Concerted Proton-coupled Electron Transfer Research Articles

Replacing a Cysteine Ligand by Selenocysteine in a [NiFe]-Hydrogenase Unlocks Hydrogen Production Activity and Addresses the Role of Concerted Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer in Electrocatalytic Reversibility.

Hydrogenases catalyze hydrogen/proton interconversion that is normally electrochemically reversible (having minimal overpotential requirement), a special property otherwise almost exclusive to platinum metals. The mechanism of [NiFe]-hydrogenases includes a long-range proton-coupled electron-transfer process involving a specific Ni-coordinated cysteine and the carboxylate of a nearby glutamate. A variant in which this cysteine has been exchanged for selenocysteine displays two distinct changes in electrocatalytic properties, as determined by protein film voltammetry. First, proton reduction, even in the presence of H2 (a strong product inhibitor), is greatly enhanced relative to H2 oxidation: this result parallels a characteristic of natural [NiFeSe]-hydrogenases which are superior H2 production catalysts. Second, an inflection (an S-shaped "twist" in the trace) appears around the formal potential, the small overpotentials introduced in each direction (oxidation and reduction) signaling a departure from electrocatalytic reversibility. Concerted proton-electron transfer offers a lower energy pathway compared to stepwise transfers. Given the much lower proton affinity of Se compared to that of S, the inflection provides compelling evidence that concerted proton-electron transfer is important in determining why [NiFe]-hydrogenases are reversible electrocatalysts.

Unraveling a Concerted Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer Pathway in Atomically Precise Gold Nanoclusters.

Metal nanoclusters (MNCs) represent a promising class of materials for catalytic carbon dioxide and proton reduction as well as dihydrogen oxidation. In such reactions, multiple proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) processes are typically involved, and the current understanding of PCET mechanisms in MNCs has primarily focused on the sequential transfer mode. However, a concerted transfer pathway, i.e., concerted electron-proton transfer (CEPT), despite its potential for a higher catalytic rate and lower reaction barrier, still lacks comprehensive elucidation. Herein, we introduce an experimental paradigm to test the feasibility of the CEPT process in MNCs, by employing Au18(SR)14 (SR denotes thiolate ligand), Au22(SR)18, and Au25(SR)18- as model clusters. Detailed investigations indicate that the photoinduced PCET reactions in the designed system proceed via an CEPT pathway. Furthermore, the rate constants of gold nanoclusters (AuNCs) have been found to be correlated with both the size of the cluster and the flexibility of the Au-S framework. This newly identified PCET behavior in AuNCs is prominently different from that observed in semiconductor quantum dots and plasmonic metal nanoparticles. Our findings are of crucial importance for unveiling the catalytic mechanisms of quantum-confined metal nanomaterials and for the future rational design of more efficient catalysts.

Valence Tautomerism Induced Proton Coupled Electron Transfer:X-H Bond Oxidation with a Dinuclear Au(II) Hydroxide Complex.

We report the preparation and characterization of the dinuclear AuII hydroxide complex AuII 2(L)2(OH)2 (L=N,N'-bis (2,6-dimethyl) phenylformamidinate) and study its reactivity towards weak X-H bonds. Through the interplay of kinetic analysis and computational studies, we demonstrate that the oxidation of cyclohexadiene follows a concerted proton-coupled electron transfer (cPCET) mechanism, a rare type of reactivity for Au complexes. We find that the Au-Au σ-bond undergoes polarization in the PCET event leading to an adjustment of oxidation levels for both Au centers prior to C(sp3)-H bond cleavage. We thus describe the oxidation event as a valence tautomerism-induced PCET where the basicity of one reduced Au-OH unit provides a proton acceptor and the second more oxidized Au center serves as an electron acceptor. The coordination of these events allows for unprecedented radical-type reactivity by a closed shell AuII complex.

