Dimer Dissociation Kinetics Research Articles

Coumarin Dimer Is an Effective Photomechanochemical AND Gate for Small-Molecule Release.

Stimulus-responsive gating of chemical reactions is of considerable practical and conceptual interest. For example, photocleavable protective groups and gating mechanophores allow the kinetics of purely thermally activated reactions to be controlled optically or by mechanical load by inducing the release of small-molecule reactants. Such release only in response to a sequential application of both stimuli (photomechanochemical gating) has not been demonstrated despite its unique expected benefits. Here, we describe computational and experimental evidence that coumarin dimers are highly promising moieties for realizing photomechanochemical control of small-molecule release. Such dimers are transparent and photochemically inert at wavelengths >300 nm but can be made to dissociate rapidly under tensile force. The resulting coumarins are mechanochemically and thermally stable, but rapidly release their payload upon irradiation. Our DFT calculations reveal that both strain-free and mechanochemical kinetics of dimer dissociation are highly tunable over an unusually broad range of rates by simple substitution. In head-to-head dimers, the phenyl groups act as molecular levers to allow systematic and predictable variation in the force sensitivity of the dissociation barriers by choice of the pulling axis. As a proof-of-concept, we synthesized and characterized the reactivity of one such dimer for photomechanochemically controlled release of aniline and its application for controlling bulk gelation.

Using light intensity to control reaction kinetics and reversibility in photomechanical crystals.

4-Fluoro-9-anthracenecarboxylic acid (4F-9AC) is a thermally reversible (T-type) photomechanical molecular crystal. The photomechanical response is driven by a [4 + 4] photodimerization reaction, while the photodimer dissociation determines the reset time. In this paper, both the chemical kinetics of dimer dissociation (using a microscopic fluorescence-recovery-after-photobleaching experiment) and mechanical reset dynamics (by imaging bending microneedles) for single 4F-9AC crystals are measured. The dissociation kinetics depend strongly on the initial concentration of photodimer, slowing down and becoming nonexponential at high dimer concentrations. This dose-dependent behavior is also observed in the mechanical response of bending microneedles. A new feature in the photomechanical behavior is identified: the ability of a very weak control beam to suppress dimer dissociation after large initial dimer conversions. This phenomenon provides a way to optically control the mechanical response of this photomechanical crystal. To gain physical insight into the origin of the nonexponential recovery curves, the experimental results are analyzed in terms of a standard first-order kinetic model and a nonlinear Finke–Watzky (FW) model. The FW model can qualitatively reproduce the transition from exponential to sigmoidal recovery with larger initial conversions, but neither model can reproduce the suppression of the recovery in the presence of a weak holding beam. These results highlight the need for more sophisticated theories to describe cooperative phenomena in solid-state crystalline reactions, as well as demonstrating how this behavior could lead to new properties and/or improved performance in photomechanical materials.

The protonation state of an evolutionarily conserved histidine modulates domain swapping stability of FoxP1

Forkhead box P (FoxP) proteins are members of the versatile Fox transcription factors, which control the timing and expression of multiple genes for eukaryotic cell homeostasis. Compared to other Fox proteins, they can form domain-swapped dimers through their DNA-binding –forkhead– domains, enabling spatial reorganization of distant chromosome elements by tethering two DNA molecules together. Yet, domain swapping stability and DNA binding affinity varies between different FoxP proteins. Experimental evidence suggests that the protonation state of a histidine residue conserved in all Fox proteins is responsible for pH-dependent modulation of these interactions. Here, we explore the consequences of the protonation state of another histidine (H59), only conserved within FoxM/O/P subfamilies, on folding and dimerization of the forkhead domain of human FoxP1. Dimer dissociation kinetics and equilibrium unfolding experiments demonstrate that protonation of H59 leads to destabilization of the domain-swapped dimer due to an increase in free energy difference between the monomeric and transition states. This pH–dependence is abolished when H59 is mutated to alanine. Furthermore, anisotropy measurements and molecular dynamics evidence that H59 has a direct impact in the local stability of helix H3. Altogether, our results highlight the relevance of H59 in domain swapping and folding stability of FoxP1.

Impact of human galectin-1 binding to saccharide ligands on dimer dissociation kinetics and structure.

