Dutch Wadden Sea Research Articles

Alkalinity sources in the Dutch Wadden Sea

Abstract. Total alkalinity (TA) is an important chemical property that plays a decisive role in the oceanic buffering capacity with respect to CO2. TA is mainly generated by weathering on land as well as by various anaerobic metabolic processes in the water and sediments. The Wadden Sea, located in the southern North Sea, is hypothesized to be a source of TA for the North Sea, but quantifications are scarce. This study shows observations of TA, dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC), and nutrients in the Dutch Wadden Sea in May 2019. Surface samples were taken along several transects in order to investigate spatial distribution patterns and compare them with data from the late 1980s. A tidal cycle was sampled to further shed light on TA generation and potential TA sources. We identified the Dutch Wadden Sea as a source of TA and estimated an export of 6.6 Mmol TA per tide to the North Sea. TA was generated in the sediments, with deep pore water flow during low tide enriching the surface water. A combination of anaerobic processes and CaCO3 dissolution were potential TA sources in the sediments. We deduce that seasonality and the associated nitrate availability specifically influence TA generation by denitrification, which is low in spring and summer.

Birds influence vegetation coverage and structure on sandy biogeomorphic islands in the Dutch Wadden Sea

Small uninhabited islands form important roosting and breeding habitats for many coastal birds. Previous studies have demonstrated that guano can promote ecosystem productivity and functionality on island ecosystems. Here, we assess the role of external nutrient input by coastal birds on the vegetation structure and coverage on sandy biogeomorphic islands, where island-forming processes depend on vegetation-sedimentation feedbacks. As a first step, we investigated whether breeding birds affect vegetation productivity on sandy back-barrier islands in the Wadden Sea. Using a combination of bird observations and plant stable isotope (δ15N) analyses, we demonstrate that (i) breeding birds transport large quantities of nutrients via their faecal outputs to these islands annually and that (ii) this external nitrogen source influences vegetation development on these sandy, nutrient-limited, islands. Based on these results we discuss how this avian nutrient pump could impact island development and habitat suitability for coastal birds and discuss future directions for research. In general, we conclude that avian subsidies have the potential to affect both the ecological and biogeomorphic functioning of coastal soft-sediment systems. However, the strength and scale of especially these biogeomorphic interactions are not fully understood. For the conservation of both threatened coastal birds and sandy back-barrier islands and the design of appropriate management strategies, we argue that three-way interactions between birds, vegetation and sandy island morphodynamics need to be further elucidated.

Stomach content analysis indicates multi decadal trophic stability in a temperate coastal fish food web, western Dutch Wadden Sea

Information about stomach content composition of fish species of a temperate coastal fish community (western Dutch Wadden Sea) over the period 1930–2019 was analysed to reconstruct long-term trends in trophic position of individual species. Stomach data were not evenly distributed but clustered both with respect to years as well as fish species. For 18 fish species, all being omnivorous and belonging to different functional groups (pelagic, benthopelagic, demersal) and guilds [(near)-resident, juvenile marine migrants, marine seasonal visitiors], prey consumption and trophic position over time could be analysed. Prey occurrence in the stomachs of different fish species showed variability over time, most likely due to fluctuations in prey abundance, but without a trend. For all species, individual fish showed variablity in trophic position in the order of 1 unit or even more both within and between years. However, in all 18 species, no significant trend in mean trophic position over time could be found, despite the serious anthropogenic stress (pollution, eutrophication events, climate change) and the decrease in fish abundance in the area during the last 50 years. The present study does not indicate any changes in trophic position of individual species in the western Dutch Wadden Sea over the last 80 years. At the community level, trophic structure varies due to interannual fluctuations in species composition and year-to year fluctuations in the relative abundance of the various fish species. At the ecosystem level the trophic role of the fish community has been degraded due to the decrease in total fish biomass in the area.

