Developed Aggregation Operators Research Articles

Utilizing sine trigonometric q-spherical fuzzy rough aggregation operators for group decision-making and their role in digital transformation

q-spherical fuzzy rough set (q-SFRS) is also one of the fundamental concepts for addressing more uncertainties in decision problems than the existing structures of fuzzy sets, and thus its implementation was more substantial. The well-known sine trigonometric function maintains the periodicity and symmetry of the origin in nature and thus satisfies the expectations of the experts over the multi-parameters. Taking this feature and the significance of the q-SFRSs into consideration, the main objective of the article is to describe some reliable sine trigonometric laws for SFSs. Associated with these laws, we develop new average and geometric aggregation operators to aggregate the q-spherical fuzzy rough numbers. Then, we presented a group decision-making strategy to address the multi-attribute group decision-making problem using the developed aggregation operators. To verify the value of the defined operators, a MAGDM strategy is provided along with applications for selecting a Cloud Service Provider and a Digital Transformation Vendor for digital transformation. Moreover, a comparative study is also performed to present the effectiveness of the developed approach.

Some T-spherical fuzzy dombi hamy mean operators and their applications to multi-criteria group decision-making process

Renewable energy sources play an influential role in the world’s climate and reduce the rate of harmful gasses such as carbon dioxide, methane, nitrous oxide, and many other greenhouse gasses that contribute to global warming. The theoretical concept of the T-spherical fuzzy (T-SF) set (T-SFS) is the most suitable model to evaluate energy resources under uncertainty. This article illustrates appropriate operations based on Dombi triangular norm and t-conorm. We derived a series of new aggregation approaches, such as T-SF Dombi Hamy mean (T-SFDHM) and T-SF weighted Dombi Hamy Mean (T-SFDWHM) operators. Further authors illustrated a list of new approaches such as T-SF Dual Dombi Hamy mean (T-SFDDHM), and T-SF Dombi weighted Dual Hamy mean (T-SFDWDHM) operators. Some exceptional cases and desirable properties of our derived approaches are also studied. We illustrate an application of renewable energy resources to be evaluated using a multi-attribute group decision-making (MAGDM) method. A case study was also studied to choose appropriate energy resources using our proposed methodology of the T-SFDWHM and T-SFDWDHM operators. To show the effectiveness and validity of our current methods, we compared the existing results with currently developed aggregation operators (AOs).

Q-rung orthopair normal fuzzy Maclaurin symmetric mean aggregation operators based on Schweizer-Skla operations

In order to be able to make a good decision, we need to evaluate the uncertainty information of multiple attributes of different alternatives that obey the normal distribution, and the interrelationship among multiple attributes should be considered in the process of evaluating. This paper aims to propose a new multiple attribute decision-making (MADM) method, which uses a new aggregation operator to evaluate the uncertainty information that obey normal distribution comprehensively. We firstly extended Schweizer-Sklar (SS) t-norm (TN) and t-conorm (TCN) to q-rung orthopair normal fuzzy number (q-RONFN) and defined the Schweizer-Skla operational laws of q-rung orthopair normal fuzzy set (q-RONFs). Secondly, we developed q-rung orthopair normal fuzzy Maclaurin symmetric mean aggregation operators based on SS operations considering that the Maclaurin symmetric mean operator can reflect the interrelationship among multiple input variables. Furthermore, we discussed some desirable properties of the above operators, such as monotonicity, commutativity, and idempotency. Lastly, we proposed a novel MADM method based on developed aggregation operators. A numerical example on enterprise partner selection is given to testify the effectiveness of the developed method. The results of analysis indicated that our proposed aggregation operators have stronger information aggregation ability and are more general and flexible for MADM problems.

