The authors assessed the outcome of the Allen’s test compared with the use of the Doppler ultrasound test of the ulnar collateral circulation. They regard the Doppler ultrasound examination of triphasic wave form in the princeps pollicis artery as the “gold standard.” The concerns we have are, firstly, regarding the acceptance of the wave form of the Doppler ultrasound as a gold standard in the assessment of the hand collateral circulation. Baxter and his colleagues [1Baxter BT, Blackburn D, Payne K, Pearce WH, Yao JS. Noninvasive evaluation of the upper extremity. Surg Clin N Am 1990;70:87–97.Google Scholar] state in relation to this test “that the wave form characteristics do not correlate accurately with disease when measured with direct intra-arterial pressure and angiography.”Secondly, the main concern with the Allen’s test is that it may provide a false negative result, thus allowing the surgeon to harvest the artery in a situation where the ulnar collateral circulation is inadequate. The Doppler ultrasound and the digital systolic blood pressure measurements only register the changes occurring immediately following the occlusion of the radial artery and do not provide any information about the subsequent return of the collateral circulation through various compensatory mechanisms. The authors have found that using the Allen’s test with a cut-off point of five seconds results in a false negative rate of 24% (8 of 33). We also found a good correlation between the time of recovery using the Allen’s test compared with the systolic blood pressure in the thumb after occlusion of the radial artery. We concluded that the time of recovery by the Allen’s test of eight seconds achieved the maximum Youden’s index (similar to the ROC curve) and produced a more acceptable false negative rate of 18%.In our unit, 1,500 patients have proceeded to radial artery harvest based on the normal Allen’s test and experienced no complications. Our current recommendation, then, is to perform Doppler ultrasound on all patients who have a positive (abnormal) Allen’s test to prevent those patients, from whom it would be safe to remove the radial artery, being excluded from radial artery harvesting. The authors assessed the outcome of the Allen’s test compared with the use of the Doppler ultrasound test of the ulnar collateral circulation. They regard the Doppler ultrasound examination of triphasic wave form in the princeps pollicis artery as the “gold standard.” The concerns we have are, firstly, regarding the acceptance of the wave form of the Doppler ultrasound as a gold standard in the assessment of the hand collateral circulation. Baxter and his colleagues [1Baxter BT, Blackburn D, Payne K, Pearce WH, Yao JS. Noninvasive evaluation of the upper extremity. Surg Clin N Am 1990;70:87–97.Google Scholar] state in relation to this test “that the wave form characteristics do not correlate accurately with disease when measured with direct intra-arterial pressure and angiography.” Secondly, the main concern with the Allen’s test is that it may provide a false negative result, thus allowing the surgeon to harvest the artery in a situation where the ulnar collateral circulation is inadequate. The Doppler ultrasound and the digital systolic blood pressure measurements only register the changes occurring immediately following the occlusion of the radial artery and do not provide any information about the subsequent return of the collateral circulation through various compensatory mechanisms. The authors have found that using the Allen’s test with a cut-off point of five seconds results in a false negative rate of 24% (8 of 33). We also found a good correlation between the time of recovery using the Allen’s test compared with the systolic blood pressure in the thumb after occlusion of the radial artery. We concluded that the time of recovery by the Allen’s test of eight seconds achieved the maximum Youden’s index (similar to the ROC curve) and produced a more acceptable false negative rate of 18%. In our unit, 1,500 patients have proceeded to radial artery harvest based on the normal Allen’s test and experienced no complications. Our current recommendation, then, is to perform Doppler ultrasound on all patients who have a positive (abnormal) Allen’s test to prevent those patients, from whom it would be safe to remove the radial artery, being excluded from radial artery harvesting.
Read full abstract