Class Ib Ribonucleotide Reductases: Activation of a Peroxido-MnIIMnIII to Generate a Reactive Oxo-MnIIIMnIV Oxidant.

In the postulated catalytic cycle of class Ib Mn2 ribonucleotide reductases (RNRs), a MnII2 core is suggested to react with superoxide (O2·-) to generate peroxido-MnIIMnIII and oxo-MnIIIMnIV entities prior to proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) oxidation of tyrosine. There is limited experimental support for this mechanism. We demonstrate that [MnII2(BPMP)(OAc)2](ClO4) (1, HBPMP = 2,6-bis[(bis(2 pyridylmethyl)amino)methyl]-4-methylphenol) was converted to peroxido-MnIIMnIII (2) in the presence of superoxide anion that converted to (μ-O)(μ-OH)MnIIIMnIV (3) via the addition of an H+-donor (p-TsOH) or (μ-O)2MnIIIMnIV (4) upon warming to room temperature. The physical properties of 3 and 4 were probed using UV-vis, EPR, X-ray absorption, and IR spectroscopies and mass spectrometry. Compounds 3 and 4 were capable of phenol oxidation to yield a phenoxyl radical via a concerted PCET oxidation, supporting the proposed mechanism of tyrosyl radical cofactor generation in RNRs. The synthetic models demonstrate that the postulated O2/Mn2/tyrosine activation mechanism in class Ib Mn2 RNRs is plausible and provides spectral insights into intermediates currently elusive in the native enzyme.

A molecular-level mechanistic framework for interfacial proton-coupled electron transfer kinetics.

Electrochemical proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions can proceed via an outer-sphere electron transfer to solution (OS-PCET) or through an inner-sphere mechanism by interfacial polarization of surface-bound active sites (I-PCET). Although OS-PCET has been extensively studied with molecular insight, the inherent heterogeneity of surfaces impedes molecular-level understanding of I-PCET. Herein we employ graphite-conjugated carboxylic acids (GC-COOH) as molecularly well-defined hosts of I-PCET to isolate the intrinsic kinetics of I-PCET. We measure I-PCET rates across the entire pH range, uncovering a V-shaped pH-dependence that lacks the pH-independent regions characteristic of OS-PCET. Accordingly, we develop a mechanistic model for I-PCET that invokes concerted PCET involving hydronium/water or water/hydroxide donor/acceptor pairs, capturing the entire dataset with only four adjustable parameters. We find that I-PCET is fourfold faster with hydronium/water than water/hydroxide, while both reactions display similarly high charge transfer coefficients, indicating late proton transfer transition states. These studies highlight the key mechanistic distinctions between I-PCET and OS-PCET, providing a framework for understanding and modelling more complex multistep I-PCET reactions critical to energy conversion and catalysis.

Modeling the Weak pH Dependence of Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer for Tryptophan Derivatives.

The oxidation of tryptophan (Trp) is an important step in many biological processes and often occurs by sequential or concerted proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET). The apparent rate constants for the photochemical oxidation of two Trp derivatives in water have been shown to be pH-independent at low pH and to exhibit weak pH dependence at higher pH. Herein, these systems are investigated with a general, multi-channel model that includes sequential and concerted mechanisms as well as various proton donors and acceptors. This model can reproduce the kinetic data for both Trp derivatives with physically meaningful parameters and suggests that the weak pH dependence may arise from the competition between OH- and H2O as proton acceptors in concerted PCET. Deprotonation of an ammonium group for one of the systems leads to a more complex pH dependence at higher pH. This work demonstrates the importance of considering multiple competing channels for the analysis of the pH dependence of apparent PCET rate constants.

