Continuous-variable Entanglement Distillation Research Articles

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation by cascaded photon replacement

We study the entanglement distillation in continuous variable systems when a photon replacement protocol is employed. A cascaded protocol is studied and we find that the resultant entanglement increases by increasing the number of repetitions. Interestingly, the entanglement enhancement is not sensitive to the asymmetry of the protocol and gives the same result for any arrangement in the absence of loss. The non-Gaussianity of the outcome state is also studied and it is found that the non-Gaussianity of the state dramatically depends on the experimental arrangements. By providing practical information on photon replacement operation, this work is one step towards realization of universal quantum computation. In particular, in setups where deGaussifying protocols are only applicable to one of the parties.

$O(\sqrt\eta)$ efficiency entanglement distillation with one-time photon subtraction over near-zero transmittance bosonic channel

Entanglement distillation is an efficient method to retrieve high-quality entanglement from a large number of noise-damped entanglement states. Many investigations on continuous variable entanglement distillation have focused on low-loss or medium-loss channels. Herein, we primarily study entanglement distillation in extremely lossy (total channel transmittance η ≪ 1 ) or even near-zero transmittance ( η ≈ 0 ) channels. In particular, we analyze the manner in which entanglement and success probability decrease as η → 0 . The performances of conventional biside photon subtraction and one-time photon subtraction on two optical modes separated by L km are investigated. The motivation for our study includes the recent advancements in twin-field quantum key distribution, wherein single-photon detection is sufficient to provide a useful private key. In the same vein, we propose an entanglement distillation scheme with an efficiency of O ( η ) using one-time photon subtraction and weak coherent state injection. Thus, our proposed scheme provides a method for distilling extremely damped entanglement states for continuous variable quantum information processing.

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation over a pure loss channel with multiple quantum scissors

Entanglement distillation is a key primitive for distributing high-quality entanglement between remote locations. Probabilistic noiseless linear amplification based on the quantum scissors is a candidate for entanglement distillation from noisy continuous-variable (CV) entangled states. Being a non-Gaussian operation, quantum scissors is challenging to analyze. We present a derivation of the non-Gaussian state heralded by multiple quantum scissors in a pure loss channel with two-mode squeezed vacuum input. We choose the reverse coherent information (RCI)---a proven lower bound on the distillable entanglement of a quantum state under one-way local operations and classical communication (LOCC), as our figure of merit. We evaluate a Gaussian lower bound on the RCI of the heralded state. We show that it can exceed the unlimited two-way LOCCassisted direct transmission entanglement distillation capacity of the pure loss channel. The optimal heralded Gaussian RCI with two quantum scissors is found to be significantly more than that with a single quantum scissors, albeit at the cost of decreased success probability. Our results fortify the possibility of a quantum repeater scheme for CV quantum states using the quantum scissors.

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation between remote quantum nodes

The development of quantum network relies on high-quality entanglement between remote quantum nodes. In reality the unavoidable decoherence limits the quality of entangled quantum nodes, however, entanglement distillation can overcome this problem. Here we propose an experimentally feasible scheme of continuous-variable entanglement generation, storage, and distillation between distant quantum nodes, which only requires the atomic ensemble quantum memory and balanced homodyne detection (BHD). Initially one copy of a bipartite entangled state of light, suffering phase fluctuations during the distributions, is stored in two distant atomic ensembles so that the atomic ensembles are entangled. Within the storage lifetime, by distributing and storing another copy of entangled optical modes in these two atomic ensembles, the distillation on entangled atomic spin waves can be implemented based on the post-selection of the BHD result. Our scheme provides a highly entangled state between remote quantum nodes for downstream applications, and enables the extension to multipartite entanglement distillation in a large-scale quantum network.

Theory of filtered type-II parametric down-conversion in the continuous-variable domain: Quantifying the impacts of filtering

Parametric down-conversion (PDC) forms one of the basic building blocks for quantum optical experiments. However, the intrinsic multimode spectral-temporal structure of pulsed PDC often poses a severe hindrance for the direct implementation of the heralding of pure single-photon states or, for example, continuous-variable entanglement distillation experiments. To get rid of multimode effects narrowband frequency filtering is frequently applied to achieve a single-mode behavior. A rigorous theoretical description to accurately describe the effects of filtering on PDC, however, is still missing. To date, the theoretical models of filtered PDC are rooted in the discrete-variable domain and only account for filtering in the low gain regime, where only a few photon pairs are emitted at any single point in time. In this paper we extend these theoretical descriptions and put forward a simple model, which is able to accurately describe the effects of filtering on PDC in the continuous-variable domain. This developed straightforward theoretical framework enables us to accurately quantify the trade-off between suppression of higher-order modes, reduced purity and lowered Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) entanglement, when narrowband filters are applied to multimode type-II PDC.

