Data-dependent Acquisition Analysis Research Articles

Electron-activated dissociation (EAD) for the complementary annotation of metabolites and lipids through data-dependent acquisition analysis and feature-based molecular networking, applied to the sentinel amphipod Gammarus fossarum.

The past decades have marked the rise of metabolomics and lipidomics as the -omics sciences which reflect the most phenotypes in living systems. Mass spectrometry-based approaches are acknowledged for both quantification and identification of molecular signatures, the latter relying primarily on fragmentation spectra interpretation. However, the high structural diversity of biological small molecules poses a considerable challenge in compound annotation. Feature-based molecular networking (FBMN) combined with database searches currently sets the gold standard for annotation of large datasets. Nevertheless, FBMN is usually based on collision-induced dissociation (CID) data, which may lead to unsatisfying information. The use of alternative fragmentation methods, such as electron-activated dissociation (EAD), is undergoing a re-evaluation for the annotation of small molecules, as it gives access to additional fragmentation routes. In this study, we apply the performances of data-dependent acquisition mass spectrometry (DDA-MS) under CID and EAD fragmentation along with FBMN construction, to perform extensive compound annotation in the crude extracts of the freshwater sentinel organism Gammarus fossarum. We discuss the analytical aspects of the use of the two fragmentation modes, perform a general comparison of the information delivered, and compare the CID and EAD fragmentation pathways for specific classes of compounds, including previously unstudied species. In addition, we discuss the potential use of FBMN constructed with EAD fragmentation spectra to improve lipid annotation, compared to the classic CID-based networks. Our approach has enabled higher confidence annotations and finer structure characterization of 823 features, including both metabolites and lipids detected in G. fossarum extracts.

4D-diaXLMS: Proteome-wide Four-Dimensional Data-Independent Acquisition Workflow for Cross-Linking Mass Spectrometry.

Cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS) is a powerful tool for examining protein structures and interactions. Nevertheless, analysis of low-abundance cross-linked peptides is often limited in the data-dependent acquisition (DDA) mode due to its semistochastic nature. To address this issue, we introduced a workflow called 4D-diaXLMS, representing the first-ever application of four-dimensional data-independent acquisition for proteome-wide cross-linking analysis. Cross-linking studies of the HeLa cell proteome were evaluated using the classical cross-linker disuccinimidyl suberate as an example. Compared with the DDA analysis, 4D-diaXLMS exhibited marked improvement in the identification coverage of cross-linked peptides, with a total increase of 36% in single-shot analysis across all 16 SCX fractions. This advantage was further amplified when reducing the fraction number to 8 and 4, resulting in 125 and 149% improvements, respectively. Using 4D-diaXLMS, up to 83% of the cross-linked peptides were repeatedly identified in three replicates, more than twice the 38% in the DDA mode. Furthermore, 4D-diaXLMS showed good performance in the quantitative analysis of yeast cross-linked peptides even in a 15-fold excess amount of HeLa cell matrix, with a low coefficient of variation and high quantitative accuracies in all concentrations. Overall, 4D-diaXLMS was proven to have high coverage, good reproducibility, and accurate quantification for in-depth XL-MS analysis in complex samples, demonstrating its immense potential for advances in the field.

Protein Contaminants Matter: Building Universal Protein Contaminant Libraries for DDA and DIA Proteomics.

Mass spectrometry-based proteomics is constantly challenged by the presence of contaminant background signals. In particular, protein contaminants from reagents and sample handling are almost impossible to avoid. For data-dependent acquisition (DDA) proteomics, an exclusion list can be used to reduce the influence of protein contaminants. However, protein contamination has not been evaluated and is rarely addressed in data-independent acquisition (DIA). How protein contaminants influence proteomic data is also unclear. In this study, we established new protein contaminant FASTA and spectral libraries that are applicable to all proteomic workflows and evaluated the impact of protein contaminants on both DDA and DIA proteomics. We demonstrated that including our contaminant libraries can reduce false discoveries and increase protein identifications, without influencing the quantification accuracy in various proteomic software platforms. With the pressing need to standardize proteomic workflow in the research community, we highly recommend including our contaminant FASTA and spectral libraries in all bottom-up proteomic data analysis. Our contaminant libraries and a step-by-step tutorial to incorporate these libraries in various DDA and DIA data analysis platforms can be valuable resources for proteomic researchers, freely accessible at https://github.com/HaoGroup-ProtContLib.

