Abstract Objective Excessive and chronic alcohol use can cause structural/functional abnormalities in the brain, including cognitive impairment (CI) (Harper, 2009). Despite these established risks, alcohol-related dementia (ARD) has received little recognition, mainly due to lack of a distinct pathophysiological profile. Through a case differential approach (concussion vs. ARD), the authors aim to clarify diagnostic criteria for ARD. Methods A 56-year-old right-handed male presented to the emergency room after fall with head strike (no loss of consciousness) with alcohol withdrawal delirium. Symptoms of cerebellar ataxia and CI of 6-month duration were noted. Past medical history was significant for alcohol use (four standard units per day), hyperlipidemia, tobacco use, and depression/anxiety. Neuroimaging revealed cerebral atrophy and chronic small vessel ischemic disease. A neuropsychological evaluation (NPE) was conducted 18 days post-fall. Results NPE revealed relative weaknesses in working memory, complex attention, and visual abstraction. Impairments were noted in visuospatial organization/planning, processing speed, basic attention, verbal fluency, and verbal memory. Motor examination was evident for intention tremor. Conclusion Brain changes associated with ARD include volume loss, altered glucose metabolism, reduced neuronal density, changes in frontal lobe function, and white matter loss. In contrast, individuals affected by concussions may encounter challenges with attention/concentration, processing speed, and working memory. Distinguishing a clear diagnostic profile for ARD is difficult due to high rates of concomitant concussion in this population. The patient’s deficits exceed those expected due to concussion alone, with an anticipated cognitive recovery timeframe of 7–14 days (Iverson, 2006). Furthermore, neuroimaging and NPE results support the diagnostic hypothesis of ARD.