Current Matrix Elements Research Articles

Timelike meson form factors beyond the elastic region from lattice QCD

We present a calculation of the vector-isovector timelike form factors of the pion and the kaon using lattice quantum chromodynamics. We calculate two-point correlation functions with mπ∼280 MeV, extracting both the finite-volume spectrum and matrix elements for these states created from the vacuum by a vector current. After determining the coupled-channel ππ,KK¯ scattering amplitudes, we perform the necessary correction for the significant finite-volume effects present in the current matrix elements, leading to the timelike form factors. We find these to be dominated by the presence of the ρ resonance, and we extract its decay constant by an analytic continuation of the amplitudes to the resonance pole. In addition, the spacelike pion form factor is determined on the same lattice configurations, and a dispersive parametrization is used to simultaneously describe the spacelike and elastic timelike regions. Published by the American Physical Society 2024

Light-front puzzles

Light-front formulations of quantum field theories have many advantages for computing electroweak matrix elements of strongly interacting systems and other quantities that are used to study hadronic structure. The theory can be formulated in Hamiltonian form so non-perturbative calculations of the strongly interacting initial and final states are in principle reduced to linear algebra. These states are needed for calculating parton distribution functions and other types of distribution amplitudes that are used to understand the structure of hadrons. Light-front boosts are kinematic transformations so the strongly interacting states can be computed in any frame. This is useful for computing current matrix elements involving electroweak probes where the initial and final hadronic states are in different frames related by the momentum transferred by the probe. Finally in many calculations the vacuum is trivial so the calculations can be formulated in Fock space. The advantages of light front-field theory would not be interesting if the light-front formulation was not equivalent to the covariant or canonical formulations of quantum field theory. Many of the distinguishing properties of light-front quantum field theory are difficult to reconcile with canonical or covariant formulations of quantum field theory. This paper discusses the resolution of some of the apparent inconsistencies in canonical, covariant and light-front formulations of quantum field theory. The puzzles that will be discussed are (1) the problem of inequivalent representations (2) the problem of the trivial vacuum (3) the problem of ill-posed initial value problems (4) the problem of rotational covariance (5) the problem of zero modes and (6) the problem of spontaneously broken symmetries.

Nucleon Sigma Terms with N_{f}=2+1 Flavors of O(a)-Improved Wilson Fermions.

We present a lattice-QCD based analysis of the nucleon sigma terms using gauge ensembles with N_{f}=2+1 flavors of O(a)-improved Wilson fermions, with a complete error budget concerning excited-state contaminations, the chiral interpolation as well as finite-size and lattice spacing effects. We compute the sigma terms determined directly from the matrix elements of the scalar currents. The chiral interpolation is based on SU(3) baryon chiral perturbation theory using the extended on-mass shell renormalization scheme. For the pion nucleon sigma term, we obtain σ_{πN}=(43.7±3.6) MeV, where the error includes our estimate of the aforementioned systematics. The tension with extractions based on dispersion theory persists at the 2.4-σ level. For the strange sigma term, we obtain a nonzero value, σ_{s}=(28.6±9.3) MeV.

Low-energy matrix elements of heavy-quark currents

In QCD at energies well below a heavy-quark threshold, the heavy-quark vector current can be represented via local operators made of the lighter quarks and of the gluon fields. We extract the leading perturbative matching coefficients for the two most important sets of operators from known results. As an application, we analytically determine the O(αs3)mc2/mb2\\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \\usepackage{amsmath} \\usepackage{wasysym} \\usepackage{amsfonts} \\usepackage{amssymb} \\usepackage{amsbsy} \\usepackage{mathrsfs} \\usepackage{upgreek} \\setlength{\\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \\begin{document}$$\ extrm{O}(\\alpha _s^3)m_c^2/m_b^2$$\\end{document} effect of the bottom quark current on the R(s) ratio below the bottom but above the charm threshold. For the low-energy representation of the charm quark current, the two most important operators are given by the total divergence of dimension-six gluonic operators. We argue that the charm magnetic moment of the nucleon is effectively measuring the forward matrix elements of these gluonic operators and predict the corresponding bottom magnetic moment. Similarly, the contribution of the charm current to R(s≈1GeV2)\\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \\usepackage{amsmath} \\usepackage{wasysym} \\usepackage{amsfonts} \\usepackage{amssymb} \\usepackage{amsbsy} \\usepackage{mathrsfs} \\usepackage{upgreek} \\setlength{\\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \\begin{document}$$R(s\\approx 1\\,\ extrm{GeV}^2)$$\\end{document}, which is associated with quark-disconnected diagrams, is dominantly determined by the decay constants of the ω\\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \\usepackage{amsmath} \\usepackage{wasysym} \\usepackage{amsfonts} \\usepackage{amssymb} \\usepackage{amsbsy} \\usepackage{mathrsfs} \\usepackage{upgreek} \\setlength{\\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \\begin{document}$$\\omega $$\\end{document} and ϕ\\documentclass[12pt]{minimal} \\usepackage{amsmath} \\usepackage{wasysym} \\usepackage{amsfonts} \\usepackage{amssymb} \\usepackage{amsbsy} \\usepackage{mathrsfs} \\usepackage{upgreek} \\setlength{\\oddsidemargin}{-69pt} \\begin{document}$$\\phi $$\\end{document} mesons with respect to the two gluonic operators.

