Decidability Properties Research Articles

Type-theoretic approaches to ordinals

In a constructive setting, no concrete formulation of ordinal numbers can simultaneously have all the properties one might be interested in; for example, being able to calculate limits of sequences is constructively incompatible with deciding extensional equality. Using homotopy type theory as the foundational setting, we develop an abstract framework for ordinal theory and establish a collection of desirable properties and constructions. We then study and compare three concrete implementations of ordinals in homotopy type theory: first, a notation system based on Cantor normal forms (binary trees); second, a refined version of Brouwer trees (infinitely-branching trees); and third, extensional well-founded orders.Each of our three formulations has the central properties expected of ordinals, such as being equipped with an extensional and well-founded ordering as well as allowing basic arithmetic operations, but they differ with respect to what they make possible in addition. For example, for finite collections of ordinals, Cantor normal forms have decidable properties, but suprema of infinite collections cannot be computed. In contrast, extensional well-founded orders work well with infinite collections, but the price to pay is that almost all properties are undecidable. Brouwer trees, implemented as a quotient inductive-inductive type to ensure well-foundedness and extensionality, take the sweet spot in the middle by combining a restricted form of decidability with the ability to work with infinite increasing sequences.Our three approaches are connected by canonical order-preserving functions from the “more decidable” to the “less decidable” notions, i.e. from Cantor normal forms to Brouwer trees, and from there to extensional well-founded orders. We have formalised the results on Cantor normal forms and Brouwer trees in cubical Agda, while extensional well-founded orders have been studied and formalised thoroughly by Escardó and his collaborators. Finally, we compare the computational efficiency of our implementations with the results reported by Berger.

Realizable and Context-Free Hyperlanguages

Hyperproperties lift conventional trace-based languages from a set of execution traces to a set of sets of executions. From a formal-language perspective, these are sets of sets of words, namely hyperlanguages. Hyperautomata are based on classical automata models that are lifted to handle hyperlanguages. Finite hyperautomata (NFH) have been suggested to express regular hyperproperties. We study the realizability problem for regular hyperlanguages: given a set of languages, can it be precisely described by an NFH? We show that the problem is complex already for singleton hyperlanguages. We then go beyond regular hyperlanguages, and study context-free hyperlanguages. We show that the natural extension to context-free hypergrammars is highly undecidable. We then suggest a refined model, namely synchronous hypergrammars, which enables describing interesting non-regular hyperproperties, while retaining many decidable properties of context-free grammars.

MOST SIMPLE EXTENSIONS OF ARE UNDECIDABLE

AbstractAll known structural extensions of the substructural logic $\textbf{FL}_{\textbf{e}}$ , the Full Lambek calculus with exchange/commutativity (corresponding to subvarieties of commutative residuated lattices axiomatized by $\{\vee , \cdot , 1\}$ -equations), have decidable theoremhood; in particular all the ones defined by knotted axioms enjoy strong decidability properties (such as the finite embeddability property). We provide infinitely many such extensions that have undecidable theoremhood, by encoding machines with undecidable halting problem. An even bigger class of extensions is shown to have undecidable deducibility problem (the corresponding varieties of residuated lattices have undecidable word problem); actually with very few exceptions, such as the knotted axioms and the other prespinal axioms, we prove that undecidability is ubiquitous. Known undecidability results for non-commutative extensions use an encoding that fails in the presence of commutativity, so and-branching counter machines are employed. Even these machines provide encodings that fail to capture proper extensions of commutativity, therefore we introduce a new variant that works on an exponential scale. The correctness of the encoding is established by employing the theory of residuated frames.

Context-free timed formalisms: Robust automata and linear temporal logics

The paper focuses on automata and linear temporal logics for real-time pushdown reactive systems bridging tractable formalisms specialized for expressing separately dense-time real-time properties and context-free properties though preserving tractability. As for automata, we introduce Event-Clock Nested Automata (ECNA), a formalism that combines Event Clock Automata (ECA) and Visibly Pushdown Automata (VPA). ECNA enjoy the same closure and decidability properties of ECA and VPA expressively extending any previous attempt of combining ECA and VPA. As for temporal logics, we introduce two formalisms for specifying quantitative timing context-free requirements: Event-Clock Nested Temporal Logic (EC_NTL) and Nested Metric Temporal Logic (NMTL). EC_NTL is an extension of both the logic CaRet and Event-Clock Temporal Logic having Exptime-complete satisfiability of EC_NTL and visibly model-checking of Visibly Pushdown Timed Systems (VPTS) against EC_NTL. NMTL is a context-free extension of standard Metric Temporal Logic (MTL) which is in general undecidable having, though, a fragment expressively equivalent to EC_NTL with Exptime-complete satisfiability and visibly model-checking of VPTS problems.

