Classification Of Ecological Status Research Articles

Potential effects of the discharge of wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluents in benthic communities: evidence from three distinct WWTP systems.

Wastewater treatment plant (WWTP) effluents can be sources of environmental contamination. In this study, we aimed to understand whether effluents of three different WWTPs may have ecological effects in riverine recipient ecosystems. To achieve this, we assessed benthic phytobenthos and macroinvertebrate communities at three different locations relative to the effluent discharge: immediately upstream, immediately downstream and 500-m downstream the effluent discharge. Two approaches were employed: the ecological status classification as defined in the Water Framework Directive (WFD) based on biological indicators; constrained multivariate analysis to disentangle the environmental drivers (physicochemical variables and contaminants, namely metals, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, pharmaceuticals, and personal care products) of ecological changes across the study sites. The results showed inconsistencies between the WFD approach and the multivariate approach, as well as between the responses of macroinvertebrates and diatoms. The WWTP effluents impacted benthic communities in a single case: macroinvertebrates were negatively affected by one of the WWTP effluents, likely by the transported pharmaceuticals (other stressors are essentially homogeneous among sites). Given the findings and the scarcity of consistent evidence on ecological impacts that WWTP effluents may have in recipient ecosystems, further research is needed towards more sustainable regulation and linked environmental protection measures.

Comparing methods and indices for biodiversity and status assessment in a hydropower-regulated river

The EU Water Framework Directive (WFD) aims to achieve good status of aquatic habitats. Classification of ecological status and identifying the stressors impacting aquatic habitats is essential for achieving this aim. Here, we evaluate different methods and indices for assessing ecological status in a hydropower-regulated river in central Norway using kick-sampling and macroinvertebrate identification through morphology and DNA as well as using environmental DNA. In Norway, the ASPT index (Average Score Per Taxon) is commonly used to evaluate ecological condition in general, although the index only provides evidence for organic pollution. We observed lower than expected diversity in the regulated river, but this was not reflected in the ASPT index, which showed “Good” to “High” status for all samples and methods. An alternative index, the IBIBI (Intercalibrated Benthic Invertebrate Biodiversity Index), returned “Bad” to “Moderate” status using the same data. The DNA-based identification methods returned in general higher species richness and somewhat higher index values than morphological species identification did. Our study exemplifies the importance of including relevant biological quality indices in WFD compliant assessments, and we advocate inclusion of a pressure-independent index like IBIBI in Norwegian river management and DNA-based identification methods for future river management in general.

A new diatom-based multimetric index to assess lake ecological status

Eutrophication impairs lake ecosystems at a global scale. In this context, as benthic microalgae are well-established warnings for a large range of stressors, particularly nutrient enrichment, the Water Framework Directive required the development of diatom-based methods to monitor lake eutrophication. Here, we present the diatom-based index we developed for French lakes, named IBDL (Indice Biologique Diatomées en Lacs). Data were collected in 93 lakes from 2015 to 2020. A challenge arose from the discontinuous pressure gradient of our dataset, especially the low number of nutrient-impacted lakes. To analyze the data we opted for the so-called “Threshold Indicator Taxa ANalysis” method, which makes it possible to determine a list of “alert taxa.” We obtained a multimetric index based on specific pressure gradients (Kjeldahl nitrogen, suspended matter, biological oxygen demand, and total phosphorous). Considering the European intercalibration process, the very good correlation between IBDL and the common metric (R2 from 0.52 to 0.87 according to the lake alkalinity type) makes us very confident in our ability to match future IBDL quality thresholds with European standards. The IBDL proved at last to be particularly relevant as it has a twofold interest: an excellent relationship with total phosphorus (R2 from 0.63 to 0.83 according to the lake alkalinity type) and a possible application to any lake metatype. Its complementarity with macrophyte-based indices moreover justifies the use of at least two primary producer components for lake ecological status classification.

