Dual-ended Readout Research Articles

The Software System of a Dedicated Brain PET Scanner Using Dual-Ended Readout Detectors With High-DOI Resolution

The Software System of a Dedicated Brain PET Scanner Using Dual-Ended Readout Detectors With High-DOI Resolution

Evaluation of monolithic crystal detector with dual-ended readout utilizing multiplexing method

Objective. Monolithic crystal detectors are increasingly being applied in positron emission tomography (PET) devices owing to their excellent depth-of-interaction (DOI) resolution capabilities and high detection efficiency. In this study, we constructed and evaluated a dual-ended readout monolithic crystal detector based on a multiplexing method. Approach. We employed two 12 × 12 silicon photomultiplier (SiPM) arrays for readout, and the signals from the 12 × 12 array were merged into 12 X and 12 Y channels using channel multiplexing. In 2D reconstruction, three methods based on the centre of gravity (COG) were compared, and the concept of thresholds was introduced. Furthermore, a light convolutional neural network (CNN) was employed for testing. To enhance depth localization resolution, we proposed a method by utilizing the mutual information from both ends of the SiPMs. The source width and collimation effect were simulated using GEANT4, and the intrinsic spatial resolution was separated from the measured values. Main results. At an operational voltage of 29 V for the SiPM, an energy resolution of approximately 12.5 % was achieved. By subtracting a 0.8 % threshold from the total energy in every channel, a 2D spatial resolution of approximately 0.90 mm full width at half maximum (FWHM) can be obtained. Furthermore, a higher level of resolution, approximately 0.80 mm FWHM, was achieved using a CNN, with some alleviation of edge effects. With the proposed DOI method, a significant 1.36 mm FWHM average DOI resolution can be achieved. Additionally, it was found that polishing and black coating on the crystal surface yielded smaller edge effects compared to a rough surface with a black coating. Significance. The introduction of a threshold in COG method and a dual-ended readout scheme can lead to excellent spatial resolution for monolithic crystal detectors, which can help to develop PET systems with both high sensitivity and high spatial resolution.

Performance Comparison of DOI-Encoding PET Detectors Based on 1.1-mm Pitch BGO Arrays With Different Reflectors.

Bismuth germanate (BGO)-based positron emission tomography (PET) detectors are potential candidates for low-dose imaging PET scanners, owing to the high stopping power and low background radiation of BGO. In this paper, we compared the performance of two dual-ended readout PET detectors based on 15 × 15 BGO arrays. Both arrays had the same 1.1 mm pitch but utilized different reflectors - barium sulfate (BaSO4) and enhanced specular reflector film (ESR) - for high-resolution PET applications. The detectors were constructed with Hamamatsu 13361-2050-08 SiPM arrays. Each BGO element had dimensions of 1.02 × 1.02 × 20 mm3. The lateral surfaces of the BGO elements were unpolished (saw-cut), while the two ends were polished. Flood histograms showed that the detector based on the BGO array with BaSO4 reflector had much better crystal identification and depth-of-interaction (DOI) resolution. Specifically, the energy, DOI, and timing resolutions for the detector using the BGO array with BaSO4 reflector were 19.8 ± 1.5%, 4.13 ± 0.48 mm, and 2.80 ± 0.23 ns, respectively. In contrast, the values obtained using the BGO array with ESR reflector were 20.9 ± 2.1%, 7.69 ± 1.92 mm, and 2.93 ± 0.20 ns, respectively.

Light response uniformity of LuAG:Ce scintillating single crystal fiber grown by laser heated pedestal growth method

Own to its fine granularity and sub-millimeter position information, scintillating single crystal fibers (SSCFs) hold great potential for various applications such as electromagnetic calorimeters, positron emission tomography, and radiotherapy dosimetry. The light response uniformity of scintillating fibers is an important parameter for precise measurements of ionizing radiation. Three methods were designed to investigate the light response uniformity of the 184-mm-long LuAG:Ce SCCF. Relatively longitudinal-distributed uniformity of cerium element was obtained in this SSCF. The scintillation light attenuation coefficient of the SSCF is 0.27 cm−1 induced by X-ray photons with single-end readout mode and about 0.29 cm−1 induced by gamma rays with dual-end readout mode. The Ce3+ ions self-absorption along the longitudinal light propagation process is one of main reasons for the scintillation light attenuation. Weakening the Ce3+ ions’ self-absorption effect is a possible way to improve the light response uniformity of the LuAG:Ce SSCF.