Toward N to Nπ matrix elements from lattice QCD

QCD matrix elements of axial and vector currents between nucleons are required for the Monte Carlo reconstruction of the energy of neutrinos that are detected in long baseline oscillation experiments in the quasielastic regime. The cleanest approach for determining the axial matrix elements is lattice QCD. However, the extraction of these from the corresponding correlation functions is complicated by very large excited state contributions, that are related to transitions from the nucleon to a nucleon-pion pair. In this pilot study with a pion mass ${m}_{\ensuremath{\pi}}=429\text{ }\text{ }\mathrm{MeV}$, we demonstrate for the first time that these contributions can be removed by including five-(anti)quark operators into the basis of interpolators used to create the nucleon. The same techniques will be needed to compute transition matrix elements between the nucleon and nucleon-pion scattering states that are relevant in the resonance production regime.

Independence of current components, polarization vectors, and reference frames in the light-front quark model analysis of meson decay constants

The issue of resulting in the same physical observables with different current components, in particular from the minus current, has been challenging in the light-front quark model (LFQM) even for the computation of the two-point functions such as meson decay constants. At the level of one-body current matrix element computation, we show the uniqueness of pseudoscalar and vector meson decay constants using all available components including the minus component of the current in the LFQM consistent with the Bakamjian-Thomas construction. Regardless of the current components, the polarization vectors, and the reference frames, the meson decay constants are uniquely determined in the noninteracting constituent quark and antiquark basis while the interactions of the constituents are added to the meson mass operator in the LFQM.

Parametrization of transition energy-momentum tensor form factors

While the Lorentz structures of the N→Δ transition matrix element of the vector current are well-known, that of the symmetric energy-momentum tensor current is unknown. In this letter, we first reproduce the Lorentz structures of the 12±→12±, 12∓→12±, and 12∓→32± transition matrix elements of the vector current. We also repeat the parametrizations of the symmetric energy-momentum tensor current for the 12±→12± and 12∓→12± transitions. We then consider both 12±→32± and 12∓→32± matrix elements of the symmetric energy-momentum tensor current (say, N→Δ transition) for the first time. We found that there are five independent conserved and four independent non-conserved energy-momentum tensor form factors.

Polarization-Dependent Selection Rules and Optical Spectrum Atlas of Twisted Bilayer Graphene Quantum Dots

Understanding how symmetries encode optical polarization information into selection rules in molecules and materials is important for their optoelectronic applications including spectroscopic analysis, display technology, and quantum computation. Here, we extend polarization-dependent selection rules from atoms to solid-state systems with various point groups with the help of the rotational operator for circular polarization and the twofold rotational operator (or reflection operator) for linear polarization. We use these new selection rules to study the optical properties of twisted bilayer graphene quantum dots (TBGQDs), which inherit advantages of graphene quantum dot including its ultrathin thickness, excellent biocompatibility, and shape- and size-tunable optical absorption or emission. We study how the electronic structures and optical properties of TBGQDs rely on size, shape, twist angle, and correlation effects for TBGQDs with 10 different point groups for which we obtain an optical selection rule database. We show how current operator matrix elements identify the generalized polarization-dependent selection rules. Our results show that both the electronic and optical band gaps follow power-law size scalings with a dominant role of the twist angle. We derive an atlas of optical conductivity spectra for both size and twist angle in TBGQDs. As a result of quantum confinement effects, in the atlas a new type of optical conductivity features emerges with multiple discrete absorption frequencies ranging from infrared to ultraviolet energy, allowing for applications in photovoltaic devices and photodetectors. The atlas and size scaling provide a full structure–symmetry-function interrelation and hence offer an excellent basis for the geometrical manipulation of optical properties of TBGQDs as building blocks for novel integrated carbon optoelectronics.2 MoreReceived 5 October 2021Revised 14 April 2022Accepted 3 May 2022DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevX.12.021055Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article’s title, journal citation, and DOI.Published by the American Physical SocietyPhysics Subject Headings (PhySH)Research AreasElectronic structureOptical conductivityPhysical SystemsGrapheneTechniquesGroup theoryMean field theorySymmetriesTight-binding modelCondensed Matter, Materials & Applied Physics

