DEER Spectroscopy Research Articles

Conformational cycle of a protease-containing ABC transporter in lipid nanodiscs reveals the mechanism of cargo-protein coupling

Protease-containing ABC transporters (PCATs) couple the energy of ATP hydrolysis to the processing and export of diverse cargo proteins across cell membranes to mediate antimicrobial resistance and quorum sensing. Here, we combine biochemical analysis, single particle cryoEM, and DEER spectroscopy in lipid bilayers along with computational analysis to illuminate the structural and energetic underpinnings of coupled cargo protein export. Our integrated investigation uncovers competitive interplay between nucleotides and cargo protein binding that ensures the latter’s orderly processing and subsequent transport. The energetics of cryoEM structures in lipid bilayers are congruent with the inferred mechanism from ATP turnover analysis and reveal a snapshot of a high-energy outward-facing conformation that provides an exit pathway into the lipid bilayer and/or the extracellular side. DEER investigation of the core ABC transporter suggests evolutionary tuning of the energetic landscape to fulfill the function of substrate processing prior to export.

Thermodynamic Details of Pinholin S2168 Activation Revealed Using Alchemical Free Energy Simulations.

Pinholin S2168 is a viral integral membrane protein whose function is to form nanoscopic "pinholes" in bacterial cell membranes to induce cell lysis as part of the viral replication cycle. Pinholin can transition from an inactive to an active conformation by exposing a transmembrane domain (TMD1) to the extracellular fluid. Upon activation, several copies of the protein assemble via interactions among a second transmembrane domain (TMD2) to form a single pore, thus hastening cell lysis and viral escape. The following experiments provide conformational descriptors of pinholin in active and inactive states and elucidate the molecular driving forces that control pinholin activity. In the present study, molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have been used to refine experimentally derived conformational descriptors into an atomistically detailed model of irsS2168, an antiholin mutant. To provide additional details about the thermodynamics of pinholin activation and to overcome large intrinsic kinetic barriers to activation, alchemical free energy simulations have been conducted. Alchemical mutations reveal the change in folding free energy upon mutation. The results suggest that alchemical mutations are an effective tool to rationalize experimental observations and predict the effects of site mutations on conformational states for proteins integrated into lipid bilayers. S16F, A17Q, A17Q+G21Q, and A17Q+G21Q+G14Q mutants reveal how changes in hydrophilicity and disruption of the glycine zipper motif influence pinholin's thermodynamic equilibrium, favoring the active conformation. These findings align with experimental observations from DEER spectroscopy, demonstrating that mutations increasing the hydrophilicity of TMD1 promote activation by making TMD1 more likely to exit the membrane and enter the extracellular fluid.

Quantitative analysis of sterol-modulated monomer-dimer equilibrium of β1-adrenergic receptor by DEER spectroscopy

Quantitative analysis of sterol-modulated monomer-dimer equilibrium of β1-adrenergic receptor by DEER spectroscopy

DEER Spectroscopy of Channelrhodopsin-2 Helix B Movements in Trapped Photocycle Intermediates

The light-gated dimeric cation channel channelrhodopsin-2 (ChR2) has been established as one of the most important optogenetic tools. During its functional cycle, ChR2 undergoes conformational changes, the most prominent ones include a movement of transmembrane helix B. In the present work, we assign this movement to a trapped photocycle intermediate using DEER spectroscopy combined with sample illumination inside the microwave resonator, allowing trapping and relaxation of defined ChR2 intermediates at different temperatures between 180 and 278 K. Intradimer distances measured between spin-labeled positions 79 located in helix B of ChR2 in the dark state and upon light activation and relaxation at 180 K were similar. In contrast, light activation at 180 K and 30 min relaxation at between 230 and 255 K results in significant changes of the distance distribution. We show that the light-induced movement of helix B is correlated with the presence of the P480 state of ChR2. We hypothesize that conformational changes occurring in this area are key elements responsible for desensitizing the channel for cation conduction.

Conserved binding site in the N-lobe of prokaryotic MATE transporters suggests a role for Na+ in ion-coupled drug efflux.

