Starting with its earliest descriptions, melanoma has been recognized as a tumor with a predilection for metastasis to regional lymph nodes. This tendency led to initial recommendations for very aggressive early surgical management of the regional nodal basin. However, those recommendations were the source of much controversy over nearly a century, until the minimally invasive surgical technique of sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy was developed by Morton, Cochran and colleagues. This technique has been evaluated in a series of prospective clinical trials, which have clarified its role and the management of lymph nodes in this disease. Current controversies relating to SLN biopsy include optimal selection of patients for the procedure, the role of gene expression profiling in initial melanoma management, and the potential therapeutic effects of SLN biopsy-based management. In addition, the SLN appears to be a rich source of data relating to the host–tumor interface and the immune microenvironment, which may advance our understanding of the biology of melanoma. Finally, although the surgical technique is well developed at this point, there may be additional technical improvements that are possible as well.