An approach to multi-attribute decision making based on intuitionistic fuzzy rough Aczel-Alsina aggregation operators

A concept of intuitionistic fuzzy rough set based on approximations plays a vital role in coping with uncertainty. Aczel-Alsina t-norm and t-conorm are the most flexible operational laws based on the parameter for fuzzy frameworks. In multi-attribute group decision-making (MAGDM), the aim of this article is to develop some tools based on norm operations for the information fusion. In this article, intuitionistic fuzzy rough Aczel-Alsina weighted geometric operators are developed and studied their properties. Based on these operators, MAGDM algorithm is presented. The developed aggregation operators (AOs) are compared with some existing AOs, and their significance is discussed.

Development of type-2 Pythagorean fuzzy set with its application to sustainable transport system selection

In resolving multicriteria decision-making (MCDM) problems, it is observed that the solution process is frequently affected by the available vague information together with intra-personal uncertainties associated with expert’s opinion. In most of the time fuzzy set or its existing variants fail to capture such uncertainties for making reasonable balance in decision making processes. To reduce the effects of uncertainties, this paper introduces a new variant of fuzzy set, viz., type-2 Pythagorean fuzzy set (T2PFS). The main advantage of using T2PFS in MCDM is that the membership and non-membership values of each argument are presented by Pythagorean fuzzy numbers rather than using fuzzy number or intuitionistic fuzzy number. In model formulation process, at first, T2PFS is explicitly formulated and some basic operations are defined. Subsequently, four aggregation operators are constructed to aggregate the arguments, and their properties are verified. Afterwards, two information measures and a score function are defined. Moreover, two MCDM algorithms based on the developed aggregation operators and TOPSIS are framed. To show the application potentiality of the proposed method, a case study relating to the selection of sustainable transport system in India is considered and solved. In the case study five different fuel-based vehicles, mostly used in India in recent times, are evaluated by the experts as transport alternatives with the consideration of thirteen sustainability related criteria. From the achieved result it is found that in future electric cars would become the most sustainable vehicle in India. Sensitivity analysis of the developed models and comparative study with existing fuzzy and non-fuzzy MCDM methods establish effectiveness of the developed models. This study may facilitate transport authority to select appropriate transport system in connection with sustainable development of a region.

MULTIMOORA Method-Based Schweizer–Sklar Operations for CO2 Geological Storage Site Selection Under Pythagorean Fuzzy Environment

The site selection of CO2 geological storage facilities is essential for the development of safe and efficient carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) projects. Normally, CO2 geological storage site selection can be regarded as a complex multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) problem. The aim of this paper is to present an integrated decision-making method for solving the site selection problem for CO2 geological storage. To achieve this goal, this method is based on multi-objective optimization by ratio analysis plus the full multiplicative form (MULTIMOORA) method and prioritized aggregation operators in Pythagorean fuzzy environment. The academic contributions of this study include: first, some Pythagorean fuzzy Schweizer–Sklar prioritized aggregation (PFSSPA) operators are proposed, which take into account the priority levels of criteria and the risk preferences of decision makers. The excellent properties of these operators are given. Then this study extends the classical MULTIMOORA method based on the developed aggregation operators (named PFSSPA-MULTIMOORA), and the calculation process of this method is described in detail. Subsequently, on the basis of the constructed criteria system, the PFSSPA-MULTIMOORA method is applied to rank the alternatives. Finally, we successfully utilized the PFSSPA-MULTIMOORA method to solve the site selection problem of CO2 geological storage in China. A comparative analysis of existing methods verifies the effectiveness and robustness of the proposed method. This work can provide advanced decision support for researchers and practitioners.

Generalized cross weighted Heronian mean operators and their application to binary classification

Heronian mean (HM) operators, which can capture the interrelationship between input arguments with the same importance, have been a hot research topic as a useful aggregation technique. In this paper, we propose the generalized normalized cross weighted HM operators on the unit interval which can not only capture the interrelationships between input arguments but also aggregate them with different weights, some desirable properties are derived. Then, generalized cross weighted HM operators are extended to real number set and applied to binary classification. We list the detailed steps of binary classification with the developed aggregation operators, and give a comparison of the proposed method with the existing ones using the Iris dataset with 5-fold cross-validation (5-f cv), the accuracy of the proposed method for the training sets and the testing sets are both 100%.