Small pelagic fish in the shallow Wadden Sea show opportunistic feeding with a strong benthic link

Abstract Small pelagic fish (SPF) are crucial in marine food webs, transferring energy from plankton to higher trophic levels. This study focuses on herring (Clupea harengus) and sprat (Sprattus sprattus), addressing knowledge gaps in their feeding ecology in a nursery area, the Dutch Wadden Sea. We conducted a year-long, monthly survey, and used DNA metabarcoding to analyse zooplankton samples and stomach contents of two size classes of herring and sprat. Intra-, interspecific, and seasonal variations in fish condition, stomach fullness, and diet composition, along with selective feeding, were studied. Our study showed that condition and diet composition of herring and sprat, along with zooplankton density, exhibited a clear seasonal pattern. Juvenile herring and sprat displayed opportunistic feeding behaviour, rather than showing distinct prey selection. Besides copepods, we regularly observed (larvae of) benthic invertebrates in their diet. This emphasizes the crucial role of SPF as energy transfer agents, not solely between trophic levels, but also from benthic to pelagic habitats. Furthermore, fish post-larvae were part of the diet of larger herring (10–15 cm). Because of its unprecedented temporal and taxonomical detail, this study advances the understanding of seasonal dynamics of dominant components at the base of the Wadden Sea food web.

Developing a novel index for detection of optically shallow waters using multispectral satellite imagery and radiative transfer modelling

ABSTRACT Optical remote sensing of water quality has been problematic due to contamination of remote sensing observations by the sea-bottom effect over complex shallow or very clear waters. This has resulted in providing misleading information on the estimation of Water Constituent Concentrations (WCCs) retrieved from satellite images. In this research, we used Radiative Transfer (RT) Modelling to develop a simple and innovative index named the Sea-Bottom Effect Index (SEBEI) to readily determine water pixels contaminated by the sea-bottom effect, (hereafter named Optically Shallow Waters, (OSWs)) from remote sensing observations. To define the SEBEI, we initially assessed the influence of the sea-bottom on simulated water-leaving reflectance (R rs ) using RT Water-Sea-Bottom (WSB) modelling. This evaluation encompassed a range of water depths, seabed albedos, and WCCs (i.e. Chlorophyll-a (Chla) and Suspended Particulate Matter (SPM)). Next, we detected the most sensitive wavelengths (i.e. 750 nm, 810 nm, and 900 nm) to the seabed contribution on the simulated R rs spectra at the water surface level and developed the SEBEI. We validated the accuracy of the proposed SEBEI over a time series of MEdium Resolution Imaging Spectrometer (MERIS) and Ocean and Land Colour Instrument (OLCI) images captured during low and high tidal phases over shallow waters of the Dutch Wadden Sea, the Netherlands. The results indicate that the SEBEI effectively distinguishes between OSWs and Optically Deep Waters (ODWs) using satellite images (with an R2 value of ≥ 0.97 and a Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) of ≤ 0.65). The SEBEI can serve as an intermediate solution for detecting OSWs in multispectral and hyperspectral satellite images worldwide. It eliminates the need for ancillary datasets like bathymetry maps and significantly enhances the reliability of WCC maps produced over complex shallow coastal waters.

Boosting efficiency of mussel spat collection for ecological sustainability: Identifying critical drivers and informing management

Abstract The long‐term sustainability of natural and bottom‐cultured mussel beds relies on the availability of spat (i.e. juvenile mussels). Traditional spat collection methods, which disrupt the donor population and its habitat, have prompted the adoption of suspended mussel spat collectors (SMCs) as an ecologically sustainable alternative. However, practical experience has demonstrated that SMC efficiency is subject to significant spatiotemporal variability, with the underlying biotic and abiotic drivers remaining unresolved. Based on 11‐year SMC practices in the Dutch Wadden Sea, we first validated, through field experiments, the inference that larval abundance and settlement rate in seawater are the primary determinants of SMC efficiency. Secondly, we screened the key factors driving variation in SMC efficiency using an integrated dataset that includes both management options (i.e. user‐defined factors, like SMC types) and environmental conditions (i.e. site‐specific factors, such as hydrodynamics). Lastly, we developed a predictive model to explore the sensitivity of SMC efficiency to these key factors. The efficiency of SMCs was not affected by larval abundance and settlement rate, but rather regulated by management options and environmental conditions, with the key factors identified as SMC type, substrate size, mean wave height and starfish abundance. Rope‐based SMCs outperform net‐based SMCs in terms of harvest efficiency. Both types of SMCs exhibit consistent sensitivity to environmental conditions, with harvest efficiency higher in areas with lower mean wave height and fewer starfish. Increasing substrate size (i.e. rope length and net area) in these areas has the potential to further improve SMC efficiency. Synthesis and applications: Our study highlights the importance of environmental conditions over life cycle‐related factors in regulating SMC efficiency. This offers optimistic prospects for investment in larger‐scale deployment of SMCs and maximizing efficiency through site suitability assessments beforehand. The predictive model we developed can provide information for this purpose. Furthermore, strategically adjusting management options would further optimize SMC efficiency, but it is necessary to balance the associated benefits and costs. Overall, our study underscores the predictability and controllability of SMC efficiency and informs management to maximize sustainable spat supply in both mussel culture and restoration.

