We studied the relative contributions of total peripheral resistance (TPR), stroke volume (SV) and heart rate (HR) to low blood pressure in classical orthostatic hypotension (cOH) on group and individual levels. We retrospectively analyzed tilt test records from cOH patients and age/sex-matched controls. We quantified relative effects of HR, SV and TPR on mean arterial pressure (MAP) with the log-ratio method. We studied relations of changes of HR, SV or TPR with the change of MAP across patients and variability of contributions of HR, SV and TPR to MAP. We also explored neurogenic vs. nonneurogenic causes. MAP responded to tilt with a decrease in patients (n = 80) and an increase in controls (n = 80). A too small TPR-increase contributed most to cOH, followed by a too large SV-decrease; both effects were partially corrected by a larger increase of HR. Only TPR changes consistently affected MAP change in patients and controls. TPR decreased almost exclusively in patients, most in those with severe cOH. Contributions of HR, SV and TPR to MAP did not differ between probable neurogenic and nonneurogenic causes. HR, SV and TPR all contributed to cOH, with a key role for TPR; a decrease of TPR was almost unique to patients and may be due to hyperventilation. The lack of differences between neurogenic and nonneurogenic causes needs further study.