Linking environmental monitoring data and the predicted effects of climate change for urban coastal management: A case study of Dublin Bay

Environmental managers of coastal regions must consider the combined effects of climate change and multiple other stressors simultaneously. While routine monitoring programmes exist, this information is usually summarised as a metric or index for ecological status classification and does not integrate the biological and environmental data in a format that is useful for managers. We present a framework using conditional inference tree analyses and Bayesian Network methodology that synthesises monitoring data, identifies links between environmental and biological variables, and predicts the effects of climate change for Dublin Bay, Ireland. The ecological quality status of phytoplankton biomass was usually high but degraded when silica became limiting. Sediment organic content was positively related to benthic invertebrate richness and the abundance of wading birds, although invertebrate communities were most indicative of pristine conditions when sediment organic content was low. Importantly, climate change simulations showed that the ecological status of Dublin Bay will decline in future, which highlights the importance of removing other stressors from the ecosystem.

Browning of boreal lakes: Do public perceptions and governance meet the biological foundations?

Browning of surface waters, also known as brownification, is a process of decreasing water transparency particularly in boreal lakes surrounded by intensively managed forests and wetlands. In this paper, we review the ecological consequences and ecosystem-based management of browning by using a systematic review approach and adopt an interdisciplinary approach to build new governance on this complex phenomenon. To understand the effect of browning on recreational values of freshwaters, we present primary survey data on public perceptions of recreational fishing tourists on water quality in Finland. We identify a need to develop ecosystem-based management beyond the EU's Water Framework Directive (WFD) to fully account for the extensive implications of browning. We also detect a need for a better understanding of the within-lake microbial processes to estimate the browning-associated changes in the greenhouse gas balance of lakes. Tourist perceptions of the quality of waterbodies in Finland were largely in agreement with the general proportion of waterbodies classified to a good or excellent ecological status class, but these perceptions may be detached from biological quality assessment criteria. Consequently, we suggest that the ecosystem-based management of inland waters should improve the utilization of information on not only biogeochemical processes but also users' perspectives on aquatic ecosystems beyond the EU WFD.

Ecological quality status of the Turkish coastal waters by using a marine macrophytic biotic index (EEI-c)

The present study includes the results of the second benthic macrophytes? monitoring period of a survey of ecological status from the Turkish coasts. The biotic index Ecological Evaluation Index (EEI-c) was used to assess the ecological status classes (ESC) and MA-LUSI the anthropogenic pressures. Sampling was made by the quadrat (20 × 20 cm) method, and the samples were collected from 93 sites in Turkish coastal waters between 2017 and 2019. In total, 240 taxa were found in the Turkish marine waters. Forty sites were classified into High ESC, 24 sites into Good, 12 sites into Moderate, 13 sites into Poor, and 4 sites into Bad ESC. The relationship between the pressure index MA-LUSI and EEIeqr values was also tested, and a negative correlation (R²= 0.62) was found.

Negative influence of a threatened species on ecological status classification: A case study of the influence of European eel within the Swedish fish index VIX

Biological indicators are important quality elements for classification of ecological status of water bodies according to the European Water Framework Directive. Multimetric indices are commonly regarded as robust and reliable indicators of human impact and are often used as quality elements. In fish-based indices, species are often grouped into guilds based on general tolerance to common anthropogenic pressures, with higher proportion of tolerant species being indicative of degraded systems. Within the Swedish electrofishing index VIX, the critically endangered European eel Anguilla anguilla (L.) is classified as a tolerant indicator species, and it therefore has a negative effect on classified ecological status. The scientific literature, however, suggests that eels are not generally tolerant and they benefit from similar environmental conditions as many insensitive species. VIX has been criticized for being too sensitive to the presence of eel in catch data, leading to low status classifications when eels are caught in the monitoring surveys. In a case study using manipulations of historical electrofishing data, we assessed the influence of eel presence and abundance on the ecological status classification as determined by VIX. We demonstrate that reduction of eels in survey data have positive effects on the classified status, in many cases substantial effects. An increase of eels in the data had the reverse effect. Mere presence of eel had a strong negative effect, which is problematic if the aim is to increase the endangered eel population. Given the Swedish classification system where the quality element indicating the worst status is decisive, the classified ecological status of Swedish rivers can theoretically be improved by management actions disfavouring eel, unless the results from VIX are carefully evaluated by experts. Along the same lines, measures implemented with an aim to increase the endangered eel population will lead to a decrease in assessed ecological status of Swedish rivers. Our conclusion is that the usage of VIX within Swedish water management is problematic and needs revision. From a broader perspective, the classification of species as generally tolerant need to be approached with great caution when developing new indices for assessing ecological status and integrity.

