Detection Of Biological Threat Agents Research Articles

Evaluation of sample processing methods to improve the detection of Bacillus anthracis in difficult sample matrices.

Large area sampling approaches have been developed and implemented by the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to increase sample sizes, and potentially representativeness, in outdoor urban environments (e.g., concrete, asphalt, grass/landscaping). These sampling approaches could be implemented in response to an outdoor biological contamination incident or bioterrorism attack to determine the extent of contamination and for clearance following remediation. However, sample collection over large areas often contains an extensive amount of co-collected debris and native background microorganisms that interfere with the detection of biological threat agents. Sample processing methods that utilize basic laboratory equipment amenable to field deployment were selected and applied to turbid aqueous samples (TAS) to reduce particulates and native environmental organisms prior to culture and rapid viability-polymerase chain reaction (RV-PCR) analytical methods. Bacillus anthracis Sterne (BaS) spores were spiked into TAS collected by soil grab, wet vacuum collection from an outdoor concrete surface, or storm water runoff from an urban parking lot. The implementation of a sample processing method improved the sensitivity of culture and RV-PCR analytical methods for BaS spore detection in soil and wet vacuum TAS samples compared to baseline (minimal to no field processing methods applied). For soil, when the processing method was applied, samples with 15 colony forming units (CFU)/ml (60CFU/g) and 1.5CFU/mL (6CFU/g) BaS spore load were detected using culture and RV-PCR, respectively. Most notably, the processing methods greatly improved the sensitivity of the RV-PCR analytical method for the wet vacuum TAS from no detection at the 1500CFU/mL BaS spore load level to as low as 1.5CFU/mL BaS spore load.

End-User Perspectives on Using Quantitative Real-Time PCR and Genomic Sequencing in the Field.

Quantitative real-time PCR and genomic sequencing have become mainstays for performing molecular detection of biological threat agents in the field. There are notional assessments of the benefits, disadvantages, and challenges that each of these technologies offers according to findings in the literature. However, direct comparison between these two technologies in the context of field-forward operations is lacking. Most market surveys, whether published in print form or provided online, are directed to product manufacturers who can address their respective specifications and operations. One method for comparing these technologies is surveying end-users who are best suited for discussing operational capabilities, as they have hands-on experience with state-of-the-art molecular detection platforms and protocols. These end-users include operators in military defense and first response, as well as various research scientists in the public sector such as government and service laboratories, private sector, and civil society such as academia and nonprofit organizations performing method development and executing these protocols in the field. Our objective was to initiate a survey specific to end-users and their feedback. We developed a questionnaire that asked respondents to (1) determine what technologies they currently use, (2) identify the settings where the technologies are used, whether lab-based or field-forward, and (3) rate the technologies according to a set list of criteria. Of particular interest are assessments of sensitivity, specificity, reproducibility, scalability, portability, and discovery power. This article summarizes the findings from the end-user perspective, highlighting technical and operational challenges.

A decade of RCPAQAP Biosecurity improving testing for biological threats in Australia

Biosecurity is a term broadly applied to the protection, control and accountability of biological agents and toxins to minimise the risk of their introduction through natural, unintentional (accidents) or deliberate processes. Biosecurity protection involves the engagement of all stakeholders including government, public health networks, industry, and scientific community. While the Commonwealth Government primarily manages biosecurity, it is also a shared responsibility with State and Territory governments. Rapid, accurate diagnosis is essential to informing all levels of response to biosecurity threats. External quality assurance (EQA) through proficiency testing (PT) is an indispensable tool to allow assessment of laboratory performance. This ensures laboratory capability and capacity are in a constant state of readiness to effectively detect biological threats and reduce the impact and transmission of disease. Since 2009, the Royal College of Pathologists Australasia Quality Assurance Program (RCPAQAP) has been contracted by the Australian Government Department of Health to establish a proficiency testing program (PTP) for the detection of biological threat agents. Starting out as a PTP for the detection of Bacillus anthracis, RCPAQAP Biosecurity has undergone significant transformation, thereby building and enhancing laboratory preparedness. Alterations in the program have been in line with the changing landscape of biosecurity and other emerging infectious diseases across Australia, and worldwide.

Label-Free Detection of Bacillus anthracis Spore Uptake in Macrophage Cells Using Analytical Optical Force Measurements.

