Detection Of Chromatin Interactions Research Articles

Leveraging multimodal chromatin profiling to identify a new potential driver of diabetic kidney disease

The 3-dimensional nature of chromatin architecture plays crucial roles in regulating gene expression in development, homeostasis, and disease. Until recently, however, comprehensive chromatin profiling in human kidneys has been lacking. In this issue, Eun and Kim etal. employed a multimodal approach by integrating a single-nucleus assay for transposase-accessible chromatin sequencing, chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing, and Hi-C (a method to comprehensively detect chromatin interactions) to investigate how the epigenetic landscape is altered in diabetic kidney disease.

Revisiting Assessment of Computational Methods for Hi-C Data Analysis.

The performances of algorithms for Hi-C data preprocessing, the identification of topologically associating domains, and the detection of chromatin interactions and promoter-enhancer interactions have been mostly evaluated using semi-quantitative or synthetic data approaches, without utilizing the most recent methods, since 2017. In this study, we comprehensively evaluated 24 popular state-of-the-art methods for the complete end-to-end pipeline of Hi-C data analysis, using manually curated or experimentally validated benchmark datasets, including a CRISPR dataset for promoter-enhancer interaction validation. Our results indicate that, although no single method exhibited superior performance in all situations, HiC-Pro, DomainCaller, and Fit-Hi-C2 showed relatively balanced performances of most evaluation metrics for preprocessing, topologically associating domain identification, and chromatin interaction/promoter-enhancer interaction detection, respectively. The comprehensive comparison presented in this manuscript provides a reference for researchers to choose Hi-C analysis tools that best suit their needs.

Improving comparative analyses of Hi-C data via contrastive self-supervised learning.

Hi-C is a widely applied chromosome conformation capture (3C)-based technique, which has produced a large number of genomic contact maps with high sequencing depths for a wide range of cell types, enabling comprehensive analyses of the relationships between biological functionalities (e.g. gene regulation and expression) and the three-dimensional genome structure. Comparative analyses play significant roles in Hi-C data studies, which are designed to make comparisons between Hi-C contact maps, thus evaluating the consistency of replicate Hi-C experiments (i.e. reproducibility measurement) and detecting statistically differential interacting regions with biological significance (i.e. differential chromatin interaction detection). However, due to the complex and hierarchical nature of Hi-C contact maps, it remains challenging to conduct systematic and reliable comparative analyses of Hi-C data. Here, we proposed sslHiC, a contrastive self-supervised representation learning framework, for precisely modeling the multi-level features of chromosome conformation and automatically producing informative feature embeddings for genomic loci and their interactions to facilitate comparative analyses of Hi-C contact maps. Comprehensive computational experiments on both simulated and real datasets demonstrated that our method consistently outperformed the state-of-the-art baseline methods in providing reliable measurements of reproducibility and detecting differential interactions with biological meanings.

Characterizing chromatin interactions of regulatory elements and nucleosome positions, using Hi-C, Micro-C, and promoter capture Micro-C

BackgroundRegulatory elements such as promoters, enhancers, and insulators interact each other to mediate molecular processes. To capture chromatin interactions of regulatory elements, 3C-derived methods such as Hi-C and Micro-C are developed. Here, we generated and analyzed Hi-C, Micro-C, and promoter capture Micro-C datasets with different sequencing depths to study chromatin interactions of regulatory elements and nucleosome positions in human prostate cancer cells.ResultsCompared to Hi-C, Micro-C identifies more high-resolution loops, including ones around structural variants. By evaluating the effect of sequencing depth, we revealed that more than 2 billion reads of Micro-C are needed to detect chromatin interactions at 1 kb resolution. Moreover, we found that deep-sequencing identifies additional long-range loops that are longer than 1 Mb in distance. Furthermore, we found that more than 50% of the loops are involved in insulators while less than 10% of the loops are promoter–enhancer loops. To comprehensively capture chromatin interactions that promoters are involved in, we performed promoter capture Micro-C. Promoter capture Micro-C identifies loops near promoters with a lower amount of sequencing reads. Sequencing of 160 million reads of promoter capture Micro-C resulted in reaching a plateau of identifying loops. However, there was still a subset of promoters that are not involved in loops even after deep-sequencing. By integrating Micro-C with NOMe-seq and ChIP-seq, we found that active promoters involved in loops have a more accessible region with lower levels of DNA methylation and more highly phased nucleosomes, compared to active promoters that are not involved in loops.ConclusionWe determined the required sequencing depth for Micro-C and promoter capture Micro-C to generate high-resolution chromatin interaction maps and loops. We also investigated the effect of sequencing coverage of Hi-C, Micro-C, and promoter capture Micro-C on detecting chromatin loops. Our analyses suggest the presence of distinct regulatory element groups, which are differently involved in nucleosome positions and chromatin interactions. This study does not only provide valuable insights on understanding chromatin interactions of regulatory elements, but also present guidelines for designing research projects on chromatin interactions among regulatory elements.