In both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, multidrug and toxic-compound extrusion (MATE) transporters catalyze the efflux of a broad range of cytotoxic compounds, including human-made antibiotics and anticancer drugs. MATEs are secondary-active antiporters, i.e. their drug-efflux activity is coupled to, and powered by, the uptake of ions down a pre-existing transmembrane electrochemical gradient. Key aspects of this mechanism, however, remain to be delineated, such as its ion specificity and stoichiometry. We previously revealed the existence of a Na+-binding site in a MATE transporter from Pyroccocus furiosus (PfMATE) and hypothesized that this site might be broadly conserved among prokaryotic MATEs. Here, we evaluate this hypothesis by analyzing VcmN and ClbM, which along with PfMATE are the only three prokaryotic MATEs whose molecular structures have been determined at resolutions better than 3 Å. Analysis of available crystallographic data and molecular dynamics simulations indeed reveal an occupied Na+-binding site in the N-terminal lobe of both structures, analogous to that identified in PfMATE. We likewise find this site to be strongly selective against K+, suggesting it is mechanistically significant. Consistent with these computational results, DEER spectroscopy measurements for multiple doubly-spin-labeled VcmN constructs demonstrate Na+-dependent changes in protein conformation. The existence of this binding site in three MATE orthologs implicates Na+ in the ion-coupled drug-efflux mechanisms of this class of transporters. These results also imply that observations of H+-dependent activity stem either from a site elsewhere in the structure, or from H+ displacing Na+ under certain laboratory conditions, as has been noted for other Na+-driven transport systems.

Conserved binding site in the N-lobe of prokaryotic MATE transporters suggests a role for Na+ in ion-coupled drug efflux

In both prokaryotes and eukaryotes, multidrug and toxic-compound extrusion (MATE) transporters catalyze the efflux of a broad range of cytotoxic compounds, including human-made antibiotics and anticancer drugs. MATEs are secondary-active antiporters, i.e., their drug-efflux activity is coupled to, and powered by, the uptake of ions down a preexisting transmembrane electrochemical gradient. Key aspects of this mechanism, however, remain to be delineated, such as its ion specificity and stoichiometry. We previously revealed the existence of a Na+-binding site in a MATE transporter from Pyroccocus furiosus (PfMATE) and hypothesized that this site might be broadly conserved among prokaryotic MATEs. Here, we evaluate this hypothesis by analyzing VcmN and ClbM, which along with PfMATE are the only three prokaryotic MATEs whose molecular structures have been determined at atomic resolution, i.e. better than 3 Å. Reinterpretation of existing crystallographic data and molecular dynamics simulations indeed reveal an occupied Na+-binding site in the N-terminal lobe of both structures, analogous to that identified in PfMATE. We likewise find this site to be strongly selective against K+, suggesting it is mechanistically significant. Consistent with these computational results, DEER spectroscopy measurements for multiple doubly-spin-labeled VcmN constructs demonstrate Na+-dependent changes in protein conformation. The existence of this binding site in three MATE orthologs implicates Na+ in the ion-coupled drug-efflux mechanisms of this class of transporters. These results also imply that observations of H+-dependent activity likely stem either from a site elsewhere in the structure, or from H+ displacing Na+ under certain laboratory conditions, as has been noted for other Na+-driven transport systems.

Probing the E/K Peptide Coiled-Coil Assembly by Double Electron-Electron Resonance and Circular Dichroism.

