Between January 2004 and June 2006, a total of 66 unselected peripheral blood or marrow aspirate samples from patients with evidence of myeloproliferation were received by our cytogenetics and molecular laboratory for BCR/ABL detection to exclude chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML) [morphological diagnosis: polycythaemia vera (PV) in 10, essential thrombocythaemia (ET) in 22, chronic idiopathic myelofibrosis (CIMF) in 12, hypereosinophilic syndrome in one, chronic myeloproliferative diseases (CMPD), unspecified in 20 and myelodysplastic/myeloproliferative diseases (MDS/MPD) in one]. Significant peripheral basophilia (absolute basophil count >1 × 109/l) was only seen in four of 57 patients with available white cell differential counts (two with CMPD, one with PV and one with CIMF), and none of them had a count >2 × 109/l. Marrow morphology was examined by haematopathologists before genetic testing. In 60 patients with available marrow aspirate specimen, proliferation of small and hypolobulated megakaryocytes typical of CML were found and documented in only four cases (one each of CMPD, unspecified, PV, ET and MDS/MPD). As none of these 66 patients received a morphological diagnosis of CML from initial peripheral blood and/or marrow examination, according to our protocol we did not perform conventional cytogenetics but employed dual-colour dual-fusion fluorescence in-situ hybridisation (D-FISH; Vysis, Downers Grove, IL, USA) for exclusion of BCR/ABL fusion in this setting (Wan et al, 2003). Three hundred nuclei were scored in each case. Test sensitivity was 0·8%. BCR/ABL fusion was not detected in any of the 66 cases. A further 14 cases with a pretest diagnosis of reactive cytosis were analysed in the same period by D-FISH and all showed a negative result. During this period, 72 cases with a morphological diagnosis of CML were analysed by conventional cytogenetics in our laboratory (plus FISH in nine cases that showed no growth or a normal karyotype). Of these, 51 cases were previously untreated and had blood counts and bone marrow examination results reported before karyotyping. All 51 cases were documented to have proliferation of small and hypolobulated megakaryocytes in bone marrow and significant peripheral basophilia of >1 × 109/l (range 1·15–38·82 × 109/l, median 10·64 × 109/l; basophil count >2 × 109/l in 47 cases). The diagnosis was confirmed in 70 cases by the detection of t(9;22)(q34;q11.2) in 63 out of 72 cases examined or positive FISH fusion signals in seven out of nine cases examined. A review of the records during this period showed that a Ph chromosome was detected in 11 non-CML cases by conventional cytogenetics. None of them had a pretest diagnosis of CMPD (precursor lymphoblastic leukaemia in nine, acute myeloid leukaemia in two). Although one may argue that the present FISH technique with 0·8% test sensitivity may not be able to detect a very small BCR/ABL fusion-positive clone, this should not be relevant in our series as most patients were newly diagnosed and untreated. None of them had received imatinib, which could have reduced the clone size to this level. Our results show that cases lacking characteristic morphological features of CML are highly unlikely to be positive for BCR/ABL fusion. Careful morphological examination can therefore help to decide whether further genetic testing to exclude CML is indicated. The well-accepted, but not well-scrutinised, approach of screening all patients with CMPD for BCR/ABL fusion to exclude CML needs to be re-evaluated. Careful re-examination of those rarely reported cases of ‘PV-like’ or ‘ET-like’ CML for these highly sensitive morphological features is warranted. We propose that in patients with evidence of myeloproliferation but without significant peripheral blood basophilia and lacking characteristic small hypolobulated megakaryocytes on bone marrow examination, specific genetic tests performed solely for the purpose of excluding CML can safely be withheld, unless suggestive morphological features develop during monitoring. With this approach, laboratory resources can be utilised more cost-effectively.
Read full abstract