DeepPHiC: predicting promoter-centered chromatin interactions using a novel deep learning approach.

Promoter-centered chromatin interactions, which include promoter-enhancer (PE) and promoter-promoter (PP) interactions, are important to decipher gene regulation and disease mechanisms. The development of next-generation sequencing technologies such as promoter capture Hi-C (pcHi-C) leads to the discovery of promoter-centered chromatin interactions. However, pcHi-C experiments are expensive and thus may be unavailable for tissues/cell types of interest. In addition, these experiments may be underpowered due to insufficient sequencing depth or various artifacts, which results in a limited finding of interactions. Most existing computational methods for predicting chromatin interactions are based on in situ Hi-C and can detect chromatin interactions across the entire genome. However, they may not be optimal for predicting promoter-centered chromatin interactions. We develop a supervised multi-modal deep learning model, which utilizes a comprehensive set of features such as genomic sequence, epigenetic signal, anchor distance, evolutionary features and DNA structural features to predict tissue/cell type-specific PE and PP interactions. We further extend the deep learning model in a multi-task learning and a transfer learning framework and demonstrate that the proposed approach outperforms state-of-the-art deep learning methods. Moreover, the proposed approach can achieve comparable prediction performance using predefined biologically relevant tissues/cell types compared to using all tissues/cell types in the pretraining especially for predicting PE interactions. The prediction performance can be further improved by using computationally inferred biologically relevant tissues/cell types in the pretraining, which are defined based on the common genes in the proximity of two anchors in the chromatin interactions. https://github.com/lichen-lab/DeepPHiC. Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

Open chromatin interaction maps reveal functional regulatory elements and chromatin architecture variations during wheat evolution

BackgroundBread wheat (Triticum aestivum) is an allohexaploid that is generated by two subsequent allopolyploidization events. The large genome size (16 Gb) and polyploid complexity impede our understanding of how regulatory elements and their interactions shape chromatin structure and gene expression in wheat. The open chromatin enrichment and network Hi-C (OCEAN-C) is a powerful antibody-independent method to detect chromatin interactions between open chromatin regions throughout the genome.ResultsHere we generate open chromatin interaction maps for hexaploid wheat and its tetraploid and diploid relatives using OCEAN-C. The anchors of chromatin loops show high chromatin accessibility and are concomitant with several active histone modifications, with 67% of them interacting with multiple loci. Binding motifs of various transcription factors are significantly enriched in the hubs of open chromatin interactions (HOCIs). The genes linked by HOCIs represent higher expression level and lower coefficient expression variance than the genes linked by other loops, which suggests HOCIs may coordinate co-expression of linked genes. Thousands of interchromosomal loops are identified, while limited interchromosomal loops (0.4%) are identified between homoeologous genes in hexaploid wheat. Moreover, we find structure variations contribute to chromatin interaction divergence of homoeologs and chromatin topology changes between different wheat species. The genes with discrepant chromatin interactions show expression alteration in hexaploid wheat compared with its tetraploid and diploid relatives.ConclusionsOur results reveal open chromatin interactions in different wheat species, which provide new insights into the role of open chromatin interactions in gene expression during the evolution of polyploid wheat.