Evaluation of two short overlapping rbcL markers for diatom metabarcoding of environmental samples: Effects on biomonitoring assessment and species resolution

Two short diatom rbcL barcodes, 331 bp and 263 bp in length, have frequently been used in diatom metabarcoding studies. They overlap in a common 263-bp region but differ in the presence or absence of a 68-bp tail at the 5′ end. Though the effectiveness of both has been demonstrated in separate biomonitoring and diversity studies, the impact of the 68-bp non-shared region has not been evaluated. Here we compare the two barcodes in terms of the values of a biotic index (IPS) and the ecological status classes derived from their application to an extensive metabarcoding dataset from United Kingdom rivers; this comprised 1703 samples and was produced using the 331-bp primers. In addition, we assess the effectiveness of each barcode for discrimination of genetic variants around and below the species level. The strong correlation found in IPS values between barcodes (Pearson's R = 0.98) indicates that the choice of the barcode does not have major implications for current WFD ecological assessments, although a very few sites (55: 3.23% of those analysed) were downgraded from an acceptable WFD class (“Good”) to an unacceptable one (“Moderate”). Analyses of the taxonomic resolution of the two barcodes indicate that for many ASVs, the use of either marker – 263-bp and 331-bp – gives unambiguous assignations at species level though with differences in bootstrap confidence values. Such differences are caused by the stochasticity involved in the naïve Bayesian classifier used and by the fact that genetic distance, regarding closely related species, is increased when using the 331-bp barcode. However, in three cases, species differentiation fails with the shorter marker, leading to underestimates of species diversity. Finally, two ASVs from Nitzschia species evidenced that the use of the shorter marker can sometimes lead to false positives when the extent and nature of infraspecific variation are poorly known.

Italian reference rivers under the Water Framework Directive umbrella: do natural factors actually depict the observed nutrient conditions?

BackgroundDespite the efforts made in the last century to counteract the nutrient enrichment from diffuse and point-sources, the excess of nitrogen and phosphorous is among the main causes of degradation of European rivers. In this context, determining natural background concentrations of nutrients in rivers is crucial for a correct definition of their ecological status. In the most anthropized regions, this is a difficult task. This study provides a nation-wide assessment of the nutrient concentration variability between Italian river reference sites.ResultsWe applied the Affinity Propagation technique to identify groups of river sites classified as reference based on measured nutrients and oxygen water saturation. The role of natural and anthropogenic factors determining differences in nutrients concentration between groups of sites was explored. Nitrate concentrations varied from 0.01 mg N l−1 to more than 5 mg N l−1. Ammonia and total phosphorous varied between 0.001 and 0.12 mg l−1. Observed nutrient levels, although in line with those identified for reference sites in other countries, largely exceed the ranges reported for natural basins. Atmospheric deposition of inorganic N and artificial and/or high-impact agricultural land use are the major factors determining differences in nutrient concentration. Factors like, e.g. catchment size, precipitation amount and altitude do not play a relevant role in explaining nutrient differences between groups of reference sites.ConclusionsWe especially focused on (i) major causes of failure in the selection of appropriate reference sites in Italy; (ii) the potential of setting higher NO3-N thresholds for the classification of ecological status in specific areas, and (iii) the prospective of a regionalization approach, in which human effects are accepted to a low degree for reference site selection or when setting thresholds for peculiar geographical areas.

Corbicula incorporation to indicator parameters to assess the ecological status of northwestern Iberian estuaries

