Recently, The Journal of British Studies published my response to Professor Richard Davis's assertion that my arguments concerning the sources of the effective demand for parliamentary reform in the years immediately preceding the first Reform Act were an hallucination (Is 'The Other Face of Reform' in Bucks an 'Hallucination?' XV, 2 [1976], 150-58), and Davis's reply, in which he not only reiterated his assertion but admonished me to be thorough and more careful (Yes, ibid., 159-61). Readers may remember that Davis's admonition concerned my use of The Times instead of a local paper to discover what happened at a meeting in Aylesbury on 24 February 1830. They may remember, too, that the immediate importance of the meeting derived from the use Davis made of it in his book, Political Change and Continuity, 1760-1885: a Buckinghamshire Study (Newton Abbot, 1972; Hamden, Conn., 1972). As he explained in his book, this meeting was undoubtedly a part of Moore's 'country' reform (p. 80). Ostensibly, however, it showed that this movement bore no relationship at all to the issues I had emphasized. In particular, there was the currency question with which, ostensibly, no one at the meeting--indeed, no one in Bucks-was concerned. Readers may recall, further, that when my curiosity had been thus aroused, I read the report of the meeting in The Times for 1 March 1830 -this paper being readily available while the Bucks Gazette for 27 February 1830, which Davis cited as the source of his information, was not. Thereby reassured-for, according to The Times's report, the currency question was heavily emphasized by almost every speaker at the meeting even though it was not mentioned in the resolutions adopted at the meetingI wrote my response, quoting from the statements of some speakers, alluding to the statements of others, to illustrate the importance which they attributed to the question. o e Thoughts on Thoroughness and arefulness Suggested by Comparing e Reports of the Aylesbury Meeting 24 February 1830 in The Times
Read full abstract