Decision Support System Based on Complex Fractional Orthotriple Fuzzy 2-Tuple Linguistic Aggregation Operator

In this research, we provide tools to overcome the information loss limitation resulting from the requirement to estimate the results in the discrete initial expression domain. Through the use of 2-tuples, which are made up of a linguistic term and a numerical value calculated between [0.5,0.5), the linguistic information will be expressed. This model supports continuous representation of the linguistic data within its scope, permitting it to express any information counting received through an aggregation procedure. This study provides a novel approach to develop a linguistic multi-attribute group decision-making (MAGDM) approach with complex fractional orthotriple fuzzy 2-tuple linguistic (CFOF2TL) assessment details. Initially, the concept of a complex fractional orthotriple fuzzy 2-tuple linguistic set (CFO2TLS) is proposed to convey uncertain and fuzzy information. In the meantime, simple aggregation operators, such as CFOF2TL weighted average and geometric operators, are defined. In addition, the CFOF2TL Maclaurin’s symmetric mean (CFOF2TLMSM) operators and their weighted shapes are presented, and their attractive characteristics are also discussed. A new MAGDM approach is built using the developed aggregation operators to address managing economic crises under COVID-19 with the CFOF2TL information. As a result, the effectiveness and robustness of the developed method are accompanied by an empirical example, and a comparative study is carried out by contrasting it with previous approaches.

Covering-based compound mean operators arising from Heronian and Bonferroni mean operators in fuzzy and intuitionistic fuzzy environments

Both Heronian mean (HM) operators and Bonferroni mean (BM) operators can capture the interrelationship between input arguments and have been a hot research topic as a useful aggregation technique in fuzzy and intuitionistic fuzzy environments. In this paper, associated with the common characters of these operators we propose the covering-based compound mean operators in fuzzy environments to capture various interrelationships between input arguments, some desirable properties and special cases of the proposed mean operators are provided. Then, conditions under which these covering-based compound mean operators can be directly used to aggregate the membership degrees and nonmembership degrees of intuitionistic fuzzy information, are provided. In particular, novel intuitionistic fuzzy HM operators and intuitionistic fuzzy BM operators are directly derived from the classical ones. We list the detailed steps of multiple attribute decision making with the developed aggregation operators, and give a comparison of the new extensions of BM operators by this paper with the corresponding existing ones to prove the rationality and effectiveness of the proposed method.

Novel Approach for Third-Party Reverse Logistic Provider Selection Process under Linear Diophantine Fuzzy Prioritized Aggregation Operators

Aggregation operators are fundamental concept for information fusion in real-life problems. Many researchers developed aggregation operators for multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) under uncertainty. Unfortunately, the existing operators can be utilized under strict limitations and constraints. In this manuscript, we focused on new prioritized aggregation operators which remove the strict limitations of the existing operators. The addition of reference parameters associated with membership and non-membership grades in the linear Diophantine Fuzzy sets provide a robust modeling for MCDM problems. The primary objective of this manuscript is to introduce new aggregation operators for modeling uncertainty by using linear Diophantine Fuzzy information. For this objective we develop aggregation operators (AO) namely, "linear Diophantine Fuzzy prioritized weighted average" (LDFPWA) operator and "linear Diophantine Fuzzy prioritized weighted geometric" (LDFPWG) operator. Certain essential properties of new prioritized AOs are also proposed. A secondary objective is to discuss a practical application of third party reverse logistic provider (3PRLP) optimization problem. The efficiency, superiority, and rationality of the proposed approach is analyzed by a numerical example to discuss 3PRLP. The symmetry of optimal decision and ranking of feasible alternatives is followed by a comparative analysis.

Robust Aggregation Operators for Intuitionistic Fuzzy Hypersoft Set With Their Application to Solve MCDM Problem.