HiC-ACT: improved detection of chromatin interactions from Hi-C data via aggregated Cauchy test

Genome-wide chromatin conformation capture technologies such as Hi-C are commonly employed to study chromatin spatial organization. In particular, to identify statistically significant long-range chromatin interactions from Hi-C data, most existing methods such as Fit-Hi-C/FitHiC2 and HiCCUPS assume that all chromatin interactions are statistically independent. Such an independence assumption is reasonable at low resolution (e.g., 40 kb bin) but is invalid at high resolution (e.g., 5 or 10 kb bins) because spatial dependency of neighboring chromatin interactions is non-negligible at high resolution. Our previous hidden Markov random field-based methods accommodate spatial dependency but are computationally intensive. It is urgent to develop approaches that can model spatial dependence in a computationally efficient and scalable manner. Here, we develop HiC-ACT, an aggregated Cauchy test (ACT)-based approach, to improve the detection of chromatin interactions by post-processing results from methods assuming independence. To benchmark the performance of HiC-ACT, we re-analyzed deeply sequenced Hi-C data from a human lymphoblastoid cell line, GM12878, and mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs). Our results demonstrate advantages of HiC-ACT in improving sensitivity with controlled type I error. By leveraging information from neighboring chromatin interactions, HiC-ACT enhances the power to detect interactions with lower signal-to-noise ratio and similar (if not stronger) epigenetic signatures that suggest regulatory roles. We further demonstrate that HiC-ACT peaks show higher overlap with known enhancers than Fit-Hi-C/FitHiC2 peaks in both GM12878 and mESCs. HiC-ACT, effectively a summary statistics-based approach, is computationally efficient (∼6min and ∼2 GB memory to process 25,000 pairwise interactions).

HiC-ACT: improved detection of chromatin interactions from Hi-C data via aggregated Cauchy test

HiC-ACT: improved detection of chromatin interactions from Hi-C data via aggregated Cauchy test

FreeHi-C spike-in simulations for benchmarking differential chromatin interaction detection.

High-throughput genome-wide chromatin conformation capture assay (Hi-C) is routinely used to profile long-range genomic interactions and three-dimensional organization of genomes. A key application of Hi-C is the comparative analysis of genomic interactions across different time points, cellular conditions, or multiple stimuli. While operating characteristics of methods for Hi-C data processing such as normalization, pairwise interaction and higher-order organization detection have been relatively well studied, properties of methods for differential chromatin interaction detection are less investigated. We have recently developed FreeHi-C to enable data-driven non-parametric simulations from Hi-C experiments. Here, we extend FreeHi-C with a user/data-driven spike-in module to facilitate comparisons of differential chromatin interaction detection methods where the ground truth differential chromatin interactions are known under a wide variety of settings. We use FreeHi-C to benchmark four differential chromatin interaction detection methods, namely HiCcompare, multiHiCcompare, diffHic, and Selfish, using three comparative analysis settings with different sequencing depths and spike-in proportions. This comparison reveals distinguished performances in terms of the standard metrics such as the false discovery rate control, detection power, significance order, precision-recall curve, and receiver operating characteristic curve as well as overall genomic properties of the types of differential chromatin interactions detectable by each method. Furthermore, it highlights the lack of power for all methods in small replication settings.

FreeHi-C simulates high-fidelity Hi-C data for benchmarking and data augmentation.

Ability to simulate high-throughput chromatin conformation (Hi-C) data is foundational for benchmarking Hi-C data analysis methods. Here we present a non-parametric strategy named FreeHi-C to simulate Hi-C data from the interacting genome fragments. Data from FreeHi-C exhibit high fidelity to biological Hi-C data. FreeHi-C boosts the precision and power of differential chromatin interaction detection through data augmentation under preserved false discovery rate control.

