PurposeTo evaluate the image quality of an ultra-fast CBCT system - Varian HyperSight. MethodsIn this evaluation, five-studies were performed to assess the image quality of HyperSight CBCT. First, a HyperSight CBCT image quality evaluation was performed and compared with Siemens simulation-CT and Varian TrueBeam CBCT. Second, a visual comparison of image quality among simulation-CTs, HyperSight CBCT and TrueBeam CBCT was performed for a head-and-neck patient, and patients with metal dental fillings and prosthesis. Third, the HU vs electron density curve of HyperSight CBCT was compared with GE and Siemens simulation-CTs. Fourth, Siemens simulation-CT and HyperSight CBCT scans were acquired on the Catphan setting-up at different locations inside the bore (±10cm in all three principal directions from the center), and the HU variations for different materials were evaluated. Fifth, a 4D lung tumor phantom study was performed to assess moving tumor alignment during image registration. ResultsSignificant improvement of image contrast, HU constancy, and noise level on HyperSight CBCT was observed compared to TrueBeam CBCT. Significant image quality improvement was observed on HyperSight CBCT for patients with dental fillings and prosthesis compared to simulation-CT without metal artifact reduction. The linear fit trend-line of HU vs electron density curves for GE simulation-CT, Siemens simulation-CT and HyperSight CBCT showed 0.6% difference for HU value below 2000. The maximum HU difference for HyperSight CBCT when Catphan positioned within ±10cm in all three principal directions was ≤98 on bone 50%, and ≤29 other than bone, and was ≤31 on bone 50%, and ≤17 other than bone for Siemens simulation-CT. Both tumor shape and tumor alignment discrepancies on CBCT scans were observed in 4D phantom study. ConclusionsThis evaluation shows significant image improvement of HyperSight CBCT over conventional CBCT on image contrast, HU constancy, and noise level with scatter correction and metal artifact reduction reconstruction methods. HyperSight CBCT has similar image quality to simulation-CTs, and shows the potential application for treatment planning. The rapid acquisition of HyperSight CBCT showed both tumor shape and tumor alignment discrepancies of moving target. Careful considerations of patient respiratory motion monitoring and target matching are highly recommended.
Read full abstract