THIS fascinating work has long since attained the rank of a classic, but attention may be directed to this new edition, which has various additions, mainly bibliographical, and seven supplements, which are reprints of papers by the author on topics related to that of his famous essay. Two of these can be enjoyed by readers with no exceptional mathematical knowledge. In the one on the equality of the base angles of an isosceles triangle, Dr. Hilbert proves, inter alia, the remarkable fact that, even if we assume Euclid's theory of proportion, we cannot prove his propositions on equalities of area, unless we assume the truth of prop. 4, bk. i., of the “Elements” in the wider sense—that is, when one triangle has to be turned over to make it fit the other. It is also pointed out (p. 68) that two tetrahedra can be constructed with equal heights, and bases of equal area, which cannot be cut up into congruent polyhedra, and to which congruent polyhedra cannot be added in such a way that the solids thus produced can be sliced up into congruent parts. Consequently it is impossible to build up a theory of equality of volumes strictly analogous to Euclid's theory of equality of areas. Grundlagen der Geometrie. By D. Hilbert. Third edition. Pp. vi+280. (Leipzig and Berlin: B. G. Teubner, 1909.) Price 6 marks.
Read full abstract