Development and performance of SIAT bPET: a high-resolution and high-sensitivity MR-compatible brain PET scanner using dual-ended readout detectors.

Positron emission tomography/magnetic resonance imaging (PET/MRI) is a powerful tool for brain imaging, but the spatial resolution of the PET scanners currently used for brain imaging can be further improved to enhance the quantitative accuracy of brain PET imaging. The purpose of this study is to develop an MR-compatible brain PET scanner that can simultaneously achieve a uniform high spatial resolution and high sensitivity by using dual-ended readout depth encoding detectors. The MR-compatible brain PET scanner, named SIAT bPET, consists of 224 dual-ended readout detectors. Each detector contains a 26 × 26 lutetium yttrium oxyorthosilicate (LYSO) crystal array of 1.4 × 1.4 × 20 mm3 crystal size read out by two 10 × 10 silicon photomultiplier (SiPM) arrays from both ends. The scanner has a detector ring diameter of 376.8mm and an axial field of view (FOV) of 329mm. The performance of the scanner including spatial resolution, sensitivity, count rate, scatter fraction, and image quality was measured. Imaging studies of phantoms and the brain of a volunteer were performed. The mutual interferences of the PET insert and the uMR790 3T MRI scanner were measured, and simultaneous PET/MRI imaging of the brain of a volunteer was performed. A spatial resolution of better than 1.5mm with an average of 1.2mm within the whole FOV was obtained. A sensitivity of 11.0% was achieved at the center FOV for an energy window of 350-750keV. Except for the dedicated RF coil, which caused a ~ 30% reduction of the sensitivity of the PET scanner, the MRI sequences running had a negligible effect on the performance of the PET scanner. The reduction of the SNR and homogeneity of the MRI images was less than 2% as the PET scanner was inserted to the MRI scanner and powered-on. High quality PET and MRI images of a human brain were obtained from simultaneous PET/MRI scans. The SIAT bPET scanner achieved a spatial resolution and sensitivity better than all MR-compatible brain PET scanners developed up to date. It can be used either as a standalone brain PET scanner or a PET insert placed inside a commercial whole-body MRI scanner to perform simultaneous PET/MRI imaging.

Coincidence time resolution measurements for dual-ended readout PET detectors

Coincidence time resolution (CTR) is an important performance parameter of clinical positron emission tomography (PET) detectors, which is dependent on the parameters of the scintillation crystal, the timing measurement methods, and the electronics. In this work, CTRs of PET detectors using dual-ended readout of segmented LYSO arrays were measured with different timing measurement methods. The detector modules were composed of LYSO arrays of 8 × 8 with a crystal size of 3.10 × 3.10 × 20 mm3 or 13 × 13 with a crystals size of 1.88 × 1.88 × 20 mm3, coupled at each end to an 8 × 8 Hamamatsu SiPM array (S13361-3050NE-08) with pixel active area of 3.00 × 3.00 mm2 and pitch of 3.20 mm. The signals of the SiPM arrays were individually read out and processed by using the TOFPET2 ASICs. The CTRs of the detectors were measured after the timing alignment of the ASICs was performed. Timing measurement methods of the dual-ended readout detector such as the average time of the two SiPMs, the faster time of the two SiPMs, the time of the back SiPM, and the time of the front SiPM were compared. The average time of the two SiPMs provides the best CTR, which is explained by a simple model about the timing measurement methods of a dual-ended readout detector. The detector with one-to-one crystal-to-SiPM coupling provides better CTR than the detector with a crystal size smaller than the pixel size of the SiPM. The best CTR of 367 ± 6 ps was obtained by using the 8 × 8 LYSO array with unpolished lateral crystal surfaces and ESR reflectors. The CTR of the dual-ended readout detector can be improved if a DOI-dependent timing correction is used.

Depth-of-interaction positron emission tomography detector with 45° tilted silicon photomultipliers using dual-ended signal readout.