7C:\xa0Computational Chromosome Conformation Capture by Correlation of ChIP-seq at CTCF motifs

BackgroundKnowledge of the three-dimensional structure of the genome is necessary to understand how gene expression is regulated. Recent experimental techniques such as Hi-C or ChIA-PET measure long-range chromatin interactions genome-wide but are experimentally elaborate, have limited resolution and such data is only available for a limited number of cell types and tissues.ResultsWhile ChIP-seq was not designed to detect chromatin interactions, the formaldehyde treatment in the ChIP-seq protocol cross-links proteins with each other and with DNA. Consequently, also regions that are not directly bound by the targeted TF but interact with the binding site via chromatin looping are co-immunoprecipitated and sequenced. This produces minor ChIP-seq signals at loop anchor regions close to the directly bound site. We use the position and shape of ChIP-seq signals around CTCF motif pairs to predict whether they interact or not. We implemented this approach in a prediction method, termed Computational Chromosome Conformation Capture by Correlation of ChIP-seq at CTCF motifs (7C). We applied 7C to all CTCF motif pairs within 1 Mb in the human genome and validated predicted interactions with high-resolution Hi-C and ChIA-PET. A single ChIP-seq experiment from known architectural proteins (CTCF, Rad21, Znf143) but also from other TFs (like TRIM22 or RUNX3) predicts loops accurately. Importantly, 7C predicts loops in cell types and for TF ChIP-seq datasets not used in training.Conclusion7C predicts chromatin loops which can help to associate TF binding sites to regulated genes. Furthermore, profiling of hundreds of ChIP-seq datasets results in novel candidate factors functionally involved in chromatin looping. Our method is available as an R/Bioconductor package: http://bioconductor.org/packages/sevenC.

High resolution discovery of chromatin interactions.

Chromatin interaction analysis by paired-end tag sequencing (ChIA-PET) is a method for the genome-wide de novo discovery of chromatin interactions. Existing computational methods typically fail to detect weak or dynamic interactions because they use a peak-calling step that ignores paired-end linkage information. We have developed a novel computational method called Chromatin Interaction Discovery (CID) to overcome this limitation with an unbiased clustering approach for interaction discovery. CID outperforms existing chromatin interaction detection methods with improved sensitivity, replicate consistency, and concordance with other chromatin interaction datasets. In addition, CID also outperforms other methods in discovering chromatin interactions from HiChIP data. We expect that the CID method will be valuable in characterizing 3D chromatin interactions and in understanding the functional consequences of disease-associated distal genetic variations.

ChIAPoP: a new tool for ChIA-PET data analysis

Chromatin Interaction Analysis by Paired-End Tag Sequencing (ChIA-PET) is a popular assay method for studying genome-wide chromatin interactions mediated by a protein of interest. The main goal of ChIA-PET data analysis is to detect interactions between DNA regions. Here, we propose a new method and the associated data analysis pipeline, ChIAPoP, to detect chromatin interactions from ChIA-PET data. We compared ChIAPoP with other popular methods, including a hypergeometric model (used in ChIA-PET tool), MICC (used in ChIA-PET2), ChiaSig and mango. The results showed that ChIA-PoP performed better than or at least as well as these top existing methods in detecting true chromatin interactions. ChIAPoP is freely available to the public at https://github.com/wh90999/ChIAPoP.

Local chromatin interactions contribute to expression of the fibrinogen gene cluster

Background The coordinately regulated genes encoding human fibrinogen are clustered. This evolutionarily conserved configuration provides a possible mechanism for co-regulation whereby regulatory elements influence gene expression locally. The cluster is flanked by CCCTC-binding factor (CTCF) interaction sites that are candidate insulator regions mediating chromatin looping. Objectives To further our understanding of fibrinogen gene regulation, we aimed to investigate whether interactions exist between parts of the fibrinogen locus and how these contacts contribute to fibrinogen expression. Methods We used chromosome conformation capture in cultured cell lines to detect chromatin interactions at the fibrinogen gene cluster. We generated clonal cell lines where two CTCF interaction sites at one end of the locus were deleted using CRISPR-Cas9-mediated genome editing. Fibrinogen expression and protein production were measured using qRT-PCR and ELISA, respectively. Results We detected proximity between the ends of the fibrinogen locus, regardless of whether cells express fibrinogen. An interaction between the FGA promoter and the edge of the locus was more frequent in fibrinogen-expressing cells. Deletion of a CTCF site at one edge of the cluster altered chromatin interactions, reduced steady-state expression of FGB and FGG mRNA, and led to a halving of secreted fibrinogen. These phenotypes were completely restored by reintroduction of the CTCF interaction motif in previously motif-deleted clones. Conclusions Chromatin interactions are important for the coordinated regulation of the human fibrinogen genes. This finding furthers our comprehension of how fibrinogen is produced and identifies a possible source of variability in plasma fibrinogen levels seen in populations.