Double electron-electron resonance (DEER, also known as PELDOR) and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopies were explored for the purpose of studying the specificity of the conformation of peptides induced by their assembly into a self-recognizing system. The E and K peptides are known to form a coiled-coil heterodimer. Two paramagnetic TOAC α-amino acid residues were incorporated into each of the peptides (denoted as K** and E**), and a three-dimensional structural investigation in the presence or absence of their unlabeled counterparts E and K was performed. The TOAC spin-labels, replacing two Ala residues in each compound, are covalently and quasi-rigidly connected to the peptide backbone. They are known not to disturb the native structure, so that any conformational change can easily be monitored and assigned. DEER spectroscopy enables the measurement of the intramolecular electron spin-spin distance distribution between the two TOAC labels, within a length range of 1.5-8 nm. This method allows the individual conformational changes for the K**, K**/E, E**, and E**/K molecules to be investigated in glassy frozen solutions. Our data reveal that the conformations of the E** and K** peptides are strongly influenced by the presence of their counterparts. The results are discussed with those from CD spectroscopy and with reference to the already reported nuclear magnetic resonance data. We conclude that the combined DEER/TOAC approach allows us to obtain accurate and reliable information about the conformation of the peptides before and after their assembly into coiled-coil heterodimers. Applications of this induced fit method to other two-component, but more complex, systems, like a receptor and antagonists, a receptor and a hormone, and an enzyme and a ligand, are discussed.

Viewing rare conformations of the β2 adrenergic receptor with pressure-resolved DEER spectroscopy

The β2 adrenergic receptor (β2AR) is an archetypal G protein coupled receptor (GPCR). One structural signature of GPCR activation is a large-scale movement (ca. 6 to 14 Å) of transmembrane helix 6 (TM6) to a conformation which binds and activates a cognate G protein. The β2AR exhibits a low level of agonist-independent G protein activation. The structural origin of this basal activity and its suppression by inverse agonists is unknown but could involve a unique receptor conformation that promotes G protein activation. Alternatively, a conformational selection model proposes that a minor population of the canonical active receptor conformation exists in equilibrium with inactive forms, thus giving rise to basal activity of the ligand-free receptor. Previous spin-labeling and fluorescence resonance energy transfer experiments designed to monitor the positional distribution of TM6 did not detect the presence of the active conformation of ligand-free β2AR. Here we employ spin-labeling and pressure-resolved double electron-electron resonance spectroscopy to reveal the presence of a minor population of unliganded receptor, with the signature outward TM6 displacement, in equilibrium with inactive conformations. Binding of inverse agonists suppresses this population. These results provide direct structural evidence in favor of a conformational selection model for basal activity in β2AR and provide a mechanism for inverse agonism. In addition, they emphasize 1) the importance of minor populations in GPCR catalytic function; 2) the use of spin-labeling and variable-pressure electron paramagnetic resonance to reveal them in a membrane protein; and 3) the quantitative evaluation of their thermodynamic properties relative to the inactive forms, including free energy, partial molar volume, and compressibility.

Anti-apoptotic BCL-2 regulation by changes in dynamics of its long unstructured loop

BCL-2, a key protein in inhibiting apoptosis, has a 65-residue-long highly flexible loop domain (FLD) located on the opposite side of its ligand-binding groove. In vivo phosphorylation of the FLD enhances the affinity of BCL-2 for pro-apoptotic ligands, and consequently anti-apoptotic activity. However, it remains unknown as to how the faraway, unstructured FLD modulates the affinity. Here we investigate the protein-ligand interactions by fluorescence techniques and monitor protein dynamics by DEER and NMR spectroscopy tools. We show that phosphomimetic mutations on the FLD lead to a reduction in structural flexibility, hence promoting ligand access to the groove. The bound pro-apoptotic ligands can be displaced by the BCL-2-selective inhibitor ABT-199 efficiently, and thus released to trigger apoptosis. We show that changes in structural flexibility on an unstructured loop can activate an allosteric protein that is otherwise structurally inactive.

Rhodopsin Oligomerization in Synthetic Lipid Bilayers and Native Cellular Membranes as Studied by DEER of a Spin-labeled Retinal Analog