Small-animal positron emission tomography (PET) systems are widely used in molecular imaging research and drug development. There is also growing interest in organ-dedicated clinical PET systems. In these small-diameter PET systems, the measurement of the depth-of-interaction (DOI) of annihilation photons in scintillation crystals allows for the correction of parallax error in PET system, leading to an improvement on the spatial resolution uniformity. The DOI information is also useful for improving the timing resolution of PET system as it enables the correction of DOI-dependent time walk in the arrival time difference measurement of annihilation photon pairs. The dual-ended readout scheme is one of the most widely investigated DOI measurement methods, which collects visible photons using a pair of photosensors located at both ends of the scintillation crystal. Although the dual-ended readout allows for simple and accurate DOI estimation, it requires twice the number of photosensors compared to the single-ended readout scheme. To effectively reduce the number of photosensors in a dual-ended readout scheme, we propose a novel PET detector configuration that employs 45° tilted and sparsely arranged silicon photomultipliers (SiPMs). In this configuration, the angle between the scintillation crystal and SiPM is 45°. Therefore, and thus, the diagonal of the scintillation crystal matches one of the lateral sides of the SiPM. Accordingly, it allows for the use of SiPM device larger than the scintillation crystal, thereby improving light collection efficiency with a higher fill factor and reducing SiPM quantity. In addition, all scintillation crystals can achieve more uniform performance than other dual-ended readout methods with a sparse SiPM arrangement because 50% of the scintillation crystal cross section is commonly in contact with the SiPM. To demonstrate the feasibility of our proposed concept, we implemented a PET detector that employs a 4 4 LSO block with a single crystal dimension of 3.03 × 3.03 × 20 mm3 and a 45° tilted SiPM array. The 45° tilted SiPM array consists of 2 × 3 SiPM elements at the top ("Top SiPM") and 3 × 2 SiPM elements at the bottom ("Bottom SiPM"). Each crystal element of the 4 × 4 LSO block is optically coupled with each quarter section of the Top SiPM and Bottom SiPM pair. To characterize the performance of the PET detector, the energy, DOI, and timing resolution were measured for all 16 crystals. The energy data was obtained by summing all the charges from the Top SiPMs and Bottom SiPMs, and the DOI resolution was measured by irradiating the side of the crystal block at five different depths (2, 6, 10, 14, and 18mm). The timing was estimated by averaging the arrival time of the annihilation photons measured at the Top SiPMs and Bottom SiPMs (Method 1). The DOI-dependent time-walk effect was further corrected by using DOI information and statistical variations in the trigger times at the Top SiPMs and Bottom SiPMs (Method 2). The average DOI resolution of the proposed PET detector was 2.5mm, thereby resolving the DOI at five different depths, and the average energy resolution was 16% full width at half maximum (FWHM). When Methods 1 and 2 were applied, the coincidence timing resolutions were 448 and 411ps FWHM, respectively. We expect that our novel low-cost PET detector design with 45° tilted SiPMs and a dual-ended readout scheme would be a suitable solution for constructing a high-resolution PET system with DOI encoding capability.

Single-Ended Readout Depth-of-Interaction Measurements Based on Random Forest Algorithm

The depth-of-interaction (DOI) information can reduce parallax errors and improve the spatial resolution of positron emission tomography (PET) imaging. Current DOI detectors, with either single-ended readout design or dual-ended readout design, usually require substantial changes to the crystal arrays and/or readout electronics. In this work, we proposed a single-ended readout DOI estimation approach with minimal changes in the detector hardware design, using a supervised machine learning algorithm, random forest (RF). The energy value measured from one end of the crystal, combined with sample points of the pulse signal, were used as inputs to the DOI estimation algorithm, which provided a DOI performance close to that of the dual-ended readout design. We compared the proposed single-ended RF method with the classic dual-ended energy ratio method and a dual-ended version of the RF method, using positioning error and resolution as performance metrics for DOI estimation. All three methods achieved average absolute DOI positioning errors of < 1.00 mm and average DOI resolutions of < 2.20 mm full width at half maximum (FWHM). More specifically, we achieved the averaged DOI resolutions of 2.15, 1.80, and 1.93 mm FWHM for the single-ended RF method, dual-ended RF method, and dual-ended energy ratio method, respectively. In conclusion, the single-ended RF method achieved comparable performance without extra photodetectors and readout electronics and may provide a feasible solution for DOI estimation.

