Early Primitive Ectoderm-like Cells Research Articles

Signalling pathway crosstalk stimulated by L-proline drives mouse embryonic stem cells to primitive-ectoderm-like cells.

The amino acid L-proline exhibits growth factor-like properties during development - from improving blastocyst development to driving neurogenesis in vitro. Addition of 400 μM L-proline to self-renewal medium drives naïve mouse embryonic stem cells (ESCs) to early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells - a transcriptionally distinct primed or partially primed pluripotent state. EPL cells retain expression of pluripotency genes, upregulate primitive ectoderm markers, undergo a morphological change and have increased cell number. These changes are facilitated by a complex signalling network hinging on the Mapk, Fgfr, Pi3k and mTor pathways. Here, we use a factorial experimental design coupled with statistical modelling to understand which signalling pathways are involved in the transition between ESCs and EPL cells, and how they underpin changes in morphology, cell number, apoptosis, proliferation and gene expression. This approach reveals pathways which work antagonistically or synergistically. Most properties were affected by more than one inhibitor, and each inhibitor blocked specific aspects of the naïve-to-primed transition. These mechanisms underpin progression of stem cells across the in vitro pluripotency continuum and serve as a model for pre-, peri- and post-implantation embryogenesis.

L-Proline Supplementation Drives Self-Renewing Mouse Embryonic Stem Cells to a Partially Primed Pluripotent State: The Early Primitive Ectoderm-Like Cell.

Mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs) can be grown under a variety of culture conditions as discrete cell states along the pluripotency continuum, ranging from the least mature "ground state" to being "primed" to differentiate. Cells along this continuum are demarcated by differences in gene expression, X chromosome inactivation, ability to form chimeras and epigenetic marks. We have developed a protocol to differentiate "naïve" mESCs to a "partially primed" state by adding the amino acid L-proline to self-renewal medium. These cells express the primitive ectoderm markers Dnmt3b and Fgf5, and are thus called early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells. In addition to changes in gene expression, these cells undergo a morphological change to flattened, dispersed colonies, have an increased proliferation rate, and a predisposition to neural fate. EPL cells can be used to study the cell states along the pluripotency continuum, peri-implantation embryogenesis, and as a starting point for efficient neuronal differentiation.

A Critical E-box in Barhl1 3' Enhancer Is Essential for Auditory Hair Cell Differentiation.

Barhl1, a mouse homologous gene of Drosophila BarH class homeobox genes, is highly expressed within the inner ear and crucial for the long-term maintenance of auditory hair cells that mediate hearing and balance, yet little is known about the molecular events underlying Barhl1 regulation and function in hair cells. In this study, through data mining and in vitro report assay, we firstly identified Barhl1 as a direct target gene of Atoh1 and one E-box (E3) in Barhl1 3’ enhancer is crucial for Atoh1-mediated Barhl1 activation. Then we generated a mouse embryonic stem cell (mESC) line carrying disruptions on this E3 site E-box (CAGCTG) using CRISPR/Cas9 technology and this E3 mutated mESC line is further subjected to an efficient stepwise hair cell differentiation strategy in vitro. Disruptions on this E3 site caused dramatic loss of Barhl1 expression and significantly reduced the number of induced hair cell-like cells, while no affections on the differentiation toward early primitive ectoderm-like cells and otic progenitors. Finally, through RNA-seq profiling and gene ontology (GO) enrichment analysis, we found that this E3 box was indispensable for Barhl1 expression to maintain hair cell development and normal functions. We also compared the transcriptional profiles of induced cells from CDS mutated and E3 mutated mESCs, respectively, and got very consistent results except the Barhl1 transcript itself. These observations indicated that Atoh1-mediated Barhl1 expression could have important roles during auditory hair cell development. In brief, our findings delineate the detail molecular mechanism of Barhl1 expression regulation in auditory hair cell differentiation.

Src Family Kinases and p38 Mitogen-Activated Protein Kinases Regulate Pluripotent Cell Differentiation in Culture.