Many-body energy invariant for T -linear resistivity

The description of dynamics of strongly correlated quantum matter is a challenge, particularly in physical situations where a quasiparticle description is absent. In such situations, however, the many-body Kubo formula from linear response theory, involving matrix elements of the current operator computed with many-body wavefunctions, remains valid. Working directly in the many-body Hilbert space and not making any reference to quasiparticles (or lack thereof), we address the puzzle of linear in temperature ($T$-linear) resistivity seen in non-Fermi liquid phases that occur in several strongly correlated condensed matter systems. We derive a simple criterion for the occurrence of $T$-linear resistivity based on an analysis of the contributions to the many-body Kubo formula, determined by an energy invariant "$f$-function" involving current matrix elements and energy eigenvalues that describes the DC conductivity of the system in the microcanonical ensemble. Using full diagonalization, we test this criterion for the $f$-function in the spinless nearest neighbor Hubbard model and in a system of Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev dots coupled by weak single particle hopping. We also study the $f$-function for the spin conductivity in the 2D Heisenberg model and arrive at similar conclusions. Our work suggests that a general principle, formulated in terms of many-body Hilbert space concepts, is at the core of the occurrence of $T$-linear resistivity in a wide range of systems, and precisely translates $T$-linear resistivity into a notion of energy scale invariance far beyond what is typically associated with quantum critical points.

Partial muon capture rates in A=3 and A=6 nuclei with chiral effective field theory

Searches for neutrinoless double-$\ensuremath{\beta}$ decay rates are crucial in addressing questions within fundamental symmetries and neutrino physics. The rates of these decays depend not only on unknown parameters associated with neutrinos, but also on nuclear properties. In order to reliably extract information about the neutrino, one needs an accurate treatment of the complex many-body dynamics of the nucleus. Neutrinoless double-$\ensuremath{\beta}$ decays take place at momentum transfers on the order of $100\phantom{\rule{0.28em}{0ex}}\mathrm{MeV}/c$ and require both nuclear electroweak vector and axial current matrix elements. Muon capture, a process in the same momentum transfer regime, has readily available experimental data to validate these currents. In this Letter, we present results of ab initio calculations of partial muon capture rates for $^{3}\mathrm{He}$ and $^{6}\mathrm{Li}$ nuclei using variational and Green's function Monte Carlo computational methods. We estimate the impact of the three-nucleon interactions, the cutoffs used to regularize two-nucleon $(2N)$ interactions, and the energy range of $2N$ scattering data used to fit these interactions.

BHLS_2 upgrade: tau spectra, muon HVP and the [pi ^0,~eta ,~{eta ^prime }] system

