp; bad about AI of bunchy resources, And changes because of the whether educational practices. Results: The results suggest that AI can greatly improve the personalization of learning, being able to provide tailored activities beyond traditional strategies. But the review also highlights worries over inequalities that may arise if only a specialist few can call upon top-notch AI tools possibly deepening of the achievement gap. Furthermore, a sanguine reliance on automated solutions could compromise the core human element in education and stymie social-emotional development for our students. Originality/value: Given the tendency for increased transparency, accountability and potential bias of AI systems in this critical domain leading to possible discrimination practices (e.g. admissions, grading etc) it is felt that the paper has great value contribution. There needs to be a spirit among policymakers, educators and developers working together to ensure that AI in education is implemented following certain principles.

Bridging the Knowledge Divide: Journalism Education and Industry Needs in East and Southern Africa

This study explores the perceived gap between journalism education and professional practice in Tanzania and Zambia. Through interviews with educators and journalists and an analysis of 12 journalism curricula, the findings reveal that both educators and journalists acknowledged a gap, with a shared desire for improved alignment between academic programs and industry needs. Educators expressed a commitment to incorporating contemporary content, but face challenges like limited industry collaboration and resource constraints. Journalists, however, observed a hesitancy among educators in implementing recommendations from the industry. Both groups see the need for integrating theory and practice into the curricula.

From classrooms to global impact

In today's fast-changing environment, the need for quality education is more crucial than ever. Therefore, this article examines how quality education can transform society and contribute to a sustainable, interconnected world. It highlights the essential role of quality education in navigating global complexities, asserting that it can drive sustainable development and promote responsible global citizenship. The study redefined the scope of quality education by advocating for a holistic approach that goes beyond academic excellence, emphasizing the development of essential 21st-century competencies, critical thinking, and creativity. The article aligned educational practices with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), highlighting the importance of environmental stewardship and social responsibility. It discussed how quality education nurtured intercultural understanding, empathy, and civic engagement, thereby cultivating a sense of global responsibility among students. Furthermore, the article identified quality education as a catalyst for sustainable development, preparing learners for the green economy and equipping them with future-ready skills to address complex global challenges through interdisciplinary problem-solving. The implementation of transformative quality education was examined, focusing on policy frameworks, inclusive curricula, and empowering educators as agents of change. The article concluded with a call to action, showcasing successful models and inspiring case studies, while mobilizing stakeholders to prioritize quality education as a means to empower global citizens and shape a better future.

AI-based feedback tools in education: A comprehensive bibliometric analysis study

This bibliometric analysis offers a comprehensive examination of AI-based feedback tools in education, utilizing data retrieved from the Web of Science (WoS) database. Encompassing a total of 239 articles from an expansive timeframe, spanning from inception to February 2024, this study provides a thorough overview of the evolution and current state of research in this domain. Through meticulous analysis, it tracks the growth trajectory of publications over time, revealing the increasing scholarly attention towards AI-driven feedback mechanisms in educational contexts. By describing critical thematic areas such as the role of feedback in enhancing learning outcomes, the integration of AI technologies into educational practices, and the efficacy of AI-based feedback tools in facilitating personalized learning experiences, the analysis offers valuable insights into the multifaceted nature of this field. By employing sophisticated bibliometric mapping techniques, including co-citation analysis and keyword co-occurrence analysis, the study uncovers the underlying intellectual structure of the research landscape, identifying prominent themes, influential articles, and emerging trends. Furthermore, it identifies productive authors, institutions, and countries contributing to the discourse, providing a detailed understanding of the collaborative networks and citation patterns within the community. This comprehensive synthesis of the literature serves as a valuable resource for researchers, practitioners, and policymakers alike, offering guidance on harnessing the potential of AI technologies to revolutionize teaching and learning practices in education.

Similar Foci, Different Lenses: Literacy Education Beliefs and Practices of Chinese and U.S. Teachers

The differences in literacy education practices between China and the United States are often attributed to their different educational, sociocultural, and historical contexts. However, this sweeping view offers little to help literacy educators in both countries understand the beliefs behind literacy instructional practices and how different or similar these beliefs are. This study examines key characteristics of how Chinese (n=40) and U.S. (n=44) literacy teachers (Pre-K-8th grade) articulate their beliefs about literacy education, delineating their differences and similarities. An inductive content analysis of teachers’ self-reported written narratives about their beliefs and practices in literacy education, along with double coding, reveal that the teachers’ espoused disciplinary beliefs focus on similar themes for the most part. However, their lenses were markedly different, tinted by both the substance and style of their literacy instruction contexts, as well as their cultural epistemological foundations. Inconsistencies between teachers’ beliefs and practices manifested differently in the two groups, but they reflected similar sources. Understanding these varying and nuanced beliefs in cross-cultural contexts can inform teacher education and education reform and counter the insularity of educational research.

‘How are rainbows made?': profiles of early childhood teachers' beliefs and their associations with responses to young children's causal questions

ABSTRACT This study investigates how early childhood teachers in China respond to children’s causal questions and explores the relationship between their belief profiles and response patterns. Grounded in Martin Buber’s dialogic philosophy and complemented by constructivist theories, latent profile analysis revealed three distinct belief profiles: leaders, followers, and polyphonists. Multilevel logistic regression showed that leaders were more inclined to provide explanations, followers tended to encourage exploration and information seeking, and polyphonists used a balanced combination of response types. These findings highlight the complex interplay between beliefs and practices in early childhood education, reflecting the cross-cultural exchange, collision, and integration of global educational ideas. The study underscores the importance of fostering critical and creative thinking in teacher education to help navigate the complexities of education.