Semilinearity of Families of Languages

Techniques are developed for creating new and general language families of only semilinear languages, and for showing families only contain semilinear languages. It is shown that for language families [Formula: see text] that are semilinear full trios, the smallest full AFL containing [Formula: see text] that is also closed under intersection with languages in [Formula: see text] (where [Formula: see text] is the family of languages accepted by [Formula: see text]s augmented with reversal-bounded counters), is also semilinear. If these closure properties are effective, this also immediately implies decidability of membership, emptiness, and infiniteness for these general families. From the general techniques, new grammar systems are given that are extensions of well-known families of semilinear full trios, whereby it is implied that these extensions must only describe semilinear languages. This also implies positive decidability properties for the new systems. Some characterizations of the new families are also given.

Clique‐convergence is undecidable for automatic graphs

AbstractThe clique operator transforms a graph into its clique graph , which is the intersection graph of all the (maximal) cliques of . Iterated clique graphs are then defined by , . If there are some such that , then we say that is clique‐convergent. The clique graph operator and iterated clique graphs have been studied extensively, but no characterization for clique‐convergence has been found so far. Automatic graphs are (not necessarily finite) graphs whose vertices and edges can be recognized by finite automata. Automatic graphs (and automatic structures) have strong decidability properties inherited from the finite automata defining them. Here we prove that clique‐convergence is algorithmically undecidable for the class of automatic graphs. Moreover, the problem remains undecidable, if we reduce to the class that contain only quasi‐clique‐Helly and bounded degree graphs. As a consequence, it follows that clique‐convergence for automatic graphs is not first‐order expressible.

On Decidability of Theories of Regular Languages

This paper is dedicated to studying decidability properties of theories of regular languages with classical operations: union, concatenation, and the Kleene star. The theory with union only is a theory of some Boolean algebra, so it is decidable. We prove that the theory of regular languages with the Kleene star only is decidable. If we use union and concatenation simultaneously, then the theory becomes both Σ1- and π1-hard over the one-symbol alphabet. Using methods from the proof of this theorem we establish that the theory of regular languages over one-symbol alphabet with union and the Kleene star is as hard as arithmetic. Then we establish that the theory with all three operations is reducible to arithmetic also, hence, it is equivalent to arithmetic. Finally, we prove that the theory of regular languages over any alphabet with concatenation only is equivalent to arithmetic also. The last result is based on our previous work where an analogous theorem was proved for one-symbol languages.

On finite-index indexed grammars and their restrictions

The family, L(INDLIN), of languages generated by linear indexed grammars has been studied in the literature. It is known that the Parikh image of every language in L(INDLIN) is semi-linear. However, there are bounded semi-linear languages that are not in L(INDLIN). Here, we look at larger families of (restricted) indexed languages and study their combinatorial and decidability properties, and their relationships.

On families of full trios containing counter machine languages

We look at nondeterministic finite automata augmented with multiple reversal-bounded counters where, during an accepting computation, the behavior of the counters is specified by some fixed pattern. These patterns can serve as a useful “bridge” to other important automata and grammar models in the theoretical computer science literature, thereby helping in their study. Various pattern behaviors are considered, together with characterizations and comparisons. For example, one such pattern defines exactly the smallest full trio containing all the bounded semilinear languages. Another pattern defines the smallest full trio containing all the bounded context-free languages. The “bridging” to other families is then applied, e.g. to certain Turing machine restrictions, as well as other families. Certain general decidability properties are also studied using this framework.