Mutual interferences between SIAT aPET insert and a 3 T uMR 790 MRI scanner

Objective. Dual-modality small animal PET/MR imaging provides temporally correlated information on two biochemical processes of a living object. An magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-compatible small animal PET insert named Shenzhen Institutes of Advanced Technology (SIAT) aPET was developed by using dual-ended readout depth encoding detectors to simultaneously achieve a uniform high spatial resolution and high sensitivity at the SIAT. In this work, the mutual interferences between SIAT aPET and the 3 T uMR 790 MRI scanner of United Imaging was quantitatively evaluated. Approach. To minimize the mutual interferences, only the PET detectors and the readout electronics were placed inside the MRI scanner, the major signal processing electronic was placed in the corner of the MRI room and the auxiliary unit was placed in the MRI technical room. A dedicated mouse radio fRequency (RF) coil with a transmitter and receiver was developed for the PET insert. The effects of PET scanner on the B 0 and B 1 field of the MRI scanner and the quality of the MRI images were measured. The effects of MRI imaging on the performance of both the PET detectors and scanner were also measured. Main results. The electronic and mechanical components of the PET insert affected the homogeneity of the B 0 field. The PET insert had no effect on the homogeneity of B 1 produced by the dedicated mouse coil but slightly reduced the strength of B 1. The mean and standard deviation of the RF noise map were increased by 2.2% and 11.6%, respectively, while the PET insert was placed in the MRI scanner and powered on. Eddy current was produced while the PET insert was placed in the MRI scanner, and it was further increased while the PET insert was powered on. Despite the above-mentioned interferences from the PET insert, the MR images of a uniform cylindrical water phantom showed that the changes in the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and homogeneity as the PET insert was placed in the MRI scanner were acceptable regardless of whether the PET insert was powered off or powered on. The maximum reduction of SNR was less than 11%, and the maximum reduction of homogeneity was less than 2.5% while the PET insert was placed inside the MRI scanner and powered on for five commonly used MRI sequences. MRI using gradient echo (GRE), spin echo (SE) and fast spin echo (FSE) sequences had negligible effects on the flood histograms and energy resolution of the PET detectors, as well as the spatial resolution and sensitivity of the PET scanner. Significance. The mutual interference between the SIAT aPET and the 3 T uMR 790 MRI scanner are acceptable. Simultaneous PET/MRI imaging of small animals can be performed with the two scanners.

Technical note: Comparison of arithmetic mean and energy-weighted mean flood histogram generation methods for dual-ended readout positron emission tomography detectors.

Dual-ended readout pixelated scintillator array detectors can provide a suitable crystal resolvability and satisfactory depth of interaction (DOI), energy, and timing resolutions. Usually, the flood histogram measured by one-sided readout is depth dependent, and the flood histogram quality degrades as the distance between the interaction site and photodetector increases. Information measured by two photodetectors must be combined to obtain an improved flood histogram yielding a better PET scanner spatial resolution. Two flood histogram generation algorithms for dual-ended readout of pixelated scintillator array detectors were compared by theoretical calculations and experimental measurements. The first algorithm is the arithmetic mean (AM) algorithm, which assigns the same weight to the flood histograms measured by photodetectors 1 and 2. The second algorithm is the energy-weighted mean (EWM) algorithm, which assigns each flood histogram a certain weight proportional to the energy measured by the photodetector. Theoretical equations were derived to determine the quality of the flood histograms obtained with these two algorithms. Experimental measurements were performed with an 18 × 18 lutetium-yttrium oxyorthosilicate (LYSO) array with a crystal size of 0.62 × 0.62 × 20 mm3 read out by two multi-anode photomultiplier tubes at both ends. Flood histograms of the whole array and five specific depths were compared between the above two algorithms. The theoretical results indicated that the flood histograms obtained with the EWM method matched those obtained with the AM method at the middle detector depth and were better at other detector depths when the distance (S) between the locations of the same crystal in the flood histograms measured by photodetectors 1 and 2 reached 0. The advantage of the EWM method decreased with increasing S value since the crystal position in the flood histogram obtained with the EWM method varies with the depth when S does not equal 0. The advantage of the EWM method decreased with increasing S value. The experimental results generally agreed with the theoretical predictions. Compared to the AM method, the EWM method provided a similar flood histogram at a depth of 10 mm but generated a better flood histogram at depths of 2 and 18 mm. Although an inverse correlation between Q (a quality factor representing the advantage of the EWM method) and S was observed, the variation in Q given the same S value was high. The average Q value at the same S still agreed with the theoretical predictions. Theoretical equations were derived, and experimental measurements were performed to compare two flood histogram generation algorithms for dual-ended readout PET detectors. The results indicated that the EWM method based on inverse variance weighting theory could provide better flood histograms than those provided by the AM method.

Performance of Dual-Ended Readout PET Detectors Based on BGO Arrays and BaSO4 Reflector.

