Following a summary of the relevant literature on nucleation and applicable nucleation and growth models and mechanisms, the kinetics and molecular mechanism of nucleation are investigated in detail starting from [(1,5-COD)IrI(NCCH3)2][BF4], 1, which upon addition of HPO42– to 1 forms a neutral, phosphate-bridged species, {[(1,5-COD)IrI(NCCH3)]2·HPO4}0, 2, en route to {[(1,5-COD)IrI·HPO4]2[Bu4N]2}, 3. Post a list of the seven advantages of the {[(1,5-COD)IrI·HPO4]2}2– precatalyst as a novel bimetallic precursor for kinetic and mechanistic studies of nucleation, six important, previously unanswered questions are raised about the ill-understood but exceedingly broad and important topic of nucleation. 1H NMR solution speciation and Signer apparatus solution molecular weight studies establish that in situ prepared {[(1,5-COD)IrI·HPO4]2}2–, 3, exists predominantly in its indicated, dimeric form. The NMR studies also identify {[(1,5-COD)IrI(NCCH3)]2·HPO4}0, 2, as an important, metastable species with one less HPO42–, formed in a dissociative equilibrium of 3 to 2 plus HPO42–. Kinetic studies reveal a first-order dependence of nucleation on the concentration of 3 and hence rule out the higher-order dependence implied by classical nucleation theory. Additional kinetic studies reveal a telling, inverse, quadratic dependence on added HPO42–, results that unveil the previously unavailable insights that a simple bimetallic, Ir2 precursor is sufficient to enable low-molecularity nucleation via {[(1,5-COD)IrI(NCCH3)]2·HPO4}0, 2, as a kinetically competent intermediate, a unique example of a nucleation mechanism known in molecular detail from a precisely defined molecular precursor that also includes spectroscopic detection of a kinetically competent intermediate. The results with {[(1,5-COD)IrI·HPO4]2}2– in comparison to previous results with {[(1,5-COD)IrI·POM]}8– (POM = the polyoxometalate P2W15Nb3O629–) allow insights into the details of nucleation, notably that Ir2 versus Ir3 kinetically effective nuclei are controlled by the different HPO42– and POM8– anion’s surface charge and resultant 2 versus 3 IrI(1,5-COD)+ moieties they are able to bind to achieve surface-charge neutrality. The state-of-the-art nucleation results allow a total of nine insights, conclusions, and two new working hypotheses, insights that promise to help drive a deeper understanding of nucleation, not just in transition-metal nanoparticle formation but hopefully more broadly across nature.
Read full abstract