Cruciform Extrusion Research Articles

Why the DNA self-depurination mechanism operates in HB-β but not in β-globin paralogs HB-δ, HB-ɛ1, HB-γ1 and HB-γ2

The human β-globin, δ-globin and ɛ-globin genes contain almost identical coding strand sequences centered about codon 6 having potential to form a stem-loop with a 5′GAGG loop. Provided with a sufficiently stable stem, such a structure can self-catalyze depurination of the loop 5′G residue, leading to a potential mutation hotspot. Previously, we showed that such a hotspot exists about codon 6 of β-globin, with by far the highest incidence of mutations across the gene, including those responsible for 6 anemias (notably Sickle Cell Anemia) and β-thalassemias. In contrast, we show here that despite identical loop sequences, there is no mutational hotspot in the δ- or ɛ1-globin potential self-depurination sites, which differ by only one or two base pairs in the stem region from that of the β-globin gene. These differences result in either one or two additional mismatches in the potential 7-base pair-forming stem region, thereby weakening its stability, so that either DNA cruciform extrusion from the duplex is rendered ineffective or the lifetime of the stem-loop becomes too short to permit self-catalysis to occur. Having that same loop sequence, paralogs HB-γ1 and HB-γ2 totally lack stem-forming potential. Hence the absence in δ- and ɛ1-globin genes of a mutational hotspot in what must now be viewed as non-functional homologs of the self-depurination site in β-globin. Such stem-destabilizing variants appeared early among vertebrates and remained conserved among mammals and primates. Thus, this study has revealed conserved sequence determinants of self-catalytic DNA depurination associated with variability of mutation incidence among human β-globin paralogs.

SIST: stress-induced structural transitions in superhelical DNA.

Supercoiling imposes stress on a DNA molecule that can drive susceptible sequences into alternative non-B form structures. This phenomenon occurs frequently in vivo and has been implicated in biological processes, such as replication, transcription, recombination and translocation. SIST is a software package that analyzes sequence-dependent structural transitions in kilobase length superhelical DNA molecules. The numerical algorithms in SIST are based on a statistical mechanical model that calculates the equilibrium probability of transition for each base pair in the domain. They are extensions of the original stress-induced duplex destabilization (SIDD) method, which analyzes stress-driven DNA strand separation. SIST also includes algorithms to analyze B-Z transitions and cruciform extrusion. The SIST pipeline has an option to use the DZCBtrans algorithm, which analyzes the competition among these three transitions within a superhelical domain. The package and additional documentation are freely available at https://bitbucket.org/benhamlab/sist_codes. dzhabinskaya@ucdavis.edu.

DNA Secondary Structure Formation in Bacterial Gene Capture Systems at Single-Molecule Resolution

Bacteria with multiple antibiotic resistances are a threat to human health. These resistances spread faster than could be expected from mutations alone. It was shown that bacteria exhibit a mechanism of exchanging and collecting genetic sections - coding for antibiotic resistances or other adaptive traits - between individuals or even across species boundaries.This mechanism relies on genetic elements termed integrons. They allow the incorporation and expression of exogenous gene cassettes through a site-specific recombination process. The process involves an enzyme, integrase, which mediates recombination between a double stranded integron recombination site (attI site) and a single-stranded cassette recombination site (attC site). The attC site is supposably recognized by integrase through specificity to the secondary structure of the DNA hairpin formed by the single-stranded attC site (1).This poses the question of how the DNA hairpin forms inside the living cell. It was shown in vivo that negative superhelicity promotes integron recombination, most likely through cruciform extrusion from double-stranded DNA (2).Here, we use single-molecule FRET and magnetic tweezers to study the formation of the postulated DNA hairpin in the presence of various proteins. We present data on the competition between SSB and integrase and on the extrusion of E. coli attC sites from dsDNA and their interaction with integrase hinting at possible molecular mechanisms underlying the function of this system in bacteria.1. Mazel, D. 2006. Integrons: agents of bacterial evolution. Nat Rev Micro. 4: 608-620.2. Loot, C., D. Bikard, A. Rachlin, and D. Mazel. 2010. Cellular pathways controlling integron cassette site folding. EMBO J. 29: 3745-3745.