In this paper, the performance of two dual-ended readout PET detectors based on 15 × 15 BGO arrays were compared. The crystal elements of one BGO array have polished lateral surfaces, while the crystal elements of the other BGO array have unpolished lateral surfaces. The two ends of the BGO elements are polished. The two BGO arrays both have a pitch size of 1.6 mm and thickness of 20 mm, and BaSO4 with a thickness of 80 μm was used as the reflector. Hamamatsu S14161-0305-08 SiPM arrays were used as photodetectors. All the measurements were performed at a bias voltage of 41.0 V and a temperature of 23.5 °C. The flood histograms show that all the crystal elements in the two BGO arrays were clearly resolved. The detector based on the BGO array with polished lateral surfaces provides an energy resolution of 16.9 ± 1.3%, timing resolution of 3.2 ± 0.2 ns, and DOI resolution of 18.4 ± 2.2 mm. In comparison, the detector based on the BGO array with unpolished lateral surfaces provides an energy resolution of 17.7 ± 2.0%, timing resolution of 3.5 ± 0.3 ns, and DOI resolution of 3.2 ± 0.2 mm.

High resolution detectors for whole-body PET scanners by using dual-ended readout

BackgroundMost current whole-body positron emission tomography (PET) scanners use detectors with high timing resolution to measure the time-of-flight of two 511 keV photons, improving the signal-to-noise ratio of PET images. However, almost all current whole-body PET scanners use detectors without depth-encoding capability; therefore, their spatial resolution can be affected by the parallax effect.MethodsIn this work, four depth-encoding detectors consisting of LYSO arrays with crystals of 2.98 × 2.98 × 20 mm3, 2.98 × 2.98 × 30 mm3, 1.95 × 1.95 × 20 mm3, and 1.95 × 1.95 × 30 mm3, respectively, were read at both ends, with 6 × 6 mm2 silicon photomultiplier (SiPM) pixels in a 4 × 4 array being used. The timing signals of the detectors were processed individually using an ultrafast NINO application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC) to obtain good timing resolution. The 16 energy signals of the SiPM array were read using a row and column summing circuit to obtain four position-encoding energy signals.ResultsThe four PET detectors provided good flood histograms in which all crystals could be clearly resolved, the crystal energy resolutions measured being 10.2, 12.1, 11.4 and 11.7% full width at half maximum (FWHM), at an average crystal depth of interaction (DOI) resolution of 3.5, 3.9, 2.7, and 3.0 mm, respectively. The depth dependence of the timing of each SiPM was measured and corrected, the timing of the two SiPMs being used as the timing of the dual-ended readout detector. The four detectors provided coincidence time resolutions of 180, 214, 239, and 263 ps, respectively.ConclusionsThe timing resolution of the dual-ended readout PET detector was approximately 20% better than that of the single-ended readout detector using the same LYSO array, SiPM array, and readout electronics. The detectors developed in this work used long crystals with small cross-sections and provided good flood histograms, DOI, energy, and timing resolutions, suggesting that they could be used to develop whole-body PET scanners with high sensitivity, uniform high spatial resolution, and high timing resolution.

Performance evaluation of dual-ended readout PET detectors based on BGO arrays with different reflector arrangements

Objective: Dual-ended readout depth-encoding detectors based on bismuth germanate (BGO) scintillation crystal arrays are good candidates for high-sensitivity small animal positron emission tomography used for very-low-dose imaging. In this paper, the performance of three dual-ended readout detectors based on 15 × 15 BGO arrays with three different reflector arrangements and 8 × 8 silicon photomultiplier arrays were evaluated and compared. Approach: The three BGO arrays, denoted wo-ILG (without internal light guide), wp-ILG (with partial internal light guide), and wf-ILG (with full internal light guide), share a pitch size of 1.6 mm and thickness of 20 mm. Toray E60 with a thickness of 50 μm was used as inter-crystal reflector. All reflector lengths in the wo-ILG and wf-ILG BGO arrays were 20 and 18 mm, respectively; the reflectors in the wp-ILG BGO array were 18 mm at the central region of the array and 20 mm at the edge. By using 18 mm reflectors, part of the crystals in the wp-ILG and wf-ILG BGO arrays worked as internal light guides. Main results: The results showed that the detector based on the wo-ILG BGO array provided the best flood histogram. The energy, timing and DOI resolutions of the three detectors were similar. The energy resolutions full width at half maximum (FWHM value) based on the wo-ILG, wp-ILG and wf-ILG BGO arrays were 27.2 ± 3.9%, 28.7 ± 4.6%, and 29.5 ± 4.7%, respectively. The timing resolutions (FWHM value) were 4.7 ± 0.5 ns, 4.9 ± 0.5 ns, and 5.0 ± 0.6 ns, respectively. The DOI resolution (FWHM value) were 3.0 ± 0.2 mm, 2.9 ± 0.2 mm, and 3.0 ± 0.2 mm, respectively. Over all, the wo-ILG detector provided the best performance.