Reintroduction of self-facilitating feedbacks could advance subtidal eelgrass (Zostera marina) restoration in the Dutch Wadden Sea

Extensive subtidal eelgrass (Zostera marina) meadows (~150 km2) once grew in the Dutch Wadden Sea, supporting diverse species communities, but disappeared in the 1930s and have been absent ever since. Identifying the most critical bottlenecks for eelgrass survival is a crucial first step for reintroduction through active restoration measures. Seagrasses are ecosystem engineers, inducing self-facilitating feedbacks that ameliorate stressful conditions. Consequently, once seagrass, including its self-facilitating feedbacks, is lost, reintroduction can be challenging. Therefore, we aimed to test whether 1) sediment stabilization and 2) hydrodynamic stress relief would facilitate eelgrass survival in a field experiment replicated at two sites in the Dutch Wadden Sea. We induced feedbacks using biodegradable root-mimicking structures (BESE-elements) and sandbag barriers. Root mimics had a significant positive effect, increasing the chances of short-term survival by +67% compared to controls. Contrary to our expectations, barriers decreased short-term survival probabilities by -26%, likely due to hydrodynamic turbulence created by the barrier edges, leading to high erosion rates (-14 cm). Site selection proved crucial as short-term survival was entirely negated on one of the two study sites after five weeks due to high floating and epiphytic macroalgae loads. No long-term survival occurred, as plants died at the other site two weeks later. Overall, we found that sediment stabilization by root-mimicking structures was promising, whereas manipulating hydrodynamic forces using sandbag barriers had adverse effects. A mechanistic understanding of transplant failures is required before attempting large-scale restoration. Our study indicates that for seagrass restoration in the Wadden Sea, one should carefully consider 1) the reintroduction of positive feedbacks through restoration tools, 2) donor population choice and transplantation timing, and 3) site selection based on local biotic and abiotic conditions. Optimizing these restoration facets might lower additive stress to a degree that allows long-term survival.

Future sediment transport to the Dutch Wadden Sea under severe sea level rise and tidal range change

Future sediment transport from the North Sea coasts to the Dutch Wadden Sea for various future sea level scenarios has been studied because it influences the future sand nourishment demand for the maintenance of the coastline and because it determines bio-geomorphological development of the Wadden Sea. The present study focuses on two questions which have not yet been considered in the previous modelling studies using ASMITA: How will the transport develop around drowning of the intertidal flats in the Wadden Sea? How will tidal range change influence the future sediment exchange? By using SLR scenarios with faster acceleration and running the simulations for longer periods of time some inlets exhibited drowning, i.e., where the tidal flat volume vanishes. When drowning occurs, the sediment import rate approaches a maximum or a minimum, depending on the initial morphological state of the tidal inlet system. This maximum or minimum rate for a certain tidal inlet system depends on the SLR scenario. Theoretical analysis as well as modelling results show that tidal range change will influence the sediment import to the Wadden Sea. A tidal range increase will cause a decrease of the sediment demand in the Wadden Sea resulting into less sediment import to the Wadden Sea. It is thus important to study the tidal range development in the Wadden Sea by considering the interaction between SLR, tidal range change and morphological development in the system. It is further concluded that the empirical relation used in the previous studies is not representative of conditions in a tidal basin with fixed basin area, even though this relation has been derived from field observations in many tidal inlet systems worldwide. The equilibrium channel volume should be proportional to the tidal prism instead of to its 1.5th power.