In this paper, we investigate the multi-criteria decision-making complications under intuitionistic fuzzy hypersoft set (IFHSS) information. The IFHSS is a proper extension of the intuitionistic fuzzy soft set (IFSS) which discusses the parametrization of multi-sub attributes of considered parameters, and accommodates more hesitation comparative to IFSS utilizing the multi sub-attributes of the considered parameters. The main objective of this research is to introduce operational laws for intuitionistic fuzzy hypersoft numbers (IFHSNs). Additionally, based on developed operational laws two aggregation operators (AOs), i.e., intuitionistic fuzzy hypersoft weighted average (IFHSWA) and intuitionistic fuzzy hypersoft weighted geometric (IFHSWG), operators have been presented with their fundamental properties. Furthermore, a decision-making approach has been established utilizing our developed aggregation operators (AOs). Through the established approach, a technique for solving decision-making (DM) complications is proposed to select sustainable suppliers in sustainable supply chain management (SSCM). Moreover, a numerical description is presented to ensure the validity and usability of the proposed technique in the DM process. The practicality, effectivity, and flexibility of the current approach are demonstrated through comparative analysis with the assistance of some prevailing studies.

Sine trigonometric spherical fuzzy aggregation operators and their application in decision support system, TOPSIS, VIKOR

Spherical fuzzy set (SFS) is also one of the fundamental concepts for address more uncertainties in decision problems than the existing structures of fuzzy sets, and thus its implementation was more substantial. The well-known sine trigonometric function maintains the periodicity and symmetry of the origin in nature and thus satisfies the expectations of the experts over the multi parameters. Taking this feature and the significance of the SFSs into the consideration, the main objective of the article is to describe some reliable sine trigonometric laws $\left( STL\right) $ for SFSs. Associated with these laws, we develop new average and geometric aggregation operators to aggregate the Spherical fuzzy numbers (SFNs). Then, we presented a group decision- making (DM) strategy to address the multi-attribute group decision making (MAGDM) problem using the developed aggregation operators. In order to verify the value of the defined operators, a MAGDM strategy is provided along with an application for the selection of laptop. Moreover, a comparative study is also performed to present the effectiveness of the developed approach.

Multi-attribute group decision making based on sine trigonometric spherical fuzzy aggregation operators.

Spherical fuzzy set (SFS) is also one of the fundamental concepts for address more uncertainties in decision problems than the existing structures of fuzzy sets, and thus its implementation was more substantial. The well-known sine trigonometric function maintains the periodicity and symmetry of the origin in nature and thus satisfies the expectations of the experts over the multi parameters. Taking this feature and the significance of the SFSs into the consideration, the main objective of the article is to describe some reliable sine trigonometric laws for SFSs. Associated with these laws, we develop new average and geometric aggregation operators to aggregate the Spherical fuzzy numbers. Then, we presented a group decision-making strategy to address the multi-attribute group decision-making problem using the developed aggregation operators. To verify the value of the defined operators, a MAGDM strategy is provided along with an application for the selection of an authentic COVID-19 laboratory. Moreover, a comparative study is also performed to present the effectiveness of the developed approach.

A Novel Approach Based on Sine Trigonometric Picture Fuzzy Aggregation Operators and Their Application in Decision Support System

Picture fuzzy sets (PFSs) are one of the fundamental concepts for addressing uncertainties in decision problems, and they can address more uncertainties compared to the existing structures of fuzzy sets; thus, their implementation was more substantial. The well-known sine trigonometric function maintains the periodicity and symmetry of the origin in nature and thus satisfies the expectations of the decision-maker over the multiple parameters. Taking this feature and the significances of the PFSs into consideration, the main objective of the article is to describe some reliable sine trigonometric laws STLs for PFSs. Associated with these laws, we develop new average and geometric aggregation operators to aggregate the picture fuzzy numbers. Also, we characterized the desirable properties of the proposed operators. Then, we presented a group decision-making strategy to address the multiple attribute group decision-making (MAGDM) problem using the developed aggregation operators and demonstrated this with a practical example. To show the superiority and the validity of the proposed aggregation operations, we compared them with the existing methods and concluded from the comparison and sensitivity analysis that our proposed technique is more effective and reliable.