Oligomerization of integral membrane proteins is often the final step of protein folding. This final step is likely to be affected by a number of factors including biophysical interactions with lipids and other proteins and so is the oligomers’ stability and their further organization into clusters/superlattices. Thus, the protein oligomers observed in different membrane mimetics including synthetic liposomes could be different from those formed in native membranes. Here we employed DEER spectroscopy to measure a distribution of long range (ca., 2-7 nm) constraints between specific protein sidechains labeled with paramagnetic tags. Spin-labeled derivative of retinal (4-[2,2,5,5-tetramethyl-1- pyrrolidinyloxy-3-carboxyl]-retinal) was synthesized and added to apo-rhodospsin for a tight non-covalent binding similar to the native retinal. Such an approach eliminated the need for covalent modification of proteins with conventional nitroxides. Further, the retinal binding is a useful probe for oligomerization of functional rhodopsins as the protein is known to lose the retinal upon denaturing. Thus, non-functional rhodopsins would be EPR-silent. Experimental DEER signals from such spin-labeled rhodopsin revealed significant differences in protein oligomerization in synthetic vs. native membranes. Specifically, while oligomers with well-defined distances were found to form in DMPC-DMPA, some shorter distances were determined to be present in the native cellular membranes. The latter distances were attributed to smaller oligomers (dimers, trimers, etc.) that could be intermediates to larger oligomers or incomplete oligomers which further oligomerization was terminated by the membrane defects and/or other protein components. The work at NCSU was supported by U.S. DOE Contract DE-FG02-02ER15354.

Spin-labeled nanobodies as protein conformational reporters for electron paramagnetic resonance in cellular membranes

Nanobodies are emerging tools in a variety of fields such as structural biology, cell imaging, and drug discovery. Here we pioneer the use of their spin-labeled variants as reporters of conformational dynamics of membrane proteins using DEER spectroscopy. At the example of the bacterial ABC transporter TM287/288, we show that two gadolinium-labeled nanobodies allow us to quantify, via analysis of the modulation depth of DEER traces, the fraction of transporters adopting the outward-facing state under different experimental conditions. Additionally, we quantitatively follow the interconversion from the outward- to the inward-facing state in the conformational ensemble under ATP turnover conditions. We finally show that the specificity of the nanobodies for the target protein allows the direct attainment of structural information on the wild-type TM287/288 expressed in cellular membranes without the need to purify or label the investigated membrane protein.

Light-induced dipolar spectroscopy – A quantitative comparison between LiDEER and LaserIMD

Nanometric distance measurements with EPR spectroscopy yield crucial information on the structure and interactions of macromolecules in complex systems. The range of suitable spin labels for such measurements was recently expanded with a new class of light-inducible labels: the triplet state of porphyrins. Importantly, accurate distance measurements between a triplet label and a nitroxide have been reported with two distinct light-induced spectroscopy techniques, (light-induced) triplet-nitroxide DEER (LiDEER) and laser-induced magnetic dipole spectroscopy (LaserIMD). In this work, we set out to quantitatively compare the two techniques under equivalent conditions at Q band. Since we find that LiDEER using a rectangular pump pulse does not reach the high modulation depth that can be achieved with LaserIMD, we further explore the possibility of improving the LiDEER experiment with chirp inversion pulses. LiDEER employing a broadband pump pulse results in a drastic improvement of the modulation depth. The relative performance of chirp LiDEER and Laser-IMD in terms of modulation-to-noise ratio is found to depend on the dipolar evolution time: While LaserIMD yields higher modulation-to-noise ratios than LiDEER at short dipolar evolution times (τ=2μs), the high phase memory time of the triplet spins causes the situation to revert at τ=6μs.

A facile approach for the in vitro assembly of multimeric membrane transport proteins

Membrane proteins such as ion channels and transporters are frequently homomeric. The homomeric nature raises important questions regarding coupling between subunits and complicates the application of techniques such as FRET or DEER spectroscopy. These challenges can be overcome if the subunits of a homomeric protein can be independently modified for functional or spectroscopic studies. Here, we describe a general approach for in vitro assembly that can be used for the generation of heteromeric variants of homomeric membrane proteins. We establish the approach using GltPh, a glutamate transporter homolog that is trimeric in the native state. We use heteromeric GltPh transporters to directly demonstrate the lack of coupling in substrate binding and demonstrate how heteromeric transporters considerably simplify the application of DEER spectroscopy. Further, we demonstrate the general applicability of this approach by carrying out the in vitro assembly of VcINDY, a Na+-coupled succinate transporter and CLC-ec1, a Cl-/H+ antiporter.

