Critical Solder Ball Research Articles

Thermo‐mechanical behavior of ball grid packages with different solder ball grid patterns investigated through moiré interferometry

AbstractPlastic ball‐grid array (PBGA) package assembly comprises various materials with different thermo‐mechanical properties, and the solder ball‐grid patterns can significantly influence the package deformation and solder ball stress. This study utilizes moiré interferometry to investigate the deformation behavior of wire bonded plastic ball‐grid array (WB‐PBGA) packages under varying temperatures. Real‐time moiré interferometry experiments were conducted to capture fringe patterns representing package deformation at different temperature stages. Experiments were conducted for three different wire bonded plastic ball‐grid array packages with distinct solder ball array configurations: full grid patterns (WB‐PBGA‐FG) and perimeter patterns with/without central connections (WB‐PBGA‐PC/P). The analysis revealed considerable variations in thermal strain distribution and positioning of the critical solder ball within the package assembly, depending on the solder ball‐grid pattern. Among these wire bonded plastic ball‐grid array packages, WB‐PBGA‐P/C exhibited the most substantial bending deformation, experiencing the highest effective strain, which directly impacts solder ball failure. These findings emphasize the importance of solder ball‐grid patterns in understanding the deformation behavior and reliability of WB‐PBGA packages under varying temperature conditions.

Thermo-mechanical reliability analysis of a RF SiP module based on LTCC substrate

The RF SiP module based on LTCC substrate has attracted considerable attention in wireless communications for the last two decades. However, the thermo-mechanical reliability of this 3D LTCC architecture has not been well-studied as common as its traditional ceramic package structure. A practical RF SiP module based on LTCC substrate was presented and its thermo-mechanical reliability was analyzed in this paper, with emphasis on the reliability of heat reflow process, the operating state and fatigue of second-level solder joints. The configuration and assembly process of the SiP module were briefly introduced at first, and qualitative analysis was made according to the reliability problem that may occur in the manufacturing process and the operating state. Through FEM simulation, this paper studied the warpage and stress variation of the RF SiP module, as well as parametric studies of some key package dimensions. Solder joint reliability under temperature cycling condition was also analyzed in particular in this paper. The results show that for the heat reflow process and operating state, the maximum warpage is both on the top LTCC substrate, but the maximum stresses are on the outermost solder ball and the kovar column at the corner, respectively. There is a large residual stress on the critical solder ball at the end of the reflow process and the key package dimensions has little effect on it. The thickness of top LTCC substrate has a significant impact on the thermal deformation and thermal stress, followed by the height of kovar columns. The reason for the considerable thermal stress on the kovar column is the non-uniform of temperature distribution. The key to reducing thermal deformation and stress in the operating state is the employment of effective cooling measures. It is found by comparison that the reliability of critical solder joints can be greatly improved by adding suitable underfill.

Experimental location of damage in microelectronic solder joints after a board level reliability evaluation

Abstract Reliability evaluation of integrated circuit (IC) packages to assess drop impact is critical, especially in the case of handheld electronic products. The objective of this study is to experimentally identify the location of damage in solder joints in electronic packaging after a board level reliability (BLR) evaluation. The BLR drop test is a useful way to characterize the drop durability of different soldered assemblies onto a printed circuit board (PCB). It is also of great importance when there is a need to evaluate the solder joint between the chip package and PCB through a daisy-chained structure during the evaluation period. However, there is no detailed information available on a pattern ground with a hatched copper PCB layout for high speed responses that are closely related to actual working conditions. In this paper, a fault location on a daisy-chained structure with a pattern ground is shown through a non-destructive analysis using a time-domain reflectometry (TDR) approach. The results obtained in this project indicate that the TDR approach can be used to detect the location of a crack in the string based on changes in the waveform response. The fault location in critical solder balls as predicted by TDR correlate well with experimental observation by cross-section.