Competitive superhelical transitions involving cruciform extrusion

A DNA molecule under negative superhelical stress becomes susceptible to transitions to alternate structures. The accessible alternate conformations depend on base sequence and compete for occupancy. We have developed a method to calculate equilibrium distributions among the states available to such systems, as well as their average thermodynamic properties. Here we extend this approach to include superhelical cruciform extrusion at both perfect and imperfect inverted repeat (IR) sequences. We find that short IRs do not extrude cruciforms, even in the absence of competition. But as the length of an IR increases, its extrusion can come to dominate both strand separation and B-Z transitions. Although many IRs are present in human genomic DNA, we find that extrusion-susceptible ones occur infrequently. Moreover, their avoidance of transcription start sites in eukaryotes suggests that cruciform formation is rarely involved in mechanisms of gene regulation. We examine a set of clinically important chromosomal translocation breakpoints that occur at long IRs, whose rearrangement has been proposed to be driven by cruciform extrusion. Our results show that the susceptibilities of these IRs to cruciform formation correspond closely with their observed translocation frequencies.

Self-catalyzed Site-specific Depurination of G Residues Mediated by Cruciform Extrusion in Closed Circular DNA Plasmids

A major variety of "spontaneous" genomic damage is endogenous generation of apurinic sites. Depurination rates vary widely across genomes, occurring with higher frequency at "depurination hot spots." Recently, we discovered a site-specific self-catalyzed depurinating activity in short (14-18 nucleotides) DNA stem-loop-forming sequences with a 5'-G(T/A)GG-3' loop and T·A or G·C as the first base pair at the base of the loop; the 5'-G residue of the loop self-depurinates at least 10(5)-fold faster than random "spontaneous" depurination at pH 5. Formation of the catalytic intermediate for self-depurination in double-stranded DNA requires a stem-loop to extrude as part of a cruciform. In this study, evidence is presented for self-catalyzed depurination mediated by cruciform formation in plasmid DNA in vitro. Cruciform extrusion was confirmed, and its extent was quantitated by digestion of the plasmid with single strand-specific mung bean endonuclease, followed by restriction digestion and sequencing of resulting mung bean-generated fragments. Appearance of the apurinic site in the self-depurinating stem-loop was confirmed by digestion of plasmid DNA with apurinic endonuclease IV, followed by primer extension and/or PCR amplification to detect the endonuclease-generated strand break and identify its location. Self-catalyzed depurination was contingent on the plasmid being supercoiled and was not observed in linearized plasmids, consistent with the presence of the extruded cruciform in the supercoiled plasmid and not in the linear one. These results indicate that self-catalyzed depurination is not unique to single-stranded DNA; rather, it can occur in stem-loop structures extruding from double-stranded DNA and therefore could, in principle, occur in vivo.

Real-time detection of cruciform extrusion by single-molecule DNA nanomanipulation

During cruciform extrusion, a DNA inverted repeat unwinds and forms a four-way junction in which two of the branches consist of hairpin structures obtained by self-pairing of the inverted repeats. Here, we use single-molecule DNA nanomanipulation to monitor in real-time cruciform extrusion and rewinding. This allows us to determine the size of the cruciform to nearly base pair accuracy and its kinetics with second-scale time resolution. We present data obtained with two different inverted repeats, one perfect and one imperfect, and extend single-molecule force spectroscopy to measure the torque dependence of cruciform extrusion and rewinding kinetics. Using mutational analysis and a simple two-state model, we find that in the transition state intermediate only the B-DNA located between the inverted repeats (and corresponding to the unpaired apical loop) is unwound, implying that initial stabilization of the four-way (or Holliday) junction is rate-limiting. We thus find that cruciform extrusion is kinetically regulated by features of the hairpin loop, while rewinding is kinetically regulated by features of the stem. These results provide mechanistic insight into cruciform extrusion and help understand the structural features that determine the relative stability of the cruciform and B-form states.