Understanding the interaction between macrophage cells and Bacillus anthracis spores is of significant importance with respect to both anthrax disease progression, spore detection for biodefense, as well as understanding cell clearance in general. While most detection systems rely on specific molecules, such as nucleic acids or proteins and fluorescent labels to identify the target(s) of interest, label-free methods probe changes in intrinsic properties, such as size, refractive index, and morphology, for correlation with a particular biological event. Optical chromatography is a label free technique that uses the balance between optical and fluidic drag forces within a microfluidic channel to determine the optical force on cells or particles. Here we show an increase in the optical force experienced by RAW264.7 macrophage cells upon the uptake of both microparticles and B. anthracis Sterne 34F2 spores. In the case of spores, the exposure was detected in as little as 1 h without the use of antibodies or fluorescent labels of any kind. An increase in the optical force was also seen in macrophage cells treated with cytochalasin D, both with and without a subsequent exposure to spores, indicating that a portion of the increase in the optical force arises independent of phagocytosis. These results demonstrate the capability of optical chromatography to detect subtle biological differences in a rapid and sensitive manner and suggest future potential in a range of applications, including the detection of biological threat agents for biodefense and pathogens for the prevention of sepsis and other diseases.

Nanomaterial-based sensors for the detection of biological threat agents.

The danger posed by biological threat agents and the limitations of modern detection methods to rapidly identify them underpins the need for continued development of novel sensors. The application of nanomaterials to this problem in recent years has proven especially advantageous. By capitalizing on large surface/volume ratios, dispersability, beneficial physical and chemical properties, and unique nanoscale interactions, nanomaterial-based biosensors are being developed with sensitivity and accuracy that are starting to surpass traditional biothreat detection methods, yet do so with reduced sample volume, preparation time, and assay cost. In this review, we start with an overview of bioagents and then highlight the breadth of nanoscale sensors that have recently emerged for their detection.

Label free detection of pseudorabies virus infection in Vero cells using laser force analysis

The rapid and robust identification of viral infections has broad implications for a number of fields, including medicine, biotechnology and biodefense. Most detection systems rely on specific molecules, such as nucleic acids or proteins, to identify the target(s) of interest. These molecules afford great specificity, but are often expensive, labor-intensive, labile and limited in scope. Label free detection methods seek to overcome these limitations by instead using detection methods that rely on intrinsic properties as a basis for identifying and separating species of interest and thus do not rely on specific prior knowledge of the target. Optical chromatography, one such technique, uses the balance between optical and fluidic drag forces within a microfluidic channel to determine the optical force on cells or particles. Here we present the application of individual optical force measurements as a means of investigating pseudorabies virus infection in Vero cells. Optical force differences are seen between cells from uninfected and infected populations at a multiplicity of infection as low as 0.001 and as soon as 2 hours post infection, demonstrating the potential of this technique as a means of detecting viral infection. Through the application of a pattern recognition neural network, individual cell size data are combined with optical force as a means of classifying cell populations. Potential applications include the early detection of bloodborne pathogens for the prevention of sepsis and other diseases as well as the detection of biological threat agents.

Toward Label-Free Optical Fractionation of Blood—Optical Force Measurements of Blood Cells

There is a compelling need to develop systems capable of processing blood and other particle streams for detection of pathogens that are sensitive, selective, automated, and cost/size effective. Our research seeks to develop laser-based separations that do not rely on prior knowledge, antibodies, or fluorescent molecules for pathogen detection. Rather, we aim to harness inherent differences in optical pressure, which arise from variations in particle size, shape, refractive index, or morphology, as a means of separating and characterizing particles. Our method for measuring optical pressure involves focusing a laser into a fluid flowing opposite to the direction of laser propagation. As microscopic particles in the flow path encounter the beam, they are trapped axially along the beam and are pushed upstream from the laser focal point to rest at a point where the optical and fluid forces on the particle balance. On the basis of the flow rate at which this balance occurs, the optical pressure felt by the particle can be calculated. As a first step in the development of a label-free device for processing blood, a system has been developed to measure optical pressure differences between the components of human blood, including erythrocytes, monocytes, granulocytes, and lymphocytes. Force differentials have been measured between various components, indicating the potential for laser-based separation of blood components based upon differences in optical pressure. Potential future applications include the early detection of blood-borne pathogens for the prevention of sepsis and other diseases as well as the detection of biological threat agents.