Thermal Cycle Consideration in Applying Lead-Free TFBGA Simulation to a Design

Three-dimensional (3D) stacked die packaging has become the trend to improve efficiency for transmitting signals, reduce the volume of the package, and help with functions integration. It is more and more applied popularly in telecommunications. Solder joints, interconnections in the packaging structure, are more easily damaged by critical stress from thermal cycle loading when the component is operating, because the coefficient of the thermal expansion of various materials mismatch. People have studied the common single die during the thermal cycle loading for a long time, but the researches for the stacked die BGA are not as complete. In addition, to protect the environment and comply with legislation, the semiconductor industry wants to find a lead-free material to replace the lead solder joints. Therefore, most extant or new types of packaging started using lead-free material to do thermal cycle testing. The critical solder ball location is not the same as in a single die package where at the die corner, due to it is influenced by stacked die with different geometry, the difference in dice length helps to redistribute the die stress. In this paper, we used FEA software, ANSYS, to build up a 3D thin-profile, fine-pitch, ball grid array (TFBGA) model. The modeling investigated the effect on solder joints under thermal cycle and included deformation, von-Mises stress and strain energy density (SED). Then we utilized Darveaux's approach, which is a common methodology used to calculate the fatigue life based on energy and damage accumulation theories, to predict the fatigue life of the critical solder joint and modify our model with the theory. We changed various kinds of SAC solder joints with different ratios of the components and Anand's constants, analyze the divergence and compared them with the lead solder material. We develop a model to forecast the failure phenomenon and fatigue damage on an electronic package. This would help engineers and designers raise the reliability of the package. In addition, we hope to find a lead-free material that can be substituted for the lead solder material. If this is the case, based on simulating results, we hope to improve it and have much a better reliability performance than the original lead solder.

Application of Optimal Design on Twin Die Stacked Package by Reliability Indicator of Average SED Concept

ABSTRACTThis paper deals with the optimal design for a twin die stacked package. Firstly, the numerical model is built up in terms of a three-dimensional slice model along the diagonal direction of the package. The material behavior of the solder balls is a consequence of the viscoplastic property which can be described by the Anand's model. Secondly, the Darveaux model is applied to predict the solder ball reliability of the stacked die package under a cyclic temperature loading. Since simulation analysis found an obvious relation is found between the fatigue life of the solder ball and the distribution of the accumulated strain energy density (SED) on the critical solder ball of the package through the simulation analysis, the average value of the strain energy density for all solder balls is adopted as the optimization indicator of reliability. With such a viewpoint, the critical solder ball position can be ignored, and accordingly an efficient analysis can be obtained. Finally, the Box-Behnken regression model is adopted to construct all the experiments. Each experiment analyzes the reliability of the package under varying parameters. Subsequently, the pattern search algorithm is applied to search for optimal factors.Through optimal analysis with the fatigue reliability indicator of an average SED, the fatigue life is found to be 59% lower than that of the original design. The fatigue life had clearly improved and the lowest ball fatigue life is found to be 2.859 times longer than the original one.

Thermal Cycling Analysis of BGA Solder Joint Reliability

The solder joint reliability of semiconductor package interconnects is critical to product durability. A dominant failure mode is solder fatigue due to the CTE mismatch between BGA component and PCB at thermal cycling. It is well known that besides thermal expansion mismatch of component and board, the solder joint geometry has a great impact on fatigue behavior and time to failure. In this study, a combination of Surface Evolver and finite element analysis are use to predict the solder joint shapes for the assembly of medium pin count BGA's and to estimate the reliability at accelerated temperature cycling conditions. Results of Surface Evolver are compared with the assumption of a truncated sphere. The solder shape predictions are applied for a subsequent thermo-mechanical analysis of the BGA assembly. Inelastic creep deformation is evaluated for critical solder balls, and the Coffin-Manson relation is used to estimate the solder joint lifetime. The entire simulation procedure will be demonstrated for a product design study for high reliability automotive BGA's. A fractional factorial design is defined that considers solder sphere diameter and solder pad sizes on BGA substrate and on PCB side. Resulting creep values and lifetime estimates will be compared.

