Abstract This paper presents the findings of research conducted at a selected university in Rwanda aiming to evaluate the mechanics of problem-solving strategies among engineering students. Problem-solving is an important component of science, technology, engineering, and mathematics education as well as in everyday life. To enhance the development of problem-solving skills, researchers and curriculum creators must develop problem-solving strategies for solving mechanics problems and for improving engineering students’ performance in physics classroom tasks. The study investigated engineering students’ strategies for their mechanics problem-solving using a mixed-methods research approach that includes questionnaires, interviews, and tests. A purposive sample of 99 students was chosen, with 20 students and three instructors randomly selected for interviews. Findings revealed that students heavily rely on algebraic equations, neglecting visual representations in mechanics problem-solving. Challenges identified include limited familiarity with alternative representations, difficulties transitioning between them, and a constrained understanding of their interrelationships. Recognizing these practices and strategies informs the design of more effective pedagogical interventions. Incorporating the best problem-solving strategies in physics education is a potential avenue to bolster problem-solving skills and deepen comprehension of mechanics concepts among engineering students.