Concerted proton-coupled electron transfer promotes NiCoP nanowire arrays for efficient overall water splitting at industrial-level current density

Inspired by the oxygen-evolving complex (OEC) in photosystem II (PS-II), self-supported Fe-doped NiCoP nanowire arrays modified with carboxylate (NCFCP@NF) is constructed to boost industrial-level overall water splitting by the concerted proton-coupled electron transfer (c-PET) mechanism. NCFCP@NF exhibits 283 mV at the current density of 3000 mA cm−2 for HER, which is attributed to the H2O adsorption sites provided by Fe and Ni, as well as the electrons provided by carboxyl ligand. Also, NCFCP@NF shows remarkable OER catalytic activity with overpotential of 329 mV to afford 3000 mA cm−2. Herein, the introduction of Fe promotes the formation of *OOH, and carboxyl ligand accelerate the deprotonation process of OER. Furthermore, NCFCP@NF displays the ultralong durability (200 h) at 1000 mA cm−2 for overall water splitting. This study offers a new perspective on designing efficient overall water splitting catalyst at the industrial-level current density by the concerted proton-coupled electron transfer mechanism.

Transition from Sequential to Concerted Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer of Water Oxidation on Semiconductor Photoanodes.

Accelerating proton transfer has been demonstrated as key to boosting water oxidation on semiconductor photoanodes. Herein, we study proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) of water oxidation on five typical photoanodes [i.e., α-Fe2O3, BiVO4, TiO2, plasmonic Au/TiO2, and nickel-iron oxyhydroxide (Ni1-xFexOOH)-modified silicon (Si)] by combining the rate law analysis of H2O molecules with the H/D kinetic isotope effect (KIE) and operando spectroscopic studies. An unexpected and universal half-order kinetics is observed for the rate law analysis of H2O, referring to a sequential proton-electron transfer pathway, which is the rate-limiting factor that causes the sluggish water oxidation performance. Surface modification of the Ni1-xFexOOH electrocatalyst is observed to break this limitation and exhibits a normal first-order kinetics accompanied by much enhanced H/D KIE values, facilitating the turnover frequency of water oxidation by 1 order of magnitude. It is the first time that Ni1-xFexOOH is found to be a PCET modulator. The rate law analysis illustrates an effective strategy for modulating PCET kinetics of water oxidation on semiconductor surfaces.

General Kinetic Model for pH Dependence of Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer: Application to an Electrochemical Water Oxidation System.

The pH dependence of proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions, which are critical to many chemical and biological processes, is a powerful probe for elucidating their fundamental mechanisms. Herein, a general, multichannel kinetic model is introduced to describe the pH dependence of both homogeneous and electrochemical PCET reactions. According to this model, a weak pH dependence can arise from the competition among multiple sequential and concerted PCET channels involving different forms of the redox species, such as protonated and deprotonated forms, as well as different proton donors and acceptors. The contribution of each channel is influenced by the relative populations of the reactant species, which often depend strongly on pH, leading to complex pH dependence of PCET apparent rate constants. This model is used to explain the origins of the experimentally observed weak pH dependence of the electrochemical PCET apparent rate constant for a ruthenium-based water oxidation catalyst attached to a tin-doped In2O3 (ITO) surface. The weak pH dependence is found to arise from the intrinsic differences in the rate constants of participating channels and the dependence of their relative contributions on pH. This model predicts that the apparent maximum rate constant will become pH-independent at higher pH, which is confirmed by experimental measurements. Our analysis also suggests that the dominant channels are electron transfer at lower pH and sequential PCET via electron transfer followed by fast proton transfer at higher pH. This work highlights the importance of considering multiple competing channels simultaneously for PCET processes.

Hydrocarbon Oxidation by a Porphyrin-π-Cation Radical Complex.

Heme and chlorin π-cation radical oxidants are widely implicated in biological and synthetic oxidation catalysis. Little insight into the role of π-cation radicals in proton coupled electron transfer (PCET) oxidation is available. We prepared a NiII-porphyrin-π-cation complex ([NiII(P•+)]) and found it to be capable of the oxidation of a variety of simple hydrocarbon substrates. Interestingly, some of the products were hydroxylated, with ([NiII(P•+)]) working in concert with atmospheric O2 to yield hydroxylated hydrocarbons. Kinetic data suggested that the porphyrin-π-cation radical species oxidised substrates via a concerted PCET mechanism, where the nickel porphyrin-π-cation radical accepted the electron, and the proton was transferred to a free anion. Our findings highlight the potential role of π-cation radicals as hydrocarbon activators, demonstrating that porphyrin ligand non-innocence could be a readily manipulated resource for oxidation catalyst development.