Multiple pluripotent cell populations, which together comprise the pluripotent cell lineage, have been identified. The mechanisms that control the progression between these populations are still poorly understood. The formation of early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells from mouse embryonic stem (mES) cells provides a model to understand how one such transition is regulated. EPL cells form from mES cells in response to l-proline uptake through the transporter Slc38a2. Using inhibitors of cell signaling we have shown that Src family kinases, p38 MAPK, ERK1/2 and GSK3β are required for the transition between mES and EPL cells. ERK1/2, c-Src and GSK3β are likely to be enforcing a receptive, primed state in mES cells, while Src family kinases and p38 MAPK are involved in the establishment of EPL cells. Inhibition of these pathways prevented the acquisition of most, but not all, features of EPL cells, suggesting that other pathways are required. L-proline activation of differentiation is mediated through metabolism and changes to intracellular metabolite levels, specifically reactive oxygen species. The implication of multiple signaling pathways in the process suggests a model in which the context of Src family kinase activation determines the outcomes of pluripotent cell differentiation.

The formation of proximal and distal definitive endoderm populations in culture requires p38 MAPK activity

Endoderm formation in the mammal is a complex process with two lineages forming during the first weeks of development, the primitive (or extraembryonic) endoderm, which is specified in the blastocyst, and the definitive endoderm that forms later, at gastrulation, as one of the germ layers of the embryo proper. Fate mapping evidence suggests that the definitive endoderm arises as two waves, which potentially reflect two distinct cell populations. Early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cell differentiation has been used successfully to identify and characterise mechanisms regulating molecular gastrulation and lineage choice during differentiation. The roles of the p38 MAPK family in the formation of definitive endoderm were investigated using EPL cells and chemical inhibitors of p38 MAPK activity. These approaches define a role for p38 MAPK activity in the formation of the primitive streak and a second role in the formation of the definitive endoderm. Characterisation of the definitive endoderm populations formed from EPL cells demonstrates the formation of two distinct populations, defined by gene expression and ontogeny, that were analogous to the proximal and distal definitive endoderm populations of the embryo. Formation of the proximal definitive endoderm was found to require p38 MAPK activity and is correlated with molecular gastrulation, defined by the expression of brachyury (T). Distal definitive endoderm formation also requires p38 MAPK activity but can form when T expression is inhibited. Understanding lineage complexity will be a prerequisite for the generation of endoderm derivatives for commercial and clinical use.

The formation of proximal and distal definitive endoderm populations in culture requires p38 MAPK activity

Endoderm formation in the mammal is a complex process with two lineages forming during the first weeks of development, the primitive (or extraembryonic) endoderm, which is specified in the blastocyst, and the definitive endoderm that forms later, at gastrulation, as one of the germ layers of the embryo proper. Fate mapping evidence suggests that the definitive endoderm arises as two waves, which potentially reflect two distinct cell populations. Early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cell differentiation has been used successfully to identify and characterise mechanisms regulating molecular gastrulation and lineage choice during differentiation. The roles of the p38 MAPK family in the formation of definitive endoderm were investigated using EPL cells and chemical inhibitors of p38 MAPK activity. These approaches define a role for p38 MAPK activity in the formation of the primitive streak and a second role in the formation of the definitive endoderm. Characterisation of the definitive endoderm populations formed from EPL cells demonstrates the formation of two distinct populations, defined by gene expression and ontogeny, that were analogous to the proximal and distal definitive endoderm populations of the embryo. Formation of the proximal definitive endoderm was found to require p38 MAPK activity and is correlated with molecular gastrulation, defined by the expression of brachyury (T). Distal definitive endoderm formation also requires p38 MAPK activity but can form when T expression is inhibited. Understanding lineage complexity will be a prerequisite for the generation of endoderm derivatives for commercial and clinical use.