Simplified Three-Dimensional Thermomechanical Applications of Ball Grid Array Package

Three dimensional finite element models were created utilizing APDL (ANSYS Parametric Design Language) for typical multi-chip BGAP (Ball Grid Array Packages) with different sizes to analyze the structure stress and strain when loading steady thermal loads upon them. Subsequently an improved modeling approach including equivalent beam and critical solder ball joint for simplification was studied and introduced. The Darveaux method based on plastic deformation energy accumulation for predicting fatigue life of solder ball joint under thermal cyclic loading was applied to the improved model for calculation, and effects of main design parameters upon fatigue life were studied accordingly. The numerical results reflected the stress distribution and varying traits of the package, compare of results between improved model and detailed model indicates that the simplified modeling method is quite effective and available for different types of analysis. Methods and results of this paper are of certain reference value for the design and optimization for similar kind of packages.

Stress Buildup of Sn3.5Ag Soldered Stacked CSPs to Board-Level Drop Impact

Solder balls, albeit mechanically soft, are the only structural support to the stacking of chip-scale packages (CSPs). This paper investigates the structural response of a Sn3.5Ag soldered bi-level stacked CSP module to board-level drop impact per the JEDEC criteria, and quantifies the stress buildup in the critical solder balls. The structural response is understood by tracking the force transmission through this 3-D packaging assembly by an elastic structural analysis, in which the solder plasticity is deliberately excluded. The elastic analysis shows that the solder balls at the ball-out level, which is the bottom level of the stacked package interconnecting to the mounting board, suffer the severest stress buildup. The results suggest that understanding of relative vibration amplitude among each level of the stacked package and the mounting board enables a good estimation of the location of critical solders without detailed modeling. For this stacked CSP module, the critical solders locate at the corners of the center package at the ball-out level. Solder balls are more severely loaded in the 0° orientation drop, about one order of magnitude larger than in the 90° orientation drop. The critical solder balls will be promptly loaded to a state in the highly plastic regime after the impact is initiated, as suggested by detailed finite element analysis which accounts for the strain-hardening of Sn3.5Ag. Larger plastic strain accumulation is observed near the interfaces to the solder pad. The solder balls at the higher level of the stacked packages are likely always free of plastic deformation in the drop testing.

Design and optimization of thermo-mechanical reliability in wafer level packaging

In this paper, a variety of wafer level packaging (WLP) structures, including both fan-in and fan-out WLPs, are investigated for solder joint thermo-mechanical reliability performance, from a structural design point of view. The effects of redistribution layer (RDL), bump structural design/material selection, polymer-cored ball application, and PCB design/material selection are studied. The investigation focuses on four different WLP technologies: standard WLP (ball on I/O WLP), ball on polymer WLP without under bump metallurgy (UBM) layer, ball on polymer WLP with UBM layer, and encapsulated copper post WLP. Ball on I/O WLP, in which solder balls are directly attached to the metal pads on silicon wafer, is used as a benchmark for the analysis. 3-D finite element modeling is performed to investigate the effects of WLP structures, UBM layer, polymer film material properties (in ball on polymer WLP), and encapsulated epoxy material properties (in copper post WLP). Both ball on polymer and copper post WLPs have shown great reliability improvement in thermal cycling. For ball on polymer WLP structures, polymer film between silicon and solder balls creates a ‘cushion’ effect to reduce the stresses in solder joints. Such cushion effect can be achieved either by an extremely compliant film or a ‘hard’ film with a large coefficient of thermal expansion. Encapsulated copper post WLP shows the best thermo-mechanical performance among the four WLP structures. Furthermore, for a fan-out WLP, it has been found that the critical solder balls are the outermost solder balls under die-area, where the maximum thermal mismatch takes place. In a fan-out WLP package, chip size, other than package size, determines the limit of solder joint reliability. This paper also discusses the polymer-cored solder ball applications to enhance thermo-mechanical reliability of solder joints. Finally, both experimental and finite element analysis have demonstrated that making corner balls non-electrically connected can greatly improve the WLP thermo-mechanical reliability.