Endogenous lectins can control critical biological responses, including cell communication, signaling, angiogenesis and immunity by decoding glycan-containing information on a variety of cellular receptors and the extracellular matrix. Galectin-1 (Gal-1), a prototype member of the galectin family, displays only one carbohydrate recognition domain and occurs in a subtle homodimerization equilibrium at physiologic concentrations. Such equilibrium critically governs the function of this lectin signaling by allowing tunable interactions with a preferential set of glycosylated receptors. Here, we used a combination of experimental and computational approaches to analyze the kinetics and mechanisms connecting Gal-1 ligand unbinding and dimer dissociation processes. Kinetic constants of both processes were found to differ by an order of magnitude. By means of steered molecular dynamics simulations, the ligand unbinding process was followed monitoring water occupancy changes. By determining the water sites in a carbohydrate binding place during the unbinding process, we found that rupture of ligand-protein interactions induces an increase in energy barrier while ligand unbinding process takes place, whereas the entry of water molecules to the binding groove and further occupation of their corresponding water sites contributes to lowering of the energy barrier. Moreover, our findings suggested local asymmetries between the two subunits in the dimer structure detected at a nanosecond timescale. Thus, integration of experimental and computational data allowed a more complete understanding of lectin ligand binding and dimerization processes, suggesting new insights into the relationship between Gal-1 structure and function and renewing the discussion on the biophysics and biochemistry of lectin-ligand lattices.

Tubulin Dimer Reversible Dissociation: AFFINITY, KINETICS, AND DEMONSTRATION OF A STABLE MONOMER

Tubulins are evolutionarily conserved proteins that reversibly polymerize and direct intracellular traffic. Of the tubulin family only αβ-tubulin forms stable dimers. We investigated the monomer-dimer equilibrium of rat brain αβ-tubulin using analytical ultracentrifugation and fluorescence anisotropy, observing tubulin in virtually fully monomeric and dimeric states. Monomeric tubulin was stable for a few hours and exchanged into preformed dimers, demonstrating reversibility of dimer dissociation. Global analysis combining sedimentation velocity and fluorescence anisotropy yielded Kd = 84 (54-123) nm Dimer dissociation kinetics were measured by analyzing the shape of the sedimentation boundary and by the relaxation of fluorescence anisotropy following rapid dilution of labeled tubulin, yielding koff in the range 10(-3)-10(-2) s(-1) Thus, tubulin dimers reversibly dissociate with moderately fast kinetics. Monomer-monomer association is much less sensitive than dimer-dimer association to solution changes (GTP/GDP, urea, and trimethylamine oxide).

Intradimer/Intermolecular Interactions Suggest Autoinhibition Mechanism in Endophilin A1

Endophilin A1 is a homodimeric membrane-binding endocytic accessory protein with a high dimerization affinity. Its function has been hypothesized to involve autoinhibition. However, the autoinhibition mechanism, as well as the physicochemical basis for the high dimerization affinity of endophilin in solution, have remained unclear. In this contribution, we use a Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET) method to investigate the homodimerization mechanism and intradimer molecular interactions in endophilin. For the endophilin N-BAR domain (which lacks the SH3 domain including a linker region of the full length protein), we observe a large temperature dependence of the dimerization affinity and dimer dissociation kinetics, implying large dimerization enthalpy and dissociation activation enthalpy, respectively. Our evaluation of the protein concentration dependence of dimer dissociation kinetics implies that endophilin reversibly forms monomers via a dissociation/reassociation mechanism. Furthermore, we use a kinetic method that allows us to compare the dissociation kinetics of full-length endophilin to that of truncated mutants. We find that mutants that lack either H0 helix or SH3 domain show significantly faster dissociation kinetics relative to full-length endophilin. This observation supports the presence of an intradimer, intermonomer cross-interaction between H0 helix and SH3 domain from different subunits within a homodimer. Because the H0 helix is known to play a significant role in endophilin’s membrane interactions, our measurements support a syngergistic model where these interactions are inhibited in the absence of SH3 domain binding ligands such as dynamin’s prolin rich domains, and where the binding of these ligands may be suppressed for non-membrane-bound endophilin.

