Abstract Introduction The incidence and clinical significance of nightmares is difficult to estimate due to varying criteria across studies. The Nightmare Disorder Index (NDI) is a validated measure to evaluate nightmare disorder. However, there is no measure to differentiate trauma-related nightmares compared to trauma associated sleep disorder (TSD), a unique REM parasomnia. The objectives of this study were to (1) determine the incidence of nightmare disorder and TSD in patients referred for a clinically indicated sleep evaluation, and (2) further characterize TSD. Methods All initial sleep referrals completed intake questionnaires including validated measures such as the NDI, Epworth Sleepiness Scale (ESS) and Insomnia Severity Index (ISI). Patients who endorsed at least weekly nightmares related to trauma, with vocalizations or disruptive nocturnal behaviors, and autonomic surges additionally received a structured clinical interview focusing on thematic content of dreams, dream enactment behavior, self-reported symptoms of autonomic hyperactivity, and, if previously treated, nightmare severity before and after therapy. Results 102 new patients completed the NDI and 56.9% (58) met criteria for probable nightmare disorder (ND). Of the 58 patients with probable ND, 13.8% (8) had symptoms consistent with TSD (7.8% of new referrals). Compared to ND patients, TSD patients were more likely to have higher ISI (24.0 ± 3.0 vs. 18.6 ± 5.6) (p=0.023) and total NDI score (15.8 ± 3.5 vs. 10.0 ± 3.7) (p< 0.001), but not ESS (p=0.158). Structured interview revealed all TSD patients had significant daytime distress or impairment. The nature of trauma was combat for 3 individuals, physical assault for 1, and sexual assault for 4 (one occurring while deployed). All individuals reported tachycardia secondary to nightmares and tachypnea and diaphoresis were each reported in 75% of patients. Regarding dream content, 25% endorsed accurate replay of trauma, 25% related to trauma but non-replay, and 50% mixed. For DNB, 87.5% of patients endorsed vocalization (moaning, screaming, or yelling), 87.5% endorsed movements (tossing, turning, or thrashing), and 37.5% endorsed combative behaviors (striking of bed partner). Conclusion This study reports a surprisingly high incidence of probable ND among all new sleep medicine patients. TSD appears to be a clinically distinct, more severe parasomnia compared to ND. Support (if any)
Read full abstract