Emergency Decision-Making Based on q-Rung Orthopair Fuzzy Rough Aggregation Information

With the frequent occurrences of emergency events, emergency decision making (EDM) plays an increasingly significant role in coping with such situations and has become an important and challenging research area in recent times. It is essential for decision makers to make reliable and reasonable emergency decisions within a short span of time, since inappropriate decisions may result in enormous economic losses and social disorder. To handle emergency effectively and quickly, this paper proposes a new EDM method based on the novel concept of q-rung orthopair fuzzy rough (q-ROPR) set. A novel list of q-ROFR aggregation information, detailed description of the fundamental characteristics of the developed aggregation operators and the q-ROFR entropy measure that determine the unknown weight information of decision makers as well as the criteria weights are specified. Further an algorithm is given to tackle the uncertain scenario in emergency to give reliable and reasonable emergency decisions. By using proposed list of q-ROFR aggregation information all emergency alternatives are ranked to get the optimal one. Besides this, the q-ROFR entropy measure method is used to determine criteria and experts’ weights objectively in the EDM process. Finally, through an illustrative example of COVID-19 analysis is compared with existing EDM methods. The results verify the effectiveness and practicability of the proposed methodology.

Linguistic Z-Number Bonferroni Mean and Linguistic Z-Number Geometric Bonferroni Mean Operators: Their Applications in Portfolio Selection Problems

The optimal combination of assets can be selected by the traditional portfolio theory which uses historical quantitative data to represent the future return of assets. However, quantitative information is inaccessible in most cases and experts can help investors and fund managers by providing qualitative information. According to above discussion, a new multi-stage qualitative approach is proposed to select the optimal portfolio under linguistic Z-number environment. To achieve this aim, this study firstly develops the Bonferroni mean (BM) operator and the geometric Bonferroni mean (GBM) operator under the linguistic Z-number environment, and introduces linguistic Z-number Bonferroni mean (LZBM) operator and linguistic Z-number geometric Bonferroni mean (LZGBM) operator to aggregate the qualitative evaluation information. Then, using the developed aggregation operators, two qualitative portfolio selection models are proposed based on the max-score rule and the score-accuracy trade-off rule for the general investors and risky investors, respectively. Finally, to illustrate the validity of the proposed models, a case study including 20 corporations of Tehran stock exchange market in Iran is provided and the obtained results are analyzed. Moreover, the qualitative proposed models are compared with another available model. The obtained results indicate that the qualitative proposed approach can help investors and fund managers to make more credible decisions so that they can select the optimal assets with considering different criteria when experts are assured about their assessments or opinions. Therefore, the qualitative proposed models are superior and more general in comparison with the other ones due to capturing the reliability of information. Also, the obtained results show the influence of reliability measures in investment processes.

Utilizing Linguistic Picture Fuzzy Aggregation Operators for Multiple-Attribute Decision-Making Problems

The linguistic picture fuzzy set (LPFS) is an extension of the linguistic intuitionistic fuzzy set (LIFS), and can contain more information than the LIFS. In this paper, the degrees of positive, neutral and non-membership of PFSs are expressed in linguistic terms, which can more easily describe the uncertain and vague information existing in the real world. By combining the PFS and the linguistic term, we define the LPFS and propose operational rules for linguistic picture fuzzy numbers (LPFNs). We further propose weighted averaging and weighted geometric operators and discuss their properties. Additionally, we propose an approach to deal with a multiple-attribute group decision-making (MAGDM) problem based on the developed aggregation operators. Finally, we present an illustrative example to demonstrate the effectiveness and advantages of the developed method by comparing it with existing methods. In addition, our method can be utilized not only to solve problems with linguistic intuitionistic fuzzy numbers (LIFNs), but also to deal with problems with LPFNs, and is a generalization of a number of existing methods.