Fret Based Thermodynamics and Kinetics Investigation of Endophilin Dimerization

Endophilin is a homodimeric endocytic accessory protein which functions as a membrane curvature sensor, and as a membrane curvature generator, and membrane binding of this proteinthe recruitment of additional endocytic accessory proteins. However, the mechanism by which endophilin dimerizes has remained unclear. In this study, we employ the Forster resonance energy transfer technique to characterize the thermodynamic and kinetic information of endophilin dimerization/dissociation in solution. Large temperature dependence of dimerization affinity and dimer dissociation kinetics are revealed for the endophilin N-BAR domain, reporting dimerization affinity ranges from low nanomolar to sub-nanomolar and an activation enthalpy of 66 kcal/mol for the dimer dissociation reaction. We discuss the contributions of various interfacial molecular interactions to the stability of endophilin N-BAR dimers. Furthermore, to elucidate the role of the SH3 domain in the dimerization of full-length endophilin, we monitor the dissociation kinetics of full-length endophilin A1 and its truncated isoforms. Mutants without H0 helix or SH3 domain show significantly faster dissociation kinetics relative to full-length endophilin A1. This observation indicates the presence of an intra-dimer, inter-monomer cross-interaction of H0 helix and SH3 domain from different subunits of the same homodimer. This interaction likely results in even higher dimerization affinity of full-length endophilin relative to the BAR domain.

Analysis of High Affinity Self-Association by Fluorescence Optical Sedimentation Velocity Analytical Ultracentrifugation of Labeled Proteins: Opportunities and Limitations

Sedimentation velocity analytical ultracentrifugation (SV) is a powerful first-principle technique for the study of protein interactions, and allows a rigorous characterization of binding stoichiometry and affinities. A recently introduced commercial fluorescence optical detection system (FDS) permits analysis of high-affinity interactions by SV. However, for most proteins the attachment of an extrinsic fluorophore is an essential prerequisite for analysis by FDS-SV. Using the glutamate receptor GluA2 amino terminal domain as a model system for high-affinity homo-dimerization, we demonstrate how the experimental design and choice of fluorescent label can impact both the observed binding constants as well as the derived hydrodynamic parameter estimates for the monomer and dimer species. Specifically, FAM (5,6-carboxyfluorescein) was found to create different populations of artificially high-affinity and low-affinity dimers, as indicated by both FDS-SV and the kinetics of dimer dissociation studied using a bench-top fluorescence spectrometer and Förster Resonance Energy Transfer. By contrast, Dylight488 labeled GluA2, as well as GluA2 expressed as an EGFP fusion protein, yielded results consistent with estimates for unlabeled GluA2. Our study suggests considerations for the choice of labeling strategies, and highlights experimental designs that exploit specific opportunities of FDS-SV for improving the reliability of the binding isotherm analysis of interacting systems.

Kinetics of Endophilin N-BAR Domain Dimerization and Membrane Interactions

The recruitment to plasma membrane invaginations of the protein endophilin is a temporally regulated step in clathrin-mediated endocytosis. Endophilin is believed to sense or stabilize membrane curvature, which in turn likely depends on the dimeric structure of the protein. The dynamic nature of the membrane association and dimerization of endophilin is thus functionally important and is illuminated herein. Using subunit exchange Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), we determine dimer dissociation kinetics and find a dimerization equilibrium constant orders of magnitude lower than previously published values. We characterize N-BAR domain membrane association kinetics under conditions where the dimeric species predominates, by stopped flow, observing prominent electrostatic sensitivity of membrane interaction kinetics. Relative to membrane binding, we find that protein monomer/dimer species equilibrate with far slower kinetics. Complementary optical microscopy studies reveal strikingly slow membrane dissociation and an increase of dissociation rate constant for a construct lacking the amphipathic segment helix 0 (H0). We attribute the slow dissociation kinetics to higher-order protein oligomerization on the membrane. We incorporate our findings into a kinetic scheme for endophilin N-BAR membrane binding and find a significant separation of time scales for endophilin membrane binding and subsequent oligomerization. This separation may facilitate the regulation of membrane trafficking phenomena.