Fatigue fracture of SnAgCu solder joints by microstructural modeling

The ongoing miniaturization trend in the microelectronic industry enforces component sizes to approach the micron, or even the nano scale. At these scales, the underlying microstructural sizes and the geometrical dimensions are comparable. The increasing influence of microscopic entities on the overall mechanical properties makes conventional continuum material models more and more questionable. In this study, the thermomechanical reliability of lead-free BGA solder balls is investigated by microstructural modeling. Microstructural input is provided by orientation imaging microscopy (OIM), converted into a finite element framework. Blowholes in BGA solder balls are examined by optical microscopy and a statistical analysis on their size, position and frequency is conducted. Combining the microstructural data with the appropriate material models, three dimensional local models are created. The fatigue life of the package is determined through a critical solder ball. The thermomechanical reliability of the local models are predicted using cohesive zone based fatigue damage models. The simulation results are validated by statistical analyses provided by the industry.

Damage Initiation and Propagation in Voided Joints: Modeling and Experiment

This study examines damage initiation and propagation in solder joints with voids, under thermomechanical cyclic loading. An accelerated thermal cycling test is conducted on printed wiring assemblies (PWAs) containing 256 input/output (I/O) plastic ball grid arrays (PBGAs) with voided solder joints. Destructive and nondestructive failure analyses of the solder balls are used to detect the presence of voids and to relate the extent of damage propagation to the number of thermal cycles. Particular cases of voided and damaged joints are selected from these tests, to guide the development of a strategy for modeling damage propagation, using a three dimensional global-local finite element analysis (FEA). The displacement results of the global FEA at the top and bottom of the selected solder balls are used as the boundary conditions in a local FEA model, which focuses on the details of damage initiation and propagation in the individual solder ball. The local model is error seeded with voids based on cases selected in experiment. The damage propagation rate is monitored for all the cases. The technique used to quantify cyclic creep-fatigue damage is a continuum model based on energy partitioning. A method of successive initiation is used to model the growth and propagation of damage in the selected case studies. The modeling approach is qualitatively verified using the results of the accelerated thermal cycling test. The verified modeling technique described above is then used for parametric study of the durability of voided solder balls in a ChipArray Thin Core BGA with 132 I/O (CTBGA132) assemblies, under thermal cycling. The critical solder ball in the package is selected and is error seeded with voids with different sizes and various distances from damage initiation site. The results show that voids in general are not detrimental to thermal cycling durability of the CTBGA132 assembly, except when a large portion of the damage propagation path is covered with voids. Small voids can arrest the damage propagation, but generally do not provide a significant increase in durability because the damage zone deflects around the void and also continues to propagate from other critical regions in the solder ball.

Advanced Numerical and Experimental Techniques for Analysis of Dynamic Responses and Solder Joint Reliability During Drop Impact

Board level solder joint reliability performance during drop test is a critical concern to semiconductor and electronic product manufacturers. A new JEDEC standard for board level drop test of handheld electronic products was just released to specify the drop test procedure and conditions. However, there is no detailed information stated on dynamic responses of printed circuit board (PCB) and solder joints which are closely related to stress and strain of solder joints that affect the solder joint reliability, nor there is any simulation technique which provides good correlation with experimental measurements of dynamic responses of PCB and the resulting solder joint reliability during the entire drop impact process. In this paper, comprehensive dynamic responses of PCB and solder joints, e.g., acceleration, strains, and resistance, are measured and analyzed with a multichannel real-time electrical monitoring system, and simulated with a novel input acceleration (Input-G) method. The solder joint failure process, i.e., crack initiation, propagation, and opening, is well understood from the behavior of dynamic resistance. It is found experimentally and numerically that the mechanical shock causes multiple PCB bending or vibration which induces the solder joint fatigue failure. It is proven that the peeling stress of the critical solder joint is the dominant failure indicator by simulation, which correlates well with the observations and assumptions by experiment. Coincidence of cyclic change among dynamic resistance of solder joints, dynamic strains of PCB, and the peeling stress of the critical solder joints indicates that the solder joint crack opens and closes when the PCB bends down and up, and the critical solder joint failure is induced by cyclic peeling stress. The failure mode and location of critical solder balls predicted by modeling correlate well with experimental observation by cross section and dye penetration tests

Board level solder joint reliability analysis of stacked die mixed flip-chip and wirebond BGA

