Prelude to Israel's Past: Background and Beginnings of Israelite History and Identity, by Niels P. Lemche. Peabody, MA: Hendrickson Publishers, 1998. 245 pp. $19.95. This book is a slightly revised translation of Lemche's 1996 work, Die Vorgeschichte Israels: Von den Anfangen bis zum Ausgang des 13. Jahrhunderts v. Chr. (Biblische Enzyklopaedie, 1: Stuttgart: Kohlhammer). The English version adheres to the intentions of the original German volume, which was meant for students and a general audience. Thus the degree of documentation via footnotes is relatively limited, in order to make the text more readable. In addition, the usefulness of the book as a reference tool is enhanced by the bibliographies which appear at the outset of each of its subsections. These structural considerations, combined with the stimulating views presented in the book, make it easy to recommend. The book is divided into four parts. Part I (pp. 1-65) reviews the biblical accounts, found in Genesis through Numbers, concerning the patriarchs, the exodus from Egypt, and the sojourn in the wilderness of Sinai. Lemche argues that these biblical stories are literary compositions and not historical sources. As works of art, the accounts may not be used to reconstruct ancient Near Eastern history. To make this case, Lemche mentions anachronisms and other disjunctures between the biblical narratives and the actual Near Eastern milieu. In sum, the Pentateuchal narratives cannot pretend to be historical documents pertaining to Israel's past; rather, they represent literary imaginings which Lemche compares to modern films. The makers of such films may pay close attention to proper clothing and speech patterns, but nevertheless they cater to contemporary sensibilities. Thus Lemche maintains that reasonable historian studies . . . Errol Flynn's portrayal of Robin Hood to reconstruct medieval English history (p. 65). In a similar vein, no one should view the Pentateuch as a reliable historical source. Part II (pp. 66-148) offers a historical reconstruction of Syria and Palestine from the early Bronze Age to the Habiru and the Sea Peoples of the twelfth century B.C.E., the supposed time period for much of the Pentateuchal narratives. Among other topics, Lemche discusses: (1) several literary texts from Syria, Palestine, Mesopotamia, and Egypt; (2) pertinent archaeological evidence; (3) the geography and ecology of the Near East; and (4) the lifestyle and economy of the Near Eastern social system. …
Read full abstract