Mutual facilitation between foundation species Mytilus edulis and Lanice conchilega promotes habitat heterogeneity on tidal flats

Foundation species that modify their habitat can facilitate other species, including other foundation species. Most studies focus solely on a single foundation species, overlooking such facilitation cascades. In this study, we investigated the interactions between the two coastal foundation species Mytilus edulis (blue mussel) and Lanice conchilega (sand mason worm). We investigated whether these species engage in facilitative interactions or if their association simply reflects a shared ecological niche on the soft-sediment intertidal flats of the Dutch Wadden Sea. To do so, we performed species distribution modeling, manipulative field experiments, and field surveys. We found a positive association between both foundation species, with a 2.45 times higher occurrence of both species compared to a random distribution. In addition, these species partially occupied the same ecological niche. We demonstrated that L. conchilega provided settlement substrate for M. edulis spat, increasing densities by 400 times compared to bare plots. Furthermore, M. edulis reefs facilitated L. conchilega occurrence in the wake of the reef. Biogenic reef development revealed that this interspecific facilitation resulted in spatial habitat heterogeneity. Therefore, we conclude that interspecific facilitation can significantly enhance the occurrence of these two important intertidal foundation species. Acknowledgment of such complex facilitation interactions has an untapped potential for improving the success of restoration and conservation programs.

A multi-scale tracking approach for conserving large migratory fish in an open coastal environment

Coastal habitats serve essential roles in the life cycles of migratory fishes, impacting both local and regional population stability. Conservation efforts for coastal fish often rely on spatial approaches within designated boundaries to mitigate threats and enhance production. However, in open coastal environments, migratory behaviours can extend beyond these protected areas, exposing individuals to potential threats or population bottlenecks elsewhere in their range. To improve conservation outcomes, a comprehensive understanding of movements across the entire migratory range is essential. Aquatic telemetry is a valuable tool for studying these behaviours, but must be adapted to address questions at multiple spatial and temporal scales. In this study we demonstrate how a combination of telemetry techniques can capture both local and regional fish behaviours. We begin by introducing the implications of migratory behaviours for fish conservation in open coastal environments, using the Wadden Sea as an example where additional research and management are needed to address fish declines. We then present a case study which uses the Dutch Wadden Sea to illustrate how a multi-scale telemetry approach can enhance both fundamental knowledge and conservation strategies for migratory fish. Within this case study, we present the general movement strategies exhibited by coastal migrants, alongside an overview of telemetry techniques applicable for open coastal systems. We then apply a size-based assessment using a reference tag to estimate the suitability of common Wadden Sea species for long-term tracking. Drawing from these results, we select four example species to showcase how species-specific understanding of fish life history and abundance can guide tracking studies, accompanied by illustrative examples using telemetry data. Expanding from this case study, we transition to a broader discussion were we provide overarching perspectives on tracking in open coastal ecosystems and offer recommendations to enhance future tracking studies in the Wadden Sea. The integration of telemetry methodologies aligns research and management with fish movement over multiple scales, improving our understanding of fish behaviors and contributing to more effective conservation strategies.

Sex-specific nest attendance rhythm and foraging habitat use in a colony-breeding waterbird

Abstract In most colony-breeding species, biparental care during both egg incubation and chick-rearing is inevitable for successful reproduction, requiring parents to coordinate their nest attendance and foraging time. The extent to which the rhythm of nest attendance is adjusted to temporal and spatial variation in food availability is poorly understood. Here, we investigate whether the rhythm of nest attendance interacts with the spatial and temporal availability of foraging habitats in Eurasian spoonbills Platalea leucorodia breeding on Schiermonnikoog, a Dutch Wadden Sea barrier island. Spoonbills are tactile foragers that forage during both day and night in habitats of varying salinity. GPS-tracking combined with acceleration-based behavioral classification of 9 female and 13 male adult spoonbills between 2013 and 2019 revealed that, despite nearby foraging opportunities following a tidal rhythm, nest attendance followed a sex-specific diel rhythm. During incubation and chick-rearing, females attended the nest at night and foraged during the day, while males showed the reverse rhythm. Females made more and shorter foraging trips to, almost exclusively, nearby marine habitats, whereas the larger males often made long trips to forage in more distant freshwater habitats. Before and after breeding, females as well as males foraged primarily at night, suggesting that this is the preferred period of foraging for both sexes. Nevertheless, foraging habitat use remained sex-specific, being most likely explained by size-dependent foraging techniques. To conclude, the sex-specific rhythm of nest attendance is not shaped by the spatial and temporal availability of foraging habitats.