The generic hidden local symmetry (HLS) model has recently given rise to its hbox {BHLS}_2 variant, defined by introducing symmetry breaking mostly in the vector meson sector; the central mechanism is a modification of the covariant derivative at the root of the HLS approach. However, the description of the tau dipion spectra, especially the Belle one, is not fully satisfactory, whereas the simultaneous dealing with its annihilation sector (e^+ e^- rightarrow pi ^+ pi ^-/pi ^+ pi ^-pi ^0/ pi ^0 gamma /eta gamma /K^+ K^-/K_L K_S) is optimum. We show that this issue is solved by means of an additional breaking term which also allows us to consistently include the mixing properties of the [pi ^0,eta ,{eta ^prime }] system within this extended hbox {BHLS}_2 (hbox {EBHLS}_2) scope. This mechanism, an extension of the usual ’t Hooft determinant term, only affects the kinetic energy part of the hbox {BHLS}_2 Lagrangian. One thus obtains a fair account for the tau dipion spectra which complements the fair account of the annihilation channels already reached. The Belle dipion spectrum is found to provide evidence in favor of a violation of the conserved vector current (CVC) in the tau lepton decay; this evidence is enforced by imposing the conditions <0|J_mu ^q |[q^prime overline{q^prime }](p)>=ip_mu f_q delta _{q q^prime }, { [q {overline{q}}], q=u,d,s} on hbox {EBHLS}_2 axial current matrix elements. hbox {EBHLS}_2 is found to recover the usual (completed) formulae for the [pi ^0,~eta ,~{eta ^prime }] mixing parameters, and the global fits return mixing parameter values in agreement with expectations and better uncertainties. Updating the muon hadronic vacuum polarization (HVP), one also argues that the strong tension between the KLOE and BaBar pion form factors imposes to provide two solutions, namely a_mu ^{HVP-LO}(mathrm{KLOE})=687.48 pm 2.93 and a_mu ^{HVP-LO}(mathrm{BaBar})=692.53 pm 2.95, in units of 10^{-10}, rather than some combination of these. Taking into account common systematics, their differences from the experimental BNL-FNAL average value exhibit significance > 5.4sigma (KLOE) and > 4.1sigma (BaBar), with fit probabilities favoring the former.

Multifarious Roles of Hidden Chiral-Scale Symmetry: “Quenching” gA in Nuclei

I discuss how the axial current coupling constant gA renormalized in scale symmetric chiral EFT defined at a chiral matching scale impacts on the axial current matrix elements on beta decays in nuclei with and without neutrinos. The “quenched” gA observed in nuclear superallowed Gamow–Teller transitions, a long-standing puzzle in nuclear physics, is shown to encode the emergence of chiral-scale symmetry hidden in QCD in the vacuum. This enables one to explore how trace-anomaly-induced scale symmetry breaking enters in the renormalized gA in nuclei applicable to certain non-unique forbidden processes involved in neutrinoless double beta decays. A parallel is made between the roles of chiral-scale symmetry in quenching gA in highly dense medium and in hadron–quark continuity in the EoS of dense matter in massive compact stars. A systematic chiral-scale EFT, presently lacking in nuclear theory and potentially crucial for the future progress, is suggested as a challenge in the field.

Eigenstate thermalization hypothesis through the lens of autocorrelation functions

Matrix elements of observables in eigenstates of generic Hamiltonians are described by the Srednicki ansatz within the eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH). We study a quantum chaotic spin-fermion model in a one-dimensional lattice, which consists of a spin-1/2 XX chain coupled to a single itinerant fermion. In our study, we focus on translationally invariant observables including the charge and energy current, thereby also connecting the ETH with transport properties. Considering observables with a Hilbert-Schmidt norm of one, we first perform a comprehensive analysis of ETH in the model taking into account latest developments. A particular emphasis is on the analysis of the structure of the offdiagonal matrix elements $|\ensuremath{\langle}\ensuremath{\alpha}|\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{O}{|\ensuremath{\beta}\ensuremath{\rangle}|}^{2}$ in the limit of small eigenstate energy differences $\ensuremath{\omega}={E}_{\ensuremath{\beta}}\ensuremath{-}{E}_{\ensuremath{\alpha}}$. Removing the dominant exponential suppression of $|\ensuremath{\langle}\ensuremath{\alpha}|\stackrel{\ifmmode \hat{}\else \^{}\fi{}}{O}{|\ensuremath{\beta}\ensuremath{\rangle}|}^{2}$, we find that (1) the current matrix elements exhibit a system-size dependence that is different from other observables under investigation and (2) matrix elements of several other observables exhibit a Drude-like structure with a Lorentzian frequency dependence. We then show how this information can be extracted from the autocorrelation functions as well. Finally, our study is complemented by a numerical analysis of the fluctuation-dissipation relation for eigenstates in the bulk of the spectrum. We identify the regime of $\ensuremath{\omega}$ in which the well-known fluctuation-dissipation relation is valid with high accuracy for finite systems.