Ecological status classification systems based on biological elements (e.g., macroinvertebrate communities) are dependent on their response to different pressures. However, there is a need to determine if invasive species should be incorporated to indicator parameters (i.e. metrics based on measurements of richness and diversity) or as a pressure affecting such parameters. Moreover, because ecosystem classification systems are lacking for northwestern Iberian estuaries, there is even the possibility to develop a new metric penalizing presence or abundance of invasive species. To increase our understanding on this topic, we analyze the taxonomic and functional responses of benthic macroinvertebrates to Corbicula invasion along the environmental gradient of 12 northwestern Iberian estuaries. Macroinvertebrate assemblages were described and compared between invaded and uninvaded sections. Additionally, to assess differences in community structure, macroinvertebrate assemblages’ similarity was examined between two distinct estuarine sections (freshwater and oligohaline vs transitional water and mesohaline) and among water body types, including and excluding Corbicula from the analysis. The salinity gradient was the main driver explaining changes in macroinvertebrate assemblages and in functional group distribution. Freshwater and transitional water sections clearly differed in macroinvertebrate assemblages and functional groups composition. In addition, differences among river types in macroinvertebrate composition were found. Corbicula inclusion or exclusion from multivariate community analysis significantly affected the results in functional feeding group composition in the Cantabric-Atlantic siliceous river axis type. Nevertheless, considering Corbicula as a pressure at the regional scale did not provide different results in diversity indices calculation. Hence, we argue that because Corbicula eradication is virtually impossible, it should be included as an additional metric evidencing its presence as a negative indication, or be included within other indicator metrics used in the assessment of the ecological status, for instance in invertebrate abundance metrics were its dominance should be indicative of invasion impairment.

Applying Generic Water Quality Criteria to Cu and Zn in a Dynamic Aquatic Environment—The Case of the Brackish Water Formation Strömmen-Saltsjön

The EU Water Framework Directive stipulates that all EU waterways shall have good chemical and ecological status by 2027. Methodologies are described for how to assess and classify waterbodies and make 7-year management plans. Aquatic risk assessment methodologies and environmental quality standards are defined and a biotic ligand model methodology is available to assess the influence of water chemistry on the ability of aquatic organisms to take up metals. Aquatic status classification practices of naturally occurring river basin-specific metals are discussed, specifically how Cu and Zn water quality criteria guideline values have been adopted and defined for Swedish coastal and estuarine waters and how well they represent possible ecological risks. Calculations of bioavailability and ecotoxicity are conducted using recognised models for the Strömmen-Saltsjön water body in Stockholm, in which naturally occurring metals, especially Cu, have among the highest background concentrations of Sweden. Proposals are made to improve risk assessment methodologies to better reflect the vitality of living organisms, and to what extent current levels of these metals in Swedish waterways may influence their welfare. The study concludes that a more local assessment including, e.g., studies of the benthic fauna would be relevant for ecological status classification.

Aquaculture organic enrichment of marine sediments: assimilative capacity, geochemical indicators, variability, and impact classification

Benthic organic enrichment at 2 high-flow Atlantic salmon Salmo salar farms and at a low-flow mussel Mytilus edulis farm was studied to assess the capacity of local physical and biological processes to assimilate organic waste inputs. Geochemical metrics served as proxies for detecting potential biological effects. High-flow sites are generally predicted to assimilate organic enrichment by flow- and wave-induced waste dispersion and metabolic processes. However, a decrease in porewater dissolved oxygen was detected out to 100 m at the salmon farm with cohesive sediments and to approximately 1000 m outside the farm with permeable sediment. Sediment oxygen consumption was responsive to the vertical flux of organic matter, resulting in hypoxic conditions. An increase in total free sulfides (H2S + HS- + S2-) in porewater was restricted to the immediate vicinity of both salmon farms. Despite exhibiting a high degree of small-scale patchiness, benthic effects were greatest at the fish farms during the pre-harvest period, regardless of season. Natural organic enrichment at the mussel farm constrained the assimilative capacity for biodeposition, resulting in substantial free sulfide accumulation. Sediment free sulfide analysis at a wide array of fish and shellfish farms showed that the ion-selective electrode method that is widely prescribed for regulatory aquaculture monitoring gave biased readings relative to methylene blue colorimetry and direct UV spectrophotometry. The ecological quality status classification system was extended to include quantitative relationships between a wide range of geochemical and biological variables employed worldwide to monitor and regulate the effects of benthic organic enrichment.

