In Response: We used the method of Soons et al. [1] to evaluate indocyanine green (ICG) clearance and estimated hepatic blood flow and thus assumed an ICG extraction ratio of 0.7 in each participant. This method assumes that the intrinsic clearance of ICG remains constant, a reasonable assumption since the high extraction ratio of ICG makes it relatively insensitive to changes in intrinsic clearance (ICG clearance depends far more on hepatic blood flow than on intrinsic clearance) [2]. Dr. Carmichael is concerned that the observed change in ICG clearance, which we concluded to be primarily due to a reduction in hepatic blood flow, might instead result from reduced intrinsic clearance of ICG, based on the report of Lange et al. [3]. Unfortunately, the study of Lange et al. [3] suffers major methodologic weaknesses, reducing confidence in their estimations of the ICG extraction ratio, intrinsic clearance, and the effect of propofol on these values. The combination of a long ICG infusion (approximately 2 h) and ICG analysis by spectrophotometry rather than high-performance liquid chromatography probably overestimated the concentration of ICG since spectrophotometry does not distinguish between the parent compound and its metabolites, which are eliminated much more slowly [1,4]. High-performance liquid chromatography methods, in contrast, do not share this problem because the parent compound is separated by chromatography from the metabolites. The extent to which the spectrophotometric method may overestimate ICG concentration increases with the duration of infusion and can be as high as 40% under the conditions of Lange et al.'s study [4]. An overestimation of ICG concentration by even 20% is sufficient to produce an erroneous apparent 16% decrease in ICG extraction ratio (assuming a starting value of 0.7) and an erroneous apparent 27% decrease in intrinsic clearance of ICG with the equations used by Lange et al. [3]. All of the apparent changes in these variables reported by Lange et al. at sternotomy may result from suboptimal methodology. Lange et al.'s assessment made immediately after induction does suggest reduced ICG extraction and intrinsic clearance. However, the study design makes it difficult to assume that the effects are due to propofol rather than the other concurrently administered drugs (fentanyl and pancuronium) or are from the anesthetic state per se. In contrast, our volunteers were anesthetized with isoflurane and nitrous oxide for at least 3 h before administration of ICG, thus allowing ICG clearance changes due to the propofol infusion to be separated from those resulting from anesthesia itself or other concurrently administered drugs. In short, the evidence that propofol changes the hepatic extraction ratio and intrinsic clearance of ICG is far from compelling. We thus stand by our conclusions, albeit with the assumptions and caveats described at length in our article. In any case, whether the actual mechanism is reduction in hepatic blood flow or intrinsic clearance (and extraction ratio), it is obvious that propofol affects hepatic elimination of drugs, including its own elimination. Kate Leslie, MB,BS, FANZCA Daniel I. Sessler, MD Andrew R. Bjorksten, PhD Azita Moayeri, BA Department of Anaesthesia The Royal Melbourne Hospital Victoria 3050, Australia
Read full abstract