Axial charge of the triton from lattice QCD

The axial charge of the triton is investigated using lattice quantum chromodynamics (QCD). Extending previous work at heavier quark masses, calculations are performed using three ensembles of gauge field configurations generated with quark masses corresponding to a pion mass of 450 MeV. Finite-volume energy levels for the triton, as well as for the deuteron and diproton systems, are extracted from analysis of correlation functions computed on these ensembles, and the corresponding energies are extrapolated to infinite volume using finite-volume pionless effective field theory (FVEFT). It is found with high likelihood that there is a compact bound state with the quantum numbers of the triton at these quark masses. The axial current matrix elements are computed using background field techniques on one of the ensembles and FVEFT is again used to determine the axial charge of the proton and triton. A simple quark mass extrapolation of these results and earlier calculations at heavier quark masses leads to a value of the ratio of the triton to proton axial charges at the physical quark masses of $g_A^{^{3}{\rm H}}/g_A^p=0.91\substack{+0.07 \\ -0.09}$. This result is consistent with the ratio determined from experiment and prefers values less than unity (in which case the triton axial charge would be unmodified from that of the proton), thereby demonstrating that QCD can explain the modification of the axial charge of the triton.

Heavy baryon wave functions, Bakamjian-Thomas approach to form factors, and observables in Λb→Λc(12±)ℓν¯ transitions

Motivated by the calculation of observables in the decays $\Lambda_b \to \Lambda_c\left({1 \over 2}^\pm \right) \ell \overline{\nu}$, as tests of Lepton Flavor Universality, we present a calculation of form factors in the quark model. Our scheme combines a spectroscopic model, providing the internal wave functions, and the Bakamjian-Thomas relativistic formalism to deduce the wave functions in motion and current matrix elements, that amount in the heavy quark limit to the Isgur-Wise (IW) function. For baryons we meet difficulties using standard spectroscopic models, leading us to propose a simple phenomenological model : a Q-pointlike-diquark model, non-relativistic with harmonic oscillator forces, with a reasonable low-lying spectrum and good slope of the IW function. We extract this slope from Lattice data and find $\rho_\Lambda^2 \sim 2$. We are not able to reproduce the right $\rho_\Lambda^2$ when using standard linear + Coulomb potential models, both with three quarks $Qqq$ or in a Q-pointlike-diquark picture. These difficulties seem to derive from the high sensitivity of $\rho_\Lambda^2$ to the structure of the light quark subsystem. After fixing the parameters of our interim model to yield correct spectrum and $\rho_\Lambda^2$, we compute observables. Bjorken sum rule shows that the inelastic IW function is large, and therefore $\Lambda_b \to \Lambda_c \left({1 \over 2}^-, {3 \over 2}^- \right) \ell \overline{\nu}$ could be studied at LHCb. Some observables in the $\tau$ case present zeroes for specific values of $q^2$ that could be tests of the Standard Model.

Energy-Momentum Relocalization, Surface Terms, and Massless Poles in Axial Current Matrix Elements

The energy-momentum relocalization in classical and quantum theory is addressed with specific impact on non-perturbative QCD and hadronic structure. The relocalization is manifested in the existence of canonical and symmetric (Belinfante and Hilbert) energy momentum tensors (EMT). The latter describes the interactions of hadrons with classical gravity and inertia. Canonical EMT, in turn, is naturally emerging due to the translation invariance symmetry and appears when spin structure of hadrons is considered. Its relation to symmetric Hilbert and Belinfante EMTs requires the possibility to neglect the contribution of boundary terms for the classical fields. For the case of quantum fields this property corresponds to the absence of zero-momentum poles of matrix element of the axial current dual to the spin density. This property is satisfied for quarks manifesting the symmetry counterpart of UA(1) problem and may be violated for gluons due to QCD ghost pole.

Erratum: Scalar and vector form factors of D→π(K)ℓν decays with Nf=2+1+1 twisted fermions [Phys. Rev. D 96 , 054514 (2017)