Influence of Anthropogenic Load in River Basins on River Water Status: A Case Study in Lithuania

Twenty-four rivers in different parts of Lithuania were selected for the study. The aim of the research was to evaluate the impact of anthropogenic load on the ecological status of rivers. Anthropogenic loads were assessed according to the pollution sources in individual river catchment basins. The total nitrogen (TN) values did not correspond to the “good” and “very good” ecological status classes in 51% of the tested water bodies; 19% had a “bad” to “moderate” BOD7, 50% had “bad” to “moderate” NH4-N, 37% had “bad” to “moderate” NO3-N, and 4% had “bad” to “moderate” PO4-P. The total phosphorus (TP) values did not correspond to the “good” and “very good” ecological status classes in 4% of the tested water bodies. The largest amounts of pollution in river basins were generated from the following sources: transit pollution, with 87,599 t/year of total nitrogen and 5020 t/year of total phosphorus; agricultural pollution, with 56,031 t/year of total nitrogen and 2474 t/year of total phosphorus. The highest total nitrogen load in river basins per year, on average, was from transit pollution, accounting for 53.89%, and agricultural pollution, accounting for 34.47%. The highest total phosphorus load was also from transit pollution, totaling 58.78%, and agricultural pollution, totaling 28.97%. Multiple regression analysis showed the agricultural activity had the biggest negative influence on the ecological status of rivers according to all studied indicators.

Comparison of Four Foraminiferal Biotic Indices Assessing the Environmental Quality of Coastal Mediterranean Soft Bottoms

Coastal environments are exposed to numerous pressures that potentially affect marine soft bottom faunas. Among these pressures, organic matter enrichment is very frequent. Several indices based on living (Rose Bengal-stained) foraminiferal communities have recently been developed to assess the induced impact and determine the environmental quality of these environments. Here, we use an open waters Mediterranean Sea data set to test the benefits and drawbacks of four foraminiferal indices: (1) the effective number of species (exp(H’bc)), (2) the Tolerant Species Index for the Mediterranean (TSI-Med), (3) the Foraminifera AMBI (Foram-AMBI), and (4) the Foram Stress Index (FSI). These indices all intend to measure the response of the foraminiferal communities to organic matter enrichment, and therefore, their results should be very similar. We found that the diversity-based index, exp(H’bc), was not suitable to evaluate the environmental quality of our Mediterranean coastal settings, as it had a non-monotonic relationship with the organic matter enrichment gradient. The three indices based on groups of indicator species (TSI-Med, Foram-AMBI, and FSI) yielded fairly similar results. For Foram-AMBI, using only assigned species to calculate proportions of indicator species partly avoided to misinterpret the results. In TSI-Med, a correction based on sediment grain size is applied to distinguish between natural and anthropogenic organic enrichment. Such a correction could also be added to Foram-AMBI and FSI. The limits between the Ecological Quality Status (EQS) classes used for macrofauna were not adapted for Foram-AMBI. Here, we propose new EQS class limits for the Foram-AMBI as follows: very good: 0 ≤ x < 1.4; good: 1.4 ≤ x < 2.4; moderate: 2.4 ≤ x < 3.4; poor: 3.4 ≤ x < 4.4; bad: 4.4 ≤ x ≤ 6. These limits could evolve in the future as new data become available, especially with a poor and bad environmental quality.

A new WFD\u2014compliant littoral macroinvertebrate index for monitoring and assessment of Mediterranean lakes (HeLLBI)

A new multimetric index (HeLLBI) based on littoral benthic macroinvertebrates is presented in this paper for classification of Greek natural lakes, in compliance with the requirements of Water Framework Directive (WFD). The method was developed based on the collection of littoral benthic invertebrate fauna and environmental data from 109 sampling sites in 21 natural lakes of the Greek National Water Monitoring Network. We focused the analysis on the effects of shore morphological alterations and eutrophication to the littoral invertebrate fauna, identified to family level, except oligochaetes, which were identified as a class, and more particularly to taxonomic composition and abundance, to taxa sensitivity, and to richness/diversity. Three metrics were included in the multimeric index: the relative abundance of Odonata classes, the Average Score per Taxon, and the Simpson’s diversity index. The metrics were converted to ecological quality ratios and ecological class boundaries were defined. The final multimetric index HeLLBI is expressed as an arithmetic average of normalized ecological quality ratios of the above metrics and a final score was assigned to each lake. Pressure-response relationships of HeLLBI scores were statistically tested for morphological alterations, expressed as percentage of artificial shoreline, and eutrophication, expressed as total phosphorus. The HeLLBI scores correspond to ecological classes, according to WFD, and sampling sites with different ecological status contained distinct biological communities; those at high status where more diverse and with sensitive taxa and as the water quality deteriorated, macroinvertebrate assemblages consisted of fewer and more tolerant to degradation taxa. The HeLLBI method gave a reliable assessment of littoral benthic invertebrate fauna of Greek natural lakes and could be a useful tool for the classification of ecological status of other Mediterranean lakes.