Environmental factors influencing red knot (Calidris canutus islandica) departure times of relocation flights within the non-breeding period.

Deciding when to depart on long-distance, sometimes global, movements can be especially important for flying species. Adverse weather conditions can affect energetic flight costs and navigational ability. While departure timings and conditions have been well-studied for migratory flights to and from the breeding range, few studies have focussed on flights within the non-breeding season. Yet in some cases, overwintering ranges can be large enough that ecological barriers, and a lack of resting sites en route, may resist movement, especially in unfavorable environmental conditions. Understanding the conditions that will enable or prohibit flights within an overwintering range is particularly relevant in light of climate change, whereby increases in extreme weather events may reduce the connectivity of sites. We tracked 495 (n = 251 in 2019; n = 244 in 2020) overwintering red knots (Calidris canutus islandica) in the Dutch Wadden Sea and investigated how many departed towards the UK (on westward relocation flights), which requires flying over the North Sea. For those that departed, we used a resource selection model to determine the effect of environmental conditions on the timing of relocation flights. Specifically, we investigated the effects of wind, rain, atmospheric pressure, cloud cover, and migratory timing relative to sunset and tidal cycle, which have all been shown to be crucial to migratory departure conditions. Approximately 37% (2019) and 36% (2020) of tagged red knots departed on westward relocation flights, indicating differences between individuals' space use within the overwintering range. Red knots selected for departures between 1 and 2.5 h after sunset, approximately 4 h before high tide, with tailwinds and little cloud cover. However, rainfall and changes in atmospheric pressure appear unimportant. Our study reveals environmental conditions that are important for relocation flights across an ecological barrier, indicating potential consequences of climate change on connectivity.

Measurements of morphodynamics of a sheltered beach along the Dutch Wadden Sea

Abstract. A field campaign was carried out at a sheltered sandy beach with the aim of gaining new insights into the driving processes behind sheltered beach morphodynamics. Detailed measurements of the local hydrodynamics, bed-level changes and sediment composition were collected at a man-made beach on the leeside of the barrier island Texel, bordering the Marsdiep basin that is part of the Dutch Wadden Sea. The dataset consists of (1) current, wave and turbidity measurements from a dense cross-shore array and a 3 km alongshore array; (2) sediment composition data from beach surface samples; (3) high-temporal-resolution RTK-GNSS beach profile measurements; (4) a pre-campaign spatially covering topobathy map; and (5) meteorological data. This paper outlines how these measurements were set up and how the data have been processed, stored and can be accessed. The novelty of this dataset lies in the detailed approach to resolve forcing conditions on a sheltered beach, where morphological evolution is governed by a subtle interplay between tidal and wind-driven currents, waves and bed composition, primarily due to the low-energy (near-threshold) forcing. The data are publicly available at 4TU Centre for Research Data at: https://doi.org/10.4121/19c5676c-9cea-49d0-b7a3-7c627e436541 (Van der Lugt et al., 2023).

When slow explorers are fast: Personality‐related differences in timing of migration in Red Knots (Calidris canutus)

The timing of migration varies significantly among individuals, even within populations sharing breeding sites. Consistent individual behavioural differences, known as personality traits, have been linked to variation in movement behaviour. However, little attention has been given to investigating whether personality traits can explain such variation in the timing of migration. We studied post‐breeding migration of Red Knots Calidris canutus islandica breeding in the High Arctic and wintering in European coastal areas. We captured Red Knots in the Dutch Wadden Sea, a main non‐breeding and moulting site, and assessed their exploration behaviour, a personality trait, before releasing them with colour‐rings. We first investigated whether arrival timing in marine areas was associated with exploration speed. Secondly, we asked whether slow explorers were more likely to fly non‐stop to the Wadden Sea compared with fast explorers, as faster explorers were expected to move more and visit more staging sites. To determine arrival timing in marine non‐breeding areas and non‐stop flights to the Wadden Sea, we analysed isotope signatures in blood samples collected after capture, as these differ between the terrestrial breeding grounds (arthropod diet) and marine non‐breeding and moulting sites (benthic invertebrate diet). Thirdly, we estimated arrival time in the Wadden Sea based on primary moult progress, allowing us to examine the relationship between arrival timing estimated from isotope values and the onset of moult. Our findings revealed that slower exploring Red Knots departed earlier from the breeding site and were more likely to fly non‐stop to the Wadden Sea than were faster exploring individuals. Arrival timing to marine areas as estimated from isotope analyses predicted arrival timing in the Wadden Sea (via moult progress) but this relationship exhibited significant variation, possibly due to individual differences in the use of staging sites en route. By migrating early, slower explorers can better outpace the aerial predators also arriving at the Wadden Sea moulting site and thereby reduce mortality risk due to predation.