Organic glass scintillator bars with dual-ended readout

Organic glass scintillator (OGS) bars (6 × 6 × 50 mm3) were melt-cast and characterized with dual-ended readout by silicon photomultiplier arrays. The results were compared to trans-stilbene bars of the same size. Energy resolution was measured via a 137Cs Compton-coincidence experiment. Time resolution was determined via a 22Na coincidence-timing experiment. Depth-of-interaction resolution was measured by moving a gamma-ray fan beam along the major axis of the bars. Pulse shape discrimination capability and neutron light output were determined via a time-of-flight measurement of a 252Cf source. The OGS bars exhibited better energy resolution at 478 keV (10.3±0.5% vs. 11.2±0.5%), better time resolution from 200–341 keVee (270ps vs. 340ps FWHM), slightly poorer depth-of-interaction resolution, poorer PSD performance, and higher neutron light output than the stilbene bars. The low cost, ease of manufacturing, brightness, and excellent time resolution make OGS a strong candidate for use in compact radiation imaging systems.

Optical Simulation and Experimental Assessment with Time-Walk Correction of TOF-PET Detectors with Multi-Ended Readouts.

As a commonly used solution, the multi-ended readout can measure the depth-of-interaction (DOI) for positron emission tomography (PET) detectors. In the present study, the effects of the multi-ended readout design were investigated using the leading-edge discriminator (LED) triggers on the timing performance of time-of-flight (TOF) PET detectors. At the very first, the photon transmission model of the four detectors, namely, single-ended readout, dual-ended readout, side dual-ended readout, and triple-ended readout, was established in Tracepro. The optical simulation revealed that the light output of the multi-ended readout was higher. Meanwhile, the readout circuit could be triggered earlier. Especially, in the triple-ended readout, the light output at 0.5 ns was observed to be nearly twice that of the single-ended readout after the first scintillating photon was generated. Subsequently, a reference detector was applied to test the multi-ended readout detectors that were constructed from a 6 × 6 × 25 mm3 LYSO crystal. Each module is composed of a crystal coupled with multiple SiPMs. Accordingly, its timing performance was improved by approximately 10% after the compensation of fourth-order polynomial fitting. Finally, the compensated full-width-at-half-maximum (FWHM) coincidence timing resolutions (CTR) of the dual-ended readout, side dual-ended readout, and triple-ended readout were 216.9 ps, 231.0 ps, and 203.6 ps, respectively.

Evaluation of dual-ended readout GAGG-based DOI-PET detectors with different surface treatments.