Applicability of diatom metabarcoding in the ecological status assessment of Hungarian lotic and soda pan habitats

Diatoms are widely applied in the ecological status assessment of aquatic ecosystems using indices calculated from pollution sensitivity and indicator values of species. Traditional, morphology-based identification of species requires in-depth taxonomic knowledge and expertise. Identifying taxa according to their barcode sequences obtained with high-throughput sequencing (metabarcoding) would be a promising alternative. In this pilot study, we tested the applicability of metabarcoding of benthic diatom assemblages for the ecological status assessment of Hungarian water bodies, comparing its performance to that of morphology-based identification of species. The barcode region of the rbcL gene was investigated in samples from running waters with various trophic states and unique lentic habitats, namely soda pans. For running waters, the Specific Pollution Sensitivity Index (IPS) and for soda pans the H index and the Indice Biologique Diatomées (IBD) were calculated from the morphology- and sequence-based abundances. The ecological quality ratio was determined for running waters. Overall, more infrageneric taxa were found with microscopy than with metabarcoding in the lotic and lentic samples. The correspondence between taxon lists detected by the two methods was relatively low but increased considerably in the case of morphologically dominant taxa. Community composition based on microscopy and DNA sequence analysis showed a significant correlation and was determined by the same main environmental drivers. Morphology-based indices strongly correlated with sequence-based indices. Both aspects indicated the same ecological status class for more than half of the lotic samples. In other cases, a status shift from good to moderate was frequent, a phenomenon that could prove problematic because the Water Framework Directive prescribes intervention for waters with a moderate or worse status. Considering discrepancies between the results obtained with microscopy and metabarcoding, using both methods in parallel could be proposed until the reference database has been suitably updated.

Diatom communities and ecological status classification in the upper Po River basin

One of the main challenges in river management is the setting of nutrient thresholds that support good ecological status, which is the main objective to achieve for the European member states. This is a complex process, which needs an accurate analysis of the data collected so far for the ecological classification of rivers belonging to different typologies. We analysed the data of the multiannual monitoring concerning diatoms and nutrients in the upper Po River (NW Italy) with the aim of exploring the response of diatom community in terms of species composition, ecological guilds and indices. We considered data of 390 samples, of which 2/3 belonging to the “Central macrotype” (i.e. lowland stretches) and 1/3 to “Alpine siliceous”. We performed a Principal Coordinate Analysis to detect community patterns with respect to water chemical classification and macrotypes highlighting species and ecological guilds characteristic of samples along a water quality gradient. We then performed a partial RDA to focus on the role of environmental and spatial factors in shaping the diatom community in each of the two macrotypes. Finally, we investigated the concordance between the Italian normative indices ICMi (for diatoms) and LIMECO (a chemical index of water quality). We found significant differences in the diatom communities of the two macrotypes and in their response to water quality and to spatial factors. Communities resulted as much more uniform in sites with a low water quality, with characteristic species such as Navicula gregaria, Nitzschia palea and Sellaphora nigri. On the other hands, moderately disturbed sites (in terms of trophic level) were characterised by the highest guild diversity. The RDA confirmed the importance of spatial factors in shaping the diatom assemblages, especially in Alpine streams where the physical barriers may condition species dispersion. The comparison between the two normative indices highlights that the correspondence in the classification is achieved in the 57% (Alpine macrotype) and 43% (Central macrotype) of samples. According to our findings, we suggest the revision of the ICMi, both class boundaries and reference value. In addition, we recommend to lower LIMECO threshold for total phosphorus: indeed, several studies have shown significant changes in the diatom community composition starting from very low values (below the current LIMECO threshold, i.e. 50 µgL-1). Moreover, the extension of our study to the whole Po River basin will complete our knowledge of species not yet included in the diatom indices and of the community response to nutrient levels also in other macrotypes.