A System to Enrich for Primitive Streak-Derivatives, Definitive Endoderm and Mesoderm, from Pluripotent Cells in Culture

Two lineages of endoderm develop during mammalian embryogenesis, the primitive endoderm in the pre-implantation blastocyst and the definitive endoderm at gastrulation. This complexity of endoderm cell populations is mirrored during pluripotent cell differentiation in vitro and has hindered the identification and purification of the definitive endoderm for use as a substrate for further differentiation. The aggregation and differentiation of early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells, resulting in the formation of EPL-cell derived embryoid bodies (EPLEBs), is a model of gastrulation that progresses through the sequential formation of primitive streak-like intermediates to nascent mesoderm and more differentiated mesoderm populations. EPL cell-derived EBs have been further analysed for the formation of definitive endoderm by detailed morphological studies, gene expression and a protein uptake assay. In comparison to embryoid bodies derived from ES cells, which form primitive and definitive endoderm, the endoderm compartment of embryoid bodies formed from EPL cells was comprised almost exclusively of definitive endoderm. Definitive endoderm was defined as a population of squamous cells that expressed Sox17, CXCR4 and Trh, which formed without the prior formation of primitive endoderm and was unable to endocytose horseradish peroxidase from the medium. Definitive endoderm formed in EPLEBs provides a substrate for further differentiation into specific endoderm lineages; these lineages can be used as research tools for understanding the mechanisms controlling lineage establishment and the nature of the transient intermediates formed. The similarity between mouse EPL cells and human ES cells suggests EPLEBs can be used as a model system for the development of technologies to enrich for the formation of human ES cell-derived definitive endoderm in the future.

The amino acid transporter SNAT2 mediatesl-proline-induced differentiation of ES cells

There is an increasing appreciation that amino acids can act as signaling molecules in the regulation of cellular processes through modulation of intracellular cell signaling pathways. In culture, embryonic stem (ES) cells can be differentiated to a second, pluripotent cell population, early primitive ectoderm-like cells in response to biological activities within the conditioned medium MEDII. The amino acid l-proline has been identified as a component of MEDII required for ES cell differentiation. Here, we define the primary l-proline transporter on ES and early primitive ectoderm-like cells as sodium-coupled neutral amino acid transporter 2 (SNAT2). SNAT2 uptake of l-proline can be inhibited by the addition of millimolar concentrations of other substrates. The addition of excess amino acids was used to regulate the uptake of l-proline by ES cells, and the effect on differentiation was analyzed. The ability of SNAT2 substrates, but not other amino acids, to prevent changes in morphology, gene expression, and differentiation kinetics suggested that l-proline uptake through SNAT2 was required for ES cell differentiation. These data reveal an unexpected role for amino acid uptake and the amino acid transporter SNAT2 in regulation of pluripotent cells in culture and provides a number of specific, inexpensive, and nontoxic culture additives with the potential to improve the quality of ES cell culture.

L-Proline as a modulator of ectodermal differentiation in ES cells. Focus on “l-Proline induces differentiation of ES cells: a novel role for an amino acid in the regulation of pluripotent cells in culture

current research is focusing on defining the control of pluripotency and lineage determination of pluripotent cells, particularly of embryonic stem (ES) cells. ES cells are usually produced from the inner cell mass (ICM) of the blastocyst and are considered equivalent to ICM cells captured during a

Proteomic comparisons of differentiating embryonic stem cells, an in vitro model of embryogenesis

Investigation of the genetic mechanisms driving embryogenetic differentiation has produced notable advances in disease research. However, reports on protein expression have been limited to comparisons between the undifferentiated and differentiated cellular states. Here, we use progressively differentiated embryonic stem cells as an in vitro model of embryogenesis. Using a quantitative proteomic approach, we explored protein regulation from mouse embryonic stem cells (ES), early primitive ectoderm‐like cells (EPL), and embryoid bodies (EB). A total of 2911 proteins were identified for the ES proteome, 1852 proteins for the EPL proteome, and 3328 proteins were identified in the embryoid body proteome. A total of 1509 proteins were shared across all three cell states and could be accuratly quantified. Differentially regulated proteins were then mapped to functional categories and correlated to embryogenetic events. This analysis represents a comprehensive investigation of protein expression during early embryogenesis.