Real-Time Detection of Cruciform Extrusion by Single-Molecule DNA Nanomanipulation

Cruciform extrusion in dsDNA can occur when a DNA palindrome is subjected to physiological levels of negative supercoiling. Here we use single-DNA nanomanipulation to explore the kinetic and structural properties of cruciform extrusion induced by negative supercoiling. Cruciform extrusion appears as an abrupt increase in the extension of negatively supercoiled DNA, and the amplitude of the change in extension is proportional to the number of bases in the cruciform. The kinetics of this two-state system, B-DNA and cruciform DNA, can be tuned by negative supercoiling which destabilizes the former and stabilizes the latter. The rate of extrusion is controlled by the size of the apical loop, decreasing as the loop size is increased from 5 to 8 bases. Cruciform rewinding is controlled by features in the stem. Perfect cruciforms will tend to extrude irreversibly, whereas shortening and addition of imperfections to a stem can render extrusion reversible. From measurements of the effect of torque on extrusion/rewinding kinetics we propose that in the transition state to cruciform extrusion the palindrome is unwound in the unpaired loop region of the cruciform. These results provide insight into the mechanism of cruciform extrusion and help to understand the potential role of these structures in processes of genomic instability as well as those underpinning the synthesis of non-coding RNAs.

Mus81-Dependent Double-Strand DNA Breaks at In Vivo-Generated Cruciform Structures in S. cerevisiae

Long DNA palindromes are implicated in chromosomal rearrangement, but their roles in the underlying molecular events remain a matter of conjecture. One notion is that palindromes induce DNA breaks after assuming a cruciform structure, the four-way DNA junction providing a target for cleavage by Holliday junction (HJ)-specific enzymes. Though compelling, few components of the "cruciform resolution" proposal are established. Here we address fundamental properties and genetic dependencies of palindromic DNA metabolism in eukaryotes. Plasmid-borne palindromes introduced into S. cerevisiae are site-specifically broken in vivo, and the breaks exhibit unique hallmarks of an HJ resolvase mechanism. In vivo resolution requires Mus81, for which the bacterial HJ resolvase RusA will substitute. These results provide confirmation of cruciform extrusion and resolution in the context of eukaryotic chromatin. Related observations are that, unchecked by a nuclease function provided by Mre11, episomal palindromes launch a self-perpetuating breakage-fusion-bridge-independent copy number increase termed "escape."

Cruciform extrusion propensity of human translocation-mediating palindromic AT-rich repeats

There is an emerging consensus that secondary structures of DNA have the potential for genomic instability. Palindromic AT-rich repeats (PATRRs) are a characteristic sequence identified at each breakpoint of the recurrent constitutional t(11;22) and t(17;22) translocations in humans, named PATRR22 (∼600 bp), PATRR11 (∼450 bp) and PATRR17 (∼190 bp). The secondary structure-forming propensity in vitro and the instability in vivo have been experimentally evaluated for various PATRRs that differ regarding their size and symmetry. At physiological ionic strength, a cruciform structure is most frequently observed for the symmetric PATRR22, less often for the symmetric PATRR11, but not for the other PATRRs. In wild-type E. coli, only these two PATRRs undergo extensive instability, consistent with the relatively high incidence of the t(11;22) in humans. The resultant deletions are putatively mediated by central cleavage by the structure-specific endonuclease SbcCD, indicating the possibility of a cruciform conformation in vivo. Insertion of a short spacer at the centre of the PATRR22 greatly reduces both its cruciform extrusion in vitro and instability in vivo. Taken together, cruciform extrusion propensity depends on the length and central symmetry of the PATRR, and is likely to determine the instability that leads to recurrent translocations in humans.