New deep-ultraviolet sources for detecting biological threats

Biological weapons have been used for warfare, criminal activities, and terrorism for centuries.1 Recently, bio-aerosol terrorist attacks have been carried out against civilians in the US, and recurrence appears inevitable. Historically, biothreat-detection functions have been broken down into four components: trigger, rapid confirmer/identifier, sample collector, and final confirmer/identifier. Greenwood and colleagues recently presented2 a more in-depth description of the individual functional components of the detection strategy. The biothreat trigger must operate continuously, or nearly so, and respond rapidly to any anomalous aerosol, hydrosol, or surface contamination. Because of the horrific potential of biological weapons to destroy human health, human life, food supplies, and the general habitat, and the virtual certainty that these weapons will be used in the future, the need for a fast, reliable, specific, and inexpensive threat trigger has been recognized for decades. It could be an important tool for detectto-protect and detect-to-treat countermeasure scenarios. These triggers have been employing laser (but recently LED) light for light-induced native or autofluorescence (LIF) for decades, but without a generally accepted solution. No single device has all of the desirable traits. We recently reviewed3 LIF bio-aerosol threat triggers. It is widely recognized that compact, efficient, long-lived, lowpower, affordable deep-UV (DUV) sources would dramatically push LIF detection forward. (Here DUV covers wavelengths of 200–250nm.) In comparison to violet, UV-A, and UV-B (see Figure 1), DUV wavelengths offer LIF detection that is more sensitive because of strong fluorescence cross sections from fluorescent amino acids in proteins, and more discriminating because it targets intrinsic biological properties rather than growth-media residues. It is also less susceptible to threatwashing techniques, residual threat moisture, and ambient Figure 1. Advantages of deep-UV (DUV) light for fluorescence detection of biological threat agents.

Real time detection of anthrax spores using highly specific anti-EA1 recombinant antibodies produced by competitive panning

We describe a targeted approach for the production of biological recognition elements capable of fast, specific detection of anthrax spores on biosensor surfaces. The aim was to produce single chain antibodies (scFvs) to EA1, a Bacillus anthracis S-layer protein that is also present, although not identical, in related to Bacillus species. The aim of the work was to produce antibodies that would detect B. anthracis EA1 protein and intact spores with a high degree of specificity, but would not detect other Bacillus species. Existing monoclonal antibodies were evaluated and found to recognise B. anthracis EA1 and S-layer proteins from other closely related Bacillus species. Recombinant anti-EA1 scFvs were isolated from B. anthracis immune library that contained antibody genes raised against B. anthracis spores and purified exosporium. Two approaches for scFv selection were used; standard (non-competitive) panning, and competitive panning. The non-competitive biopanning strategy isolated scFvs that recognised EA1 from B. anthracis, but also cross-reacted with other Bacillus species. In contrast, the competitive panning approach used S-layer proteins from other Bacillus species to generate scFvs that were highly specific to B. anthracis EA1 and demonstrated apparent nanomolar binding affinities. Specific, real time detection of B. anthracis spores was demonstrated with these scFvs using an evanescent wave biosensor, the Resonant Mirror. The approach described can be used to generate specific antibodies to any desired target where homologous proteins also exist in closely related species, and demonstrates clear advantages to using recombinant technology to produce biological recognition elements for detection of biological threat agents.

Chemical and biological threat-agent detection using electrophoresis-based lab-on-a-chip devices

The ability to separate complex mixtures of analytes has made capillary electrophoresis (CE) a powerful analytical tool since its modern configuration was first introduced over 25 years ago. The technique found new utility with its application to the microfluidics based lab-on-a-chip platform (i.e., microchip), which resulted in ever smaller footprints, sample volumes, and analysis times. These features, coupled with the technique's potential for portability, have prompted recent interest in the development of novel analyzers for chemical and biological threat agents. This article will comment on three main areas of microchip CE as applied to the separation and detection of threat agents: detection techniques and their corresponding limits of detection, sampling protocol and preparation time, and system portability. These three areas typify the broad utility of lab-on-a-chip for meeting critical, present-day security, in addition to illustrating areas wherein advances are necessary.