Local squeezing-assisted two-copy and single-copy continuous variable entanglement distillation

Entanglement distillation is a physically feasible operation which helps to partially or completely eliminate noise-induced decoherence in the distribution of entangled states. In this paper, we investigate the two-copy and single-copy distillation of an amplitude-damped continuous variable two-mode squeezed vacuum state. We consider local squeezing as one of the important tools [Phys. Rev. A84, 062309 (2011)] to enhance distillation. Our result is twofold. First, we show that local squeezing is useful to improve the distillation of two-copy interference-based distillation. Second, we show single-copy photon subtraction-based distillation is more efficient in providing more entangled outputs. However, such an advantage would diminish and two-copy distillation could succeed with much higher probability of success for a fixed amount of distilled entanglement.

Compact entanglement distillery using realistic quantum memories

We adopt the beam splitter model for losses to analyse the performance of a recent compact continuous-variable entanglement distillation protocol [Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 060502, (2012)] implemented using realistic quantum memories. We show that the decoherence undergone by a two-mode squeezed state while stored in a quantum memory can strongly modify the results of the preparatory step of the protocol. We find that the well-known method for locally increasing entanglement, phonon subtraction, may not result in entanglement gain when losses are taken into account. Thus, we investigate the critical number $m_c$ of phonon subtraction attempts from the matter modes of the quantum memory. If the initial state is not de-Gaussified within $m_c$ attempts, the protocol should be restarted to obtain any entanglement increase. Moreover, the condition $m_c>1$ implies an additional constraint on the subtraction beam splitter interaction transmissivity, viz. it should be about 50% for a wide range of protocol parameters. Additionally, we consider the average entanglement rate, which takes into account both the unavoidable probabilistic nature of the protocol and its possible failure as a result of a large number of unsuccessful subtraction attempts. We find that a higher value of the average entanglement can be achieved by increasing the subtraction beam splitter interaction transmissivity. We conclude that the compact distillation protocol with the practical constraints coming from realistic quantum memories allows a feasible experimental realization within existing technologies.

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation and noncommutative central limit theorems

Entanglement distillation transforms weakly entangled noisy states into highly entangled states, a primitive to be used in quantum repeater schemes and other protocols designed for quantum communication and key distribution. In this work, we present a comprehensive framework for continuous-variable entanglement distillation schemes that convert noisy non-Gaussian states into Gaussian ones in many iterations of the protocol. Instances of these protocols include (a) the recursive-Gaussifier protocol, (b) the temporally-reordered recursive-Gaussifier protocol, and (c) the pumping-Gaussifier protocol. The flexibility of these protocols give rise to several beneficial trade-offs related to success probabilities or memory requirements, which that can be adjusted to reflect experimental demands. Despite these protocols involving measurements, we relate the convergence in this protocols to new instances of non-commutative central limit theorems, in a formalism that we lay out in great detail. Implications of the findings for quantum repeater schemes are discussed.

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation with noiseless linear amplification

Quantum entanglement distillation is a probabilistic process which protects entanglement from environment-induced decoherence. In this paper, we investigate the distillation of a continuousvariable optic entangled state with noiseless linear amplification (NLA). NLA schemes perform better than the conventional photon-subtraction-based distillation scheme, particularly in distributing entanglement over extremely low efficiency quantum channels. Finally, a comparison between the NLA-based scheme and the local squeezing-enhanced photon subtraction scheme is also investigated.

Enhancing quantum entanglement by photon addition and subtraction

The non-Gaussian operations effected by adding or subtracting a photon on entangled optical beams emerging from a parametric down-conversion process have been suggested to enhance entanglement. Heralded photon addition or subtraction is, as a matter of fact, at the heart of continuous-variable entanglement distillation. The use of such processes has recently been experimentally demonstrated in the context of the generation of optical coherent-state superpositions or the verification of canonical commutation relations. Here, we carry out a systematic study of the effect of local photon additions and subtractions on a two-mode squeezed vacuum state, showing that the entanglement generally increases with the number of such operations. This is analytically proven when additions or subtractions are restricted to one mode only, while we observe that the highest entanglement is achieved when these operations are equally shared between the two modes. We also note that adding photons typically provides a stronger entanglement enhancement than subtracting photons, while photon subtraction performs better in terms of energy efficiency. Furthermore, we analyze the interplay between entanglement and non-Gaussianity, showing that it is more subtle than previously expected.