Intercalators: Contra cruciform extrusion in DNA

Although there is a wealth of structural and theoretical data relating to palindromic sequences in genomes, the mechanisms of extrusion of cruciform structures during various biological processes in the presence of intercalating agents are still poorly understood. The current study addresses the effects of temperature and intercalator on cruciform extrusion from plasmids and also considers the effects of divalent metal ions on cruciform extrusion. It presents evidence that the cytotoxic effects of certain DNA binding drugs in vivo occur over concentration ranges corresponding to those that modulate cruciform extrusion in vitro. The results confirm earlier studies showing an inverse relationship between the effects of negative superhelicity and temperature on cruciform extrusion. By extrapolation, divalent metal ions facilitate cruciform extrusion by increasing superhelicity. The results allow the concentrations that preclude cruciform extrusion in DNA to be determined, and these are potentially informative about the relationships among temperature, DNA helical winding, cruciform formation, and intercalation. Overall, we provide new and interesting insights into the potential role of cruciform structures in biology and, by implication, cancer therapy.

Detection of cruciform extrusion in DNA by temperature-gradient gel electrophoresis

Repetitive sequences in DNA molecules, some of which are palindromic, tend to form stable cruciforms. These are frequently located in promoter regions of a specific operon and origin of replication. Temperature gradient gel electrophoresis can be used to distinguish among various supercoiled DNA topoisomers and to ascertain whether or not the cruciform motif has been extruded. In the current study, this technique is implemented for the first time to address the role of temperature in cruciform extrusion from plasmids.

Extrusion of an imperfect palindrome to a cruciform in superhelical DNA: complete determination of energetics using a statistical mechanical model

We present a detailed study of the extrusion of an imperfect palindrome, derived from the terminal regions of vaccinia virus DNA and contained in a superhelical plasmid, into a cruciform containing bulged bases. We monitor the course of extrusion by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis experiments as a function of temperature and linking number. We find that extrusion pauses at partially extruded states as negative superhelicity increases. To understand the course of extrusion with changes in linking number, Δ Lk, we present a rigorous semiempirical statistical mechanical analysis that includes complete coupling between Δ Lk, cruciform extrusion, formation of extrahelical bases, and temperature-dependent denaturation. The imperfections in the palindrome are sequentially incorporated into the cruciform arms as hairpin loops, single unpaired bases, and complex local regions containing several unpaired bases. We analyze the results to determine the free energies, enthalpies and entropies of formation of all local structures involved in extrusion. We find that, for each unpaired structure, the Δ G, Δ H and Δ S of formation are all approximately proportional to the number of unpaired bases contained therein. This surprising result holds regardless of the arrangement or composition of unpaired bases within a particular structure. Imperfections have major effects on the overall energetics of cruciform extrusion and on the course of this transition. In particular, the extent of the Δ Lk change necessary to extrude an imperfect palindrome is considerably greater than that required for extrusion of the underlying perfect palindrome. Our analysis also suggests that, at higher temperatures, significant denaturation at the base of an imperfect cruciform can successfully compete with extension of the cruciform arms.

Magnesium concentration effects on cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA examined by atomic force microscopy

Cruciform structures can form in DNA sequences with inverted repeats or palindromic symmetry under unwinding torsional stress. DNA repeats are widespread in the genomes of eukaryotes and prokaryotes, and their extrusion into cruciform structures may be involved in various genetic processes, including transcription and replication. Intracellular Mg 2+ may change the free energy of supercoiling to provide the driving force for cruciform extrusion. We have used atomic force microscopy (AFM) to image the effects of magnesium concentrations on cruciform extrusions in supercoiled DNA. Mg 2+ concentration dependent cruciform extrusions were observed in the supercoiled topoisomer of the pPR-PARP plasmid (〈 σ〉=−0.065). These data show an application of AFM imaging to demonstrate that the presence of Mg 2+ results in increased extrusions and promotes compact cruciform conformation.

Role of the Double-Strand Origin Cruciform in pT181 Replication

pT181 is a small rolling-circle plasmid from Staphylococcus aureus whose initiator protein, RepC, melts the plasmid's double-strand origin (DSO) and extrudes a cruciform involving IR II, a palindrome flanking the initiation nick site. We have hypothesized that the cruciform is required for initiation, providing a single-stranded region for the assembly of the replisome (R. Jin et al., 1997, EMBOJ. 16, 4456–4566). In this study, we have tested the requirement for cruciform extrusion by disrupting the symmetry of the IR II palindrome or by increasing its length. The modified DSOs were tested for replication with RepC in trans. Rather surprisingly, disruption of the IR II symmetry had no detectable effect on replication or on competitivity of the modified DSO, though plasmids with IR II disrupted were less efficiently relaxed than the wild type by RepC. However, in conjunction with IR II disruption, modification of the tight RepC binding site IR III blocked replication. These results define two key elements of the pT181 initiation mechanism—the IR II conformation and the RepC binding site (IR III)—and they indicate that pT181 replication initiation is sufficiently robust to be able to compensate for significant modifications in the configuration of the DSO.