Restored intertidal eelgrass (Z. marina) supports benthic communities taxonomically and functionally similar to natural seagrasses in the Wadden Sea

Ecological restoration has become an important management-tool to counteract the widespread losses of seagrass meadows and their associated biodiversity. In the Dutch Wadden Sea, long-term restoration efforts have recently led to the successful restoration of annual eelgrass (Zostera marina) at high densities on a local scale. However, it is yet unknown if restored seagrass plants also lead to improved local biodiversity and ecosystem functioning in the intertidal zone. We therefore compared the macrozoobenthos communities of a small-scale restored meadow to 22 naturally occurring intertidal seagrass meadows. Using a taxonomic and trait-based approach we aimed to study 1) how intertidal seagrasses (Zostera marina and Zostera noltii) affect benthic communities and their functional trait distribution and 2) if a restored meadow facilitates benthic communities similar to natural meadows. We found that both natural and restored seagrasses increased abundances of benthic animals and the richness (both taxonomic and functional) of associated benthic communities compared to nearby unvegetated areas. Additionally, the presence of intertidal seagrass shifted benthic community composition both taxonomically and functionally, thus broadening the niche space for species inhabiting tidal flats. Seagrasses especially facilitated epifaunal species and traits associated with these animals. Surprisingly, our results indicate that the mere presence of seagrass aboveground structure is enough to facilitate benthic communities, as neither higher seagrass cover nor biomass increased benthic biodiversity in the intertidal zone. By studying the effect of seagrass restoration on benthic diversity, we found that the restored meadow functioned similarly to the natural meadows after only two years and that the success of our restoration efforts indeed led to local biodiversity enhancements. Our findings contribute to the understanding of the ecological functioning of intertidal seagrasses and can be used to define/refine conservation and restoration goals of these valuable ecosystems.

Aggregation of monitoring datasets for functional diversity estimation

Long-term monitoring data is central for the analysis of biodiversity change and its drivers. Time series allow a more accurate evaluation of diversity indices, trait identification and community turnover. However, evaluating data collected across different monitoring programs remains complicated because of data discrepancies and inconsistencies. Here we propose a method for aggregating datasets using diffusion maps. The method is illustrated by aggregating long-term phytoplankton abundance data from the Wadden Sea and Southern North Sea gathered by two institutions located in Germany and The Netherlands. The aggregated data allowed us to infer species traits, to reconstruct the main trait axis which drives community functionality, ultimately quantifying functional diversity of the individual samples, having used only the co-occurrence of species in samples. Although functional diversity varies greatly among sampling stations, we detect a slight positive trend in German stations, which contrasts with the clear decreasing trend observed in most of the Dutch Wadden Sea stations. At the Terschelling transect, in Southern North Sea, the stations also showed contrasting estimations of functional diversity between off-shore and in-shore stations. Our research provides further evidence that traits and functional diversity can be robustly reconstructed from monitoring data alone, showing that data aggregation can increase the accuracy of this reconstruction, being able to aggregate heterogeneous datasets.

The effects of gas extraction under intertidal mudflats on sediment and macrozoobenthic communities

