Subclinical atrial fibrillation (SAF) represents the most prevalent underlying etiology detected after an embolic stroke of undetermined source (ESUS). Investigating SAF is strongly recommended during the diagnostic work-up. The efficacy of oral anticoagulant (OAC) therapy in reducing the risk of stroke recurrence post-SAF detection remains a conundrum. Thus, our study aimed to analyze the management of secondary antithrombotic prophylaxis and the rate of 12-month stroke recurrence in real-life ESUS patients. We retrospectively analyzed clinical, radiographic, and echocardiographic findings of patients with ESUS who underwent non-implantable 2-week electrocardiogram (ECG) monitoring after discharge. Episodes of SAF of any duration were considered diagnostic. Antithrombotic treatment at hospital discharge and after ECG monitoring, as well as 12-month recurrence, were registered. We compared the rate of stroke recurrence between patients with and without detection of SAF. One hundred and fifty-nine patients (75 females) with a median age of 73.5 (interquartile range [IQR] = 66.75 – 79) years represented the study population. At hospital discharge, 96.9% of patients received antiplatelet therapy as secondary antithrombotic prophylaxis. SAF was detected in 82 patients (51.5%), and OAC was prescribed in 98.6% of them. The median time from stroke onset to OAC prescription was 143 (IQR = 94 – 178) days. Overall, 12-month stroke recurrence occurred in eight patients (5%). The stroke recurrence rate was lower in patients prescribed OAC compared with those not prescribed it, although the difference was not significant (3.7% vs. 6.25%; P = 0.7202). In our study, OACs prescribed post-SAF detection in patients with ESUS reduced, but not significantly, the risk of stroke recurrence. Future research and prospective multicenter studies are warranted.