Variations of checking stack automata: Obtaining unexpected decidability properties

We introduce a model of one-way language acceptors (a variant of a checking stack automaton) and show the following decidability properties:1.The deterministic version has a decidable membership problem but has an undecidable emptiness problem.2.The nondeterministic version has an undecidable membership problem and emptiness problem. There are many models of accepting devices for which there is no difference with these problems between deterministic and nondeterministic versions, i.e., the membership problem for both versions are either decidable or undecidable, and the same holds for the emptiness problem. As far as we know, the model we introduce above is the first one-way model to exhibit properties (1) and (2). We define another family of one-way acceptors where the nondeterministic version has an undecidable emptiness problem, but the deterministic version has a decidable emptiness problem. We also know of no other model with this property in the literature. We also investigate decidability properties of other variations of checking stack automata (e.g., allowing multiple stacks, two-way input, etc.). Surprisingly, two-way deterministic machines with multiple checking stacks and multiple reversal-bounded counters are shown to have a decidable membership problem, a very general model with this property.

Decision problems of tree transducers with origin

A tree transducer with origin translates an input tree into a pair of output tree and origin information. The origin information maps each node in the output tree to the unique node in the input tree that created it. In this way, the implementation of the transducer becomes part of its semantics. We show that the landscape of decidable properties changes drastically when origin information is added. For instance, equivalence of nondeterministic top-down and MSO transducers with origin becomes decidable. Both problems are undecidable without origin. The equivalence of deterministic top-down tree-to-string transducers is decidable with origin, while without origin it has (until very recently) been a long standing open problem. With origin, we can decide if a deterministic macro tree transducer can be realized by a deterministic top-down tree transducer; without origin this is an open problem.

Automatic program inversion using symbolic transducers

We propose a fully-automated technique for inverting functional programs that operate over lists such as string encoders and decoders. We consider programs that can be modeled using symbolic extended finite transducers (), an expressive model that can describe complex list-manipulating programs while retaining several decidable properties. Concretely, given a program P expressed as an , we propose techniques for: (1) checking whether P is injective and, if that is the case, (2) building an P -1 describing its inverse. We first show that it is undecidable to check whether an is injective and propose an algorithm for checking injectivity for a restricted, but a practical class of . We then propose an algorithm for inverting based on the following idea: if an is injective, inverting it amounts to inverting all its individual transitions. We leverage recent advances program synthesis and show that the transition inversion problem can be expressed as an instance of the syntax-guided synthesis framework. Finally, we implement the proposed techniques in a tool called and show that can invert 13 out 14 real complex string encoders and decoders, producing inverse programs that are substantially identical to manually written ones.

Rewriting Higher-Order Stack Trees

Higher-order pushdown systems and ground tree rewriting systems can be seen as extensions of suffix word rewriting systems. Both classes generate infinite graphs with interesting logical properties. Indeed, the model-checking problem for monadic second order logic (respectively first order logic with a reachability predicate) is decidable on such graphs. We unify both models by introducing the notion of stack trees, trees whose nodes are labelled by higher-order stacks, and define the corresponding class of higher-order ground tree rewriting systems. We show that these graphs retain the decidability properties of ground tree rewriting graphs while generalising the pushdown hierarchy of graphs.

A temporal logic for micro- and macro-step-based real-time systems: Foundations and applications

Many systems include components interacting with each other that evolve at possibly very different speeds. To deal with this situation many formal models adopt the abstraction of “zero-time transitions”, which do not consume time. These, however, have several drawbacks in terms of naturalness and logic consistency, as a system is modeled to be in different states at the same time. We propose a novel approach that exploits concepts from non-standard analysis and pairs them with the traditional “next” operator of temporal logic to introduce a notion of micro- and macro-steps; our approach is enacted in an extension of the TRIO metric temporal logic, called X-TRIO. We study the expressiveness and decidability properties of the new logic. Decidability is achieved through translation of a meaningful subset of X-TRIO into Linear Temporal Logic, a traditional way to support automated verification. We illustrate the usefulness and the generality of our approach by applying it to provide a formal semantics of timed Petri nets, which allows for their automated verification. We also give an overview of a formal semantics of Stateflow/Simulink diagrams, defined in terms of X-TRIO, which has been applied to the automated verification of a robotic cell.

