This paper proposes a new adaptive approach called adaptive mean (ADM) that combines the strengths of trimming and winsorization to minimize the mean square error (MSE). ADM will contribute significantly to insurers by enabling them to mitigate risk exposure caused by inaccurate premium estimation and establish more precise premiums for their clients. Furthermore, the proposed mean offers several pros compared to the conventional mean. It facilitates the natural and intuitive calculation of risk loading, identifies and measures the impact of large claims, and analyzes premium susceptibility to skewed risk by capturing the tails of the relevant loss models. In addition, this paper reviews two established, robust credibility methods (trimming and winsorization). It compares them with our proposed method, resulting in a more reliable and robustly accurate method for credibility premium estimation. We presented and analyzed two real data sets from engineering insurance companies and the Wisconsin Office of the Insurance Commissioner to highlight the advances of ADM in minimizing the MSE and building more robust credibility models that are less vulnerable to outlier events and model uncertainty.