Parallax error is a major issue in small animal positron emission tomography (PET) scanners which are used in preclinical studies or detailed scanning of human organs. Several methods have been proposed and investigated to reduce this radial artifact in PET images by estimating the depth of interaction (DOI) of 511-keV photons in the crystal. Among all, the dual-ended readout method seems to be very simple and effective as it does not have any fabrication and readout complications. In the past, some studies suggested that increasing the roughness of crystal lateral surfaces improves DOI resolution. In this paper, this was experimentally examined for four Ce:GAGG crystals with different surface structures. Four 1.2×1.2×20mm3 GAGG crystals with following surface treatment were examined: polished with optical finishing, fine grinding (using a fine surface grinding machine), fine cutting (no treatment), and coarse cutting (no treatment). These crystals were coupled individually to two SiPMs for dual-ended readout and placed in a coincidence detection circuit for electronic collimation of 511keV incidents. The crystals were compared in terms of energy response and DOI estimation capability. DOI function for each crystal was extracted and FWHM DOI resolution was calculated. DOI resolution for the polished crystal varied in the range of 0.54-4.14mm throughout the length of the crystal due to its nonlinear DOI function. The fine grinding crystal showed a linear DOI function within the dynamic range of (-0.75, 0.75), and its DOI resolution varied in the range of 1.24-1.50mm (1.37±0.13mm DOI resolution). The fine-cut crystal had almost a linear DOI function and a wider dynamic range of (-0.85, 0.85) and therefore the best performance with 1.2±0.08mm DOI resolution. However, for the crystal with the roughest surface (coarse-cut crystal), even though the dynamic range expanded to (-0.95, 0.95), its DOI function became nonlinear resulting in 1.24±0.28mm DOI resolution. This means there is an optimum surface roughness to provide the crystal with the best DOI capability. The pulse-height spectrum measured at each depth was used as a measure to compare the energy performance of the four crystals. The photopeak of 511keV was observed for all depths, all crystals. The photopeak position for the coarse-cut crystal had extensive depth dependency which results in poorer energy resolution unless the energy window is calibrated for each depth. This variation of photopeak for the fine-cut and fine grinding crystals was comparable with that of polished crystal. This paper reports 1.2±0.08mm FWHM DOI resolution for a fine-cut unpolished crystal. This resolution is as narrow as the crystal width, resulting in the complete elimination of parallax error in PET images. Results suggest that there is an optimum roughness for the best performance of the dual-ended method and further increase in the roughness, degrades DOI resolution. Thanks to the high light yield of GAGG, the energy performance of the fine-cut crystal is acceptable, and the depth dependency of the spectrum is negligible.

A thick semi-monolithic scintillator detector for clinical PET scanners

Both monolithic and semi-monolithic scintillator positron emission tomography (PET) detectors can measure the depth of interaction with single-ended readout. Usually scintillators with a thickness of 10 mm or less are used since the position resolutions of the detectors degrade as the scintillator thickness increases. In this work, the performance of a 20 mm thick long rectangular semi-monolithic scintillator PET detector was measured by using both single-ended and dual-ended readouts with silicon photomultiplier (SiPM) arrays to provide a high detection efficiency. The semi-monolithic scintillator detector consists of nine lutetium–yttrium oxyorthosilicate slices measuring 1.37 × 51.2 × 20 mm3 with erythrocyte sedimentation rate foils of 0.065 mm thickness in between the slices. The SiPM array at each end of the scintillator detector consists of 16 × 4 SiPMs with a pixel size of 3.0 × 3.0 mm2 and a pitch of 3.2 mm. The 64 signals of each SiPM array are processed by using the TOFPET2 application-specific integrated circuit individually. All but the edge slices can be clearly resolved for the detectors with both single-ended and dual-ended readouts. The single-ended readout detector provides an average full width at half maximum (FWHM) Y (continuous direction) position resolution of 2.43 mm, Z (depth direction) position resolution of 4.77 mm, energy resolution of 25.7% and timing resolution of 779 ps. The dual-ended readout detector significantly improves the Y and Z position resolutions, slightly improves the energy and timing resolution at the cost of two photodetectors required for one detector module and provides an average FWHM Y position resolution of 1.97 mm, Z position resolution of 2.60 mm, energy resolution of 21.7% and timing resolution of 718 ps. The energy and timing resolution of the semi-monolithic scintillator detector in this work are worse than those of the segmented scintillator array detector and need to be further improved. The semi-monolithic scintillator detector described in this work reduces costs as compared to the traditional segmented scintillator array detector and reduces the edge effect as compared to the monolithic scintillator detector.

H2RSPET: a 0.5 mm resolution high-sensitivity small-animal PET scanner, a simulation study

With the goal of developing a total-body small-animal PET system with a high spatial resolution of ∼0.5 mm and a high sensitivity >10% for mouse/rat studies, we simulated four scanners using the graphical processing unit-based Monte Carlo simulation package (gPET) and compared their performance in terms of spatial resolution and sensitivity. We also investigated the effect of depth-of-interaction (DOI) resolution on the spatial resolution. All the scanners are built upon 128 DOI encoding dual-ended readout detectors with lutetium yttrium oxyorthosilicate (LYSO) arrays arranged in 8 detector rings. The solid angle coverages of the four scanners are all ∼0.85 steradians. Each LYSO element has a cross-section of 0.44 × 0.44 mm2 and the pitch size of the LYSO arrays are all 0.5 mm. The four scanners can be divided into two groups: (1) H2RS110-C10 and H2RS110-C20 with 40 × 40 LYSO arrays, a ring diameter of 110 mm and axial length of 167 mm, and (2) H2RS160-C10 and H2RS160-C20 with 60 × 60 LYSO arrays, a diameter of 160 mm and axial length of 254 mm. C10 and C20 denote the crystal thickness of 10 and 20 mm, respectively. The simulation results show that all scanners have a spatial resolution better than 0.5 mm at the center of the field-of-view (FOV). The radial resolution strongly depends on the DOI resolution and radial offset, but not the axial resolution and tangential resolution. Comparing the C10 and C20 designs, the former provides better resolution, especially at positions away from the center of the FOV, whereas the latter has 2× higher sensitivity (∼10% versus ∼20%). This simulation study provides evidence that the 110 mm systems are a good choice for total-body mouse studies at a lower cost, whereas the 160 mm systems are suited for both total-body mouse and rat studies.