Structural Insight into the Role of the Ton Complex in Energy Transduction

In Gram-negative bacteria, outer membrane (OM) transporters import nutrients by coupling to an inner membrane (IM) protein complex called the Ton complex. The Ton complex consists of TonB, ExbB, and ExbD, and uses the proton motive force (pmf) at the IM to transduce energy to the OM via TonB. Here, we structurally characterize the Ton complex from E. coli using X-ray crystallography, electron microscopy, DEER spectroscopy, and crosslinking, revealing a stoichiometry consisting of a pentamer of ExbB, a dimer of ExbD, and at least one TonB. Electrophysiology studies show that the Ton subcomplex forms pH-sensitive cation-selective channels, providing insight to the mechanism by which it may harness the pmf for energy production.

Exploring Complexes of Rhodopsin and Binding Partners in Virtual Reality

Protein structures are important for understanding biological processes on the most fundamental level. However, communicating 3D protein structures using 2D projections in publications or presentations does not deliver a complete representation of the important structural components, especially to scientists working outside of structural biology, to students, and to a lay audience.We present our latest structural work characterizing complexes of rhodopsin, the G protein-coupled photoreceptor in found in rod cells, and its binding partners based on structures solved by crystallography or structural models derived from sparse structural data, such as DEER spectroscopy distance measurements. In collaboration with Autodesk Research, we present in an accessible, immersive virtual reality environment to allow attendees to freely explore the important, highlighted structural features to be discussed. The presentation of pre-authored models generated in Autodesk's web-based Molecule Viewer is accessed by entering a URL into a web browser on a smartphone. These structural models can be accessed and explored in virtual reality on any smartphone using provided cardboard virtual reality devices.

Structure and Dynamics of Nanopore-Confined Membrane Proteins are Affected by Bilayer Lipid Composition

Self-assembled nanotubular lipid bilayers confined within macroscopically aligned high-density homogeneous nanopore array structure of anodic aluminum oxide (AAO) membranes exhibit a high degree of macroscopic alignment that facilitates their studies by oriented sample solid state (OS SS) NMR and spin-labeling EPR methods. The principal advantages of the lipid nanotube arrays are in the applicability of this method to essentially any lipid composition and a tolerance of the macroscopic alignment to a wide range of environmental conditions such as, e.g., temperature, pH, and ionic strength. Here we describe 1) a recent progress in reconstructing small pore-forming and transmembrane peptides as well as large membrane protein complexes, such as photosynthetic reaction center (RC) protein in inorganic nanopores and 2) utilization of this technology to study lipid-induced changes in protein conformations by magnetic resonance methods. Specifically, by using OS SS NMR we have shown that the tilt and α-helix kink angles of Pf1 coat protein are affected by the bilayer composition on example of DOPC, POPC and DMPC bilayers. Effects of unsaturated lipids on Pf1 dynamics as evidenced by the changes in the linewidths in the Pf1 spectra are also reported. We relate these changes to the bilayer fluidity and its effects on the uniaxial rotational diffusion of the protein within the membrane. Further, we demonstrate the use of DEER spectroscopy to obtain long-range distance constraints for membrane protein systems incorporated into lipid nanotubes. The improved nanopore alignment technique described here provides a general method for studying lipid-induced structural conformations of membrane proteins under physiologically relevant conditions by magnetic resonance. Supported by U.S. DOE contract No. DE-FG02-02ER15354 to A.I.S. and NSF MRI 1229547 to A.A.N.

Rates and equilibrium constants of the ligand-induced conformational transition of an HCN ion channel protein domain determined by DEER spectroscopy.