Toward a theory of input-driven locally parsable languages

If a context-free language enjoys the local parsability property then, no matter how the source string is segmented, each segment can be parsed independently, and an efficient parallel parsing algorithm becomes possible. The new class of locally chain parsable languages (LCPLs), included in the deterministic context-free language family, is here defined by means of the chain-driven automaton and characterized by decidable properties of grammar derivations. Such automaton decides whether to reduce or not a substring in a way purely driven by the terminal characters, thus extending the well-known concept of input-driven (ID) alias visibly pushdown machines. The LCPL family extends and improves the practically relevant Floyd's operator-precedence (OP) languages which are known to strictly include the ID languages, and for which a parallel-parser generator exists.

Extended symbolic finite automata and transducers

Symbolic finite automata and transducers augment classic automata and transducers with symbolic alphabets represented as parametric theories. This extension enables to succinctly represent large and potentially infinite alphabets while preserving closure and decidability properties. Extended symbolic finite automata and transducers further extend these objects by allowing transitions to read consecutive input elements in a single step. In this paper we study the properties of these models. In contrast to the case of finite alphabets, we show how reading multiple symbols increases the expressiveness of the models, which causes some closure properties to stop holding and most decision problems to become undecidable. In particular we show how extended symbolic finite transducers are not closed under composition, and the equivalence problem is undecidable for both extended symbolic finite automata and transducers. We then introduce the subclass of Cartesian extended symbolic finite transducers in which guards are limited to conjunctions of unary predicates and we propose an equivalence algorithm for this subclass in the single-valued case. We also present a heuristic algorithm for composing extended symbolic finite transducers that works for many practical cases. Finally, we model real world programs with Cartesian extended symbolic finite transducers and use the proposed algorithms to prove their correctness.

On decidability and closure properties of language classes with respect to bio-operations

We present general results that are useful in showing closure and decidable properties of large classes of languages with respect to biologically-inspired operations. We use these results to prove new decidability results and closure properties of some classes of languages under bio-operations such hairpin-inversion, the recently studied operation of pseudo-inversion, and other bio-operations. We also provide techniques for proving undecidability results. In particular, we give a new approach for proving the undecidability of problems for which the usual method of reduction to the undecidability of the Post Correspondence Problem seems hard to apply. Our closure and decidability results strengthen or generalize previous results.

Distributive Laws and Decidable Properties of SOS Specifications

Some formats of well-behaved operational specifications, correspond to natural transformations of certain types (for example, GSOS and coGSOS laws). These transformations have a common generalization: distributive laws of monads over comonads. We prove that this elegant theoretical generalization has limited practical benefits: it does not translate to any concrete rule format that would be complete for specifications that contain both GSOS and coGSOS rules. This is shown for the case of labeled transition systems and deterministic stream systems.

Refining the Process Rewrite Systems Hierarchy via Ground Tree Rewrite Systems

In his seminal paper, Mayr introduced the well-known process rewrite systems (PRS) hierarchy, which contains many well-studied classes of infinite-state systems including pushdown systems (PDS), Petri nets, and PA-processes. A separate development in the term rewriting community introduced the notion of ground tree rewrite systems (GTRS), which is a model that strictly extends PDS while still enjoying desirable decidable properties. There have been striking similarities between the verification problems that have been shown decidable (and undecidable) over GTRS and over models in the PRS hierarchy such as PA and PAD processes. It is open to what extent PRS and GTRS are connected in terms of their expressive power. In this article, we pinpoint the exact connection between GTRS and models in the PRS hierarchy in terms of their expressive power with respect to strong, weak, and branching bisimulation. Among others, this connection allows us to give new insights into the decidability results for subclasses of PRS, such as simpler proofs of known decidability results of verifications problems on PAD.

Measuring Communication in Parallel Communicating Finite Automata

Systems of deterministic finite automata communicating by sending their states upon request are investigated, when the amount of communication is restricted. The computational power and decidability properties are studied for the case of returning centralized systems, when the number of necessary communications during the computations of the system is bounded by a function depending on the length of the input. It is proved that an infinite hierarchy of language families exists, depending on the number of messages sent during their most economical recognitions. Moreover, several properties are shown to be not semi-decidable for the systems under consideration.