We applaud the efforts of Bernat et al. (1Bernat JL D’Alessandro AM Port FK et al.Report of a national conference on donation after cardiac death.Am J Transplant. 2006; 6: 281-291.Crossref PubMed Scopus (452) Google Scholar) in trying to define and clarify the different phases of ischaemia during organ donation. Accurate recording of data relating to transplantation is essential for audit and research, and to provide a common language of transplantation yet 50 years after the first successful renal transplant, there is still confusion about the nomenclature of time points in transplantation. We propose that ‘ischaemic’ terminology needs further clarification and internationally approved definitions to standardize nomenclature and allow accurate comparisons of results. The suggested use of withdrawal phase (Phase I) and the acirculatory phase (Phase II) is sensible but this classification needs to be extended to clarify the remainder of donor organ ischaemia. What is the first warm ischaemic time? Is the second warm ischaemic time really warm? Is the ischaemic time inclusive or exclusive of the warm period? Indeed is the ischaemic time that point in time at which ischaemia occurred, or a duration of time, more accurately referred to as a time period? Figure 1 depicts a timeline of events that occur to a typical kidney from donor retrieval to implantation. At time point ‘A’ the donor becomes asystolic, and at point ‘B’ perfusion of the donor organs with cold preservation solution starts. In donation after cardiac death the time period ‘AB’ represents the warm ischaemic period prior to cooling. Currently this time period is variously called the first warm time or the warm ischaemic time. An unambiguous nomenclature would be the ‘Asystolic Warm Period’, reflecting the fact that during this time the organ remained in situ sustaining warm ischaemic damage. In a heart beating donor ‘AB’ is zero, i.e. there is no asystolic warm period. Time point ‘C’, commonly referred to as ‘time on ice’, should be taken as the time the organ is placed into cold storage, be that on a machine or in an ice box. The time taken to remove, store and pack the organ occurs between ‘B’ and ‘C’ and we think of this as ‘the organ recovery period’. At the recipient operation, the organ is removed from ice, time point ‘D’, and implanted in the recipient. The kidney is perfused with recipient blood at time point ‘E’. The period ‘DE’ is also known as the warm ischaemic time and the second warm time, although in reality the kidney is cold during this period and warms up relatively slowly in the 15–60 min, it takes to perform vascular anastomosis. For this reason we prefer to think of this time period as ‘the anastomosis period’. The total period of ischaemia is often referred to as the cold ischaemic time, and many surgeons discount the anastomosis period and/or asystolic period from this. The most useful time to quote is the total period of ischaemia, or ‘total ischaemic period’, representing the period ‘AE’. However, it should be noted that this aggregate value is less useful in predicting outcome than each of the contributing phases considered separately; for example, the asystolic warm period is more damaging per minute than the cold storage period. In conclusion, an internationally accepted nomenclature is needed to define donor organ ischaemic times that would provide accurate recording of events which will aid audit and research in transplantation.
Read full abstract