Ligand binding can induce significant conformational changes in proteins. The mechanism of this process couples equilibria associated with the ligand binding event and the conformational change. Here we show that by combining the application of W-band double electron-electron resonance (DEER) spectroscopy with microfluidic rapid freeze quench (μRFQ) it is possible to resolve these processes and obtain both equilibrium constants and reaction rates. We studied the conformational transition of the nitroxide labeled, isolated carboxy-terminal cyclic-nucleotide binding domain (CNBD) of the HCN2 ion channel upon binding of the ligand 3',5'-cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP). Using model-based global analysis, the time-resolved data of the μRFQ DEER experiments directly provide fractional populations of the open and closed conformations as a function of time. We modeled the ligand-induced conformational change in the protein using a four-state model: apo/open (AO), apo/closed (AC), bound/open (BO), bound/closed (BC). These species interconvert according to AC + L ⇌ AO + L ⇌ BO ⇌ BC. By analyzing the concentration dependence of the relative contributions of the closed and open conformations at equilibrium, we estimated the equilibrium constants for the two conformational equilibria and the open-state ligand dissociation constant. Analysis of the time-resolved μRFQ DEER data gave estimates for the intrinsic rates of ligand binding and unbinding as well as the rates of the conformational change. This demonstrates that DEER can quantitatively resolve both the thermodynamics and the kinetics of ligand binding and the associated conformational change.

Structural insight into the role of the Ton complex in energy transduction.

SummaryIn Gram-negative bacteria, outer membrane (OM) transporters import nutrients by coupling to an inner membrane (IM) protein complex called the Ton complex. The Ton complex consists of TonB, ExbB, and ExbD, and uses the proton motive force (pmf) at the IM to transduce energy to the OM via TonB. Here, we structurally characterize the Ton complex from E. coli using X-ray crystallography, electron microscopy, DEER spectroscopy, and crosslinking, revealing a stoichiometry consisting of a pentamer of ExbB, a dimer of ExbD, and at least one TonB. Electrophysiology studies show that the Ton subcomplex forms pH-sensitive cation-selective channels, providing insight to the mechanism by which it may harness the pmf for energy production.

Coherent pump pulses in Double Electron Electron Resonance spectroscopy.

The recent introduction of shaped pulses to Double Electron Electron Resonance (DEER) spectroscopy has led to significant enhancements in sensitivity through increased excitation bandwidths and improved control over spin dynamics. The application of DEER has so far relied on the presence of an incoherent pump channel to average out most undesired coherent effects of the pump pulse(s) on the observer spins. However, in fully coherent EPR spectrometers that are increasingly used to generate shaped pulses, the presence of coherent pump pulses means that these effects need to be explicitly considered. In this paper, we examine the effects of coherent rectangular and sech/tanh pump pulses in DEER experiments with up to three pump pulses. We show that, even in the absence of significant overlap of the observer and pump pulse excitation bandwidths, coherence transfer pathways involving both types of pulses generate spin echoes of considerable intensity. These echoes introduce artefacts, which, if not identified and removed, can easily lead to misinterpretation. We demonstrate that the observed echoes can be quantitatively modelled using a simple spin quantum dynamics approach that includes instrumental transfer functions. Based on an analysis of the echo crossing artefacts, we propose efficient phase cycling schemes for their suppression. This enables the use of advanced DEER experiments, characterized by high sensitivity and increased accuracy for long-distance measurements, on novel fully coherent EPR spectrometers.

Conformational dynamics of metallo-β-lactamase CcrA during catalysis investigated by using DEER spectroscopy.

Previous crystallographic and mutagenesis studies have implicated the role of a position-conserved hairpin loop in the metallo-β-lactamases in substrate binding and catalysis. In an effort to probe the motion of that loop during catalysis, rapid-freeze-quench double electron-electron resonance (RFQ-DEER) spectroscopy was used to interrogate metallo-β-lactamase CcrA, which had a spin label at position 49 on the loop and spin labels (at positions 82, 126, or 233) 20-35 Å away from residue 49, during catalysis. At 10 ms after mixing, the DEER spectra show distance increases of 7, 10, and 13 Å between the spin label at position 49 and the spin labels at positions 82, 126, and 233, respectively. In contrast to previous hypotheses, these data suggest that the loop moves nearly 10 Å away from the metal center during catalysis and that the loop does not clamp down on the substrate during catalysis. This study demonstrates that loop motion during catalysis can be interrogated on the millisecond time scale.