A streamlined platform for analyzing tera-scale DDA and DIA mass spectrometry data enables highly sensitive immunopeptidomics

Integrating data-dependent acquisition (DDA) and data-independent acquisition (DIA) approaches can enable highly sensitive mass spectrometry, especially for imunnopeptidomics applications. Here we report a streamlined platform for both DDA and DIA data analysis. The platform integrates deep learning-based solutions of spectral library search, database search, and de novo sequencing under a unified framework, which not only boosts the sensitivity but also accurately controls the specificity of peptide identification. Our platform identifies 5-30% more peptide precursors than other state-of-the-art systems on multiple benchmark datasets. When evaluated on immunopeptidomics datasets, we identify 1.7-4.1 and 1.4-2.2 times more peptides from DDA and DIA data, respectively, than previously reported results. We also discover six T-cell epitopes from SARS-CoV-2 immunopeptidome that might represent potential targets for COVID-19 vaccine development. The platform supports data formats from all major instruments and is implemented with the distributed high-performance computing technology, allowing analysis of tera-scale datasets of thousands of samples for clinical applications.

A data-independent acquisition (DIA)-based quantification workflow for proteome analysis of 5000 cells

Data independent acquisition (DIA) has emerged as a powerful proteomic technique with exceptional reproducibility and throughput, and has been widely applied to clinical sample analysis. DIA approaches normally rely on project-specific spectral libraries generated by data dependent acquisition (DDA), requiring extensive off-line fractionation and large amounts of input material. In this study, we aimed to explore the utility of DIA for the analysis of samples with limited quantities. We employed three software tools (DIA-NN, Spectronaut, and EncyclopeDIA) for data analysis and generated three types of libraries, including an experiment-specific library built by DDA analysis of off-line fractions, a FASTA sequence database, and a library generated by gas-phase fractionation (GPF), resulting in eight analysis pipelines. Then we systematically compared the performance of the eight strategies by analyzing the DIA data from HEK293T cell tryptic peptides with sample loads of 500 ng, 100 ng, 20 ng, and 4 ng. The results showed that DIA-NN with GPF-based libraries outperformed the others in protein identification and retention time calibration. Next, we further evaluated the optimized workflow by analyzing the proteome alteration in 5000 peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) induced by lipopolysaccharide (LPS) stimulation. As a result, 3179 protein groups were quantified, and functional analysis revealed activation of multiple signaling pathways, e. g., endocytosis, NF-kappa B signaling, and T cell receptor signaling. The results showed the practicability of using DIA for scarce samples, and the established workflow of PBMC analysis could be easily adapted for biomarker discovery, immune status evaluation, and drug response monitoring, especially for diseases involved with dysfunction of the immune system.

DeepPhospho accelerates DIA phosphoproteome profiling through in silico library generation

Phosphoproteomics integrating data-independent acquisition (DIA) enables deep phosphoproteome profiling with improved quantification reproducibility and accuracy compared to data-dependent acquisition (DDA)-based phosphoproteomics. DIA data mining heavily relies on a spectral library that in most cases is built on DDA analysis of the same sample. Construction of this project-specific DDA library impairs the analytical throughput, limits the proteome coverage, and increases the sample size for DIA phosphoproteomics. Herein we introduce a deep neural network, DeepPhospho, which conceptually differs from previous deep learning models to achieve accurate predictions of LC-MS/MS data for phosphopeptides. By leveraging in silico libraries generated by DeepPhospho, we establish a DIA workflow for phosphoproteome profiling which involves DIA data acquisition and data mining with DeepPhospho predicted libraries, thus circumventing the need of DDA library construction. Our DeepPhospho-empowered workflow substantially expands the phosphoproteome coverage while maintaining high quantification performance, which leads to the discovery of more signaling pathways and regulated kinases in an EGF signaling study than the DDA library-based approach. DeepPhospho is provided as a web server as well as an offline app to facilitate user access to model training, predictions and library generation.

Application of spectral library prediction for parallel reaction monitoring of viral peptides.

A major part of the analysis of parallel reaction monitoring (PRM) data is the comparison of observed fragment ion intensities to a library spectrum. Classically, these libraries are generated by data‐dependent acquisition (DDA). Here, we test Prosit, a published deep neural network algorithm, for its applicability in predicting spectral libraries for PRM. For this purpose, we targeted 1529 precursors derived from synthetic viral peptides and analyzed the data with Prosit and DDA‐derived libraries. Viral peptides were chosen as an example, because virology is an area where in silico library generation could significantly improve PRM assay design. With both libraries a total of 1174 precursors were identified. Notably, compared to the DDA‐derived library, we could identify 101 more precursors by using the Prosit‐derived library. Additionally, we show that Prosit can be applied to predict tandem mass spectra of synthetic viral peptides with different collision energies. Finally, we used a spectral library predicted by Prosit and a DDA library to identify SARS‐CoV‐2 peptides from a simulated oropharyngeal swab demonstrating that both libraries are suited for peptide identification by PRM. Summarized, Prosit‐derived viral spectral libraries predicted in silico can be used for PRM data analysis, making DDA analysis for library generation partially redundant in the future.