We present a lattice determination of the vector and scalar form factors of the $D \to \pi(K) \ell \nu$ semileptonic decays, which are relevant for the extraction of the CKM matrix elements $|V_{cd}|$ and $|V_{cs}|$ from experimental data. Our analysis is based on the gauge configurations produced by the European Twisted Mass Collaboration with $N_f = 2+1+1$ flavors of dynamical quarks, at three different values of the lattice spacing and with pion masses as small as 210 MeV. The matrix elements of both vector and scalar currents are determined for a plenty of kinematical conditions in which parent and child mesons are either moving or at rest. Lorentz symmetry breaking due to hypercubic effects is clearly observed in the data and included in the decomposition of the current matrix elements in terms of additional form factors. After the extrapolations to the physical pion mass and to the continuum limit we determine the vector and scalar form factors in the whole kinematical region from $q^2 = 0$ up to $q^2_{max} = (M_D - M_{\pi(K)})^2$ accessible in the experiments, obtaining a good overall agreement with experiments, except in the region at high values of $q^2$ where some deviations are visible. A set of synthetic data points, representing our results for $f_+^{D \pi(K)}(q^2)$ and $f_0^{D \pi(K)}(q^2)$ for several selected values of $q^2$, is provided and also the corresponding covariance matrix is available. At zero 4-momentum transfer we get: $f_+^{D \to \pi}(0) = 0.612 ~ (35)$ and $f_+^{D \to K}(0) = 0.765 ~ (31)$. Using the experimental averages for $|V_{cd}| f_+^{D \to \pi}(0)$ and $|V_{cs}| f_+^{D \to K}(0)$, we extract $|V_{cd}| = 0.2330 ~ (137)$ and $|V_{cs}| = 0.945 ~ (38)$, respectively. The second-row of the CKM matrix is found to be in agreement with unitarity within the current uncertainties: $|V_{cd}|^2 + |V_{cs}|^2 + |V_{cb}|^2 = 0.949 ~ (78)$.

Nucleon structure functions from the NJL-model chiral soliton

We present numerical simulations for unpolarized and polarized structure functions in a chiral soliton model. The soliton is constructed self-consistently from quark fields from which the structure functions are extracted. Central to the project is regularizing the Dirac sea (or vacuum) contribution to structure functions directly from the regularized action functional that defines the model. In turn, the structure functions are obtained from matrix elements of symmetry currents without assumptions on the nature of quark bilocal and bilinear operators. We discuss in detail how sum rules are realized at the level of the quark wave-functions in momentum space. The comparison with experimental data is convincing for the polarized structure functions but exhibits some discrepancies in the unpolarized case. The vacuum contribution to the polarized structure functions is particularly small.

Representations of relativistic particles of arbitrary spin in Poincaré, Lorentz, and Euclidean covariant formulations of relativistic quantum mechanics

Relativistic treatments of quantum mechanical systems are important for understanding hadronic structure and dynamics at sub-nucleon distance scales. Hadronic states in different inertial reference frames are needed to compute current matrix elements that probe hadronic structure and dynamics. Relativistic invariance is an important consideration as the resolution of the probe is increased. Many different treatments of relativistic dynamics are used in practice, including Poincar\'e covariant methods, Lorentz covariant methods, Euclidean covariant methods and methods based on quantum fields. Wave functions are typically matrix elements of interacting relativistic states in a basis of non-interacting relativistic states. The purpose of this work is to develop the relation between these different representations of relativistic states that are used in different applications from a unified point of view, starting with positive mass irreducible representations of the Poincar\'e group.

Unambiguous extraction of the electromagnetic form factors for spin-1 particles on the light-front

The electromagnetic form factors of a composite vector particle within the light-front formulation of the Mandelstam formula is investigated. In order to extract the form factors from the matrix elements of the plus component of the current in the Drell–Yan frame, where the momentum transfer is chosen such that q+=q0+q3=0, one has in principle the freedom to choose between different linear combinations of matrix elements of the current operator. The different prescriptions to calculate the electromagnetic form factors, G0,G1 and G2, i.e.; charge form factor, magnetic and quadrupole respectively. If the covariance is respected, all prescriptions give the same results; misfortune, is not the situation; the light-front approach produce different results, which depend of the prescriptions as utilized to extract the electromagnetic form factors in the case of the spin-1 particles. The main differences of the prescriptions appear because of the light-front matrix elements of the electromagnetic current are contaminated by the zero-modes contributions to the same with the plus component of the matrix elements of the electromagnetic current. However, the Inna Grach prescription is immune to the zero-modes contributions to the electromagnetic current, then the electromagnetic form factors extracted with that prescriptions do not have zero-modes contribution and give the same result compared with the instant form quantum field theory. Another's prescriptions with the light-front approach are contaminated by the zero-modes contributions to the matrix elements of the electromagnetic current with the plus component of the current. With some relations between the electromagnetic matrix elements of the electromagnetic current Jji+, as demonstrated analytical here, it was possible to calculate the electromagnetic form factors for spin-1 particles without zero-modes or non-valence contributions.