The gut microbiome is a dense and diverse community of different microorganisms that deeply influence human physiology and that have important interactions with pathogens. For the correct antibiotic treatment of infections, with its twin goals of effective inhibition of the pathogen and limitation of collateral damage to the microbiome, the identification of infectious organisms is key. Microbiological culturing is still the mainstay of pathogen identification, and anaerobic species are among the most demanding bacterial communities to culture. This study aimed to evaluate the impact of growth media on the culture of an-aerobic bacteria from human stool samples. Stool samples from eight human subjects were cultured each on a yeast extract cysteine blood agar (HCB) and a modified peptone-yeast extract-glucose (MPYG) plate and subjected to Illumina NGS analysis after DNA extraction and amplification. The results showed tight clustering of sequencing samples belonging to the same human subject. Various differences in bacterial richness and evenness could be observed between the two media, with HCB plates supporting the growth of a more diverse microbial community, and MPYG plates improving the growth rates of certain taxa. No statistical significance was observed between the groups. This study highlights the importance of choosing the appropriate growth media for anaerobic bacterial culture and adjusting culture conditions to target specific pathological conditions. HCB plates are suitable for standard microbiological diagnostics, while MPYG plates may be more appropriate for targeting specific conditions. This work emphasizes the role of next-generation sequencing in supporting future research in clinical microbiology.