Multi-Attribute Multi-Perception Decision-Making Based on Generalized T-Spherical Fuzzy Weighted Aggregation Operators on Neutrosophic Sets

The framework of the T-spherical fuzzy set is a recent development in fuzzy set theory that can describe imprecise events using four types of membership grades with no restrictions. The purpose of this manuscript is to point out the limitations of the existing intuitionistic fuzzy Einstein averaging and geometric operators and to develop some improved Einstein aggregation operators. To do so, first some new operational laws were developed for T-spherical fuzzy sets and their properties were investigated. Based on these new operations, two types of Einstein aggregation operators are proposed namely the Einstein interactive averaging aggregation operators and the Einstein interactive geometric aggregation operators. The properties of the newly developed aggregation operators were then investigated and verified. The T-spherical fuzzy aggregation operators were then applied to a multi-attribute decision making (MADM) problem related to the degree of pollution of five major cities in China. Actual datasets sourced from the UCI Machine Learning Repository were used for this purpose. A detailed study was done to determine the most and least polluted city for different perceptions for different situations. Several compliance tests were then outlined to test and verify the accuracy of the results obtained via our proposed decision-making algorithm. It was proved that the results obtained via our proposed decision-making algorithm was fully compliant with all the tests that were outlined, thereby confirming the accuracy of the results obtained via our proposed method.

T-Spherical Fuzzy Power Muirhead Mean Operator Based on Novel Operational Laws and Their Application in Multi-Attribute Group Decision Making

T-spherical fuzzy set (T-SPFS) is a generalization of several fuzzy concepts such as fuzzy set (FS), intuitionistic FS, picture FS, Pythagorean FS, and q-rung orthopair FS. T-SPFS is a more powerful mathematical tool to handle uncertain, inconsistent, and vague information than the above-defined sets. In this paper, some limitations in the operational laws for SPF numbers (SPFNs) are discussed and some novel operational laws for SPFNs are proposed. Furthermore, two new aggregation operators for aggregating SPF information are proposed and are applied to multiple-attribute group decision-making (MAGDM). To take the advantages of Muirhead mean (MM) operator and power average operator, the SPF power MM (SPFPMM) operator, weighted SPFPMM operator, SPF power dual MM (SPFPDMM) operator, weighted SPFPDMM operator are introduced and their anticipated properties are discussed. The main advantage of these developed aggregation operators is that they take the relationship among fused data and the interrelationship among aggregated values, thereby getting more information in the process of MAGDM. Moreover, a novel approach to MAGDM based on the developed aggregation operators is established. Finally, a numerical example is given to show the effectiveness of the developed approach and comparison with the existing approaches is also given.

A Multi-Criteria Group Decision-Making Method with Possibility Degree and Power Aggregation Operators of Single Trapezoidal Neutrosophic Numbers

Single valued trapezoidal neutrosophic numbers (SVTNNs) are very useful tools for describing complex information, because of their advantage in describing the information completely, accurately and comprehensively for decision-making problems. In the paper, a method based on SVTNNs is proposed for dealing with multi-criteria group decision-making (MCGDM) problems. Firstly, the new operations SVTNNs are developed for avoiding evaluation information aggregation loss and distortion. Then the possibility degrees and comparison of SVTNNs are proposed from the probability viewpoint for ranking and comparing the single valued trapezoidal neutrosophic information reasonably and accurately. Based on the new operations and possibility degrees of SVTNNs, the single valued trapezoidal neutrosophic power average (SVTNPA) and single valued trapezoidal neutrosophic power geometric (SVTNPG) operators are proposed to aggregate the single valued trapezoidal neutrosophic information. Furthermore, based on the developed aggregation operators, a single valued trapezoidal neutrosophic MCGDM method is developed. Finally, the proposed method is applied to solve the practical problem of the most appropriate green supplier selection and the rank results compared with the previous approach demonstrate the proposed method's effectiveness.