RNA interference (RNAi) is an effective pest management strategy through silencing the crucial genes in target organisms. However, the effectiveness of targeting a single gene is often limited by the silencing efficiency due to tissue or developmental stage-specific gene expression. Moreover, multiple pests often infest the same crop simultaneously under current ecological conditions. Therefore, a combined strategy of “targeting multiple genes” and “controlling multiple pests” is expected to yield better management results. In this study, homologous genes from two globally sap-sucking pests, the peach aphid (Myzus persicae) and the whitefly (Bemisia tabaci), were screened on a genome-wide scale. Subsequently, RNAi bioassays showed silencing the genes (MpAbd-A, MpH3, MpRpL27a, and MpScr) exhibited high mortalities in both species, which were further selected for designing fusion dsRNAs. These fusion dsRNAs resulted in higher mortalities in both pests than single gene silencing and posed a minimal off-target risk to the predator ladybeetle (Propylaea japonica) based on the sequence analysis. Finally, the tobacco plants expressing the fusion dsRNAs through virus-induced gene silencing (VIGS) technology enhanced the resistance to both pests. In conclusion, this study proposes a novel RNAi-based approach for managing two sap-sucking pests simultaneously.