Germ layer induction from embryonic stem cells

Embryonic stem (ES) cells have the potential to develop into all cell types of the adult body. This capability provides the basis for considering the ES cell system as a novel and unlimited source of cells for replacement therapies for the treatment of a wide range of diseases. Before the cell-based therapy potential of ES cells can be realized, a better understanding of the pathways regulating lineage-specific differentiation is required. Current studies suggest that the bone morphogenic protein, transforming growth factor-beta, Wnt, and fibroblast growth factor pathways that are required for gastrulation and germ layer induction in the embryo are also essential for differentiation of ES cells in culture. The current understanding of how these factors influence germ layer induction in both the embryo and in the ES cell differentiation system is addressed in this review.

Lineage Specific Differentiation of Mouse ES Cells: Formation and Differentiation of Early Primitive Ectoderm-like (EPL) Cells

The purpose of this chapter is to discuss, at a technical level, the formation and use of early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells, including methodologies for further differentiation of EPL cells to the mesodermal or ectodermal lineage and identification of alternative pluripotent and somatic cell populations. There is particular merit in differentiation regimes that recapitulate lineage establishment during normal embryogenesis. These are anticipated to provide a non-transformed model system for the investigation of cell-fate choice, identification, characterization, and production of transient differentiation intermediates, and identification of signaling pathways that regulate cell identity and acquisition of positional information. In conjunction with the extraordinary experimental malleability of the embryonic stem (ES) cell genome, this enables sophisticated analysis of gene function at the cellular level in a system that is not restricted by limitations associated with maintenance of a viable embryo. The most commonly used protocols for ES cell differentiation rely on differentiation within complex cellular aggregates known as “embryoid bodies (EBs).” ES cells share a gene expression, differentiation potential, and cytokine responsiveness with their source cell population, the pluripotent cells of the inner cell mass (ICM). The immediate developmental fate of ICM en route to the formation of the embryo proper, differentiation to primitive ectoderm, can be recapitulated in vitro by the formation of EPL cells. Unlike ES cells, when EPL cells are differentiated in vitro, they do not form visceral endoderm, thus providing a technology for pluripotent cell differentiation that is devoid of extraembryonic signals. This enables control over the formation of somatic lineages from pluripotent cells by manipulation of the differentiation environment and thereby overcomes many of the inherent problems associated with ES cell EBs.

Pluripotent cell division cycles are driven by ectopic Cdk2, cyclin A/E and E2F activities.

Pluripotent cells of embryonic origin proliferate at unusually rapid rates and have a characteristic cell cycle structure with truncated gap phases. To define the molecular basis for this we have characterized the cell cycle control of murine embryonic stem cells and early primitive ectoderm-like cells. These cells display precocious Cdk2, cyclin A and cyclin E kinase activities that are conspicuously cell cycle independent. Suppression of Cdk2 activity significantly decreased cycling times of pluripotent cells, indicating it to be rate-limiting for rapid cell division, although this had no impact on cell cycle structure and the establishment of extended gap phases. Cdc2-cyclin B was the only Cdk activity that was identified to be cell cycle regulated in pluripotent cells. Cell cycle regulation of cyclin B levels and Y(15) regulation of Cdc2 contribute to the temporal changes in Cdc2-cyclin B activity. E2F target genes are constitutively active throughout the cell cycle, reflecting the low activity of pocket proteins such as p107 and pRb and constitutive activity of pRb-kinases. These results show that rapid cell division cycles in primitive cells of embryonic origin are driven by extreme levels of Cdk activity that lack normal cell cycle periodicity.

Transient pluripotent cell populations during primitive ectoderm formation: correlation of in vivo and in vitro pluripotent cell development.