Hydrocarbon Oxidation by a Porphyrin‐π‐Cation Radical Complex

AbstractHeme and chlorin π‐cation radical oxidants are widely implicated in biological and synthetic oxidation catalysis. Little insight into the role of π‐cation radicals in proton coupled electron transfer (PCET) oxidation is available. We prepared a NiII‐porphyrin‐π‐cation complex ([NiII(P⋅+)]) and found it to be capable of the oxidation of a variety of simple hydrocarbon substrates. Interestingly, some of the products were hydroxylated, with ([NiII(P⋅+)]) working in concert with atmospheric O2 to yield hydroxylated hydrocarbons. Kinetic data suggested that the porphyrin‐π‐cation radical species oxidised substrates through a concerted PCET mechanism, where the porphyrin‐π‐cation radical accepted the electron, and the proton was transferred to a free anion. Our findings highlight the potential role of π‐cation radicals as hydrocarbon activators, demonstrating that porphyrin ligand non‐innocence could be a readily manipulated resource for oxidation catalyst development.

Concerted Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer to a Graphite Adsorbed Metalloporphyrin Occurs by Band to Bond Electron Redistribution.

Surface immobilized catalysts are highly promising candidates for a range of energy conversion reactions, and atomistic mechanistic understanding is essential for their rational design. Cobalt tetraphenylporphyrin (CoTPP) nonspecifically adsorbed on a graphitic surface has been shown to undergo concerted proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) in aqueous solution. Herein, density functional theory calculations on both cluster and periodic models representing π-stacked interactions or axial ligation to a surface oxygenate are performed. As the electrode surface is charged due to applied potential, the adsorbed molecule experiences the electrical polarization of the interface and nearly the same electrostatic potential as the electrode, regardless of the adsorption mode. PCET occurs by electron abstraction from the surface to the CoTPP concerted with protonation to form a cobalt hydride, thereby circumventing Co(II/I) redox. Specifically, the Co(II) d-state localized orbital interacts with a proton from solution and an electron from the delocalized graphitic band states to produce a Co(III)-H bonding orbital below the Fermi level, corresponding to redistribution of electrons from the band states to the bonding states. These insights have broad implications for electrocatalysis by chemically modified electrodes and surface immobilized catalysts.

Reactivity of trans-Resveratrol toward Electrogenerated Superoxide in N,N-Dimethylformamide.

The reactivity of 5-[(E)-2-(4-hydroxyphenyl)ethen-1-yl]benzene-1,3-diol (trans-resveratrol) and related compounds toward electrogenerated superoxide radical anion (O2•-) were investigated using electrochemistry, in situ electrolytic electron spin resonance, and in situ electrolytic ultraviolet-visible spectral measurements, in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) with the aid of density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The quasi-reversible cyclic voltammogram of dioxygen/O2•- was modified by the presence of trans-resveratrol, suggesting that the electrogenerated O2•- was scavenged by trans-resveratrol through proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) via three phenolic hydroxy groups (OH) on the stilbene moiety. The reactivity of trans-resveratrol toward O2•- characterized by the OHs was experimentally confirmed in comparative analyses using some related compounds, pinosylvin, pterostilbene, p-coumaric acid, and so on, in DMF. The electrochemical and DFT results suggested that a concerted PCET mechanism via 4'OH of trans-resveratrol proceeds, where the coplanarity of the two phenolic rings in the stilbene moiety linked by an ethylene bridge is essential for a successful O2•- scavenging.

Electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution by a dinuclear copper complex and mechanistic elucidation through DFT studies.

A novel dinuclear copper complex, [CuII2(L1)2] (L1 = 2-{[2-(8-hydroxyquinolin-2-yl)-1H-benzimidazol-1-yl]methyl}quinolin-8-ol) was synthesised and characterised through various spectroscopic techniques. This dinuclear complex (as an electrocatalyst) was employed to examine the catalytic ability towards an electrochemical hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). Redox studies in 95/5 (v/v) DMF/H2O with the addition of 30-equivalent AcOH (acid source) led to higher catalytic activities for the HER. The evolved H2, as the resultant product, was detected and confirmed from gas chromatography to afford a faradaic efficiency of 93% at an applied potential of -1.9 V vs. SCE. Based upon measurements of open-circuit potential and electrocatalytic responses, the mechanistic route for the reduction process using [CuII2(L1)2] was elucidated. Density functional theory studies reveal that through a concerted proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) path, the HER proceeded via the formation of a Cu-H bond with a low activation energy for the dehydrogenation reaction.

Mussel-inspired binder with concerted proton-electron transfer for pH-universal overall H2O2 synthesis

Despite being an essential component for attaching powders or films in various electrode preparations, binders hardly have received attention. Due to the poor adherence and environmental adaptation of binder, the shedding of the materials during application causes a diminishing performance and poor environmental tolerance. Inspired by the catechol in mussels, we offer a one-step prepared polydopamine (PDA) binder with intrinsically strong stickiness throughout the entire pH value. The electrolytic preparation rates for H2O2 displayed a W-shaped pattern at an increasing overall pH value, which is the concerted proton-coupled electron transfer mechanism, as we investigated the environmental tolerance of the PDA binder (PCET). Our work will draw more attention to binders and PDA binders, and provide a descriptor for the effect of electrolytes on electrocatalytic activity.

Reactivities of 1,2-, 1,3-, and 1,4-dihydroxynaphthalenes toward electrogenerated superoxide in N,N-dimethylformamide through proton-coupled electron transfer

We have carried out an electrochemical and theoretical study on the reactivity of 1,2-, 1,3-, and 1,4-dihydroxynaphthalenes (1nH2NQ, n = 2, 3, 4) toward electrogenerated superoxide radical anion (O2•−) in N,N-dimethylformamide. Cyclicvoltammetry and in situ electrolytic electron spin resonance measurements revealed that the quinone–hydroquinone π-conjugation plays an important role in a successful O2•− scavenging by 12H2NQ and 14H2NQ through proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reaction. The reactivities of 12H2NQ and 14H2NQ toward O2•− were mediated by the ortho- (catechol) or para-diphenol (hydroquinone) moieties, as experimentally confirmed in comparative analyses with catechol, hydroquinone, and 13H2NQ, aided by density functional theory (DFT) calculations. The electrochemical and DFT results suggested that a concerted PCET mechanism involving two-proton transfers and one-electron transfer proceeds, demonstrating a successful O2•− scavenging by 12H2NQ and 14H2NQ. Furthermore, a subsequent electron transfer between molecular dioxygen and product-naphthoquinone-radicals was observed, where O2•− was regenerated. The DFT analysis suggested that the spin distribution on the planar naphthalene ring embodies the superior kinetics of the PCET and the subsequent generation of O2•− from dioxygen demonstrated in the electrochemical results.

Chalcogen Atoms as Electron Donors in Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer Reactions.

Proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions are crucial for the optimal functioning of a broad scope of chemical and biological processes. In this report, we present an unprecedented type of concerted PCET (cPCET), in which a chalcogen atom acts as the electron donor. The nature of this mechanism is key for understanding the reactivity of different radical-trapping antioxidants having heavy chalcogens (S, Se, or Te) in their structures. Moreover, this chalcogen-assisted cPCET is likely to be occurring in multiple systems of biological interest.