Stacked die BGA has recently gained popularity in telecommunication applications. However, its board level solder joint reliability during the thermal cycling test is not as well-studied as common single die BGA. In this paper, solder joint fatigue of lead-free stacked die BGA with mixed flip-chip (FC) and wirebond (WB) interconnect is analyzed in detail. 3D fatigue model is established for stacked die BGA with considerations of detailed pad design, realistic shape of solder ball, and non-linear material properties. The fatigue model applied is based on a modified Darveaux’s approach with non-linear viscoplastic analysis of solder joints. Based on the FC–WB stack die configuration, the critical solder ball is observed located between the top and bottom dice corner, and failure interface is along the top solder/pad interface. The modeling predicted fatigue life is first correlated to the thermal cycling test results using modified correlation constants, curve-fitted from in-house lead-free TFBGA46 (thin-profile fine-pitch BGA) thermal cycling test data. Subsequently, design analyzes are performed to study the effects of 20 key design variations in package dimensions, material properties, and thermal cycling test conditions. In general, thinner PCB and mold compound, thicker substrate, larger top or bottom dice sizes, thicker top die, higher solder ball standoff, larger solder mask opening, smaller PCB pad size, smaller thermal cycling temperature range, longer ramp time, and shorter dwell time contribute to longer fatigue life. SnAgCu is a common lead-free solder, and it has much better board level reliability performance than eutectic solder based on modeling results, especially low stress packages.

Impact of the number of chips on the reliability of the solder balls for wire-bonded stacked-chip ball grid array packages

This investigation examines how the number of chips affects the reliability of solder balls for wire-bonded stacked-chip ball grid array packages under thermal cycling tests. The studied objects were packages with one, two, three and four stacked chips. Three-dimensional finite element analysis was utilized to simulate the stress/strain behavior of all studied packages. Two kinds of properties of 63Sn/37Pb eutectic solder were employed individually in the finite element analyses. One property of the solder was assumed to exhibit the elastic–plastic–creep behavior. Temperature-dependent stress/strain curves and Norton’s steady creep equation were used in the analysis. Another property of the solder governed by the Anand’s viscoplastic model was also employed to describe the behavior of solder balls. The simulation results in the elastic–plastic–creep analyses and viscoplastic analyses reveal that the von Mises stress, the non-linear strain, and the inelastic strain energy density of the critical solder balls increase with the number of stacked chips, but the increments become gradually stable as the number of chips increases. Three fatigue life prediction models—Darveaux’s model, the modified Coffin–Manson model and the creep-fatigue model—were applied to evaluate the fatigue life of the studied packages. Prediction results indicate that the fatigue life of the solder balls decreases as the number of stacked chips increases, and the decrease in predicted life shows stable behavior as the number of chips increases. The stable trend is consistent with experimental observation in the thermal cycling tests. By comparing with the experimental data, it is shown that the Darveaux’s model gives better prediction than the other two models.

Board level solder joint reliability analysis and optimization of pyramidal stacked die BGA packages

Due to requirements of cost-saving and miniaturization, stacked die BGA has recently gained popularity in many applications. However, its board level solder joint reliability during the thermal cycling test is not as well-studied as common single die BGA. In this paper, solder joint fatigue of wirebond stacked die BGA is analyzed in detail. 3D fatigue model is established for stacked die BGA with considerations of detailed pad design, realistic shape of solder ball, and non-linear material properties. The fatigue model applied is based on a modified Darveaux's approach with non-linear viscoplastic analysis of solder joints. The critical solder ball is observed located between the top and bottom dice corner, and failure interface is along the top solder/pad interface. The modeling predicted fatigue life is first correlated to the thermal cycling test results using modified correlation constants, curve-fitted from in-house TFBGA (thin-profile fine-pitch BGA) thermal cycling test data. Subsequently, design analyses are performed to study the effects of 16 key design variations in package dimensions, material properties, and thermal cycling test conditions. In general, smaller top and bottom dice sizes, thicker top or bottom die, thinner PCB, thicker substrate, higher solder ball standoff, larger solder mask opening size, smaller maximum ball diameter, smaller PCB pad size, smaller thermal cycling temperature range, longer ramp time, and shorter dwell time contribute to longer fatigue life. The effect of number of layers of stacked-die is also investigated. Finally, design optimization is performed based on selected critical design variables.

