One of the most challenging tasks in the design of the inner fuel cycle system lies in the effective design of Tritium Extraction System (TES), which involves proper extraction and purification of tritium in a fusion reactor. A prototype Hydrogen Isotopes Recovery System (HIRS) is being developed to validate the concepts for tritium extraction by adsorption mass transfer mechanism. The two main systems of HIRS are Atmospheric Molecular Sieve Bed (AMSB) adsorber and Cryogenic Molecular Sieve Bed (CMSB) adsorber. AMSB removes ppm levels of water vapour while CMSB removes ppm levels of hydrogen isotopes, oxygen and nitrogen gas from Helium purge gas. Selection of appropriate adsorbents for the HIRS is important for its efficient functioning. Adsorbents, namely, Zeolites 3A, 4A, 5A, 13X and Activated Carbon have been studied in detail at cryogenic temperatures to understand their surface characteristics and adsorption potential. In this work, we have generated the adsorption isotherms for hydrogen isotopes on potential adsorbents using a volumetric adsorption apparatus for a wide range of pressure from 1 Pa to 105 Pa. The BET and DFT models are applied for the determination of the textural properties of the adsorbents and the Langmuir-Freundlich composite model is used to fit the isotherm data. The parameters of the model were determined using nonlinear regression analysis. The enthalpy of adsorption is determined and is in the range of 8–11.5 kJ/mol for the adsorbate loadings corresponding to the partial pressure of hydrogen isotopes of ∼ 50–500 Pa in the TES. At low pressures of hydrogen isotopes, the free energy plot followed Henry’s law. The isotherms and enthalpy of adsorption clearly indicate reversible physisorption and monolayer formation of hydrogen isotopes on the potential adsorbents. Amongst hydrogen and deuterium, hydrogen is more strongly adsorbed on Zeolites 4A, whereas deuterium is more strongly adsorbed on Zeolites 13X. In case of activated carbon, no isotopic selectivity was observed. This study facilitates the selection of potential adsorbents for the CMSB and quantification of the parameters associated with the adsorbents.