To study the mechanical properties of manufactured sand recycled aggregate concrete-filled steel tubular (RACFST) columns, a total of 81 square short RACFST column specimens with different types of manufactured sand and natural sand were created and subjected to axial compression tests. The variables included sand type, core concrete strength, slenderness ratio, and steel tube thickness. The failure mode, axial load-displacement curve, axial compressive capacity, and deformation capacity of the specimens were analyzed in detail. The results indicate that the failure mode of the specimen is generally waist drum-type failure and shear-type failure, and both of them are local buckling. The load-displacement curve of the manufactured sand specimen is similar to that of the natural sand specimen, but the steel tube of the manufactured sand specimen yields later than that of the natural sand specimen. Generally, the limestone manufactured sand specimen has the highest axial compressive capacity and the best ductility ratio, while the pebble manufactured sand specimen has an axial compressive capacity similar to the natural sand specimen but a lower ductility ratio. The effects of concrete compressive strength, slenderness ratio, and steel tube thickness on specimens with manufactured sand are similar to those with natural sand. Based on the results of this experimental study, a formula for calculating the axial compressive capacity of square RACFST columns is provided.