Off-rate and concentration diversity in multidonor-derived dimers of immunoglobulin G

IgG-dimers in multidonor-derived preparations of IgG antibodies represent not only agents of therapeutic potential, but also molecules of basic immunological interest since their composition mirrors the currently unknown range of clonal concentrations and affinities. To analyze this fundamental type of diversity, a computational model is developed in agreement with a density functional theory and used to simulate the dissociation kinetics of dimers separated from a 5000 donor-derived IgG preparation (protein concentration: 0.74mg/mL) via superimposition of 8100 arbitrary combinations of off-rates and initial concentrations. The Greedy algorithm-like procedure described requires iterative and consecutive changes of 8 from a total of 11 fitting parameters and allows to approximate the probability density distributions of either quantities within defined limits (apparent off-rates: ∼4×10−4 to 9×10−17s−1; concentrations: ∼3×10−20 to 1×10−11M) by lognormal distributions of log–log10-type, each of them adapted with four particular parameters, as well as the number of different dimer populations (∼2×1013). Moreover, reasonably dimensioned equilibrium constants involved in monovalent and bivalent random IgG dimerization are estimated by using a mean on-rate of 2.5×105M−1s−1 and interrelationships of molecular parameters derived from known models for antibody–antigen interaction.

Free energy perturbation study of water dimer dissociation kinetics.

An efficient approach is described for using accurate ab initio calculations to determine the rates of elementary condensation and evaporation processes that lead to nucleation of aqueous aerosols. The feasibility of the method is demonstrated in an application to evaporation rates of water dimer at 230 K. The method, known as ABC-FEP (ab initio/classical free energy perturbation), begins with a calculation of the potential of mean force for the dissociation (evaporation) of small water clusters using a molecular dynamics (MD) simulation with a model potential. The free energy perturbation is used to calculate how changing from the model potential to a potential calculated from ab initio methods would alter the potential of mean force. The difference in free energy is the Boltzmann-weighted average of the difference between the ab initio and classical potential energies, with the average taken over a sample of configurations from the MD simulation. In principle, the method does not require a highly accurate model potential, though more accurate potentials require fewer configurations to achieve a small sampling error in the free energy perturbation step. To test the feasibility of obtaining accurate potentials of mean force from ab initio calculations at a modest number of configurations, the free energy perturbation method has been used to correct the errors when some standard models for bulk water (SPC, TIP4P, and TIP4PFQ) are applied to water dimer. To allow a thorough exploration of sampling issues, a highly accurate fit to results of accurate ab initio calculations, known as SAPT-5s, as been used a proxy for the ab initio calculations. It is shown that accurate values for a point on the potential of mean force can be obtained from any of the water models using ab initio calculations at only 50 configurations. Thus, this method allows accurate simulations of small clusters without the need to develop water models specifically for clusters.

Slow dimer dissociation of the TATA binding protein dictates the kinetics of DNA binding

The association of the TATA binding protein (TBP) to eukaryotic promoters is a possible rate-limiting step in gene expression. Slow promoter binding might be related to TBP's ability to occlude its DNA binding domain through dimerization. Using a "pull-down" based assay, we find that TBP dimers dissociate slowly (t1/2 = 6-10 min), and thus present a formidable kinetic barrier to TATA binding. At 10 nM, TBP appears to exist as a mixed population of monomers and dimers. In this state, TATA binding displays burst kinetics that appears to reflect rapid binding of monomers and slow dissociation of dimers. The kinetics of the slow phase is in excellent agreement with direct measurements of the kinetics of dimer dissociation.

Cooperativity and Dimerization of Recombinant Human Estrogen Receptor Hormone-binding Domain

The estrogen receptor dimerizes and exhibits cooperative ligand binding as part of its normal functioning. Interaction of the estrogen receptor with its ligands is mediated by a C-terminal hormone-binding domain (HBD), and residues within the HBD are thought to contribute to dimerization. To examine dimer interactions in the isolated HBD, a human estrogen receptor HBD fragment was expressed in high yield as a cleavable fusion protein in Escherichia coli. The isolated HBD peptide exhibited affinity for estradiol, ligand discrimination, and cooperative estradiol binding (Hill coefficient approximately 1.6) similar to the full-length protein. Circular dichroism spectroscopy suggests that the HBD contains significant amounts of alpha-helix ( approximately 60%) and some beta-strand ( approximately 7%) and that ligand binding induces little change in secondary structure. HBD dimer dissociation, measured using size exclusion chromatography, exhibited a half-life of approximately 1.2 h, which ligand binding increased approximately 3-fold (estradiol) to approximately 4-fold (4-hydroxytamoxifen). These results suggest that the isolated estrogen receptor HBD dimerizes and undergoes conformational changes associated with cooperative ligand binding in a manner comparable to the full-length protein, and that one effect of ligand binding is to alter the receptor dimer dissociation kinetics.