Capture Hi-C Library Generation and Analysis to Detect Chromatin Interactions.

Chromosome conformation capture (3C), coupled with next-generation sequencing (Hi-C), provides a means for deciphering not only the principles underlying genome folding and architecture, but more broadly, the role 3D chromatin structure plays in gene regulation and the replication and repair of DNA. The recently implemented modification, in situ Hi-C, maintains nuclear integrity during digestion and ligation steps, reducing random ligation of Hi-C fragments. Although Hi-C allows for genome-wide characterization of chromatin contacts, it requires high-depth sequencing to discover significant contacts. To address this, Capture Hi-C (CHi-C) enriches standard Hi-C libraries for regions of biological interest, for example by specifically targeting gene promoters, aiding identification of biologically significant chromatin interactions compared to conventional Hi-C, for an equivalent number of sequence reads. Illustrating the application of CHi-C applied to genome-wide analysis of chromatin interactions with promoters, we detail the protocols for in situ Hi-C and CHi-C library generation for sequencing, as well as the bioinformatics tools for data analysis. © 2018 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

A cautionary note on the use of chromosome conformation capture in plants

Background The chromosome conformation capture (3C) technique is a method to study chromatin interactions at specific genomic loci. Initially established for yeast the 3C technique has been adapted to plants in recent years in order to study chromatin interactions and their role in transcriptional gene regulation. As the plant scientific community continues to implement this technology, a discussion on critical controls, validations steps and interpretation of 3C data is essential to fully benefit from 3C in plants.ResultsHere we assess the reliability and robustness of the 3C technique for the detection of chromatin interactions in Arabidopsis. As a case study, we applied this methodology to the genomic locus of a floral integrator gene SUPPRESSOR OF OVEREXPRESSION OF CONSTANS1 (SOC1), and demonstrate the need of several controls and standard validation steps to allow a meaningful interpretation of 3C data. The intricacies of this promising but challenging technique are discussed in depth.ConclusionsThe 3C technique offers an interesting opportunity to study chromatin interactions at a resolution infeasible by microscopy. However, for interpretation of 3C interaction data and identification of true interactions, 3C technology demands a stringent experimental setup and extreme caution.

Long-read ChIA-PET for base-pair-resolution mapping of haplotype-specific chromatin interactions.

Chromatin interaction analysis by paired-end tag sequencing (ChIA-PET) is a robust method for capturing genome-wide chromatin interactions. Unlike other 3C-based methods, it includes a chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) step that enriches for interactions mediated by specific target proteins. This unique feature allows ChIA-PET to provide the functional specificity and higher resolution needed to detect chromatin interactions, which chromosome conformation capture (3C)/Hi-C approaches have not achieved. The original ChIA-PET protocol generates short paired-end tags (2 × 20 base pairs (bp)) to detect two genomic loci that are far apart on linear chromosomes but are in spatial proximity in the folded genome. We have improved the original approach by developing long-read ChIA-PET, in which the length of the paired-end tags is increased (up to 2 × 250 bp). The longer PET reads not only improve the tag-mapping efficiency but also increase the probability of covering phased single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), which allows haplotype-specific chromatin interactions to be identified. Here, we provide the detailed protocol for long-read ChIA-PET that includes cell fixation and lysis, chromatin fragmentation by sonication, ChIP, proximity ligation with a bridge linker, Tn5 tagmentation, PCR amplification and high-throughput sequencing. For a well-trained molecular biologist, it typically takes 6 d from cell harvesting to the completion of library construction, up to a further 36 h for DNA sequencing and <20 h for processing of raw sequencing reads.