Impact life prediction modeling of TFBGA packages under board level drop test

Reliability performance of IC packages during drop impact is critical, especially for handheld electronic products. Currently, there is no model that provides good correlation with experimental measurements of acceleration and impact life. In this paper, detailed drop tests and simulations are performed on TFBGA (thin-profile fine-pitch BGA) and VFBGA (very-thin-profile fine-pitch BGA) packages at board level using testing procedures developed in-house. The packages are susceptible to solder joint failures, induced by a combination of PCB bending and mechanical shock during impact. The critical solder ball is observed to occur at the outermost corner solder joint, and fails along the solder and PCB pad interface. Various testing parameters are studied experimentally and analytically, to understand the effects of drop height, drop orientation, number of PCB mounting screws to fixture, position of component on board, PCB bending, solder material, etc. Drop height, felt thickness, and contact conditions are used to fine-tune the shape and level of shock pulse required. Board level drop test can be better controlled, compared with system or product level test such as impact of mobile phone, which sometimes has rather unpredictable results due to higher complexity and variations in drop orientation. At the same time, dynamic simulation is performed to compare with experimental results. The model established has close values of peak acceleration and impact duration as measured in actual drop test. The failure mode and critical solder ball location predicted by modeling correlate well with testing. For the first time, an accurate life prediction model is proposed for board level drop test to estimate the number of drops to failure for a package. For the correlation cases studied, the maximum normal peeling stresses of critical solder joints correlate well with the mean impact lives measured during the drop test. The uncertainty of impact life prediction is within ±4 drops, for a typical test of 50 drops. With this new model, a failure-free state can be determined, and drop test performance of new package design can be quantified, and further enhanced through modeling. This quantitative approach is different from traditional qualitative modeling, as it provides both accurate relative and absolute impact life prediction. The relative performance of package may be different under board level drop test and thermal cycling test. Different design guidelines should be considered, depending on application and area of concern.

Evaluation of thermal deformation model for BGA packages using moiré interferometry

A compact model approach of a network of spring elements for elastic loading is presented for the thermal deformation analysis of BGA package assembly. High-sensitivity moire interferometry is applied to evaluate and calibrated the model quantitatively. Two ball grid array (BGA) package assemblies are employed for moire experiments. For a package assembly with a small global bending, the spring model can predict the boundary conditions of the critical solder ball excellently well. For a package assembly with a large global bending, however, the relative displacements determined by spring model agree well with that by experiment after accounting for the rigid-body rotation. The shear strain results of the FEM with the input from the calibrated compact spring model agree reasonably well with the experimental data. The results imply that the combined approach of the compact spring model and the local FE analysis is an effective way to predict strains and stresses and to determine solder damage of the critical solder ball.

Three-Dimensional Effects of Solder Joints in Micro-Scale BGA Assembly

Micro-scale BGA has attracted more and more interest due to their high performance/area ratio. This technology is especially important for mobile personal equipment, such as cellular phones and laptop computers. With the decrease of solder ball sizes, the reliability problem becomes the major concern for the package design, which requires more powerful tools to address this issue. Finite element method is a useful tool for packaging design and analysis. For some BGAs, the critical solder balls are sometimes not located at a symmetric plane and the deformations in three directions will affect the distribution of stress/strain in these solder balls. Therefore, a full three-dimensional analysis is necessary to address these effects. However, it is almost impossible to run a three-dimensional single finite element model to consider all design details even with simplified material properties, not to mention creep constitutive law. Therefore, the global/local modeling technique provides an alternate way, which can simplify the modeling work’ Significantly, reduce the computational time, and enhance the crucial information at critical locations. In this study, the global/local technique was used to study a micro-scale BGA assembly and to investigate the three-dimensional effects of stress/strain distribution inside the solder joints. It was found that the maximum creep strain is not located at the plane passing through the package center and solder joint axis. It was also found that the position of maximum creep strain will shift during first several cycles, but will stabilize after the fourth cycle. This result is also helpful in evaluating the reliability of the critical solder joints in micro-scale BGA assemblies.