Formation and differentiation of a pluripotent cell population is central to mammalian development, and the isolation, identification and manipulation of human pluripotent cells is predicted to be of therapeutic use. Within the early mammalian embryo, two distinct populations of pluripotent cells have been described: the inner cell mass (ICM), which differentiates to form a second pluripotent cell populations, the primitive ectoderm. Indirect evidence suggests the existence of temporally distinct intermediate pluripotent cell populations as primitive ectoderm is formed. We coupled an in vitro model of primitive ectoderm formation (the transition of embryonic stem cells to early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells) with ddPCR-based techniques to identify three novel genes, Psc1, CRTR-1 and PRCE, that were expressed differently during pluripotent cell progression. Detailed mapping of these genes with Oct4, Rex1 and Fgf5 on pregastrulation embryos provided the first molecular evidence for the existence of successive, temporally distinct pluripotent cell populations in the embryo between the ICM and primitive ectoderm. No evidence was found for spatial heterogeneity within the Oct4(+) pool. The transition between populations correlated with morphological or developmental alterations in pluripotent cells in vivo. Genes that are temporally expressed during pluripotent cell progression may provide an opportunity for molecular discrimination of pluripotent cells at different stages of maturation in vivo and an understanding of the cellular origins and properties of pluripotent cell lines isolated from diverse sources. Furthermore, the strong correlation of gene expression demonstrated between EPL cell formation in vitro and primitive ectoderm formation in vivo validates EPL cells as a model for primitive ectoderm, thereby providing a model system for the investigation of pluripotent differentiation and an opportunity for directed differentiation of pluripotent cells to therapeutically useful cell populations.

Lineage specific differentiation of pluripotent cells in vitro: a role for extraembryonic cell types.

The controlled differentiation of pluripotent cells will be a prerequisite for many cell therapies. We have previously reported homogeneous conversion of embryonic stem (ES) cells in vitro to early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells, equivalent to early primitive ectoderm, an obligatory differentiation intermediate between ES cells and somatic cell populations. Early primitive ectoderm-like cells differentiated within aggregates form mesodermal lineages at the expense of ectoderm. In this work we demonstrate that the failure of EPL cells to form ectodermal cell types does not reflect an inherent restriction in developmental potential. Early primitive ectoderm-like cells form ectodermal derivatives such as neurons in response to neural inducers such as retinoic acid, or when differentiated in the environment provided by ES cell embryoid bodies. This could be explained by signals from the extraembryonic cell type visceral endoderm which forms in differentiating ES cell but not EPL cell aggregates. Consistent with this possibility, culture of EPL cell aggregates in the presence of visceral endoderm-like signals did not prevent differentiation of the pluripotent cells, but resulted in suppression of mesoderm formation. These results suggest a role for visceral endoderm in regulation of germ layer specification from pluripotent cells, and can be integrated into a model for cell differentiation in vitro and in vivo.

Formation of a primitive ectoderm like cell population, EPL cells, from ES cells in response to biologically derived factors.

The primitive ectoderm of the mouse embryo arises from the inner cell mass between 4.75 and 5.25 days post coitum, around the time of implantation. Positioned at a pivotal time in development, just prior to formation of the three germ layers of the embryo proper, the primitive ectoderm responds directly to the signals generated during gastrulation. We have identified a conditioned medium, MEDII, which caused the homogeneous conversion of ES cells to a morphologically distinct cell population, termed early primitive ectoderm-like (EPL) cells. EPL cells expressed the pluripotent cell markers Oct4, SSEA1 and alkaline phosphatase. However, the formation of EPL cells was accompanied by alterations in Fgf5, Gbx2 and Rex1 expression, a loss in chimaera forming ability, changes in factor responsiveness and modified differentiation capabilities, all consistent with the identification of EPL cells as equivalent to the primitive ectoderm population of the 5.5 to 6.0 days post coitum embryo. EPL cell formation could be reversed in the presence of LIF and withdrawal of MEDII, which suggested that EPL cell formation was not a terminal differentiation event but reflected the ability of pluripotent cells to adopt distinct cell states in response to specific factors. Partial purification of MEDII revealed the presence of two separable biological activities, both of which were required for the induction and maintenance of EPL cells. We show here the first demonstration of uniform differentiation of ES cells in response to biological factors. The formation of primitive ectoderm, both in vivo and in vitro, appears to be an obligatory step in the differentiation of the inner cell mass or ES cells into cell lineages of the embryonic germ layers. EPL cells potentially represent a model for the development of lineage specific differentiation protocols and analysis of gastrulation at a molecular level. An understanding of the active components of MEDII may provide a route for the identification of factors which induce primitive ectoderm formation in vivo.