Homolytic X-H Bond Cleavage at a Gold(III) Hydroxide: Insights into One-Electron Events at Gold.

C(sp3)‐H and O−H bond breaking steps in the oxidation of 1,4‐cyclohexadiene and phenol by a Au(III)‐OH complex were studied computationally. The analysis reveals that for both types of bonds the initial X−H cleavage step proceeds via concerted proton coupled electron transfer (cPCET), reflecting electron transfer from the substrate directly to the Au(III) centre and proton transfer to the Au‐bound oxygen. This mechanistic picture is distinct from the analogous formal Cu(III)‐OH complexes studied by the Tolman group (J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2019, 141, 17236–17244), which proceed via hydrogen atom transfer (HAT) for C−H bonds and cPCET for O−H bonds. Hence, care should be taken when transferring concepts between Cu−OH and Au−OH species. Furthermore, the ability of Au−OH complexes to perform cPCET suggests further possibilities for one‐electron chemistry at the Au centre, for which only limited examples exist.

Concerted and Stepwise Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer for Tryptophan-Derivative Oxidation with Water as the Primary Proton Acceptor: Clarifying a Controversy

Concerted electron-proton transfer (CEPT) reactions avoid charged intermediates and may be energetically favorable for redox and radical-transfer reactions in natural and synthetic systems. Tryptophan (W) often partakes in radical-transfer chains in nature but has been proposed to only undergo sequential electron transfer followed by proton transfer when water is the primary proton acceptor. Nevertheless, our group has shown that oxidation of freely solvated tyrosine and W often exhibit weakly pH-dependent proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) rate constants with moderate kinetic isotope effects (KIE ≈ 2–5), which could be associated with a CEPT mechanism. These results and conclusions have been questioned. Here, we present PCET rate constants for W derivatives with oxidized Ru- and Zn-porphyrin photosensitizers, extracted from laser flash-quench studies. Alternative quenching/photo-oxidation methods were used to avoid complications of previous studies, and both the amine and carboxylic acid groups of W were protected to make the indole the only deprotonable group. With a suitably tuned oxidant strength, we found an ET-limited reaction at pH < 4 and weakly pH-dependent rates at pH > ∼5 that are intrinsic to the PCET of the indole group with water (H2O) as the proton acceptor. The observed rate constants are up to more than 100 times higher than those measured for initial electron transfer, excluding the electron-first mechanism. Instead, the reaction can be attributed to CEPT. These conclusions are important for our view of CEPT in water and of PCET-mediated radical reactions with solvent-exposed tryptophan in natural systems.

Phytate Coordination-Enhanced Electrocatalytic Activity of Copper for Nitroarene Hydrogenation through Concerted Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer.

Coupling acid-electrolyte proton exchange membrane fuel cells for electricity generation and cathodic hydrogenation for valuable chemical production shows great potential in energy and chemical industry. The key for this promising approach is the identification of cathode electrocatalysts with acid resistance, high activity, and low fabrication cost for practical applications. Among various promising cathodic candidates for this integrative approach, the easily available and cheap Cu suffers from low acidic hydrogenation activity due to kinetically arduous proton adsorption/activation. Inspired by the kinetic advantages of the concerted proton-coupled electron transfer (CPET) over the sequential proton-electron transfer process, herein, we use phytate coordination on Cu surface to overcome the kinetic bottleneck for proton adsorption/activation through the CPET pathway in an acidic half-cell setup; this leads to 1 order of magnitude activity enhancement (36.94-fold) for nitrobenzene hydrogenation. Mechanistic analysis confirms that phytate, as proton acceptor, induces the CPET process and overcomes the above kinetic limitations by tuning the d-band center and concentrating protons on the Cu surface. Consequently, the CPET process facilitates the formation of active hydrogen intermediates for efficient cathodic hydrogenation. This work provides a promising approach to integrate electricity generation and chemical production.