Evidence for two mechanisms of palindrome-stimulated deletion in Escherichia coli: single-strand annealing and replication slipped mispairing.

Spontaneous deletion mutations often occur at short direct repeats that flank inverted repeat sequences. Inverted repeats may initiate genetic rearrangements by formation of hairpin secondary structures that block DNA polymerases or are processed by structure-specific endonucleases. We have investigated the ability of inverted repeat sequences to stimulate deletion of flanking direct repeats in Escherichia coli. Propensity for cruciform extrusion in duplex DNA correlated with stimulation of flanking deletion, which was partially sbcD dependent. We propose two mechanisms for palindrome-stimulated deletion, SbcCD dependent and SbcCD independent. The SbcCD-dependent mechanism is initiated by SbcCD cleavage of cruciforms in duplex DNA followed by RecA-independent single-strand annealing at the flanking direct repeats, generating a deletion. Analysis of deletion endpoints is consistent with this model. We propose that the SbcCD-independent pathway involves replication slipped mispairing, evoked from stalling at hairpin structures formed on the single-stranded lagging-strand template. The skew of SbcCD-independent deletion endpoints with respect to the direction of replication supports this hypothesis. Surprisingly, even in the absence of palindromes, SbcD affected the location of deletion endpoints, suggesting that SbcCD-mediated strand processing may also accompany deletion unassociated with secondary structures.

Effect of Magnesium on Cruciform Extrusion in Supercoiled DNA

Recently, it was reported that Mg2+greatly facilitates cruciform extrusion in the short palindromes of supercoiled DNA, thereby allowing the formation of cruciform structures in vivo. Because of the potential biological importance of this phenomenon, we undertook a broader study of the effect of Mg2+on a cruciform extrusion in supercoiled DNA. The method of two-dimensional gel electrophoresis was used to detect the cruciform extrusion both in the absence and in the presence of these ions. Our results show that Mg2+shifts the cruciform extrusion in the d(CCC(AT)16GGG) palindrome to a higher, rather than to a lower level of supercoiling. In order to study possible sequence-specific properties of the short palindromes for which the unusual cruciform extrusion in the presence Mg2+was reported, we constructed a plasmid with a longer palindromic region. This region bears the same sequences in the hairpin loops and four-arm junction as the short palindrome, except that the short stems of the hairpins are extended. The extension allowed us to overcome the limitation of our experimental approach which cannot be used for very short palindromes. Our results show that Mg2+also shifts the cruciform extrusion in this palindrome to a higher level of supercoiling. These data suggest that cruciform extrusion in the short palindromes at low supercoiling is highly improbable. We performed a thermodynamic analysis of the effect of Mg2+on cruciform extrusion. The treatment accounted for the effect of Mg2+on both free energy of supercoiling and the free energy of cruciform structure per se. Our analysis showed that although the level of supercoiling required for the cruciform extrusion is not reduced by Mg2+, the ions reduce the free energy of the cruciform structure.