Capture Hi-C identifies a novel causal gene, IL20RA, in the pan-autoimmune genetic susceptibility region 6q23.

BackgroundThe identification of causal genes from genome-wide association studies (GWAS) is the next important step for the translation of genetic findings into biologically meaningful mechanisms of disease and potential therapeutic targets. Using novel chromatin interaction detection techniques and allele specific assays in T and B cell lines, we provide compelling evidence that redefines causal genes at the 6q23 locus, one of the most important loci that confers autoimmunity risk.ResultsAlthough the function of disease-associated non-coding single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) at 6q23 is unknown, the association is generally assigned to TNFAIP3, the closest gene. However, the DNA fragment containing the associated SNPs interacts through chromatin looping not only with TNFAIP3, but also with IL20RA, located 680 kb upstream. The risk allele of the most likely causal SNP, rs6927172, is correlated with both a higher frequency of interactions and increased expression of IL20RA, along with a stronger binding of both the NFκB transcription factor and chromatin marks characteristic of active enhancers in T-cells.ConclusionsOur results highlight the importance of gene assignment for translating GWAS findings into biologically meaningful mechanisms of disease and potential therapeutic targets; indeed, monoclonal antibody therapy targeting IL-20 is effective in the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis and psoriasis, both with strong GWAS associations to this region.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s13059-016-1078-x) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

In the loop: promoter-enhancer interactions and bioinformatics.

Enhancer–promoter regulation is a fundamental mechanism underlying differential transcriptional regulation. Spatial chromatin organization brings remote enhancers in contact with target promoters in cis to regulate gene expression. There is considerable evidence for promoter–enhancer interactions (PEIs). In the recent years, genome-wide analyses have identified signatures and mapped novel enhancers; however, being able to precisely identify their target gene(s) requires massive biological and bioinformatics efforts. In this review, we give a short overview of the chromatin landscape and transcriptional regulation. We discuss some key concepts and problems related to chromatin interaction detection technologies, and emerging knowledge from genome-wide chromatin interaction data sets. Then, we critically review different types of bioinformatics analysis methods and tools related to representation and visualization of PEI data, raw data processing and PEI prediction. Lastly, we provide specific examples of how PEIs have been used to elucidate a functional role of non-coding single-nucleotide polymorphisms. The topic is at the forefront of epigenetic research, and by highlighting some future bioinformatics challenges in the field, this review provides a comprehensive background for future PEI studies.

Single-cell Hi-C for genome-wide detection of chromatin interactions that occur simultaneously in a single cell.

Hi-C is a powerful method that provides pairwise information on genomic regions in spatial proximity in the nucleus. Hi-C requires millions of cells as input and, as genome organization varies from cell to cell, a limitation of Hi-C is that it only provides a population average of genome conformations. We developed single-cell Hi-C to create snapshots of thousands of chromatin interactions that occur simultaneously in a single cell. To adapt Hi-C to single-cell analysis, we modified the protocol to include in-nucleus ligation. This enables the isolation of single nuclei carrying Hi-C-ligated DNA into separate tubes, followed by reversal of cross-links, capture of biotinylated ligation junctions on streptavidin-coated magnetic beads and PCR amplification of single-cell Hi-C libraries. The entire laboratory protocol can be carried out in 1 week, and although we have demonstrated its use in mouse T helper (TH1) cells, it should be applicable to any cell type or species for which standard Hi-C has been successful. We also developed an analysis pipeline to filter noise and assess the quality of data sets in a few hours. Although the interactome maps produced by single-cell Hi-C are sparse, the data provide useful information to understand cellular variability in nuclear genome organization and chromosome structure. Standard wet and dry laboratory skills in molecular biology and computational analysis are required.