Detection of Biological Threat Agents by Real-Time PCR: Comparison of Assay Performance on the R.A.P.I.D., the LightCycler, and the Smart Cycler Platforms

Rapid detection of biological threat agents is critical for timely therapeutic administration. Fluorogenic PCR provides a rapid, sensitive, and specific tool for molecular identification of these agents. We compared the performance of assays for 7 biological threat agents on the Idaho Technology, Inc. R.A.P.I.D., the Roche LightCycler, and the Cepheid Smart Cycler. Real-time PCR primers and dual-labeled fluorogenic probes were designed to detect Bacillus anthracis, Brucella species, Clostridium botulinum, Coxiella burnetii, Francisella tularensis, Staphylococcus aureus, and Yersinia pestis. DNA amplification assays were optimized by use of Idaho Technology buffers and deoxynucleotide triphosphates supplemented with Invitrogen Platinum Taq DNA polymerase, and were subsequently tested for sensitivity and specificity on the R.A.P.I.D., the LightCycler, and the Smart Cycler. Limit of detection experiments indicated that assay performance was comparable among the platforms tested. Exclusivity and inclusivity testing with a general bacterial nucleic acid cross-reactivity panel containing 60 DNAs and agent-specific panels containing nearest neighbors for the organisms of interest indicated that all assays were specific for their intended targets. With minor supplementation, such as the addition of Smart Cycler Additive Reagent to the Idaho Technology buffers, assays for DNA templates from biological threat agents demonstrated similar performance, sensitivity, and specificity on all 3 platforms.

A review of molecular recognition technologies for detection of biological threat agents

The present review summarizes the state of the art in molecular recognition of biowarfare agents and other pathogens and emphasizes the advantages of using particular types of reagents for a given target, (e.g. detection of bacteria using antibodies versus nucleic acid probes). It is difficult to draw firm conclusions as to type of biorecognition molecule to use for a given analyte. However, the detection method and reagents are generally target-driven and the user must decide on what level (genetic versus phenotypic) the detection should be performed. In general, nucleic acid-based detection is more specific and sensitive than immunological-based detection, while the latter is faster and more robust. This review also points out the challenges faced by military and civilian defense components in the rapid and accurate detection and identification of harmful agents in the field. Although new and improved sensors will continue to be developed, the more crucial need in any biosensor may be the molecular recognition component (e.g. antibody, aptamer, enzyme, nucleic acid, receptor, etc.). Improvement in the affinity, specificity and mass production of the molecular recognition components may ultimately dictate the success or failure of detection technologies in both a technical and commercial sense. Achieving the ultimate goal of giving the individual soldier on the battlefield or civilian responders to an urban biological attack or epidemic, a miniature, sensitive and accurate biosensor may depend as much on molecular biology and molecular engineering as on hardware engineering. Fortunately, as this review illustrates, a great deal of scientific attention has and is currently being given to the area of molecular recognition components. Highly sensitive and specific detection of pathogenic bacteria and viruses has increased with the proliferation of nucleic acid and immuno-based detection technologies. If recent scientific progress is a fair indicator, the future promises remarkable new developments in molecular recognition elements for use in biosensors with a vast array of applications.

Detection of biological threat agents by immunomagnetic microsphere-based solid phase fluorogenic- and electro-chemiluminescence

This article reviews the recent development of two solid-phase chemiluminescence-based techniques, fluorogenic-chemiluminescence (FCL) and electro-chemiluminescence (ECL) for detection of biological threat agents. Both techniques entail a labeled sandwich immunoassay. The objectives of this work are to develop advanced techniques for sensitive and effective detection of a target analyte, particularly in cases where the analysis includes complex samples containing multiple contaminating factors. Other important considerations in developing such detection techniques include the ease of use, the rapid determination of the results, and system automation for field applications. In FCL, alkaline phosphatase is used as a label and this technique utilizes the dual features of fluorescence and visual color generated upon the presence of the fluorogenic compound, AttoPhos ™. The assay reaction is determined by measuring the fluorescence. In ECL, the label is a ruthenium-trisbipyridal, which is excited to a higher energy state by an electric current-driven redox reaction, and the extent of the reaction is assessed via photon emission. Both techniques depend upon the magnetic separation technique as a means to isolate the target immunological agents from the sample for analysis. This magnetic capture system allows for a reaction to occur on the electron effective-transfer zone in the ECL and also provides the reaction site for the labeled sandwich in the FCL. Comparative studies of these two techniques for detection of biological threat agents have been performed and the advantages of using magnetic microspheres versus conventional solid-phase matrices are discussed.