A GPU-accelerated fully 3D OSEM image reconstruction for a high-resolution small animal PET scanner using dual-ended readout detectors

In this work, a GPU-accelerated fully 3D ordered-subset expectation maximization (OSEM) image reconstruction with point spread function (PSF) modeling was developed for a small animal PET scanner with a long axial field of view (FOV). Dual-ended readout detectors that provided high depth of interaction (DOI) resolution were used for the small animal PET scanner to simultaneously achieve uniform high spatial resolution and high sensitivity. First, we developed a novel sinogram generation method, in which the dimension of the sinogram was determined first and then an event was assigned to a few neighboring sinogram elements by using weights that are inversely proportional to the distance from the measured line of response (LOR) to the LOR of the sinogram elements. System geometric symmetry, precomputation of LOR-driven ray-tracing and texture memory were applied to accelerate the GPU-based reconstruction. We developed a spatially variant PSF model where the PSF parameters were obtained by using point source images measured at 18 positions in the FOV and a spatial invariant PSF model where the PSF parameters were obtained by using only one image measured at the center FOV. The performance of the image reconstruction method was evaluated by using simulated phantom data as well as phantom and in-vivo mouse data acquired on the scanner. The results showed that the proposed reconstruction method provided better spatial resolution, a higher contrast recovery coefficient and lower noise than the OSEM reconstruction and was more than 1000 times faster than the CPU-based reconstruction. The spatially variant PSF model did not result in any spatial resolution improvement compared to the spatial invariant PSF model, and thus, the latter that is much easier to implement in image reconstruction and can be used in a small animal PET scanner using detectors with very high DOI resolution. A whole body 18F-FDG mouse image with high resolution and a high contrast to noise ratio was obtained by using the proposed reconstruction method.

Performance comparison of dual-ended readout depth-encoding PET detectors based on BGO and LYSO crystals

The performance of dual-ended readout depth-encoding positron emission tomography (PET) detectors based on bismuth germanate (BGO) coupled to silicon photomultipliers (SiPM) arrays was measured for the first time and compared to lutetium-yttrium oxyorthosilicate (LYSO)-based detectors using the same readout. The BGO and LYSO crystal arrays all had a crystal pitch of 2.2 mm and were coupled to 8 × 8 SiPM arrays with a matching pitch of 2.2 mm, using a one-to-one coupling configuration. Three types of crystals with Toray reflector were used: polished LYSO, polished BGO, and unpolished BGO, and for two different crystal thicknesses of 20 mm and 30 mm. All the crystal elements in the BGO arrays were clearly resolved in the flood histogram. Better flood histograms were obtained using the LYSO arrays for a selected crystal thickness, and better flood histograms were obtained using the 20 mm thick crystal arrays for a selected crystal type. The average crystal level energy resolution and timing resolution for 20 mm polished LYSO, polished BGO and unpolished BGO crystals at their optimal SiPM bias voltage were 18.6 ± 1.3% and 1.19 ± 0.20 ns, 17.8 ± 0.8% and 4.43 ± 0.47 ns, and 18.0 ± 1.0% and 4.68 ± 1.0 ns, respectively. Depth-of-interaction (DOI) resolution of the 20 mm polished LYSO array was 2.31 ± 0.17 mm and for the 20 mm unpolished BGO array was 3.53 ± 0.25 mm. However, polished BGO arrays with Toray reflector did not provide DOI information. Our key conclusion is that dual-ended readout depth-encoding 20 mm thick unpolished BGO detectors are good candidates for low-activity PET systems with small field-of-view and low timing performance requirements, such as preclinical or compact organ-dedicated PET systems, with the advantage over LYSO of having no background radiation and significantly lower cost.