Qualitative and Quantitative Shotgun Proteomics Data Analysis from Data-Dependent Acquisition Mass Spectrometry.

Shotgun proteomics is the inferential analysis of proteoforms using peptide proxies produced by enzyme-catalyzed hydrolysis of entire proteomes. Such peptides are usually identified by nanoflow liquid chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry analysis (nLC-MS/MS). Traditionally, MS/MS analysis is performed in data-dependent acquisition (DDA) mode, which usually produces a pattern of fragment masses unique to a single peptide's fragmentation. Here, I describe a statistically rigorous qualitative and quantitative computational analysis for shotgun proteomics DDA analysis using free open-source software tools. MS/MS data are used to identify peptides, and the area of peptide mass/charge over chromatographic elution is used to quantify peptides. All peptides that uniquely map to a protein sequence predicted from the genome are combined into a single protein quantity, which can then be compared across experimental conditions. Statistically significant protein changes can be summarized using gene ontology or pathway term enrichment analysis.

Urine Proteomics: Evaluation of Different Sample Preparation Workflows for Quantitative, Reproducible, and Improved Depth of Analysis.

The growing field of urinary proteomics shows promise to expand the number of biomarkers for the diagnosis and prognosis of a number of human diseases. With the rapid developments in mass spectrometry methods for proteome quantification, there exists an opportunity for improved sample processing and separation workflows to make important contributions to urine proteomic analyses. Here we evaluate the performance of four sample preparation methods: MStern, PreOmics in-StageTip (iST), suspension-trapping (S-Trap), and conventional urea In-Solution trypsin hydrolysis for nondepleted urine samples. Data-dependent acquisition (DDA) mode on a QExactive HF mass spectrometer was used for single-shot label-free data acquisition. Our results demonstrate a high degree of reproducibility within each workflow. PreOmics iST yields the best digestion efficiency, whereas the S-Trap workflow gives the greatest number of peptide and protein identifications. Using the S-Trap method and starting with ∼0.5 mL, we identify ∼1500 protein groups and ∼17 700 peptides from DDA analysis with a single injection on the mass spectrometer.

Reproducibility, Specificity and Accuracy of Relative Quantification Using Spectral Library-based Data-independent Acquisition.

Currently data-dependent acquisition (DDA) is the method of choice for mass spectrometry-based proteomics discovery experiments, but data-independent acquisition (DIA) is steadily becoming more important. One of the most important requirements to perform a DIA analysis is the availability of suitable spectral libraries for peptide identification and quantification. Several studies were performed addressing the evaluation of spectral library performance for protein identification in DIA measurements. But so far only few experiments estimate the effect of these libraries on the quantitative level.In this work we created a gold standard spike-in sample set with known contents and ratios of proteins in a complex protein matrix that allowed a detailed comparison of DIA quantification data obtained with different spectral library approaches. We used in-house generated sample-specific spectral libraries created using varying sample preparation approaches and repeated DDA measurement. In addition, two different search engines were tested for protein identification from DDA data and subsequent library generation. In total, eight different spectral libraries were generated, and the quantification results compared with a library free method, as well as a default DDA analysis. Not only the number of identifications on peptide and protein level in the spectral libraries and the corresponding DIA analysis results was inspected, but also the number of expected and identified differentially abundant protein groups and their ratios.We found, that while libraries of prefractionated samples were generally larger, there was no significant increase in DIA identifications compared with repetitive non-fractionated measurements. Furthermore, we show that the accuracy of the quantification is strongly dependent on the applied spectral library and whether the quantification is based on peptide or protein level. Overall, the reproducibility and accuracy of DIA quantification is superior to DDA in all applied approaches.Data has been deposited to the ProteomeXchange repository with identifiers PXD012986, PXD012987, PXD012988 and PXD014956.

Discovering Protein Biomarkers from Clinical Peripheral Blood Mononuclear Cells Using Data-Independent Acquisition Mass Spectrometry.

Global proteomics analyses are traditionally performed in data-dependent acquisition (DDA) mode, which results in inadequate reproducibility across large sample cohorts due to the under-sampling inherent to shotgun proteomics. Recently, data-independent acquisition (DIA) strategies were introduced to allow reproducible detection and quantification of thousands of proteins with consistent sensitivity across samples. Here, we present an approach to analyze changes to the protein network in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from clinical blood samples, using DIA as a unique platform for biomarker discovery. We describe how to generate spectral PBMC proteome libraries by applying peptide fractionation followed by DDA analysis, and then how to apply DIA methods to PBMC samples from individual patients using a high-resolution Orbitrap Fusion mass spectrometer.

