Abstract Sodium benzoate is a naturally occurring preservative present in substances including cinnamon and apples. It is used as a food preservative and increasingly in leave-on and wash-off personal care products (PCPs), including moisturizers, hand washes, shampoos, mouthwash, toothpaste and baby wipes. Increased use results, in part, from European Union legislation regulating other preservatives, notably methylchloroisothiazolinone and methylisothiazolinone, which are banned in leave-on PCPs and are required to be used in reduced concentrations in wash-off products. Sodium benzoate was recently recommended for consideration for inclusion in the British Society for Cutaneous Allergy facial series after a national audit demonstrated that 1.5% of patients tested positive on patch testing when tested to sodium benzoate 5% in petrolatum (pet.) (Rolls S, Owen E, Bertram CG et al. What is in? What is out? Updating the British Society for Cutaneous Allergy facial series. Br J Dermatol 2021; 184:151–5). In our institution, 3229 patients were patch tested to sodium benzoate 5% in pet. from Chemotechnique Diagnostics™ from 2008 to 2022. It was tested in targeted series, bakery and cheilitis (2008–2022), and variably in fragrance (2012–2018) and cosmetic (2015–2018 and 2021–2022) series. We noted many irritant reactions to sodium benzoate 5% pet. and undertook an audit. Fifty-seven (1.8%) patients had positive reactions (+/++), 52 (1.6%) had doubtful reactions (? +), and 133 (4.1%) had irritant reactions. Of the positive reactions, 38 (66.7%) were of current relevance and 19 (33.3%) were of unknown relevance. The frequency of positive (+/++) reactions in the different targeted series was as follows: bakery and cheilitis 1.5%, cosmetic 1.7% and fragrance 2.1%. Concerningly, over three times more patients had irritant or doubtful reactions (5.7%) than those who tested positive (1.8%). When concentrations of a patch test preparation are decreased, the rate of irritancy on patch testing usually also decreases (Johansen J, Aalto-Korte K, Agner T et al. European Society of Contact Dermatitis guideline for diagnostic patch testing – recommendations on best practice. Contact Dermatitis 2015; 73:195–221). Given that sodium benzoate is a known allergen with increasing frequency of use, it is important that the optimum concentration and vehicle are used for patch testing to ensure adequate sensitivity but low irritancy. Decreasing the patch test concentration of sodium benzoate to 2% in pet., which is commercially available, may reduce irritant reactions and the risk of false positives. We recommend that dilutional studies should be performed comparing 5% with 2% in pet. with the hope that the latter is comparatively a nonirritant preparation without loss of sensitivity.
Read full abstract