C1 Inhibitor Gene Sequence Facilitates Frameshift Mutations

Mutations disrupting the function or production of C1 inhibitor cause the disease hereditary angioneurotic edema. Patient mutations identified an imperfect inverted repeat sequence that was postulated to play a mechanistic role in the mutations. To test this hypothesis, the inverted repeat was cloned into the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene in pBR325 and its mutation rate was studied in four bacterial strains. These strains were selected to assay the effects of recombination and superhelical tension on mutation frequency. Mutations that revert bacteria to chloramphenicol resistance (Cmr) were scored. Both pairs of isogenic strains had reversion frequencies of approximately 10(-8). These rare reversion events in bacteria were most often a frameshift that involved the imperfect inverted repeat with a deletion or a tandem duplication, an event very similar to the human mutations. Increased DNA superhelical tension, which would be expected to enhance cruciform extrusion, did not accentuate mutagenesis. This finding suggests that the imperfect inverted repeat may form a stem-loop structure in the single-stranded DNA created by the duplex DNA melting prior to replication. Models explaining the slippage can be drawn using the lagging strand of the replication fork. In this model, the formation of a stem-loop structure is responsible for bringing the end of the deletion or duplication into close proximity.

Quasipalindrome Instability in the C1 Inhibitor Gene • 20

Mutations disrupting the function or production of C1 inhibitor cause hereditary angioneurotic edema. Frameshift mutations in separate kindred identified an imperfect inverted repeat sequence that was postulated to play a mechanistic role in the mutations. This inverted repeat was cloned into the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase gene in pBR325 and its mutation rate was studied in four bacterial strains. These strains were selected to assay for effects of recombination and superhelical tension on mutation frequency. Mutations that revert bacteria to chloramphenicol resistance (Cmr) were scored. The recombination proficient cell line RR1 did not produce revertants. The other recombination deficient cell lines had reversion frequencies of approximately 10-9. These rare reversion events in bacteria were most often a frameshift that involved the imperfect inverted repeat with a deletion or a tandem duplication, an event very similar to the human mutations. Increased DNA superhelical tension, that would be expected to enhance cruciform extrusion, did not accentuate mutagenesis (p=0.081). This finding suggests that the imperfect inverted repeat may form a stem loop structure in the single stranded DNA created by the duplex DNA melting prior to replication, and models explaining the slippage can be drawn using the lagging strand of the replication fork. Such intrinsically unstable DNA may have facilitated the apparent enhanced regional evolutionary rate that has been observed in the serine protease inhibitors, the protein superfamily to which C1 inhibitor belongs.

Why is the initiation nick site of an AT-rich rolling circle plasmid at the tip of a GC-rich cruciform?

pT181 and other closely related rolling circle plasmids have the nicking site for initiation of replication between the arms of a GC-rich inverted repeat sequence adjacent to the binding site for the dimeric initiator protein. Replication is initiated by the initiator-induced extrusion of this sequence as a cruciform, creating a single-stranded region for nicking by the protein. Nicking is followed by assembly of the replisome without relaxation of the secondary structure. Following termination, the initiator protein is released with a short oligonucleotide attached to one subunit, which prevents it from being recycled, a necessary feature of the plasmid's replication control system. The modified initiator can cleave single-stranded substrates and can nick and relax supercoiled plasmid DNA weakly. Although it can bind to its recognition sequence in the leading strand origin, the modified protein cannot induce cruciform extrusion, and it is proposed that this inability is the key to understanding the biological rationale for having the nicking site at the tip of a cruciform: the need to provide the functional initiator with a catalytic advantage over the modified one sufficient to offset the numerical advantage and metabolic stability of the latter.

A 140-bp-long palindromic sequence induces double-strand breaks during meiosis in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Palindromic sequences have the potential to form hairpin or cruciform structures, which are putative substrates for several nucleases and mismatch repair enzymes. A genetic method was developed to detect such structures in vivo in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Using this method we previously showed that short hairpin structures are poorly repaired by the mismatch repair system in S. cerevisiae. We show here that mismatches, when present in the stem of the hairpin structure, are not processed by the repair machinery, suggesting that they are treated differently than those in the interstrand base-paired duplex DNA. A 140-bp-long palindromic sequence, on the contrary, acts as a meiotic recombination hotspot by generating a site for a double-strand break, an initiator of meiotic recombination. We suggest that long palindromic sequences undergo cruciform extrusion more readily than short ones. This cruciform structure then acts as a substrate for structure-specific nucleases resulting in the formation of a double-strand break during meiosis in yeast. In addition, we show that residual repair of the short hairpin structure occurs in an MSH2-independent pathway.