Differential protein expression in human knee articular cartilage and medial meniscus using two different proteomic methods: a pilot analysis

BackgroundProteomics is an emerging field in the study of joint disease. Our two aims with this pilot analysis were to compare healthy human knee articular cartilage with meniscus, two tissues both known to become affected in the osteoarthritic disease process, and to compare two mass spectrometry (MS)-based methods: data-dependent acquisition (DDA) and data-independent acquisition (DIA).MethodsHealthy knee articular cartilage taken from the medial tibial condyle and medial meniscus samples taken from the body region were obtained from three adult forensic medicine cases. Proteins were extracted from tissue pieces and prepared for MS analysis. Each sample was subjected to liquid chromatography (LC)-MS/MS analysis using an Orbitrap mass spectrometer, and run in both DDA and DIA mode. Linear mixed effects models were used for statistical analysis.ResultsA total of 653 proteins were identified in the DDA analysis, of which the majority was present in both tissue types. Only proteins with quantitation information in both tissues (n = 90) were selected for more detailed analysis, of which the majority did not statistically significantly differ in abundance between the two tissue types, in either of the MS analyses. However, 21 proteins were statistically significantly different (p < 0.05) between meniscus and cartilage in the DIA analysis. Out of these, 11 proteins were also significantly different in the DDA analysis. Aggrecan core protein was the most abundant protein in articular cartilage and significantly differed between the two tissues in both methods. The corresponding protein in meniscus was serum albumin. Dermatopontin exhibited the highest meniscus vs articular cartilage ratio among the statistically significant proteins. The DIA method led to narrower confidence intervals for the abundance differences between the two tissue types than DDA.ConclusionsAlthough articular cartilage and meniscus had similar proteomic composition, we detected several differences by MS. Between the two analyses, DIA yielded more precise estimates and more statistically significant different proteins than DDA, and had no missing values, which makes it preferable for future LC-MS/MS analyses.

Infrared laser ablation sampling coupled with data independent high resolution UPLC-IM-MS/MS for tissue analysis

Infrared laser ablation microsampling was used with data-dependent acquisition (DDA) and ion mobility-enhanced data-independent acquisition (HDMSE) for mass spectrometry based bottom-up proteomics analysis of rat brain tissue. Results from HDMSE and DDA analyses of the 12 laser ablation sampled tissue sections showed that HDMSE consistently identified approximately seven times more peptides and four times more proteins than DDA. To evaluate the impact of ultra-performance liquid chromatography (UPLC) peak congestion on HDMSE and DDA analysis, whole tissue digests from rat brain were analyzed at six different UPLC separation times. Analogous to results from laser ablated samples, HDMSE analyses of whole tissue digests yielded about four times more proteins identified than DDA for all six UPLC separation times.

Missing Value Monitoring Enhances the Robustness in Proteomics Quantitation.

In global proteomic analysis, it is estimated that proteins span from millions to less than 100 copies per cell. The challenge of protein quantitation by classic shotgun proteomic techniques relies on the presence of missing values in peptides belonging to low-abundance proteins that lowers intraruns reproducibility affecting postdata statistical analysis. Here, we present a new analytical workflow MvM (missing value monitoring) able to recover quantitation of missing values generated by shotgun analysis. In particular, we used confident data-dependent acquisition (DDA) quantitation only for proteins measured in all the runs, while we filled the missing values with data-independent acquisition analysis using the library previously generated in DDA. We analyzed cell cycle regulated proteins, as they are low abundance proteins with highly dynamic expression levels. Indeed, we found that cell cycle related proteins are the major components of the missing values-rich proteome. Using the MvM workflow, we doubled the number of robustly quantified cell cycle related proteins, and we reduced the number of missing values achieving robust quantitation for proteins over ∼50 molecules per cell. MvM allows lower quantification variance among replicates for low abundance proteins with respect to DDA analysis, which demonstrates the potential of this novel workflow to measure low abundance, dynamically regulated proteins.

High Throughput In Situ DDA Analysis of Neuropeptides by Coupling Novel Multiplex Mass Spectrometric Imaging (MSI) with Gas-Phase Fractionation.

Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometric imaging (MSI) is a powerful tool to map the spatial distribution of biomolecules on tissue sections. Recent developments of hybrid MS instruments allow combination of different types of data acquisition by various mass analyzers into a single MSI analysis, which reduces experimental time and sample consumptions. Here, using the well-characterized crustacean nervous system as a test-bed, we explore the utility of high resolution and accurate mass (HRAM) MALDI Orbitrap platform for enhanced in situ characterization of the neuropeptidome with improved chemical information. Specifically, we report on a multiplex-MSI method, which combines HRAM MSI with data dependent acquisition (DDA) tandem MS analysis in a single experiment. This method enables simultaneous mapping of neuropeptide distribution, sequence validation, and novel neuropeptide discovery in crustacean neuronal tissues. To enhance the dynamic range and efficiency of in situ DDA, we introduced a novel approach of fractionating full m/z range into several sub-mass ranges and embedding the setup using the multiplex-DDA-MSI scan events to generate pseudo fractionation before MS/MS scans. The division of entire m/z into multiple segments of m/z sub-ranges for MS interrogation greatly decreased the complexity of molecular species from tissue samples and the heterogeneity of the distribution and variation of intensities of m/z peaks. By carefully optimizing the experimental conditions such as the dynamic exclusion, the multiplex-DDA-MSI approach demonstrates better performance with broader precursor coverage, less biased MS/MS scans towards high abundance molecules, and improved quality of tandem mass spectra for low intensity molecular species. Graphical Abstract ᅟ.

Whole cell, label free protein quantitation with data independent acquisition: quantitation at the MS2 level.

Label free quantitation by measurement of peptide fragment signal intensity (MS2 quantitation) is a technique that has seen limited use due to the stochastic nature of data dependent acquisition (DDA). However, data independent acquisition has the potential to make large scale MS2 quantitation a more viable technique. In this study we used an implementation of data independent acquisition--SWATH--to perform label free protein quantitation in a model bacterium Clostridium stercorarium. Four tryptic digests analyzed by SWATH were probed by an ion library containing information on peptide mass and retention time obtained from DDA experiments. Application of this ion library to SWATH data quantified 1030 proteins with at least two peptides quantified (∼ 40% of predicted proteins in the C. stercorarium genome) in each replicate. Quantitative results obtained were very consistent between biological replicates (R(2) ∼ 0.960). Protein quantitation by summation of peptide fragment signal intensities was also highly consistent between biological replicates (R(2) ∼ 0.930), indicating that this approach may have increased viability compared to recent applications in label free protein quantitation. SWATH based quantitation was able to consistently detect differences in relative protein quantity and it provided coverage for a number of proteins that were missed in some samples by DDA analysis.

Comparison of data acquisition strategies on quadrupole ion trap instrumentation for shotgun proteomics.

The most common data collection in shotgun proteomics is via data-dependent acquisition (DDA), a process driven by an automated instrument control routine that directs MS/MS acquisition from the highest abundant signals to the lowest. An alternative to DDA is data-independent acquisition (DIA), a process in which a specified range in m/z is fragmented without regard to prioritization of a precursor ion or its relative abundance in the mass spectrum, thus potentially offering a more comprehensive analysis of peptides than DDA. In this work, we evaluate both DDA and DIA on three different linear ion trap instruments: an LTQ, an LTQ modified with an electrodynamic ion funnel, and an LTQ Velos. These instruments represent both older (LTQ) and newer (LTQ Velos) ion trap designs (i.e., linear versus dual ion traps, respectively), and allow direct comparison of peptide identifications using both DDA and DIA analysis. Further, as the LTQ Velos has an enhanced "S-lens" ion guide to improve ion flux, we found it logical to determine if the former LTQ model could be leveraged by improving sensitivity by modifying with an electrodynamic ion guide of significantly different design to the S-lens. We find that the ion funnel enabled LTQ identifies more proteins in the insoluble fraction of a yeast lysate than the other two instruments in DIA mode, whereas the faster scanning LTQ Velos performs better in DDA mode. We explore reasons for these results, including differences in scan speed, source ion optics, and linear ion trap design.

The Implications of Proteolytic Background for Shotgun Proteomics

The analysis by liquid chromatography coupled to tandem mass spectrometry of complex peptide mixtures, generated by proteolysis of protein samples, is the main proteomics method used today. The approach is based on the assumption that each protein present in a sample reproducibly and predictably generates a relatively small number of peptides that can be identified by mass spectrometry. In this study this assumption was examined by a targeted peptide sequencing strategy using inclusion lists to trigger peptide fragmentation attempts. It was found that the number of peptides observed from a single protein is at least one order of magnitude greater than previously assumed. This unexpected complexity of proteomics samples implies substantial technical challenges, explains some perplexing results in the proteomics literature, and prompts the need for developing alternative experimental strategies for the rapid and comprehensive analysis of proteomes.