Compact Continuous-Variable Entanglement Distillation

We introduce a new scheme for continuous-variable entanglement distillation that requires only linear temporal and constant physical or spatial resources. Distillation is the process by which high-quality entanglement may be distributed between distant nodes of a network in the unavoidable presence of decoherence. The known versions of this protocol scale exponentially in space and doubly exponentially in time. Our optimal scheme therefore provides exponential improvements over existing protocols. It uses a fixed-resource module-an entanglement distillery-comprising only four quantum memories of at most 50% storage efficiency and allowing a feasible experimental implementation. Tangible quantum advantages are obtainable by using existing off-resonant Raman quantum memories outside their conventional role of storage.

Local Gaussian operations can enhance continuous-variable entanglement distillation

Entanglement distillation is a fundamental building block in long-distance quantum communication. Though known to be useless on their own for distilling Gaussian entangled states, local Gaussian operations may still help to improve non-Gaussian entanglement distillation schemes. Here we show that by applying local squeezing operations both the performance and the efficiency of existing distillation protocols can be enhanced. We find that such an enhancement through local Gaussian unitaries can be obtained even when the initially shared Gaussian entangled states are mixed, as, for instance, after their distribution through a lossy-fiber communication channel.

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation of non-Gaussian mixed states

Many different quantum information communication protocols such as teleportation, dense coding and entanglement based quantum key distribution are based on the faithful transmission of entanglement between distant location in an optical network. The distribution of entanglement in such a network is however hampered by loss and noise that is inherent in all practical quantum channels. Thus, to enable faithful transmission one must resort to the protocol of entanglement distillation. In this paper we present a detailed theoretical analysis and an experimental realization of continuous variable entanglement distillation in a channel that is inflicted by different kinds of non-Gaussian noise. The continuous variable entangled states are generated by exploiting the third order non-linearity in optical fibers, and the states are sent through a free-space laboratory channel in which the losses are altered to simulate a free-space atmospheric channel with varying losses. We use linear optical components, homodyne measurements and classical communication to distill the entanglement, and we find that by using this method the entanglement can be probabilistically increased for some specific non-Gaussian noise channels.

Entanglement quantification from incomplete measurements: applications using photon-number-resolving weak homodyne detectors

The certificate of success for a number of important quantum information processing protocols, such as entanglement distillation, is based on the difference in the entanglement content of the system quantum states before and after the protocol. In such cases, effective bounds need to be placed on the entanglement of non-local states consistent with statistics obtained from local measurements. In this paper, we study numerically the ability of a hybrid homodyne detector that combines phase sensitivity and photon-number resolution to set accurate bounds on the entanglement content of two-mode quadrature squeezed states without the need for full state tomography. We show that it is possible to set tight lower bounds on the entanglement of a family of two-mode degaussified states using only a few measurements. This presents a significant improvement over the resource requirements for the experimental demonstration of continuous-variable entanglement distillation, which traditionally relies on full quantum state tomography.

Continuous-variable entanglement distillation over a general lossy channel

Any continuous-variable distillation protocol that does not change the effective loss of the transmission channel cannot be used to achieve maximum Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen style correlations after distillation. We analyze the continuous-variable entanglement distillation protocol described by [Browne et al., Phys. Rev. A 67, 062320 (2003)] and show that it does not change the effective loss of the transmission of entanglement. We extend this scheme to one which does change the effective transmission coefficient of the channel. Our scheme has the added benefit that the states generated exhibit isotropic noise which is best suited to applications of continuous-variable entanglement such as continuous-variable teleportation.

On the experimental feasibility of continuous-variable optical entanglement distillation

Entanglement distillation aims at preparing highly entangled states out of a supply of weakly entangled pairs, using local devices and classical communication only. In this note we discuss the experimentally feasible schemes for optical continuous-variable entanglement distillation that have been presented in [D.E. Browne, J. Eisert, S. Scheel, and M.B. Plenio, Phys. Rev. A 67, 062320 (2003)] and [J. Eisert, D.E. Browne, S. Scheel, and M.B. Plenio, Annals of Physics (NY) 311, 431 (2004)]. We emphasize their versatility in particular with regards to the detection process and discuss the merits of the two proposed detection schemes, namely photo-detection and homodyne detection, in the light of experimental realizations of this idea becoming more and more feasible.

Distillation of continuous-variable entanglement with optical means

We present an event-ready procedure that is capable of distilling Gaussian two-mode entangled states from a supply of weakly entangled states that have become mixed in a decoherence process. This procedure relies on passive optical elements and photon detectors distinguishing the presence and the absence of photons, but does not make use of photon counters. We identify fixed points of the iteration map, and discuss in detail its convergence properties. Necessary and sufficient criteria for the convergence to two-mode Gaussian states are presented. On the basis of various examples we discuss the performance of the procedure as far as the increase of the degree of entanglement and two-mode squeezing is concerned. Finally, we consider imperfect operations and outline the robustness of the scheme under non-unit detection efficiencies of the detectors. This analysis implies that the proposed protocol can be implemented with currently available technology and detector efficiencies.