In the present investigation, the combined influence of coir, glass fibers and charcoal content on the mechanical properties of epoxy-based hybrid composites has been explored, providing insights for the potential development of advanced materials with tailored performance characteristics. Through a systematic analysis of the mechanical properties (tensile strength, Young's modulus, flexural strength, flexural modulus, and Brinell hardness number), various composite formulations were evaluated to discern their performance characteristics. The study reveals significant variations in mechanical properties across different composite configurations, highlighting the critical role of fiber type and charcoal content in determining the materials’ performance. Notably, composites featuring alternating layers of glass and coir fibers exhibit superior tensile and flexural strengths, underscoring the synergistic effects of hybridization. Conversely, the introduction of charcoal as a reinforcement agent leads to deterioration in the mechanical properties, indicating a trade-off between the reinforcement and other desirable attributes. These findings offer valuable insights for the strategic design and engineering of advanced materials tailored to specific applications, paving the way for the development of high-performance epoxy-based hybrid composites with enhanced mechanical properties and durability.