Hydromorphological assessment of Polish lakes: Elaborating the Lake Habitat Survey for Polish Lakes (LHS_PL) method and determining ecologically based boundary values for lake classification

AbstractThe Lake Habitat Survey for Polish Lakes (LHS_PL) is a method for the hydromorphological investigation of lakes employed for the assessment of the ecological status of surface water bodies in Poland. It was developed based on the British Lake Habitat Survey method. In 2015, after almost a decade of work on the adaptation, the LHS method was finally adjusted to Polish conditions, and since 2016, it has been implemented in the State Environmental Monitoring programme. This paper presents the assumptions and evolution of the method and the approach for determining boundary values for the high/good (H/G) and good/less than good (G/LTG) ecological status classes. The method involves the assessment of the morphological features of the lake and anthropogenic pressures at 10 observation plots as well as the analysis of hydrological alterations and anthropogenic activities within the lake basin and the entire catchment area. The data collected in the field are used to calculate the index of lake hydromorphological alteration, that is, the Lake Habitat Modification Score for Polish Lakes (LHMS_PL). The LHMS_PL values range from 0 to 144, where 0 means no modification and 144 refers to a hydromorphologically highly modified state. The boundary values for the H/G and G/LTG status classes have been determined using the quartile method based on the relationship between hydromorphological modifications of lakes and the condition of the phytoplankton and macrophyte communities therein.

Uncertainty in phytoplankton-based lake ecological status classification: Implications of sampling frequency and metric simplification

We examined the influence of sampling frequency and the elimination of selected metrics from the Phytoplankton Multimetric for Polish Lakes (PMPL index) on lake ecological status classification. The effect of sampling frequency was analysed by calculating the official PMPL index using data from four sampling periods (848 lake-years; 478 Polish lakes), and compared the Pmpl-based classification to that assessed from PMPL variants calculated using one, two and three sampling periods. The effect of metric elimination was analysed by comparing the official three-metric PMPL classification with two variants, a one-metric PMPL including only the concentration of chlorophyll-a and a two-metric variant including total phytoplankton biomass and summer cyanobacterial biomass. Correlation strength between the official PMPL and simplified variants weakened by reducing sampling frequency but varied by period combinations. Uncertainty of ecological status classification increased in both simplification types but it was greatest when using the one-metric (chlorophyll-a based) variant. Sampling reduction from four to three periods resulted in 0.5–6.5% of lakes being over- or under-classified (total lake-year misclassification: 3.7–6.7%). Highest uncertainty of classification to at least good status occurred when the spring sampling period was excluded (6.5%). The risk of misclassification increased to 4.2–14.9% when two sampling periods were used. When classification was based only on a one-period (late summer) PMPL, 12.1% of lake-years were misclassified to at least good and 9.3% to below-good ecological status. The risk of misclassification to at least good ecological status was 2% when the two-metric (biomass-based) PMPL index was used and 28.9% when the one-metric (chlorophyll-a based) was used. Lowest misclassification error (0.5%–5.2%) occurred when a three-period (spring-August-October), three-metric PMPL index was used, but as this 5.2% would result in substantial status under-classification, we recommend further research to possibly optimize a three-period PMPL variant to reduce the costs of lake ecological monitoring in Poland.

Building on gAMBI in ports for a challenging biological invasions scenario: Blue-gNIS as a proof of concept

The status of aquatic ecosystems has historically been monitored by the use of biotic indices. However, few biotic measures consider the presence of non-indigenous species as a sign of anthropogenic pollution and habitat disturbance even when this may seriously affect the metric scores and ecological status classifications of an environment. Today, biological invasions are currently one of the greatest threats to biodiversity and sustainable blue economies around the world. In this work, environmental assessments were conducted in the Port of Gijon, Northern Spain, using eDNA metabarcoding, and the gAMBI (genetics based AZTI Marine Biotic Index) was estimated. Results indicate a high/good ecological status within the port. However, nine non-indigenous species and five invasive species were found, and a modification of the gAMBI that includes species invasiveness was proposed: Blue-gNIS. The index was preliminary tested against existing validated indices such as gAMBI, BENTIX (based on the ecology of macroinvertebrates) and ALEX (based on the invasiveness of the species). Blue-gNIS classified the port in a good ecological status and showed its potential usefulness to achieve more complete water quality assessments of ports.