AbstractCold and diffuse hydrothermal circulation on mid‐ocean ridge flanks impacts heat and fluid fluxes between the seafloor and the ocean. One mode of this circulation is given by outcrop‐to‐outcrop flow, where seawater circulates through a crustal aquifer that connects two or more recharging and discharging seamounts or basement highs that outcrop through the less permeable sediment cover. The physical mechanism driving this flow is a lateral pressure gradient that is sustained by contrasting the hydrological properties of the recharging and discharging outcrops. To investigate the physical controls of this pressure gradient, we performed two‐dimensional numerical simulations of coupled heat transfer and fluid flow. We have modified aquifer permeability, outcrop permeability and width, outcrop distance, and sediment thickness to assess their mutual effects on the lateral pressure differences. We have also investigated how different flow patterns, resulting from changes in these parameters, manifest themselves in seafloor observables such as flow rates, aquifer temperatures, and heat flow. Our models show that outcrop‐to‐outcrop flow generally occurs for aquifer permeabilities ≥10−14 m2, depending on the basal heat input. High aquifer permeabilities correspond to fast flow rates and low fluid temperatures, whereas the maximum lateral pressure differences arise for lower permeabilities. The permeability and the geometric shape of the outcrops determine the flow direction, while the aquifer temperature is also affected by the distance between the outcrops. Thicker sediments increase the lateral pressure difference and the flow rate. Our models thus provide constraints for predicting subseafloor hydrothermal ridge flank flow behavior from regional field data.