Abstract Land subsidence in intertidal environments may change the flooding regime and sediment composition, two drivers of the macrozoobenthic community. In the Dutch Wadden Sea, a UNESCO world heritage site, gas extraction has resulted in an average subsidence of intertidal mudflats of 2 mm year−1. These mudflats support an abundant macrozoobenthic community that offers important resources for birds and fish. The area is managed through the ‘hand on the tap’ principle, meaning that human activities should be halted if they affect the natural values. To what extent land subsidence affects sediment and macrozoobenthos remains unknown and is increasingly important given sea level rise. Taking advantage of a large‐scale monitoring program, we evaluated the effect of anthropogenically caused subsidence on sediment composition and macrozoobenthos. Nearly 4600 points were sampled yearly (2008–2020) across the Dutch Wadden Sea, allowing us to compare sediment composition and macrozoobenthos biomass within and outside the subsidence area while controlling for the main drivers of these variables. We also compared population trends within and outside the subsidence area for 31 species with different habitat use. Mud fraction was 3% higher within the subsided area and median grain size decreased at 1 μm year−1 while remaining constant in other mudflats. This had no effect on the total biomass of macrozoobenthos. Within the subsidence area, however, the biomass of species that use deeper areas increased compared to outside, and the opposite was true for species using shallower habitat. Policy implications: Land subsidence is related to changes in median grain size and macrozoobenthic community composition. However, because thresholds have not been defined, it is not clear if this requires management actions. For a successful implementation of the ‘hand on the tap’ principle in the Wadden Sea, it is necessary to define beforehand the relevant variables that represent the natural values, implement proper monitoring and define thresholds above which effects are not acceptable. We propose median grain size, mud fraction and macrozoobenthic composition as good measures of the natural values of the Wadden Sea, and the methods used here as a way for identifying anthropogenic effects on them.

The seafloor from a trait perspective. A comprehensive life history dataset of soft sediment macrozoobenthos

Biological trait analysis (BTA) is a valuable tool for evaluating changes in community diversity and its link to ecosystem processes as well as environmental and anthropogenic perturbations. Trait-based analytical techniques like BTA rely on standardised datasets of species traits. However, there are currently only a limited number of datasets available for marine macrobenthos that contain trait data across multiple taxonomic groups. Here, we present an open-access dataset of 16 traits for 235 macrozoobenthic species recorded throughout multiple sampling campaigns of the Dutch Wadden Sea; a dynamic soft bottom system where humans have long played a substantial role in shaping the coastal environment. The trait categories included in this dataset cover a variety of life history strategies that are tightly linked to ecosystem functioning and the resilience of communities to (anthropogenic) perturbations and can advance our understanding of environmental changes and human impacts on the functioning of soft bottom systems.

Diel and seasonal methane dynamics in the shallow and turbulent Wadden Sea

Abstract. The Wadden Sea is a coastal system along the fringe of the land–sea borders of Denmark, Germany and the Netherlands. The Wadden Sea is extremely productive and influenced by strong variations in physical and biological forcing factors that act on timescales of hours to seasons. Productive coastal seas are known to dominate the ocean's methane emission to the atmosphere, but knowledge of controls and temporal variations in methane dynamics in these vastly dynamic systems is scarce. Here we address this knowledge gap by measuring methane inventories and methanotrophic activity at a temporal resolution of 1 h over a period of 2 d, repeatedly during four successive seasons in the central Dutch Wadden Sea. We found that methane dynamics varied between colder and warmer seasons, with generally higher water column methane concentrations and methanotrophic activity in the warmer seasons. The efflux of methane to the atmosphere was, on the other hand, lower in the warmer seasons because of lower wind speeds. On a diel scale, tides controlled methanotrophic activity, which increased ∼40 % at low tide compared to high tide. We estimate that methane oxidizing bacteria reduce the methane budget of the Dutch Wadden Sea by only 2 %, while ∼1/3 escapes to the atmosphere and ∼2/3 are flushed out into the open North Sea at ebb tide. Our findings indicate that tides play a key role in controlling methane dynamics and methanotrophic activity and highlight the importance of high-resolution and repeated sampling strategies to resolve methane dynamics in fast-changing coastal systems.

A re‐evaluation of the effects of mechanical cockle dredging in the Dutch Wadden Sea

Abstract Marine bivalves provide an important seafood resource, but conflicts between bivalve fisheries and conservation goals may arise. A scientific debate about cockle dredging in the Dutch Wadden Sea resulted in an apparent consensus among scientists of a severe and long‐lasting impact of the mechanical fisheries, and the fisheries were banned. Specifically, two highly cited papers concluded that the fisheries caused a strong reduction in bivalve recruitment for a period of 8 years and that the fisheries led to the loss of red knots from the Dutch Wadden Sea and a decline of the European wintering population. Here, we show that these papers had severe shortcomings in terms of data selection and data analysis and we challenge their conclusions.