Reviewed by: Historic Homes of Bastrop, Texas by Robbie Moore Sanders Kenneth Hafertepe Historic Homes of Bastrop, Texas. By Robbie Moore Sanders, with Sandra Chipley. Photographs by Marker Winslett. (College Station: Texas A&M University Press, 2022. Pp. 240. Notes, index.) The rich architectural heritage of Bastrop, one of the oldest towns in Texas, has long been acknowledged. In the 1930s, the Historic American Buildings Survey (HABS) made measured drawings, took photographs and collected historic data about several of the earliest houses. Moreover, Texas Historical Commission historical markers are abundant. In spite of [End Page 608] this early recognition, there has never been a book dedicated to the buildings of Bastrop. This book seeks to rectify this, covering these early houses but also the charming houses large and small of the Victorian era, colonial revival houses, and bungalows and foursquares of the early twentieth century. This is a very attractive volume. The contemporary photographs are uniformly good, well framed and well lit, allowing the rich variety of Bastrop houses to be showcased. Modern photography is supplemented by a selection of historic photos, both of houses and the people who lived in them, a few photos of related structures, and a few floor plans from HABS. The text, however, is not as ambitious as recent studies of such Texas towns as Waxahachie, Glen Rose, and Waco. The book lacks an introduction and simply begins with a discussion of the first house. An introduction is critical here to orient the reader, if briefly, to the general history of Bastrop and to give some sense of the evolution of the town's houses. This is all the more crucial given that the book is organized by street, which is helpful for anyone attempting a windshield survey of the town, but results in a patchwork quilt of eras and styles. Essentially this book is a composite of existing knowledge rather than an attempt at a new interpretation. The county tax assessor records are occasionally used to good advantage, as are early local newspapers, but most of the house entries are based on notes for historic homes tours, recent newspaper articles, or historical markers. Indeed, sometimes historical markers are quoted in their entirety. (Historical markers may be cast in bronze but they are not writ in stone.) Moreover, the entries are so focused on the individual properties that there is no attempt to show how they fit in with the rest of Bastrop houses, much less other Texan or American examples. The reliance on secondary sources leads to the repetition of a great deal of speculation. In the preface the authors acknowledge that many stories included are "unverifiable" but that they are part of the traditions associated with a house. However, no attempt is made to separate family stories which are verifiable from those that are not. Perhaps the most important primary sources in a book like this are the houses themselves. They must be interrogated to see how they evolved over time and who did what and when. The authors use architectural terminology that is sometimes vague or not in common usage, such as "national style," "farmhouse style" or "pinwheel" floorplan. At times it seems that the term "dogtrot" is used to describe an enclosed central passage rather than a roofed-over open space between rooms. The book also exhibits an antiquarian tendency to date a house by its earliest rooms, even if a few early rooms are later overshadowed by a substantial two-story Victorian addition. The point here is not that early rooms [End Page 609] should not be recognized, but that dating should be nuanced enough to acknowledge later additions that fundamentally change a house. Still, this is a handsome volume, and one may hope that it will stimulate more original research into the architectural heritage of Bastrop. [End Page 610] Kenneth Hafertepe Baylor University Copyright © 2022 The Texas State Historical Association
Read full abstract